Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You were the one who tried to link the two. Why do I have to do your homework?
There is NO difference. That's patently obvious. Both groups broke the law. Both groups suffered the consequences of breaking the law.

One can give an opinion on a topic, no?
I'm giving you my honest opinion. If I were in charge I damn well wouldn't arrest them. But I'm biased. I'm honest about that. To say "no they shouldn't be arrested" would be to insert my bias. I'm not in charge. I don't know the various issues to be weighed.

Do you have any sort of source that backs up your claim that police do in fact deal with protesters on a regular basis by physically pulling the chain apart? Please, provide a link.
Straw man. I provided a link where the police deal with chains.


Since you do not agree the protesters should have been arrested, I think it's safe to say any measure of force would be considered excessive.
A.) I'm not contesting that they should not have been arrested. That's a canard. B.) I concede that the protestors INTENTIONALLY put themselves at risk. It IS IN PART THEIR FAULT. C.) I have for years, on this very forum, maintained that protestors MUST bear the consequences of their actions. D.) That does not justify the use of more force than is necessary.

Now, about that ACLU report. Do you have evidence that the use of pepper spray is less harmful than other means? Or will you keep dodging every question I ask?

And let's be honest, you do keep dodging my questions. I answer questions. Problem is I can't get answers.

Will you finally address my questions?
 
I'm still wating for your sources.
And I'm not going to go back through the thread and hand feed them to you.

Still waiting for those sources.
Already cited. Don't expect to arrive late then demand everyone else get you up to speed.

Oh, the ever elusive, I lost my homework.
Not at all. It's there. I'm not redoing it because of your laziness.


Straw man. The appeals court, DA and Sheriff of Yolo county.
What part of "investigating" do you not understand? "investigating" does not equal "they did not follow the correct protocol". It means they are looking at what happened to make sure procedures were followed. The appeals court was not based on what happened in Davis, it was a separate different situation. I provided testimony from current police experts who viewed the video of the Davis incident. You have provided nothing.

Folks, we can have a discussion. But it isn't going to work if we are are only talking past each other. I will commit to toning it down a bit but I ask you to also. Can we have a rational discussion without recriminations?
Sure, but it's hard to do when you demand to discuss an incident that was already discussed and won't take the time to read the previous discussion and demand that everyone repeat and dig up everything that was already posted.

Given that there are serious potential health risks associated with pepper spray I find it difficult to buy into the argument that pepper spray is used to ensure the safety of protestors.
It doesn't matter whether you buy into it or not. It is the best choice as determined by standard police procedures.

I don't think that is warranted and as of yet no one, as far as I know, has posted any data showing pepper spray to be less harmful than other means.
That's because you don't really want to know. It's already been cited. You are too lazy to go back through the thread and read it.

000063 said:
There is no feasible alternative to pepper spray in that particular situation that was less of a risk of damage. If there is, Rand does not know what it is. He has admitted it, yet refuses to listen to people who actually know what they're talking about, or to educate himself on the use of force continuum. I'd really like to see the source of his claims about the police departments offering their opinion, but I can't, because I have him on ignore.
Rest assured, he doesn't. His lack of initiative and honesty is tempting me to put him on ignore as well.
 
If I may, pepper spray is far less harmful than other methods.


Like steamrolling them into the pavement and picking them up with an oversized spatula.


Seriously though - off the top of my head, I can't think of any less harmful methods that are still effective.
 
No such thing exists.

Glad we agree.

The question is what is the safest tactic.

The 'safest' tactic is to leave them alone. You must of course find a balance between safety and effectiveness. Thus far, you have not addressed what would be more effective, and less dangerous, than pepper spray. Simply saying "pepper spray is too dangerous" doesn't answer the question.

Do you have evidence that pepper spray is safer for the protestors than pepper spray? ACLU prepared a report that says no.

This doesn't make much sense, but if you're asking do I have evidence that pepper spray is safe, the obvious answer is..well, obvious.

Getting into that article, you should read section 1 of :

Model Oleoresin Capsicum Policy
Police Departments
To: All commands, divisions and/or precincts
Subject: Use of Oleoresin Capsicum (pepper spray) products


Most interestingly:

When use of force is necessary and appropriate, officers shall, to the greatest extent possible, utilize an escalating scale of options and
not employ more forceful measures unless it is determined that a lower level of force would not be adequate, or such a level of force is
attempted and actually found to be inadequate. It is not the intent of this policy to require officers to try each of the options before escalating
to the next. Clearly, good judgment and the circumstances of each situation will dictate the level at which an officer will start. Officers using
any type of force are accountable for its use.

OC should be used only against violent or hostile subjects. It is a defensive weapon intended for use when attempting to subdue an
unarmed attacker or to overcome resistance likely to result in injury to either the suspect, officer or bystander.

The amount and degree of force that may be employed will be determined by the surrounding circumstances including, but not limited
to: a) the nature of the offense; b) the behavior of the subject against whom force is to be used; c) actions by third parties who may be
present; d) physical odds against the officer; and e) the feasibility or availability of alternative actions.

Please list what alternative actions would be possible in the situation at U.C. Davis.

[/quote]

They are called bolt cutters and there is documented evidence that they work.

We are talking about human chains made of blood and flesh, not of metal.

Please think critically.
 
Last edited:
You must of course find a balance between safety and effectiveness.

Given:

  • Pepper spray is known to be potentially harmful.
  • Police have, for years, dealt with protestors without the use of pepper spray.
To justify the risk the onus is on you I'm afraid. It is not my to prove that pepper spray is unjustified. I've given you a report that shows that pepper spray to be potentially harmful. Show me that not using pepper spray on seated protestors is more harmful.

Please think critically.
I commited to toning down the rhetoric. I will keep my commitment but if you can't comport yourself with a minimum of decorum then I'm going to put you on ignore.

  • You are the one that mentioned chain ("officers tugged on a chain", "pulled it harder").
  • I didn't remember a chain.
  • So, I watched a 4 camera perspective and did see officers pulling on a metal chain.
  • So, I posted a link to a Google search for protestors and chains.
  • You didn't object.
Again, if you continue to patronize and act like that I will put you on ignore. Are you sincerely interested in a rational and honest discussion?
 
Last edited:
Given:

  • Pepper spray is known to be potentially harmful.
  • Police have, for years, dealt with protestors without the use of pepper spray.

What methods were used to control rights and arrest protesters before the 90s that resulted in fewer injuries?

To justify the risk the onous is on you I'm affraid.

I am not the one objecting to its' use. You are the one who first mentioned it being dangerous. Well if it's dangerous, there must be safer alternatives to controlling a riot.

Not me to prove that pepper spray is jsutified. I've given you a report that shows that pepper spray to be potentially harmful. Show me that not using pepper spray on seated protestors is harmful.

I never said it wasn't harmful. Every thing used to break up a riot or subdue protesters has the potential to be harmful. Your own article, I think, suggests using tear gas in a situation like U.C. Davis was justified, but I don't think you read the part I quoted.


  • You are the one that mentioned chain ("officers tugged on a chain", "pulled it harder").
  • I didn't remember a chain.

Please think abstractly/critically. When people link up their arms, they are forming a human chain. How does one break apart a human chain without injuring both protester and officer?
 
Please list what alternative actions would be possible in the situation at U.C. Davis.
I asked. Three times. He admits he doesn't know.

I'd like to point out that the standard escalation of force, according to thirty seconds on Wikipedia, which John Galt here apparently finds too strenuous, is from officer presence, to verbal command, to gentle physical compulsion, then to pepper spray. All of those were tried at UC Davis.

I also don't think Rand has ever even acknowledged the possibility the cops were in the right. I've acknowledged they might be wrong. Falsifiability is a vital part of skepticism and scientific inquiry.
 
I'd like to point out that the standard escalation of force, according to thirty seconds on Wikipedia, which John Galt here apparently finds too strenuous, is from officer presence, to verbal command, to gentle physical compulsion, then to pepper spray. All of those were tried at UC Davis.

All of which are seen in the video I posted.
 
What methods were used to control rights and arrest protesters before the 90s that resulted in fewer injuries?
Cue repetition of previous points, and/or bleats of not being an expert.

I think it is entirely possible to have a valid opinion on the matter without being an expert.

I am not the one objecting to its' use. You are the one who first mentioned it being dangerous. Well if it's dangerous, there must be safer alternatives to controlling a riot.
Strictly speaking, it being dangerous does not necessarily mean there are safer alternatives. However, IIRC, Rand said there were, but has refused to name them.

I never said it wasn't harmful. Every thing used to break up a riot or subdue protesters has the potential to be harmful. Your own article, I think, suggests using tear gas in a situation like U.C. Davis was justified, but I don't think you read the part I quoted.
Which is why they are now called "less-lethal" rather than "non-lethal". However, they are still distinct from "deadly force".

Please think abstractly/critically. When people link up their arms, they are forming a human chain. How does one break apart a human chain without injuring both protester and officer?
That should really be an "or", not an "and".
 
All of which are seen in the video I posted.
Yet curiously, the most distributed version of the video starts when Pike steps over the line. Almost as if it was deliberately edited out, or deemed irrelevant. But those upstanding, honest folks at Occupy would never do that, would they?
 
Seriously though - off the top of my head, I can't think of any less harmful methods that are still effective.
Argument from ignorance. Do you have any evidence that this is true? People have died from pepper spray. How many protestors have died from officers arresting them while linked up in similar fashion to the ones detailed in the link I provided by the California appeals court? They ruled that it was excessive force. Those people were linked.

This is what frustrates me.

  • I provide a link from a court decision stating that use of pepper spray in a similar situation is excessive.
  • I provide a link for an ACLU report that cites scientific data.
What do I get?

  • Argument by assertion.
  • Argument from ignorance.
And I'M told to think critically.

Can you see why I'm reasonably frustrated?
 
Yet curiously, the most distributed version of the video starts when Pike steps over the line. Almost as if it was deliberately edited out, or deemed irrelevant. But those upstanding, honest folks at Occupy would never do that, would they?

It took almost two weeks to get that footage out, and it's been a week still before it really gets noticed.

By now, most people have made up their minds and won't care what actually happened, or will excuse away, or ignore, the obvious facts. See: RandFan.

And nothing of value was lost.
 
I tell him to think for himself, then he Ignores me.
You tell him to think critically, he Ignores you.

I'm noticing a pattern here.

I was watching longer vids from around the 20s of November. I like how Rand insisted he didn't know much about what he was talking about whenever someone asked him for evidence, then he would act like his opinion is superior to that of people who clearly know more than him. Textbook sophist.
 
Last edited:
People have died from pepper spray.

People have died by beaing beaten with batons, and helmets, and shields - still in use, and not so taboo. Why are you so selective?

How many protestors have died from officers arresting them while linked up in similar fashion to the ones detailed in the link I provided by the California appeals court?

One in 600 cases, according to your source.

They ruled that it was excessive force. Those people were linked.

Not in the same way U.C. Davis protesters were linked. The case you linked to would be like someone in handcuffs, shackled to a pipe being pepper sprayed. Obviously they can't go anywhere, and can't hurt anyone.



  • I provide a link from a court decision stating that use of pepper spray in a similar situation is excessive.

Saying it's a similar situation doesn't make it a similar situation. Please explain how they are similar?

  • I provide a link for an ACLU report that cites scientific data.

Scientific data that non-lethal ordinance can be lethal? Stop the presses folks. Every piece in the Police arsenal has the ability to be harmful/lethal. Please list alternatives that could be used to subdue protesters without causing similar damage, or less. You have been challenged repeatedly to do this and you have failed repeatedly.

And I'M told to think critically.

Yes, you were being a wise-ass, or you were obviously 100% oblivious to what I was referring to. For what it's worth, I'm sorry what I said ruffled your feathers so much, but if you can't think abstractly that's not my problem.
 
Last edited:
One more time:

For those sincerely interested in a rational discussion.
​

http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1332957.html
United States Court of Appeals,Ninth Circuit.
HEADWATERS FOREST DEFENSE v. COUNTY OF HUMBOLDT

During three nonviolent protests against the logging of ancient redwood trees in the Headwaters Forest, plaintiffs-appellants (“protestors”) linked themselves together with self-releasing lock-down devices known as “black bears.”   A “black bear” is a cylinder with a rod or post welded into the center. The protestors placed their arms into the steel cylinders and attached steel bracelets worn around their wrists to the center rods or posts in the “black bears” by using mountain climbers' carabiners.   When in place, the devices immobilized their arms and prevented their separation, although the protestors could disengage themselves from the devices by unclipping the carabiners from inside the cylinders.   From 1990 until the fall of 1997, defendants had forcibly, but safely, removed hundreds of “black bears” from protestors' arms by cutting the cylinders with a hand-held electric grinder.

We concluded in our prior opinion that, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the protestors, a rational juror could conclude that the use of pepper spray against the protestors constituted excessive force and that Lewis and Philip were liable for the protestors' unconstitutional injury.​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom