Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's a post at the Moderate Voice which lists less forceful measures that could have been used at Davis:

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.

Obviously they were unable to use handcuffs or twisting an arm because of the human chain. They did threaten use of chemical agents. Chasing the suspects in a car is out, so that leaves pressure hold, kicking or hitting the suspects.

Which of those would be okay with you, Randfan?
 
Problem is, none of those are really lesser uses. They were informed that they would likely be hit with pepper spray.
 
Argument from ignorance. Do you have any evidence that this is true?

You may want to read that post of mine again. Next time, don't be so quick to jump down my throat.

"Argument from ignorance"....

NO KIDDING. I even said it.

Hint:

When I said "I can't think of...."

That was YOUR cue to educate me.
 
Last edited:
From my link above.

From 1990 until the fall of 1997, defendants had forcibly, but safely, removed hundreds of “black bears” from protestors' arms by cutting the cylinders with a hand-held electric grinder.
Also, in regards to the information I provided earlier about civil disobedience and the role of police.

Police tactics at protests

Police have a great deal of discretion in the way they deal with protests. Police do not mechanically enforce the law and will often ignore minor breaches of the law.

Enforcing the law actually makes up a small proportion of police action at protests. Police are also aware of civil disobedience and its use as a political tactic and will sometimes not arrest to undermine the political meaning generated by arrest and subsequent court and legal processes.
Police often play a careful and strategic role at protests, which is most often designed to maintain control ( Alderson 1998; Della Porta and Reiter 1998 ). Having said that, police often make mistakes, misinterpret the situation and choose highly ineffective

There are four very common police approaches to controlling protest actions:
Negotiation or directives:

Accommodation:

Containment: Use of Force and the Law
Use of reasonable force'

In many circumstances, police are empowered to use "reasonable force" in executing their powers. This includes the power of arrest, the power to take finger prints and forensic samples and the power to detain. Police also now have the power to use capsicum spray and in some instances stun guns to restrain people who are violent or threatening violence.
What is "reasonable force"? This depends upon the circumstances. A good guide is that the police are entitled to use whatever force the average person would accept as necessary and proportionate in the circumstances. The greater the physical threat to the police, the greater force it may be acceptable to use to detain a person.



"Reasonable force" does not include assaulting people on arrest, arbitrary use of hand-cuffs or verbal intimidation.



Ultimately the courts decide what constitutes reasonable force when police action is challenged. In circumstances where there are a large number of protesters engaged in resolute civil disobedience police may choose not to arrest, or only arrest selected protesters. They could also engage in mass arrests or use dispersal tactics.
Again, not my call. This demand that I must prove that pepper spray is excessive force is unreasonable. It is up to the police to follow reasonable procedures. It is up to them to justify such efforts that cause pain and can kill.
 
Here's a post at the Moderate Voice which lists less forceful measures that could have been used at Davis:

Obviously they were unable to use handcuffs or twisting an arm because of the human chain. They did threaten use of chemical agents. Chasing the suspects in a car is out, so that leaves pressure hold, kicking or hitting the suspects.

Which of those would be okay with you, Randfan?
Sorry I AM going to respond.
In a ranking of police officer use of non-lethal force in a study of 7,512 arrests (pdf), deploying pepper spray ranked 45.9 on scale of 1 (no action) to 82 (use of handgun); the average ranking was 30.0.
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.
Since there is little evidence die from the other methods and since YOUR link by officers of risk puts those methods below spraying then I would say those methods.
 
Last edited:
The differences between the two cases have been explained to you repeatedly. The biggest one is that there was an alternative available to the HCSO to affect a removal which did not require the use of force. There was no such option available to the UC Davis cops, and all standard lesser uses of force had been tried. Your attempt to strawman the situation into a binary of "harmful" and "harmless" is transparent, as are your attempts to claim a false equivalence to the Humboldt case.


Why was it so important that the "cops" do anything at all?
 
That was YOUR cue to educate me.
Sorry, not my job. I've given you court decisions. I've given you an ACLU report. And you've given me? Argument from ignorance (I don't care that you are using it as a rhetorical device).

Do you have anything to support your position? Yes? No? .... I'm waiting.

Bob: Is there a better method?
Tim: I don't know.
Bob: Well, then let's spray them.

Good, real good. BTW, the report by the ACLU points to a dearth of data provided by law enforcement. Seems that what you don't know won't hurt you.
 
Sorry, not my job. I've given you court decisions. I've given you an ACLU report. And you've given me? Argument from ignorance (I don't care that you are using it as a rhetorical device).

Do you have anything to support your position? Yes? No? .... I'm waiting.

Bob: Is there a better method?
Tim: I don't know.
Bob: Well, then let's spray them.

Good, real good. BTW, the report by the ACLU points to a dearth of data provided by law enforcement. Seems that what you don't know won't hurt you.

insufferable.


You're painting yourself as the resident expert on what's better than pepper spray.

I can't think of anything better than pepper spray, so I'm deferring to your expertise. I'm asking to be educated here. Whose to say I'm not going to be on your side?

Your response is pathetic and expected.


ETA - Uh.... do you know what "ignorant" means?
 
insufferable.
:rolleyes:


You're painting yourself as the resident expert on what's better than pepper spray.
No. On the contrary I've said over and over and over THAT I'M NOT AN EXPERT!

Dude, ONE MORE TIME,

  • I gave you an ACLU report.
  • I gave you a court finding.
Whose to say I'm not going to be on your side?
hmmm...

Your response is pathetic and expected.
Well, you have your answer then don't you....

If you can't act in a civil manner then you can be put on ignore also.
 
Sorry, not my job. I've given you court decisions. I've given you an ACLU report. And you've given me? Argument from ignorance (I don't care that you are using it as a rhetorical device).

Do you have anything to support your position? Yes? No? .... I'm waiting.

Bob: Is there a better method?
Tim: I don't know.
Bob: Well, then let's spray them.
Straw man. Tim's answer, as Noah, and several others are all asserting, was "no". Not "IDK", not "I'm not an expert", an unequivocal no. Tim better represents your position of self-admitted lack of knowledge than those of the officers.

Good, real good. BTW, the report by the ACLU points to a dearth of data provided by law enforcement. Seems that what you don't know won't hurt you.
The ACLU report is from the 90s, IIRC, does not state how many people were exposed to pepper spray overall, and has a remarkably loose definition of fatalities from such.
 
ETA - Uh.... do you know what "ignorant" means?
Yeah, you.

  • You refuse to accept the data I provide.
  • You refuse to lift a finger to find anything out so you can contribute.
That's not just ignorant, it's willful ignorance.
 
Why was it so important that the "cops" do anything at all?
Because the protestors were actively preventing them from doing their jobs. Specifically, breaking down the Occupy camp.

They weren't "peacefully" protesting. They were obstructing police. If they were protesting anything, it was the presence of cops themselves, judging by their chants of "Cops off campus!" and "**** the police!"

Say, did you ever respond to my post with all the links to people saying Megyn Kelly should be sprayed with pepper spray?
 
Let me try this simpler:

Pepper Spray = Bad

In your opinion,

___________ = Better than Pepper Spray.

Annd... Go

The means they used BEFORE pepper spray. But Brainster posted a link. I posted a link.

But that misses the point.

Pepper spray is known to contribute to death during police arrests.
ARE THERE REPORTS OF THE OTHER METHODS USED THAT KILLED?

See, you are playing a game. You are pretending that either A.) Police never arrested anyone prior to pepper spray or B.) those methods were more dangerous.

  • Is absurd.
  • The appeals court and ACLU say no to "B".
 
Yeah, you.

  • You refuse to accept the data I provide.
  • You refuse to lift a finger to find anything out so you can contribute.
That's not just ignorant, it's willful ignorance.

Ignorant means you don't know.

If you were on here trying to tell me that RGB is the best color space for printing offset, I'd tell you you're wrong. You'd be ignorant of the CMYK color space. You wouldn't know.

Then I'd educate you.

Then you'd know.

See how that works?

__________ = Better than Pepper Spray.

Anddd GO

You refuse to lift a finger to find anything out so you can contribute.

For the love of God and everything decent in this world, I'm asking YOUR OPINION! HELP me contribute.
 
Yeah, you.

  • You refuse to accept the data I provide.
  • You refuse to lift a finger to find anything out so you can contribute.
That's not just ignorant, it's willful ignorance.
Says the guy who can't go back a few pages in this very thread to find someone's information, and admits he's not an expert then ignores people who know more about the subject than him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom