On Again Off Again Airfones

Apathoid...

you are absolutely correct. the spacing between "Page 1" and the date is not adequate to allow for the tail of the "g". Clearly, the date was pasted on top of the original date. FAKE.

TAM:)
 
That it, it is a done deal...that is a FAKE!!!

Page 1
01/28/01

I see a "g", not a "c".

TAM:)
 
Ok, what is the big deal here?? If you look at the evidence that was provided at the Moussoui trail, it was clearly stated that the calls made were from cell phones.

2 from Renee May. (one did not connect) One lasted 158 seconds
Barbra Olsen, and 5 other calls to unknown numbers.

There was never any question about where that calls came from! Unless Im missing something??

I wasn't aware that evidence submitted in that trial positively ID'ed the callers. Are you privy to new information?
From the article in discussion:

As we mentioned earlier, the FBI report on phone calls from AA planes on 9/11 does not cite records from the DOJ showing that any calls from AA 77 were received that morning. Instead, the FBI report refers merely to four “connected calls to unknown numbers.” The 9/11 Commission, putting the best possible spin on this report, commented: “The records available for the phone calls from American 77 do not allow for a determination of which of [these four calls] represent the two between Barbara and Ted Olson, although the FBI and DOJ believe that all four represent communications between Barbara Olson and her husband’s office.”27 That is, it must be said, a very strange conclusion: If Ted Olson reported receiving only two calls, why would the Commission conclude that the DOJ had received four connected calls from his wife?

That conclusion is, in any case, starkly contradicted by evidence about phone calls from Flight 77 presented by the US government at the trial of Zacarias Moussaoui in 2006.28 Far from attributing all four of the “connected calls to unknown numbers” to Barbara Olson, as the 9/11 Commission suggested, the government’s evidence here attributes none of them to her, saying instead that each of them was from an “unknown caller.” The only call attributed to Barbara Olson, moreover, is an “unconnected call” to the Department of Justice, which was said to have been attempted at “9:18:58” and to have lasted “0 seconds.” According to the US government in 2006, in other words, Barbara Olson attempted a call to the DOJ, but it did not go through.29 The government itself has presented evidence in a court of law, therefore, that implies that unless its former solicitor general was the victim of two faked phone calls, he was lying.
 
I just realized this isn't Lyte's story. He has nothing to do with it.

It's a fantasy of Balsamo's and David Ray Griffin. They have a lengthy article at the pft site if you really want to read all of the allegations and secret stuff that happened.

Here is their conclusion.

"For those eight reasons alone, we would be justified in concluding, from simply this aspect of the official story, that the entire official story about 9/11 was a fabrication. This conclusion is greatly strengthened, however, by the almost definitive evidence that, besides the fact that Barbara Olson’s alleged calls could not have been made from a cell phone (which the US government now appears implicitly to have acknowledged), they also could not have been made from an onboard phone."
 
Your entire "suggestion" is just that. He isn't claiming anything in regards to the phone calls authenticity in this thread, only the question of whether airphones were a method of communication on that particular flight.

You are a true critical thinker that clearly uses logic.

We remember you for your phone call during the debate between Brainster and Bermas.

You know your stuff!
;)
 
how do you explain the missing tail of the "g" in the word Page" above the faked date Lyte?

TAM:)
 
No that is perfect, thanks SWING.

So the email proves nothing, except that as of 2006 there are no Airfones on AA's 757s. It has no relevence to the airfone status on AA 757's for 2001.

So toss the email out as useless.

TAM:)

So you don't accept the statement of the spokesperson regarding the content of the email? Why is that?
 
This is too much trouble, cell phones work, the manual section in question was updated to say deactivated at some unknown time, there are revision notes in the left margin. Just like "|" revisions in Delta manuals, the codes in the left hand column are revised data. The original was in 2001, what are the revisions dates. Without the entire revision history this is JUNK. You would have to have a forensic expert on manuals to study this with access to historical documents from AA. The manual page talks about procedures for maintenance of the phone system and how it works. The ECOs were added at a later date, as was the deactivation information. I use flight manuals and this one is not original, it has been changed. There is no proof of the original date of the document, or revisions. JDX does this all the time. He cherry picks, make a statement and ignores any rebuttal.

There is no technical reason in 2001 that regular cell phones could not be used to talk to people on 9/11. Zip, show me the technical manuals that talk about flying with cell phones and they do not rule out cell phones functioning in flight. These are facts, and I have used cell phones in flight in 2001 and before. I have seen technical manuals on cell phones and they discuss flying. Why is it the truth movement does not publish them? I will tell you why. The manuals plainly state that cell phones can work in flight. I was given a lecture by a born again truther who threw all the manuals at me. I annotated them and showed her that cell phones can work in flight, she lost. Why are the truthers unable to research and find what an idiot can find, this lady was nuts, but she produced technical manuals on cell phones. Why are truthers nuts?

So, even if the phones were deactivated, cell phones work. I have been on planes with deactivated phones, the phone is in the seat but it does not work.

So this is a smoke screen for JDX to say something that means nothing.

Need to know original date of manual. Need to know revisions and how they are made. Looks like the data is not available to solve this newest waste of time by JDX and the mentally challenged pilots who make up stuff about 9/11. JDX, it does not matter what you do, terrorist pilots did fly on 9/11 and they seem to be able to hit the building your and your buddies missed in a simulator. Next time do not be so cheap and use a 737 sim, the 757/767 has much better dutch roll damping, and BTW the dutch roll in the 737 is damped, unlike a KC-135, you would have problems with the 707 flying.

We have cell phones that can work, and a manual without dates of revision. What does this mean for 9/11? NADT
 
How do you know this? Do you have a document that explains AA's online manual revision dates and software revision dates?

Our mechanic told us.. prove it wrong.

Can you explain why AA hasn't revised their AMM in 6 years? The FAA would surely love to hear about that...

If you know anything about manuals and doing revisions. each last revision date is on the page itself... not every page has the same date... have you ever revised your manual?

The page itself obviously wasn't revised since the date noted.. but I'm sure other pages in the manual were. Ever seen a revision log at beginning of manuals? Not every revision is the whole manual. And if they do replace full manuals, they do not revise a date on a page that hasn't been revised.

And can you please respond to this:

"What you need is:

Engineering Authorization(EA)/ Engineering Order(EO) documents. EO/EA compliance reports saying when individual aircraft (ship 644) were complete, or even logbook history documents. All of the above should be available to your source."


Can he get this or not? I could have all of the above info for any aircraft in my employers fleet within minutes(and I'm not even at work right now!). Don't believe me? Try me.

I'll check.
 
Apathoid, where do you think the documentation on flight 77 and 93 would be right now, concerning what was installed on board and what was not? Would that be in the hands of the FBI do you think? would AA have copies of the maintenance records for that particular flight, even 6 years later?

TAM:)

It should online on AA's/UA's maintenance homepage. The EOs/EAs should be searchable online, the compliance status should be available either online or in AA's engineering/planning department(its online at my employer), and the log history may or may not be available since the aircraft were destroyed(log history for all aircraft is available online at my employer). Like I said, I could get all of that and possibly even copies of the work cards(with mechanic/inspector signoffs) for any mod done to any plane in our fleet rather easily...

eta: about the longish timeframe. For my remote takeover piece I looked up all the GPS/GPWS mods for our 757 and 767 fleet and I was able to pull up records from 1998......
 
Last edited:
So you don't accept the statement of the spokesperson regarding the content of the email? Why is that?

Swing....is the spokesperson referring to the status of the airfones on AA flights in 2001 in his email reply? If not, it is irrelivent.

TAM:)
 
Ahh, gotcha. That may be the case. I have to take these manual system computer training modules every year and I usually sleep or daydream through them(seriously, watching paint dry is more exciting).

It could be very likely that the REV 62 Jan 28/2007 is the date the manual was revised and the date on the bottom could be the original manual publication date..

Perhaps they need to update their TPS reports. :)

Lurker
 
Swing:

The Flash presentation, used in the Moussaoiu trial as evidence, clearly indicates that the calls from flight 93 were made using airfones. When they detail the calls, they tell you where, which seating row they were made from, which is different from the seating assignment of the actual passenger who made the calls.

Now clearly, if they know the seating row the call was made from by caller X, and that row is different from the seating assignment from passenger X, than the only way to know the row the call was made from, is if it was from an ACTIVE AIRFONE!!!

So either this evidence is true, or it is fake, which is what the new claim is implying...so now Rob and Lyte, are witholding evidence that could free a potentially innoncent man due to tampered evidence!!!!

TAM:)
 
Two words:

Conspiracy theory.

Go do some research and find some evidence on your own.

ahh...why I am...I am researching the validity of your provided evidence...doesnt seem to be valid.

If this is your idea of research, obtaining forged documents, than you can remain the researcher...I'll stick with the truth.

TAM:)
 
I'm Done. Unless they can provide a valid reason why part of the "g" is missing, when it clearly should not, if the form is legitimate (you know with line spacing and all) than it is FAKE...EOS.

TAM:)
 
Can anyone provide any other page of this AMM whatsoever, unredacted, for comparison and examination of the format? It doesn't have to be anything that anyone could possibly get in trouble for revealing. How about the page on how to change the light bulbs in the No Smoking signs?

As best as I can determine without such a comparison page:

- Both dates appear to have been altered in their last two digits.

- The two visible dates are supposed to match. That they do not, I strongly suspect, would reveal immediately to anyone knowledgeable about the format of these particular documents that this page has been falsified.

- That the redactor is attempting to disguise the page revision date at upper left as the software revision date, by blacking out the actual revision numbers and date that appear in the blacked-out field next to "Software Release." This is supported by:

1. There is no reason to conceal the software release; it could not possibly identify the individual user.

2. A software release is usually identifed by a revision number, and sometime also by a date. But what else is needed? If the software "REV" number (62) and date are visible on the line below, what other information about the software release would be left to appear on the line above?

- That the redactor changed the date at the bottom in order to back-date the document, and is attempting to disguise the resulting mismatch by making the top date appear to be a software revision date instead, and changing the year on that top date to appear plausibly recent for a software revision date.

- That the match in month and day is not a 1 in 365 coincidence, but an indication that the dates are supposed to match and the document has been altered. Conservatively estimating that there is at least a 10% chance of a document appearing in such circumstances (heavily redacted, by an anyonymous source, concerning a controversial issue) is faked, interpreting the 1 in 365 coincidence of the date match as conclusive evidence of a fake will lead to the correct conclusion 35 times out of 36.

Thus I conclude, not with certaintly but with considerable confidence, that this is a fake, and a clumsy one.

Of course, if images of unredacted pages from this same system by an impartial source are made available showing me wrong, then I'll gladly retract the above and apologize.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
You are a true critical thinker that clearly uses logic.

We remember you for your phone call during the debate between Brainster and Bermas.

You know your stuff!
;)

Thanks. It isn't too difficult to debunk some of these folks. Heck Rmackey had to flat out lie and twist meanings in his little discussion over Val's photo while back.
And even Gravy tried but couldn't dispute the valid premise of the explosions in the basement theory.
Tam-Swing....is the spokesperson referring to the status of the airfones on AA flights in 2001 in his email reply? If not, it is irrelivent.

Tam you made this same error surrounding the money Val was making from the article I posted on that thread. The author of this particular email is clearly referring to 757 on 9/11 as he references flight 77.
There is no separation of the content and it is in the context of the email's discussion. You also fail to consider the affirmation of the content of his email via the phone call. “That sounds like an accurate statement.”-Kinder.
Notice he does not correct any of the email's content, but only confirms it. He doesn't change the content of the email via the phone call.

He confirms the official story or are you trying to state that the official story is wrong and they used airphones?

That is correct we do not have phones on our Boeing 757. The passengers on flight 77 used their own personal cellular phones to make out calls during the terrorist attack.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom