Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
That message is long gone though. All we get now is misfit loner anarchists with unresolved anger issues compering for attention and occupiers whining about how restrictions against their tents are a violation of their rights.

It's sort of like thinking about the true meaning of Christmas on black friday.
I honestly don't know. If there is no change and OWS disappears, it won't be long before protestors are back. The 60s and 70s protests were not static. It could very well take years or even a decade or more. One reason I'm not cynical but optimistic is that we do live in a Democracy and the 60s have shown us that change can happen.
 
Once again, I have to ignore Jane (note, not Ignore) because she can't be intellectually honest in a debate, and thinks that asking questions about everything while ignoring mine (which she admits) is a valid and productive form of debate.

Dodge.

Dangling those donuts was a dick move by the protestors, period. If dangling things is so harmless, I wonder if people would find it so funny if the cops dangled, I dunno, severed heads in the face of protestors? How about sex toys? Knives? Aborted babies? Nazi flags? Because dangling things is harmless, right?

Yeah, but they didn't, did they? They dangled donuts. You're being intellectually dishonest (and a little bit weird!).


Dumbass did it in the wrong order. Shoot himself first to make sure the gun's working.
What an occutard. :boxedin:

It takes a brave man to abuse people with disabilities.


Call them tards, okay. I call the Tea Party "tea baggers"

Only difference is that the tea party were proud to tea bag, until they going out what the slang term meant....
I don't think any OWS protesters have claimed to be tards.

Shame on you, thaiboxerken.


263894fa3a4131a47e.jpg
263894fa26adf4cfd8.jpg
 
Last edited:
Do you think that they should, if they had enough money to rent the parks?

Even if you rent a park, you don't get to set your own rules. And, as you know, evil rich people/evil corporations/evil organizations only rent a park generally for a day, maybe for 2-3, if it's a weekend festival. But, as you also know, they do this by following well laid out rules, which had been agreed to via a democratic process. Did the occutards do this? (Hint: the answer begins with an "N", and is two letters)
 
Unless they have lots of money, right?

That same ruling about political speech would also apply to OWS, if they cared to organize. If people in suits were protesting something in central park, the police would hold them to the same rules as OWS

It's kind of like how digital pirates pretend that only big, evil corporations should care about copyright, when the protection of such rights really protects everyone.
 
Do you think that they should, if they had enough money to rent the parks?

Yes, as long as they don't break some other law that would give the cops cause to remove them.

Of course, this is all hypothetical, since OWS not only doesn't rent the parks, they are actively defiant of the law.
 
The tactics of the 60s demonstrators. I think most people in this thread are inconsistent. They would defend the civil disobedience of the civil rights activists but not OWS. Of course, you can always fall back on special pleading.

Civil rights activists HAD A POINT.

OWS does not.

HUGE difference between eliminating the idiocy of segregation and pissing and moaning because of a percieved slight by rich people. I really wish they'd stop calling themselves the 99% - because it's become painfully obvious that they themselves are the 1%. 1% of the idiots in this country who think defecating on a cop car will be the catalyst for sweeping change.
 
Time to put this "occupy" baloney to bed. Wait a year until it's blown over.

Then GET SOME FRIGGIN LEADERSHIP, call it something else and try again. Do it right.
 
http://www.alternet.org/rights/1552...ll_street_lead_to_another_kent_state_massacre
What’s similar today, but happening faster in our Internet-driven era, is how both sides, police and a handful of provocateurs—who may not even be associated with protesters—are willing to use violence.
Ah, yes, the "agent provocateurs" argument.

Once again, there is nothing about Occupy's stated principles that prohibits the use of violence. The only time OWS ever speaks out against violence is after it may have been perpetrated by people who may be associated by them. And as we've seen in the discussions of the UC Davis incident, many of their supporters have no problem with Occupiers deliberately threatening cops.

Basically, anything short of actually committing violence against cops is fine, and even then that's often excused or ignored (Occupy Oakland).

EDIT: Oh, and the comparison being made is ludicrous, used as a buzzword by Occupiers who want to be Oppressed without any actual thought. Today's cops are supposedly more "militarized" than those of the past, yet they have more less-lethal options and are much less likely to harm protestors than, well, other protesters? Because more people have been hurt and killed in the camps than any police action. Even assuming that those are all committed by No True Occupier, that means the general public is more dangerous to OWS members than the "militarized" cops.
 
Last edited:
I honestly don't know. If there is no change and OWS disappears, it won't be long before protestors are back. The 60s and 70s protests were not static. It could very well take years or even a decade or more. One reason I'm not cynical but optimistic is that we do live in a Democracy and the 60s have shown us that change can happen.

When they do come back, maybe they'll have some concrete demands other that all this generalisation that they're engaging in now. Which corporations ? Which politicians ? What type of regulations and on which industries ?

Right now, occupy is just blindly flinging poo at a Teflon wall hoping something sticks.
 
When they do come back, maybe they'll have some concrete demands other that all this generalisation that they're engaging in now. Which corporations ? Which politicians ? What type of regulations and on which industries ?
It's the job of the legislature to identify and solve problems. Personally I don't care about that. I just want people to understand they are being hosed. In any event, a real "volker" rule would be nice. Breaking up financial institutions so America isn't beholden to them would be really nice. A stronger SEC would be a good thing. It's not as if no one has identified the failures or make recommendations.

Right now, occupy is just blindly flinging poo at a Teflon wall hoping something sticks.
They are doing the same that the pinko commie protestors have done for decades if not more.
 
When they do come back, maybe they'll have some concrete demands ...
FWIW: I shouldn't be too dismissive of your point. It could very well be that OWS improves its rhetoric and even its tactics. I can't honestly say they've made no mistakes or that they couldn't do a better job. But as I said earlier, I can't identify precisely what worked for the 60s movement. I suspect raising awareness and agitation was the most effective but I don't think anyone knows for sure. Further, dynamics change. Assuming that agitation worked before it might not work now.

So, trying to be honest.
 
It's the job of the legislature to identify and solve problems. Personally I don't care about that. I just want people to understand they are being hosed. In any event, a real "volker" rule would be nice. Breaking up financial institutions so America isn't beholden to them would be really nice. A stronger SEC would be a good thing. It's not as if no one has identified the failures or make recommendations.

They are doing the same that the pinko commie protestors have done for decades if not more.

Yet occupy fails to articulate your recommendations. I had to look up the Volcker rule, looks like it's happening.

I posit that people know they're being hosed yet willingly submit to that hosing for reasons (mostly ) of convenience. Take credit cards and their outrageous interest rates for example. Yes you want to go out for dinner, have a nice steak and a bottle of wine, after all, isn't that what life's all about ? Slap it on the card, Bob's your mother's brother. A month or so later that meal is forgotten however that bill isn't and unless the cardholder has the resources to zero that account every month, the cost of that meal just went up.

But hey, whipping out the plastic sure was easier than hoofing it to the ATM and pushing a few buttons and maybe thinking about whether or not you want to spend the resources.

I don't know about investing in the USA but up here in Canada, if I
m dealing with a proper investment advisor I'm required to disclose both my knowledge about the industry and my risk tolerance before any money crosses the desk.
 
Please tell me how I am being hosed.
You live in a society where the govt removed regulations that had been in effect since the great depression to protect us from greed and power. Banks were allowed to become to large to fail and the govt failed to provide sufficient oversight for financial institutions putting the economy at risk. This resulted in the banking collapse and your money being used to bail out the geniuses that packaged worthless assets into complex derivatives and sold them to clients. Your money was used to purchase those worthless assets. Now, govt malfeasance and corporate corruption might not bother you. A growing debt to cover the markers for those drunk wagers might not bother you. But you still got hosed.
 
Yet occupy fails to articulate your recommendations. I had to look up the Volcker rule, looks like it's happening.
Not according to Pual Volcker. And he's right. The socalled "Volker Rule" is a joke and the powers that be are already working to undermine it more with more legislation. It's nice for corporations have lobbyists that actually write many of our laws. BTW: Just for the record, Paul Volker isn't commie pinko.

I posit that people know they're being hosed yet willingly submit to that hosing for reasons (mostly ) of convenience. Take credit cards and their outrageous interest rates for example. Yes you want to go out for dinner, have a nice steak and a bottle of wine, after all, isn't that what life's all about ? Slap it on the card, Bob's your mother's brother. A month or so later that meal is forgotten however that bill isn't and unless the cardholder has the resources to zero that account every month, the cost of that meal just went up.

But hey, whipping out the plastic sure was easier than hoofing it to the ATM and pushing a few buttons and maybe thinking about whether or not you want to spend the resources.

I don't know about investing in the USA but up here in Canada, if I
m dealing with a proper investment advisor I'm required to disclose both my knowledge about the industry and my risk tolerance before any money crosses the desk.
There's nothing here for me to respond to. The problems are a bit more complex than that. My concern BTW is primarily more to do with US problems than globalization in general. But I do think globalization is a serious problem that can't be so glibly pawned off onto consumers and investors.
 
Last edited:
Raising awareness about corporate corruption and changing the status quo is a difficult goal but not impossible.
Goals that sfaik only you ascribe to OWS.

ps. You also seem to think the 60's protest were instrumental in ending Vietnam; I think you have a correlation =/= causation problem. IMO, CBS news and Cronkite ended the war.
 
Goals that sfaik only you ascribe to OWS.
Not sure if what you "know" is of any significance.

ps. You also seem to think the 60's protest were instrumental in ending Vietnam; I think you have a correlation =/= causation problem. IMO, CBS news and Cronkite ended the war.
We don't know what the cause of the end of the war is to any certainty. Likewise we don't know if the civil rights protests had any affect on anything. We don't know if any social event has any affect on anything to any 100% certainty. There is only correlation and some controls. I don't think that the idea at all controversial among social scientists. If you want to adopt global skepticism when it suits you then be my guest.

{sigh}
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom