Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ignorant means you don't know.

If you were on here trying to tell me that RGB is the best color space for printing offset, I'd tell you you're wrong. You'd be ignorant of the CMYK color space. You wouldn't know.

Then I'd educate you.

Then you'd know.

See how that works?

__________ = Better than Pepper Spray.

Anddd GO



For the love of God and everything decent in this world, I'm asking YOUR OPINION! HELP me contribute.
3 to 5 posts before he Ignores you. Place your bets, ladies and germs.
 
See, you are playing a game. You are pretending that either A.) Police never arrested anyone prior to pepper spray or B.) those methods were more dangerous.


And you got that...where?

Don't be putting words in my mouth. I may have to use the ignore feature.

:D
 
Because the protestors were actively preventing them from doing their jobs. Specifically, breaking down the Occupy camp.

They weren't "peacefully" protesting. They were obstructing police. If they were protesting anything, it was the presence of cops themselves, judging by their chants of "Cops off campus!" and "**** the police!"

Why was it so important that they break down the Occupy camp?

Say, did you ever respond to my post with all the links to people saying Megyn Kelly should be sprayed with pepper spray?

Yes.

Hey guys, this is what happens when I tell RandFan to actually learn for himself what he's talking about.


No, he put you on ignore for being dishonest:


Stop it. Have an honest conversation with me or I'm putting you on ignore.
 
Ignorant means you don't know.If you were on here trying to tell me that RGB is the best color space for printing offset, I'd tell you you're wrong. You'd be ignorant of the CMYK color space. You wouldn't know.
Wait, hold on. Just a moment. You ARE NOT LISTENTING.

Please for the love of god would you stop, take a deep breath and follow the logic? Please?

  • Okay, prior to pepper spray the police arrested people. Right?
  • Then the police started using pepper spray. Right?
  • Then people died. Right?
  • People were injured. Right?
Are you with me so far?

Okay,

  • So the California appeals court issues a ruling that pepper spray can be an excessive force in an example similar to this one.
  • The ACLU issues a report documenting the problems of pepper spray.
Now, is there something about that, that you do not understand?


For the love of God and everything decent in this world, I'm asking YOUR OPINION! HELP me contribute.

HERE IS YOUR ANSWER! Already posted.

Pepper Spray Incidents Backfire In California and Oregon; When Is Pepper Spray Excessive Force?

In a ranking of police officer use of non-lethal force in a study of 7,512 arrests (pdf), deploying pepper spray ranked 45.9 on scale of 1 (no action) to 82 (use of handgun); the average ranking was 30.0.
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.
 
Last edited:
Why was it so important that they break down the Occupy camp?

Because protecting the rights of the students not taking part in the protest (which had nothing to do with OWS, but with police action at Berkely) is more important than allowing U.C. Davis protesters to squat on the quad.
 
Remember Nathan Brown, the assistant professor of English, who organized the protest at UC-Davis and described himself in a poorly-written letter as an asset to the college community (while insisting the chancellor wasn't)?

Here's his webpage, where he describes his specialty as:

Holy crap! I had to google more than half of that webpage, just to find out what he's about.

Instead of going all protesty about having to pay to much money to study all that stuff, maybe they should refocus their energies and inquire as to what happens to Mr. Brown's students after they graduate.

Do they find jobs utilizing that type of coursework, or will we see them at the next occupy holding signs lamenting how they spent 15K/year on tuition, plus living expenses and now they can't find a job in their "fields" ?

I don't know about the USA, but in Canada the days of going to university and getting a degree in anything you want, then finding a good job ended in
the 1970s.
 
Why was it so important that they break down the Occupy camp?

Irrelevant for the purposes of this discussion. They were preventing police from doing their job.

(You guys know the police is in the 99%, right?)
 
Wait, hold on. Just a moment. You ARE NOT LISTENTING.

Please for the love of god would you stop, take a deep breath and follow the logic? Please?


  • Okay, prior to pepper spray the police arrested people. Right?
  • The the police started using pepper spray. Right?
  • Then people died. Right?
  • People were injured. Right?
Are you with me so far?
Wrong.

The list implies people only started dying and being injured during arrests after pepper spray was employed, which is manifestly not the case. If this were the conspiracy forum, I'd nominate it for a Stundie.

  • So the California appeals court issues a ruling that pepper spray can be an excessive force in an example similar to this one.
  • The ACLU issues a report documenting the problems of pepper spray.
Now, is there something about that, that you do not understand?
The case differs in several critical factors, as has been pointed out.

Why won't you follow the links.
Why are you unable to restate what they say in your own words?

HERE IS YOUR ANSWER! Already posted.
So you're saying kicking protestors is better than pepper spray?

The other options were unfeasible, specifically because of the protestors' linked-arm setup designed to make those measures unfeasible. They wanted to make the police use force in a big, showy manner, or leave.
 
HERE IS YOUR ANSWER! Already posted.

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.

Please watch the video again and explain what you see insofar as police escalation goes. Explain how the use of handcuffs on a human chain will not result in injuries greater than or equal to the use of pepper spray.
 
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.

But some of those were not available to the cops.

You would not be able to handcuff them. You can't twist their arms if they're already forming a human chain. As for the baton, kicking or hitting? The same reaction would take place. They'd be crucified just as quick as if they had used pepper spray.
You have to know that.

It's called inference.

Your inference skills are lacking for a moment.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant for the purposes of this discussion. They were preventing police from doing their job.

Irrelevant.

(You guys know the police is in the 99%, right?)

How is this relevant?

(Which "guys" are you addressing?)

Why was it deemed necessary to "break down" the camp? It could simply have been left where it was.

The police could also have chosen not to arrest the seated protestors.
 
But some of those were not available to the cops.

You would not be able to handcuff them. You can't twist their arms if they're already forming a human chain. As for the baton, kicking or hitting? The same reaction would take place. They'd be crucified just as quick as if they had used pepper spray.
You have to know that.

Let's parse that, "we will be in trouble for using less harmful means so let's use more harmful means."

You have to know that police DO arrest protestors in similar situations without pepper spray, right?
 
Yes. And I don't fault the police for doing their job. I do fault them when I believe that they use excessive force.

Every time you post, it's more obvious you did not watch the video I posted.

Proper escalation was used. Several methods, per police doctrine that you linked to, were not used as it was not feasible. This would be the police forgoing the option to use handcuffs, as they were dealing with a physical human chain that would have to be pried apart manually.
 
Let's parse that, "we will be in trouble for using less harmful means so let's use more harmful means."

You have to know that police DO arrest protestors in similar situations without pepper spray, right?

Please list a similar situation - hundreds of protesters surrounding a small contingent of police, verbally threatening them, and preventing them from peacefully doing their jobs where a small number of them are pepper-sprayed.

(No, your black bear situation is not similar unless you explain why/how).
 
I'm still wating for your sources.
And I'm not going to go back through the thread and hand feed them to you.

Still waiting for those sources.
Already cited. Don't expect to arrive late then demand everyone else get you up to speed.

Oh, the ever elusive, I lost my homework.
Not at all. It's there. I'm not redoing it because of your laziness.


Wow! It always amazes me when someone passes up an opportunity to post evidence which they think supports their claim.

I could understand a person asked for evidence saying, it would be very time-consuming to find good sources to support what I'm saying and I don't have time to research this at the moment. But you say you've already already presented this evidence -- but don't want to take the time or effort to present it again.

Now as for me, I'm delighted to re-post evidence as often as people need to see it. If I've got strong evidence for the point I'm making, I'd be happy to post it and re-post it and re-post it, on every page of a thread, to make sure people who hadn't seen it could see it. The reason I don't is because most people would think of that as spamming.

But here RandFan has invited you to post this strong evidence of yours. Here's your chance to make this evidence available not only to RandFan but to anyone else who didn't see it when you first posted it. And you can't be criticized for red-posting it, or accused of spamming, because you were asked to re-post it. Sweet!

Yet for some reason you don't want to take advantage of the invitation. You'd rather waste time calling RandFan lazy (which is unlikely to convince RandFan -- or anyone else -- of the merits of what you're saying) than to simply post the evidence and demonstrate how strong your case is.

I don't know what your reason for being reluctant to post your evidence is. But in the past I've noticed a strong correlation people making excuses for not posting evidence they claim to have and the evidence turning out to be non-existent or exceedingly weak.
 
Last edited:
The police could also have chosen not to arrest the seated protestors.
Yes. But that would have shown contempt.

We need to understand something important here. We need to discuss the elephant in the room.

  • Protests are used because they can be effective.
  • The people the protests are aimed at don't want the protests.
  • The protestors are violating the law.
  • The people who don't want the protests can use the law to stop the protests.
  • This is a war between the powers that be and the protestors.
  • Protestors use public anger and they desire confrontation.
  • It's STUPID TO PLAY INTO THEIR HANDS. But that's just my opinion.
To some degree the police are pawns of the powers that be and the protestors.
 
Irrelevant.



How is this relevant?

(Which "guys" are you addressing?)

Why was it deemed necessary to "break down" the camp? It could simply have been left where it was.

The police could also have chosen not to arrest the seated protestors.

That's why I asked earlier. Were they not blocking the police from removing people who were already arrested?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom