Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think randfan is including incidents in which protestors were evicted from public parks in accordance with local ordinances and laws in those jurisdictions. I've seen many of those twisted into violations of the first amendment. Incidents where the first amendment right to free speech is conflated with the ability to violate said ordinances. I'm not against outcry for incidents like the pepperspray one with the protestors doing nothing wrong, but other incidents of conflating law enforcement with constitutional rights violations is another matter.
Don't you get it? The First Amendment is the absolute tippy-top of all laws, and trumps all others. As long as you're exercising your right to free speech, it is impossible that you can break any other laws.

Seriously, I've seen a few people in this thread argue that OWS has a right to break the law, which is something of a paradox.
 
Actually, there was a murder at Oakland already. It was dismissed as just a victim of Oakland crime totally unrelated to Occupy despite the fact that both the vic and the alleged perp lived in the camps.
 
Seriously, I've seen a few people in this thread argue that OWS has a right to break the law, which is something of a paradox.

Their rights trump other people's rights. They can't tell you why, though.
 
Didn't you suggest that they should've sprayed the crowd if they were concerned only a few posts ago?
I'm arguing that IF the police were threatened then that would would have been the logical response. Not spraying people who are sitting down. Pepper spray can be used if an office is threatened.

Moving the goalposts. All of a sudden, the ones sitting down on the ground are not part of the larger group, even if all of them are trying to create an intimidating environment for the 5-0.
No moving of goal posts. Pepper spray isn't to be used on people who are sitting and are no threat.

Yes, by definition of "only recourse", which means they could not do anything else. Fortunately, modern peace officers have an array of compliance options short of shooting people, and this is what they used. Nice attempt at equivalence, though, and I note you didn't actually answer the question.
Looks, this isn't difficult. Use the pepper spray against those who are threatening you. People seated on the ground aren't threatening.

They weren't peaceful; they were impeding the cops in their duties...
Two very different things.
 
Last edited:
I have literally never seen anyone call OWS protestors "dirty hippies" or even "dirty", barring a sardonic or factual sense (IE referring to hygiene). Either you and other people who act like the term is in common usage are taking such uses in a different manner than intended, or you're making them up so you can put everyone who uses "military-grade chemical weapons" on protestors in a little box that you can shove in a corner and dismiss.
There are none so blind as they who will not see. "take a bath". In this thread there has been much talk of hygiene. But more importantly, there are posts after posts of anecdotes disparaging the protestors. They are said to have an entitled attitude and/or criminal. Much of the rhetoric used is similar to the rhetoric used against the protestors of the 60s.

I became active in this thread because I found that to be intellectually dishonest and demonstrated an unwillingness to have an honest and rational discussion. This thread was propaganda to malign a movement because that is easier than having a discussion. I'm pushing back. If you want to have an honest discussion I'll engage you and not use such rhetoric. Fair enough?
 
Last edited:
Don't you get it? The First Amendment is the absolute tippy-top of all laws, and trumps all others. As long as you're exercising your right to free speech, it is impossible that you can break any other laws.
Straw man.

Seriously, I've seen a few people in this thread argue that OWS has a right to break the law, which is something of a paradox.
Seriously, show me where I did?

My positions:

  • Communities have the right to limit access to public places.
  • The police have the right to remove protestors who break the law.
You SERIOUSLY don't understand the history of protest and civil disobedience in America.

During the civil rights movement when protestors refused to obey the laws the police used fire hoses and dogs to disperse them. Those images are now iconic of the civil rights movement. NOT because the protestors broke the law but because the police (iconic of authority) used excessive force.

I don't know you. Or I don't recognize your user name. Do me a favor? If you don't know what my position is, could you ask me? Oh, one more thing, take a moment to find out what the The Role of Civil Disobedience in Democracy is?

It would seriously help the discussion. I don't claim these rights you accuse me of. That's just a straw man invention.
 
I'm arguing that IF the police were threatened then that would would have been the logical response.
So they were not being threatened by the crowd, or did they have an illogical response?

Not spraying people who are sitting down. Pepper spray can be used if an office is threatened.
It can also be used to ensure compliance when an officer or the public is not being threatened.

No moving of goal posts. Pepper spray isn't to be used on people who are sitting and are no threat.

Looks, this isn't difficult. Use the pepper spray against those who are threatening you. People seated on the ground and threatening.
Except there are sanctioned uses for pepper spray on people who are not being threatening, such as someone resisting arrest or removal.

Two very different things.
I'd say anyone who is arranges themselves in such a way as to deliberately bring themselves into a confrontation with police is not "peaceful". It's the equivalent of a bratty sibling going "I'm not touching you!" and when you slap their hand away they go "Mom, Jeannie hit me!".

Funny how you deleted the rest of my post.
resisting peaceful removal, and being deliberately threatening. Or did you miss one of them going "F* THE POLICE!"? Did you miss the linked arms, deliberately meant to make it hard for the cops to remove them?

Seriously, Roark, you've been dodging direct questions for two pages now.
So when I ask you a direct question, and point out that you've been dodging questions, you dodge the question. In fact, you're selectively responding to all of my posts directed at you.

There are none so blind as they who will not see. "take a bath". In this thread there has been much talk of hygiene.
Yes, talk of hygiene as I acknowledged in my post. There has also been talk of crime coming from OWS, but its detractors are not regularly stereotyped as saying OWS a bunch of criminals. Frankly, assuming Newt Gingrich speaks for everyone who has a problem with OWS is called a "generalization".
 
Straw man.
No, it's not. Several supporters of OWS have expressed sentiments from which one can reasonably infer that they think the First Amendment is Holy Writ, which covers a multitude of lesser lawbreaking.

Seriously, show me where I did?
I didn't say you, did I? I didn't even have you in mind when I wrote it.

My positions:

  • Communities have the right to limit access to public places.
  • The police have the right to remove protestors who break the law.
You SERIOUSLY don't understand the history of protest and civil disobedience in America.

During the civil rights movement when protestors refused to obey the laws the police used fire hoses and dogs to disperse them. Those images are now iconic of the civil rights movement. NOT because the protestors broke the law but because the police (iconic of authority) used excessive force.
And pepper spray, used every day by cops around the world, suddenly becomes "military-grade chemical weapons" when used on the UC Davis students in the Occusphere blogosphere.

Police are not "iconic of authority". They are authority.

I don't know you. Or I don't recognize your user name. Do me a favor? If you don't know what my position is, could you ask me? Oh, one more thing, take a moment to find out what the The Role of Civil Disobedience in Democracy is?
Sure thing. Assuming the police did have a case to remove the UC Davis protestors, what was the lowest effective use of force they could've employed?

It would seriously help the discussion. I don't claim these rights you accuse me of. That's just a straw man invention.
I wasn't talking about you, but Occupiers in general. I apologize if I was unclear.
 
It can also be used to ensure compliance when an officer or the public is not being threatened.
I would be interested in reading your source.

Except there are sanctioned uses for pepper spray on people who are not being threatening, such as someone resisting arrest or removal.
Okay, perhaps I'm wrong. Perhaps the appeals court ruling I posted is wrong. I'll gladly admit it when you post that link.

Funny how you deleted the rest of my post.
So when I ask you a direct question, and point out that you've been dodging questions, you dodge the question. In fact, you're selectively responding to all of my posts directed at you.
What is your question?

I have not intentionally dodged any question. I'm not going to respond to every jot and tittle of a post. If you don't like it then block me.
 
No, it's not. Several supporters of OWS have expressed sentiments from which one can reasonably infer that they think the First Amendment is Holy Writ, which covers a multitude of lesser lawbreaking.
You were responding to a post directed at me.

Police are not "iconic of authority". They are authority.
I'm not just talking about them. I'm talking about those who make the laws and those who lobby the law makers. The rich and powerful who don't have to answer to anyone when they take down our economy through corruption. It's the reason the protestors are there and it's the reason the police there. Like the protests of the 60s and 70s there is a larger reason for what you see on TV. And that is not because of some lazy entitled group wants something for free.

Assuming the police did have a case to remove the UC Davis protestors, what was the lowest effective use of force they could've employed?
Let's back up, pepper spray was invented to be non lethal force. To take the place of lethal force. Are you saying that had they not had pepper spray they would have started shooting people? Are you saying that was their only option?

The AG and Sheriffs department of Yolo county and others have said they are concerned that the pepper spray represented excessive force. I'm not an expert. I don't know what the tactics are. I'm only relaying what other experts are saying. In the end those who are performing the investigation may very well find no excessive force. My point is that people who are experts think it is. That's it.
 
Last edited:
You were responding to a post directed at me.
And I have already apologized for any ambiguity.

I'm not talking about them. I'm talking about those who make the laws.
Which makes them "iconic of an authority", since they are themselves an authority.

Let's back up, pepper spray was invented to be non lethal force. To take the place of lethal force. Are you saying that had they not had pepper spray they would have started shooting people? Are you saying that was their only option?
Do not attempt to shift the burden of proof or create hypothetical straw men wildly different from the circumstances proposed.

RandFan, I am going to ask you only once more after this.

Propose plausible alternatives to the use of pepper spray by US Davis Campus Security officers, assuming, for the sake of argument, that the protestors were in fact breaking the law and/or campus regulations.

The AG and Sheriffs department of Yolo county and others have said they are concerned that the pepper spray represented excessive force.
Of course. They're covering their political rears.

I'm not an expert. I don't know what the tactics are. I'm only relaying what other experts are saying. In the end those who are performing the investigation may very well find no excessive force. My point is that people who are experts think it is. That's it.
And there are other people who are also "experts" who think that the force was appropriate. I am fairly certain you're hiding behind the opinions of "experts" instead of being able to justify your opinion on its own merits.

In fact, lets up the ante. Did any of your experts propose alternatives to pepper spray use besides leaving the students alone? Did any of them consider the legality of the students actions? Because the version of the video commonly presented is classic propaganda. Control the viewer's emotional reaction, and any information they later learn will be biased in your favor. Why doesn't the video show the students being warned, or Pike allowing them plenty of time to change their minds? Because the people editing that thought all of it was unimportant. Personally I disagree.
 
Last edited:
Which makes them "iconic of an authority", since they are themselves an authority.
This is a silly debating point. The police don't make the laws.

Propose plausible alternatives to the use of pepper spray by US Davis Campus Security officers...
NO. I'm not an expert. I don't claim to know what the plausible alternatives are. THAT'S my answer. I don't give a damn if you don't like it. Now...
Let's back up, pepper spray was invented to be non lethal force. To take the place of lethal force. Are you saying that had they not had pepper spray they would have started shooting people? Are you saying that was their only option
Now you answer my question. Or tell me you don't know. Fair enough?

And there are other people who are also "experts" who think that the force was appropriate. I am fairly certain you're hiding behind the opinions of "experts" instead of being able to justify your opinion on its own merits.
One more time Mr. you didn't answer the question". Source?

The AG and Sheriffs department of Yolo county and others have said they are concerned that the pepper spray represented excessive force.
Of course. They're covering their political rears.
Why do you say that? It wasn't their responsibility. It's not their jurisdiction.

In fact, lets up the ante. Did any of your experts propose alternatives to pepper spray use besides leaving the students alone? Did any of them consider the legality of the students actions? Because the version of the video commonly presented is classic propaganda. Control the viewer's emotional reaction, and any information they later learn will be biased in your favor. Why doesn't the video show the students being warned, or Pike allowing them plenty of time to change their minds? Because the people editing that thought all of it was unimportant. Personally I disagree.
I've seen the video. IMO the use of pepper spray was not warranted. I'm NOT an expert but I think the evidence fairly conclusive.
 
Propose plausible alternatives to the use of pepper spray by US Davis Campus Security officers, assuming, for the sake of argument, that the protestors were in fact breaking the law and/or campus regulations.

He/she agrees they were breaking the law. He/she also likes to throw in pictures of the Civil Rights movement, and how he agrees they were breaking the law, attempting to draw an imaginary parallel between the morality of arresting black protesters and arresting OWS Protesters. He/she will not say that they should be arrested at all.

In fact, lets up the ante. Did any of your experts propose alternatives to pepper spray use besides leaving the students alone?

Of course not. The most common response is "the cops should pull harder."

Did any of them consider the legality of the students actions?

Irrelevant. It's for the Greater Good.
 
Last edited:
He/she agrees they were breaking the law. He/she also likes to throw in pictures of the Civil Rights movement, and how he agrees they were breaking the law, attempting to draw an imaginary parallel between the morality of arresting black protesters and OWS Protesters.
Oh, well, please to explain the difference?

He/she will not say that they should be arrested.
"should be arrested"? That's not my call. That's up to those who are in authority to make. I've said that they can be arrested.

Of course not. The most common response is "the cops should pull harder."
Silly and fatuous response. The police do in fact deal with protestors (chained or otherwise) without using pepper spray. I've demonstrated that fact and you have ignored it.

Did any of them consider the legality of the students actions?
Irrelevant. It's for the Greater Good.
Breaking the law does not justify the excessive force.

  • Did the fact that the civil rights protestors broke the law justify water hoses?
  • Did the fact that the civil rights protestors broke the law justify dogs?
  • Did the fact that the civil rights protestors broke the law justify horses?
  • Did the fact that the civil rights protestors broke the law justify beating?
I'm accused of dodging question yet most of my questions go unanswered.
 
NO. I'm not an expert. I don't claim to know what the plausible alternatives are. THAT'S my answer. I don't give a damn if you don't like it.

Perhaps you should consider talking to those who are in a position to know what the alternatives are for crowd control?

I know you have your one source that you keep posting, but you still have yet to flesh out how it is at all analogous to what happened at U.C. Davis. People being pepper sprayed is not enough to link the two events.
 
Oh, well, please to explain the difference?

You were the one who tried to link the two. Why do I have to do your homework?

"should be arrested"? That's not my call. That's up to those who are in authority to make. I've said that they can be arrested.

One can give an opinion on a topic, no? Should the protesters be arrested or not? There are two groups here, the people who set up the camps and refused to take them down, and the people who prevented the police fro arresting the first group.

Silly and fatuous response. The police do in fact deal with protestors (chained or otherwise) without using pepper spray. I've demonstrated that fact and you have ignored it.

You have only posted your one source that says the protesters were literally picked up and taken away, after having pepper spray applied directly to their eyes. Now that was the moral thing to do (ETA* physically removing them, not pepper spraying them) since the protesters had literally immobilized themselves in devices that would have to be physically removed with a machine. It is not in any way similar to someone being "dead-weight" and refusing to move, and being prevented from moving by compatriots. How do you suggest the police break the links in the chain in a fashion that doesn't injure the protester, or the officer?

Do you have any sort of source that backs up your claim that police do in fact deal with protesters on a regular basis by physically pulling the chain apart? Please, provide a link.

Breaking the law does not justify the excessive force.

Since you do not agree the protesters should have been arrested, I think it's safe to say any measure of force would be considered excessive.
 
Last edited:
This is a silly debating point. The police don't make the laws.
They are an authority. They enforce the law. You keep dodging the point.

NO. I'm not an expert. I don't claim to know what the plausible alternatives are. THAT'S my answer. I don't give a damn if you don't like it.
Do you know what the plausible alternatives are? Because if not, you're a parrot. If you do, please share it with the class. That was the last time, by the way, and your second evasion.

Now...
Now you answer my question. Or tell me you don't know. Fair enough?
No. They wouldn't have. They would've resorted to wrestling the "protestors" apart. Which would've likely resulted in a dislocated arm or two. Pepper spray, by contrast, causes an hour or so of irritation, and is much, much less likely to result in permanent harm, which is why it is used. Shooting protestors is extremely unlikely, barring a cop losing their mind, or protestors employing deadly force against the cops. I mean, "rushing at them with a knife in hand and murder in their eyes" deadly force. "Pulling a gun out of a bag and refusing to put it down" force. Your straw man requires the police to actively be under serious assault or at risk of such before it is even remotely plausible.

One more time Mr. you didn't answer the question". Source?
Right after you provide yours.

Why do you say that? It wasn't their responsibility. It's not their jurisdiction.
Yet their opinions are valid when you use it to support the claim of brutality.

Political advantage can be gained by commenting on something outside one's bailiwick.

I've seen the video. IMO the use of pepper spray was not warranted. I'm NOT an expert but I think the evidence fairly conclusive.
I am fairly well versed in the use of force, though I would hesitate to call myself an expert. Not as much as a peace officer, but more than you are. I think the use of pepper spray is warranted to facilitate removal and/or arrest persons who actively prevent officers from carrying out their duties, as the "protestors" seem to have been doing.

Also, you did not answer my questions. In fact, I don't think you've ever acknowledged the officers may be in the legal right. (For the record: I think it is possible that the cops could be wrong, but do not believe that to be the case, in light of the evidence I have gathered.) You've claimed it was brutality, and in the same breath hid behind "experts". You've been shuckin' and jivin' this entire time. You can't even admit you don't know of any alternatives, weasel-wording it as you never claimed you know any alternatives, which is about two qualifiers away from a concrete statement. In fact, it's a politician's answer.

wow...perhaps you are just being overly argumentative.
it is often your M.O..
Anyone have a spare irony meter?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom