On Again Off Again Airfones

Perhaps those of you who doubt the authenticity of the document as well as the public relations officer for AA could follow up with your own investigation, then you might have a leg to stand on. The burden of proof is now upon the debunker's shoulders.

You of course would forget that the original burden of proof falls upon truthers. So ask yourself, what purpose would it serve to try to present faked evidence to support a cause that is based upon truth? Do you think these folks want to discredit themselves? Mistakes and further information is one thing, but to fake something that could easily be verified or debunked makes no sense at all and would only hurt the truth movement itself.

And I can contest that I have flown on 757s that year and I have seen people use the phones. So this notion that there were no phones on any 757s is clearly not true.
Of course you can provide evidence of this, correct?
That memo doesn't make much sense. They say that the telephone system was deactivated, but then it continues on to talk about what it does, how it works, and who will perform maintenance on it.
It is from a maintenance manual is it not? The system of course could be reactivated and which would necessitate the what, how and who of the document. If they were completely removed, then perhaps you would have a point.
Pseudo-skeptics bug me.
I think you meant pseudo-skeptics are bugs.
Johnny,Regardless, I believe Barbra was one of the only people to actually use a cell phone.
So this is the version of Ted Olson's story you believe?
And then explain how that cell phone worked at altitude and at that speed.
JamesB And why does the print for the date at the bottom look different than the rest of the document?
Perhaps you should contact AA and find out what type of printer they use. Then you could find out what type of scanner is used and run several tests to see if you can reproduce the issue you are pointing out. You know, carry out the research.
 
Well, he's a Bush Cronie, so why wouldn't he allow his own wife to be killed in the process and help cover that up.

But you also forgot about Rene May. ANOTHER person to make calls. And how about the people on the other 757 flight that day?

Unfortunately I don't know who the people were on some of the flights I made that year that were happily using the airphones. But maybe I can look them up and ask them why they were making pretend phone calls on phones that don't work. Maybe they were all in on it too!
 
I am not saying it is a fake but it does seem a bit vague to reach any conclusions from.

Was it just for that one plane? Were they swapping out old equipment for newer equipment? Changing phone service? Any can be reasonably inferred from what you provided.

I think it would be irresponsible to jump to any conclusions one way or another until more evidence comes in on this.

Lurker
 
Listen....we have obtained this evidence from a licensed A&P mechanic employee within American Airlines.

He remembers clearly the phones with inoperable placards and was pissed he had to keep replacing the phones during C Checks (IIRC it was C Checks)... because the phones didnt even work and he felt it was double the work for nothing.. they should have kept the phones out since they weren't even operative he thought. But AA told their mechanics to put them back in even though they were deactivated. you cant leave a hole in the back of a seat.

We think this maintenance manual is strong evidence so PFT and DRG have ran with it and we back them 100%.

If you can prove them incorrect with stronger evidence then by all means go right ahead.

I'm quite certain they would have no problem admitting their error.

So get to work!
 
Perhaps you should contact AA and find out what type of printer they use. Then you could find out what type of scanner is used and run several tests to see if you can reproduce the issue you are pointing out. You know, carry out the research.

But this wasn't provided by AA, it was provided by an anonymous troofer. How exactly do you expect me to contact an anonymous troofer in order to find out how he obtained, printed and scanned this document?
 
Of course you can provide evidence of this, correct?
\\And how exactly would you like me to do that? Perhaps you could provide some evidence that the pentacon witnesses actually saw what they saw?

Tell you what, when you provide that evidence, I will provide you the evidence that I saw people making calls. Does that sound fair?
 
I am not saying it is a fake but it does seem a bit vague to reach any conclusions from.

Was it just for that one plane? Were they swapping out old equipment for newer equipment? Changing phone service? Any can be reasonably inferred from what you provided.

I think it would be irresponsible to jump to any conclusions one way or another until more evidence comes in on this.

Lurker


The EFFECTIVITY block at the bottom shows the tail number range the reference is applicable to. Typically, you'll see a range of numbers or simply ALL if the system is applicable to all aircraft in the fleet.
 
Apart from Renee May's mother. But best avoid talking about her, right?

I stand corrected and already edited my response. I forgot about Renee May.

There are many ways these people could have been fooled.

Bottom line the citgo witnesses have proven that there was a deception.

We don't claim to know exactly how.
 
Listen....we have obtained this evidence from a licensed A&P mechanic employee within American Airlines.

He remembers clearly the phones with inoperable placards and was pissed he had to keep replacing the phones during C Checks (IIRC it was C Checks)... because the phones didnt even work and he felt it was double the work for nothing.. they should have kept the phones out since they weren't even operative he thought. But AA told their mechanics to put them back in even though they were deactivated. you cant leave a hole in the back of a seat.

We think this maintenance manual is strong evidence so PFT and DRG have ran with it and we back them 100%.

If you can prove them incorrect with stronger evidence then by all means go right ahead.

I'm quite certain they would have no problem admitting their error.

So get to work!

Still ignoring my questions, Lyte?
 
Listen....we have obtained this evidence from a licensed A&P mechanic employee within American Airlines.

He remembers clearly the phones with inoperable placards and was pissed he had to keep replacing the phones during C Checks (IIRC it was C Checks)... because the phones didnt even work and he felt it was double the work for nothing.. they should have kept the phones out since they weren't even operative he thought. But AA told their mechanics to put them back in even though they were deactivated. you cant leave a hole in the back of a seat.

We think this maintenance manual is strong evidence so PFT and DRG have ran with it and we back them 100%.

If you can prove them incorrect with stronger evidence then by all means go right ahead.

I'm quite certain they would have no problem admitting their error.

So get to work!

If the phones were not working the calls from the victims to their families are fake, yes or no?

It requires a one word answer, yes or no.
 
. . .
Published: February 6, 2002, 4:20 PM PST
. . .
American Airlines will discontinue its AT&T in-flight phone service by March 31, a spokesman for the airline said Wednesday.
. . .
Southwest Airlines started removing AT&T phones from its planes Aug. 1 last year.
. . .
American will stop the service by March 31 and then take steps to remove the phones from its airplanes.
. . .
http://news.com.com/Airline+grounds+in-flight+phone+service/2100-1033_3-831093.html

bolding mine
 
Why did they black out the date at the top?

If this mechanic has proof that his company lied to the FBI during its investigation, commiting perjury and obstruction of justice, and conspiracy to commit murder, and has known this for 6 years, than why doesn't he take this to the proper authorities? Why is he just passing around JPEG's anonymously on the Internet?

56. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Ronald and Nancy May, Sept. 12, 2001.

57.The records available for the phone calls from American 77 do not allow for a determination of which of four "connected calls to unknown numbers" represent the two between Barbara and Ted Olson, although the FBI and DOJ believe that all four represent communications between Barbara Olson and her husband's office (all family members of the Flight 77 passengers and crew were canvassed to see if they had received any phone calls from the hijacked flight, and only Renee May's parents and Ted Olson indicated that they had received such calls).The four calls were at 9:15:34 for 1 minute, 42 seconds; 9:20:15 for 4 minutes, 34 seconds; 9:25:48 for 2 minutes, 34 seconds; and 9:30:56 for 4 minutes, 20 seconds. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Helen Voss, Sept. 14, 2001;AAL response to the Commission's supplemental document request, Jan. 20, 2004.

58. FBI report, "American Airlines Airphone Usage," Sept. 20, 2001; FBI report of investigation, interview of Theodore Olson, Sept. 11, 2001.
 
\\And how exactly would you like me to do that? Perhaps you could provide some evidence that the pentacon witnesses actually saw what they saw?
Tell you what, when you provide that evidence, I will provide you the evidence that I saw people making calls. Does that sound fair?

Are you suggesting no plane hit the Pentagon?

Besides, no need to change the subject. I'm simply asking for evidence of what you state is true. That is exactly what has been provided to you: a document and an email to an AA representative. You are trying to refute the evidence with your statement. I believe the burden of proof is upon your shoulders as you are using your own unproven experience to refute Lyte.
Stating something and proving it are two separate things. You of course stated it, but offered no evidence supporting your statement.
 
Renee May is reported to have used a cell phone and it was reportedly made at above 24,000 according to the FDR.
 
That's what I am doing every day.

Why is it when I come around here once or month or so with new info you have to chime in with "get to work!"?

I understand the truth hurts and you like it when I stay away from here for long periods of time.

Sorry to disrupt your veil of denial.

No, sorry to burst your bubble. I just find it hilarious that after months of pimping your "irrefutable" evidence that there has been not one iota of real, tangible change from your work. Not a mention anywhere in the MSM, much less much talk in the conspiracy underworld.

If your evidence is so strong and damning, where is the outcry from the public? Where is the outcry from other experts? From pundits? From politicians?
 
Why did they black out the date at the top?

If this mechanic has proof that his company lied to the FBI during its investigation, commiting perjury and obstruction of justice, and conspiracy to commit murder, and has known this for 6 years, than why doesn't he take this to the proper authorities? Why is he just passing around JPEG's anonymously on the Internet?
Do you have a family, James? He may. Perhaps job security, James, to feed himself and his family. Maybe passing along documents from AA aircraft manuals is a violation of company policy. Maybe he doesn't want any public spotlight shinning on him. Perhaps he doesn't want the FBI investigating him?
His motive doesn't change the fact, James.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom