Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
They don't have any concrete plan, direction or even a core issue that they're protesting about. Because their attraction to protest isn't about that.

To which I agree. And I have made that point several times about the OWS. What does it take to tell you that when I agree, IT ACTUALLY MEANS - I AGREE???

Should I type it out in Sanskrit?

It's a play-date for leftists to come together and indulge their ridiculously inflated egos.

And that is your opinion.
 
That would be an irrelevant question. Since this thread is not about the Tea Party, as much as it serves as a useful distraction for OWS supporters on the defensive.

Well no. That would be wrong again, Virus. The tea party, as I mentioned before, have many supporters who also support OWS. And the tea party has been mentioned in this thread as two comparable populist uprisings. So yes, it is actually a relevant question!

So did the tea party ever exist as one sole entity?
 
Well no. That would be wrong again, Virus. The tea party, as I mentioned before, have many supporters who also support OWS. And the tea party has been mentioned in this thread as two comparable populist uprisings. So yes, it is actually a relevant question!

So did the tea party ever exist as one sole entity?
You may have a point. It came into existence as a number of groups of individuals who shared concerns about the power of the federal government and the level of taxation.

However, "sole entity" or not, it did have an easily identifiable twofold goal: to reduce the power of the federal government and reduce taxes. You'd probably find some who would argue that this is the same thing. The groups individually organizing under that "tea party" brand went to some trouble to keep their protests legal.

OWS, on the other hand, seems like an umbrella brand for folks who have made a hobby of protest.
 
OWS, on the other hand, seems like an umbrella brand for folks who have made a hobby of protest.
Yeah, kinda like the 60s counter culture which were an outgrowth of the civil rights movement of the 50s. The 60s saw an expansion where we had anti-war, anti-capitalism, anti-govt, women's rights, minority rights, voting rights, sexual revolution, legalizing drugs, environmentalism and gay rights, there were sit ins at campuses, marches on Washington, etc., etc.

Of course most people only know about or only remember civil rights. The protestors of the 50s, 60s and 70s were also accused of simply protesting for the sake of protesting.
 
I heard an analogy on the radio the other day that was bang on the money. A political-science professor had had his fill of the people in his class nattering on about the Occupy movement, so he said "OK, we're going to implement income equality here in the class. I'm going to take 200 points away from all the A students, and 100 points from the B students, and give them to the F students."

Of course, there was much screeching about the unfairness of it all.

The prof just smiled smugly and waited for the analogy to hit them...
 
I heard an analogy on the radio the other day that was bang on the money. A political-science professor had had his fill of the people in his class nattering on about the Occupy movement, so he said "OK, we're going to implement income equality here in the class. I'm going to take 200 points away from all the A students, and 100 points from the B students, and give them to the F students."

Of course, there was much screeching about the unfairness of it all.

The prof just smiled smugly and waited for the analogy to hit them...
That's about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. I hope most professors are not that clueless and I hope most students are smart enough to figure out why the analogy is a straw man argument. Perhaps some will take the time to find out what the issues really are and not simply resentment of people who have more because of their talent and hard work.

This little anecdote reminds me why I am no longer a conservative. A huge Rush Limbaugh fan I bought into this 1 dimensional thinking. Rush is very good with these kinds of silly straw men arguments. He paints his opponents as simply lazy and wanting to improve their lives by taking from the rich.
 
That's about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. I hope most professors are not that clueless and I hope most students are smart enough to figure out why the analogy is a straw man argument. Perhaps some will take the time to find out what the issues really are and not simply resentment of people who have more because of their talent and hard work.
Much of what we've seen from the signs, chanting, and written stuff from OWS has been about greed, redistribution of wealth, and anti capitalist ideas. That you want to say what the movement is really about is a fallacy by assertion.
 
That's about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. I hope most professors are not that clueless and I hope most students are smart enough to figure out why the analogy is a straw man argument. Perhaps some will take the time to find out what the issues really are and not simply resentment of people who have more because of their talent and hard work.

This little anecdote reminds me why I am no longer a conservative. A huge Rush Limbaugh fan I bought into this 1 dimensional thinking. Rush is very good with these kinds of silly straw men arguments. He paints his opponents as simply lazy and wanting to improve their lives by taking from the rich.

But, RandFan, that's the whole problem. No one in Occupy even seems to know what their issues are, beyond this vague "income inequality" and "wealth redistribution" stuff. Student loan relief? The Volcker Rule? Something? Anything? Bueller? Give us one thing, just one, that we can agree on as an Occupy objective.

You won't be able to, because Occupy's very structure makes it impossible. They're protesting now for its own sake, not because they have any particular agenda. And, believe me, the 99% see that. I am firmly in the 99%, and Occupy doesn't speak for me.
 
But, RandFan, that's the whole problem. No one in Occupy even seems to know what their issues are, beyond this vague "income inequality" and "wealth redistribution" stuff. Student loan relief? The Volcker Rule? Something? Anything? Bueller? Give us one thing, just one, that we can agree on as an Occupy objective.
I don't buy the meme. It strikes me largely as ad hoc rationalization. Exposing corporate corruption and malfeasance is what I want from them and IMO we are getting that. But that's fine, we can disagree about that. Like the counter culture protests of the 60s I think there is plenty to criticize and I don't mind that you do so.

You won't be able to, because Occupy's very structure makes it impossible. They're protesting now for its own sake, not because they have any particular agenda. And, believe me, the 99% see that. I am firmly in the 99%, and Occupy doesn't speak for me.
"Impossible?" When the criticism veers into absolutes I tend to lose interest in the argument.
 
I don't buy the meme. It strikes me largely as ad hoc rationalization. Exposing corporate corruption and malfeasance is what I want from them and IMO we are getting that. But that's fine, we can disagree about that. Like the counter culture protests of the 60s I think there is plenty to criticize and I don't mind that you do so.

"Impossible?" When the criticism veers into absolutes I tend to lose interest in the argument.
You don't appear to know anything about OWS.

It is what it is, however you seem to think it's what you wish it to be. It doesn't even slightly resemble what you claim it represents these days.
 
You don't appear to know anything about OWS.

It is what it is, however you seem to think it's what you wish it to be. It doesn't even slightly resemble what you claim it represents these days.
But it's just like the wonderful 60's protests! They accomplished so much, as will OWS!
 
But, RandFan, that's the whole problem. No one in Occupy even seems to know what their issues are, beyond this vague "income inequality" and "wealth redistribution" stuff. Student loan relief? The Volcker Rule? Something? Anything? Bueller? Give us one thing, just one, that we can agree on as an Occupy objective.

You won't be able to, because Occupy's very structure makes it impossible. They're protesting now for its own sake, not because they have any particular agenda. And, believe me, the 99% see that. I am firmly in the 99%, and Occupy doesn't speak for me.

And who does?

I'm not trying to be flippant. There are so many polls which show a majority of Americans are against corporate welfare, subsidies to companies with billion dollar profits, frustrated by income equality and other social issues that fall under the OWS umbrella. Our senate and congress does not address these. Instead they focus on gay marriage, the war on women and meaningless vague phrases like "job creators."

Both tea partiers and OWS are driven by the feeling that our government is an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few.
 
And who does?

I'm not trying to be flippant. There are so many polls which show a majority of Americans are against corporate welfare, subsidies to companies with billion dollar profits, frustrated by income equality and other social issues that fall under the OWS umbrella. Our senate and congress does not address these. Instead they focus on gay marriage, the war on women and meaningless vague phrases like "job creators."
Both tea partiers and OWS are driven by the feeling that our government is an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few.
This is what steams me so much. It is so transparent. But let's all calm down. Someone is sure to post an anecdote about OWS shortly and we can all laugh at that and ignore the real problems.
 
Yeah, kinda like the 60s counter culture which were an outgrowth of the civil rights movement of the 50s. The 60s saw an expansion where we had anti-war, anti-capitalism, anti-govt, women's rights, minority rights, voting rights, sexual revolution, legalizing drugs, environmentalism and gay rights, there were sit ins at campuses, marches on Washington, etc., etc.

Of course most people only know about or only remember civil rights. The protestors of the 50s, 60s and 70s were also accused of simply protesting for the sake of protesting.

Many of those groups had an actual goal that one could agree or disagree with.

And those groups that didn't, like the yippies, looked much the same as the OWS.
What, precisely, did the rioting at the 1968 Democratic National Convention accomplish other than to give Jerry Rubin and Abbie Hoffman celebrity?
Is making terrorist threats, even though the threats are not carried out, a legitimate form of protest? (I'm referring here to the threat of dosing the water supply with LSD.) I don't think so.

I'm not saying that OWS is the first hobby protest group. Let me paraphrase a line from the The Incredibles: When everything is being protested, nothing is being protested.
 
And who does?

I'm not trying to be flippant. There are so many polls which show a majority of Americans are against corporate welfare, subsidies to companies with billion dollar profits, frustrated by income equality and other social issues that fall under the OWS umbrella.

Our senate and congress does not address these. Instead they focus on gay marriage, the war on women and meaningless vague phrases like "job creators."
Because gay rights, and women's reproductive rights are minor social issues which certainly don't have protest movements and marches about them, and trying to give people jobs has nothing to do with the economy, right?

Both tea partiers and OWS are driven by the feeling that our government is an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few.
Which does not in itself mean that OWS-sorry, "street thespians"-actually represents the views of the majority.
 
Last edited:
Because gay rights, and women's reproductive rights are minor social issues which certainly don't have protest movements and marches about them, and trying to give people jobs has nothing to do with the economy, right?

Which does not in itself mean that OWS-sorry, "street thespians"-actually represents the views of the majority.

Perhaps some Americans would like to see a focus on gay rights, women's reproductive rights AND addressing corporate welfare, income inequality, and a recession caused by top-level financial gambling, and trying to pay for two wars while reducing taxes on the top 1%.

There seems to be precious little link between protecting the so-called job creators from a small tax hike and actually creating jobs.

As you pointed out, equal rights for women and gays already have activist groups. Who speaks for the rest?
 
Many of those groups had an actual goal that one could agree or disagree with.

And those groups that didn't, like the yippies, looked much the same as the OWS.
What, precisely, did the rioting at the 1968 Democratic National Convention accomplish other than to give Jerry Rubin and Abbie Hoffman celebrity?
Is making terrorist threats, even though the threats are not carried out, a legitimate form of protest? (I'm referring here to the threat of dosing the water supply with LSD.) I don't think so.

I'm not saying that OWS is the first hobby protest group. Let me paraphrase a line from the The Incredibles: When everything is being protested, nothing is being protested.
Ad hoc. I don't accept your characterization. I lived it. Much of the protests were chaotic and there was a lot of disagreement and lots of vague "love is all we need" propaganda.

As far as your other complaint, honestly, there are not many single protests that I can look at and tell you that it made a difference. I think that is a fools errand. And as for the Incredibles quote, I think that beautifully matches the 60s and 70s counter culture. They had everything. Doesn't mean that they failed though. So, it's noteworthy and thought provoking and I think it well worth discussion and consideration by those who are protesting. But, at the end of the day it strikes me as overly simplistic belied by history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom