Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I NEVER disputed that the protestors wanted a confrontation or provoked a response, THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH MY CONTENTION. ZERO ZIP NADA.

On the contrary Noah, I conceded this a day or two ago.

So you've seen the video's.

Why do you keep asking for evidence if you admit you've seen it? that's what's so damn baffling about this.

You keep asking for things you've been provided, and now have said you've been provided.
 
He didn't say he saw the videos. In fact, he very carefully did not say he saw the videos.
 
Did you watch the video?
Yes. Don't ask again.

So you know their options were limited at that point, so what is it we're discussing again?
  • If the police didn't have pepper spray then they would not have been without other non-lethal options.
  • That some of those options were considered safer (or preferable to pepper spray).
When Is Pepper Spray Excessive Force?

In a ranking of police officer use of non-lethal force in a study of 7,512 arrests (pdf), deploying pepper spray ranked 45.9 on scale of 1 (no action) to 82 (use of handgun); the average ranking was 30.0.
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.
 
So you've seen the video's.

Why do you keep asking for evidence if you admit you've seen it? that's what's so damn baffling about this.
... I'm really trying here. But not for much longer at this rate. I'm not browbeating or berating you. I expect to be treated in kind.

You keep asking for things you've been provided, and now have said you've been provided.
What evidence do you suppose the video reveals and provides that I've been asking for?
 
Last edited:
  • If the police didn't have pepper spray then they would not have been without other non-lethal options

Correct.

  • That some of those options were considered safer (or preferable to pepper spray).

Disputed. You've gathered data that says Pepper-spray is dangerous in X amount of cases. Find the other relevant data for other non-lethal options if you wish to compare the two.

Regardless, these other "safer" options were attempted, and some disregarded per the situation the officers found themselves in. This is standard police escalation procedure, and it is observable in the video you said you've watched.
 
Last edited:
Are we still talking about the pepper spray incident?

I bet even the people who got sprayed have moved on already.
 
What evidence do you suppose the video reveals and provides that I've been asking for?

Police escalation procedures that lead up to the use of pepper-spray. Please observe Robrob's photo that graphs the escalation procedure, maybe juxtaposed with the video that's been posted?
 
Last edited:
Are we still talking about the pepper spray incident?

I bet even the people who got sprayed have moved on already.

Everything else involving OWS is less than exciting. It's no surprise this is a hot topic.

What else are we going to talk about Pardalis? :D
 
Still waiting for you to address my arguments with something more than gainsaying.

Odd that you won't address my arguments with anything substantive. Gainsaying makes for poor argument. In fact, it's not argument at all.
Your arguments? You have yet to make a single argument that supports your claim!

You know, like comparing pepper-spray rates of injury and death to to other non-lethal force available to police.

This is central to your argument, and you haven't even attempted to show evidence of it. The pdf doesn't even address injuries caused by various methods, let alone quantify them.

Valid criticisms of the court cases you cited have gone ignored by you.

You claim to want a rational discussion, yet you refuse to have one.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Don't ask again.


  • If the police didn't have pepper spray then they would not have been without other non-lethal options.
  • That some of those options were considered safer (or preferable to pepper spray).
We've already told you. All of those were more likely to cause damage or were tried, and that list is not an objective ranking of safety. In addition, almost all of those were unavailable to the police, because the protestors had taken measures to prevent them. And again; you are arguing police should kick protestors before deciding to pepper spray. Spitting is ranked lower than pepper spray. You're saying spitting, choke holds, using a helicopter, and biting suspects would've been appropriate, just because they were ranked lower.

And again, you're relying on someone else's opinion of something instead of forming one yourself. If you actually checked the PDF, you might've noticed the survey also included the circumstances in which force was deployed. The fact that you're just reposting TMV's interpretation means you're just parroting again.
 
Last edited:
When Is Pepper Spray Excessive Force?

In a ranking of police officer use of non-lethal force in a study of 7,512 arrests (pdf), deploying pepper spray ranked 45.9 on scale of 1 (no action) to 82 (use of handgun); the average ranking was 30.0.
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.

Threaten use of chemical agent was "deployed".
Handcuffs could not be deployed.
Batons could have been deployed, but would obviously be viewed by anybody not named RandFan as excessive force.
Ditto with twisting arms that are interlocked (is that even possible?) kicking, or hitting.
Can't chase with a car.
Pressure holds? Perhaps. I don't know enough about them to say if they'd have worked or not.

So there you have it. From where I'm sitting, we have ONE thing that could have been used aside from pepper spray. Seeing as though these are the people there on scene, I'll defer to their judgement.

I was on your side at first - livid at the use of pepper spray. Then I saw the whole story, not the occutard edited propoganda version.
 
... I'm really trying here. But not for much longer at this rate. I'm not browbeating or berating you. I expect to be treated in kind.

No, you're not browbeating or berating me. You're ignoring. What's worse? I dunno. Both are damn frustrating though.

What evidence do you suppose the video reveals and provides that I've been asking for?

That the list of tactics you provided aside from pepper spray were indeed deployed - or it showed that they could not have been deployed.
 
Look, I'm honestly not trying to be snarky. I resent being told there is evidence out there somewhere and then being refused the evidence or links to that evidence.
Like when I asked you to quote the parts of your pdf that you think shows that pepper spray is more dangerous than other means of force available? :rolleyes:

There is much hypocrisy from you in this thread. You demand evidence that disprove your claim, and refuse to provide evidence that proves your own claim. This is a skeptics board, if you make the claim you must provide the evidence for it, you don't get to demand that others prove you wrong.

And when you claim a document you found provides evidence of your claim it is up to you to identify which parts of the document supports your claim and why. You haven't done any of this.
 
Charles J. Kelly, a former Baltimore Police Department lieutenant who wrote the department's use of force guidelines, said pepper spray is a "compliance tool" that can be used on subjects who do not resist, and is preferable to simply lifting protesters.


"When you start picking up human bodies, you risk hurting them," Kelly said. "Bodies don't have handles on them."


After reviewing the video, Kelly said he observed at least two cases of "active resistance" from protesters. In one instance, a woman pulls her arm back from an officer. In the second instance, a protester curls into a ball. Each of those actions could have warranted more force, including baton strikes and pressure-point techniques.


"What I'm looking at is fairly standard police procedure," Kelly said.
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-201_162-57328362/officers-in-pepper-spray-incident-put-on-leave/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom