Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Also odd how reluctant the side condemning the police has been to directly address the "continue to protest peacefully" declaration, and to a lesser extent the "we will let you leave" demand. JQ addressed the latter in #424, but only to scoff at the idea that it was a threat, not to actually address what it was. They then asked what remark was threatening, and it was the former, which was literally seconds later in the video. I'm not sure how one can miss two statements less than a minute apart, unless one somehow skipped over precisely that portion, or was being disingenuous, or just plain forgot.

I think when you start telling cops that you'll let them do something, you can pretty much just go ahead and scrunch your eyes shut and try to take shallow breaths.
 
feelin alright

I think when you start telling cops that you'll let them do something, you can pretty much just go ahead and scrunch your eyes shut and try to take shallow breaths.
That was funny, the kid said go ahead, spray me. And he did.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wuWEx6Cfn-I

Policeman leaves after he punished the students. New one stop justice. Combine arrest with trial, judge and jury all in one pepper spray cop. (policeman)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIewW8WNN5c&feature=related


Super pepper spray policeman returns ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJUatBFbSqM&feature=related

Did he do this so the kids could sue; does he get a cut? Is this the same policeman who cause a 250,000 dollar settlement?

He did look kind of chummy with a student he sprayed. Did they plan this?
111apepperCTcrop.jpg


Report on UC Davis pepper spray spree, delayed until the 15th or longer, to scrub personal information of officers. Maybe the report will say it was okay to pepper spray kids and send some to the hospital for sitting in the 500x600 foot quad.

http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-0307-pepper-spray-20120307,0,144818.story




... So if charges are dropped, that means no crime was committed? What if the charges are filed again, and the students are convicted? The school can file and drop as many times as they like as long as the statute isn't out, and Katehi only dropped them because of the political consequences.
The charges were dropped, because the police failed to write it up properly. There can't be a refile, the file failed. No big deal but this is fact, not made up nonsense. I am not deciding what happened, I am trying to repeat what happened.

The cool part, this is politics. There is no right or wrong; ask Hitler, and Stalin; They were right, they said so.

If you think the police were right pepper spraying the kids, you win. I think they did not have to pepper spray the kids; I lost, they pepper sprayed the kids; you won. We lost freedom to speak out, and protest peacefully. I prefer UC Davis student protest over violence.

I loved it when one woman, stood up and held her hands out and moved the police off the quad. She was in-charge, she is a leader! She won! Police LOST.
 
Last edited:
I think when you start telling cops that you'll let them do something, you can pretty much just go ahead and scrunch your eyes shut and try to take shallow breaths.
Indeed. Which is why I found it ironic when someone suggested the cops be communicative and patient, when they were precisely that trying to resolve the situation without pepper spray. It's the students who were refusing to listen to the cops and impatient enough to obstruct them and form the inner line.

That was funny, the kid said go ahead, spray me. And he did.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wuWEx6Cfn-I
After the policeman warned him that if he didn't get up and leave on his own, he would use force, yes. The lad was willing to accept the consequences of his non-compliance. You and others, however, seem to think he should be exempt from those charges.

Policeman leaves after he punished the students. New one stop justice. Combine arrest with trial, judge and jury all in one pepper spray cop. (policeman)
He used a standard compliance tool on resisting suspects who were obstructing them. That's not "trial, judge and jury".

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIewW8WNN5c&feature=related


Super pepper spray policeman returns ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJUatBFbSqM&feature=related

Did he do this so the kids could sue; does he get a cut? Is this the same policeman who cause a 250,000 dollar settlement?

He did look kind of chummy with a student he sprayed. Did they plan this?
[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111apepperCTcrop.jpg[/qimg]
You're just as bad as those moon hoaxers who say the Apollo 11 astronauts didn't look happy at the post-mission press conference, when by that point they just wanted to go home and kiss their wives.

Report on UC Davis pepper spray spree, delayed until the 15th or longer, to scrub personal information of officers. Maybe the report will say it was okay to pepper spray kids and send some to the hospital for sitting in the 500x600 foot quad.
Sooner or later, you're going to have to admit they were obstructing officers. I've provided evidence that indicated they may have been legally rioting. You have ignored claims from the police, the video, and the open testimony of the students in question themselves.

Oh, wow, a Judge stopped the report's release because...they wanted to remove confidential information. Given that Pike's name, address, and phone numbers have been exposed, this seems prudent.

The charges were dropped, because the police failed to write it up properly. There can't be a refile, the file failed. No big deal but this is fact, not made up nonsense. I am not deciding what happened, I am trying to repeat what happened.
Wait, so you were implying that the charges were dropped because they were baseless, and now you're claiming (without evidence) it was a clerical error? And are you literally just reading the last lines of my posts and ignoring everything else? Have you noticed how even the people on your side won't back you up? <SNIP>.

The cool part, this is politics. There is no right or wrong; ask Hitler, and Stalin; They were right, they said so.
Yet you have been swearing up and down the cops were wrong to spray the kids.

If you think the police were right pepper spraying the kids, you win. I think they did not have to pepper spray the kids; I lost, they pepper sprayed the kids; you won. We lost freedom to speak out, and protest peacefully. I prefer UC Davis student protest over violence.
Well, that's rather hypocritical, seeing as the students threatened violence on the cops who were actively trying to let them protest peacefully.

I loved it when one woman, stood up and held her hands out and moved the police off the quad. She was in-charge, she is a leader! She won! Police LOST.
I'd ask you to provide evidence, such as a video and timestamp, but I know you wouldn't, just like you ignore almost all of my posts so you can rant and rave and spout sentence fragments.

How? How, pray tell, would an officer remove them from the line? What feasible alternatives to pepper spray were there available to the officers? Describe them for the class.

Don't suppose you're gonna respond to post 430 either, are you?

Edited, breach of rule 0, rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Many many times in this thread those defending the students actions have referred to them as "kids". This seems to be red-herring attempt at garnering extra sympathy for them based on their age. I have not seen any "kids" in the videos posted. The protesters in these videos all appear to be adults and deserve to be referred to and treated as such.
 
Oh, wow, a Judge stopped the report's release because...they wanted to remove confidential information. Given that Pike's name, address, and phone numbers have been exposed, this seems prudent.
Agreed, and the law requires the those details to be omitted. Given the fact that a campaign was orchestrated to have people personally call Pike at home and insult him, which included at least one member of this very forum, I can see why those personal details needed to be removed.
 
Many many times in this thread those defending the students actions have referred to them as "kids". This seems to be red-herring attempt at garnering extra sympathy for them based on their age. I have not seen any "kids" in the videos posted. The protesters in these videos all appear to be adults and deserve to be referred to and treated as such.

How many many? I would have thought, round here, that you'd have actually counted the incidences, if not calculated some ratios. Your red-herring looks more like a strawman. Who has called the students 'kids'? I've consistently referred to them as students. Seated, unarmed students.

The students are adults, and deserve to be referred to and treated as such. Seated unarmed adults. Care to address the question of whether seated unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed? Or can I take that as a given?
 
I think when you start telling cops that you'll let them do something, you can pretty much just go ahead and scrunch your eyes shut and try to take shallow breaths.

"Officer, you have no warrant, but I have nothing to hide. I will let you search my home. Hey, what?! Don't pepper spray me, dude!"

Gosh, isn't life simple when you don't allow for complications. Of course, you'll argue that the two 'let's are different, but that's the nub of the argument anyway.
 
How many many? I would have thought, round here, that you'd have actually counted the incidences, if not calculated some ratios. Your red-herring looks more like a strawman. Who has called the students 'kids'? I've consistently referred to them as students. Seated, unarmed students.

The students are adults, and deserve to be referred to and treated as such. Seated unarmed adults. Care to address the question of whether seated unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed? Or can I take that as a given?

Well, from the last two pages alone - see hilites:

Where do you get your edited video at low res from? No wonder you believe the student who was actually surrounded by police. What is your point? I got some hi-res video, and it shows a lot more. There is video showing arrested students escorted out of the area, and how the police are all over, and the funny one showing Mr. Pepper-spray step over the students who surrounded him, yet there are police on both sides of the students sitting. He steps out of the circle, so he can get them in the face.

Quote-mining, and cherry-picking.
An edited video, which clearly shows super pepper spray man on one side of the kids, if you had some more info, and the video cuts and then on the other side of the kids, in their faces spraying kids who are sitting, big threat. I guess some people pick those who will not fight back, sitting on the ground, the sign of a coward.
You should not cherry-pick a video like this, it shows pepper spray was not needed to get past the big wall of sitting students. If you knew the Quad, you could see super pepper-spray man, had to move over the students. But I will show a frame of other video which show the truth, if you want it. But your video is better cut to support your claim the sitting students were blocking the center of the quad, and it must be impossible to walk around since the field is only 600x500 feet.


In your posted video, where words become weapons, we miss the fact the Brave Pepper Spray Savior of the UC Davis, steps over the impossible to get over wall of students sitting. He steps over them to pepper spray them in the face, instead of remaining surrounded by the threating circle of kids sitting, talking.

[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg[/qimg]
Oh noes, he steps of he wall, and behind him are Police, and on the other side are Police. Before this happened, students that had been arrested were conducted off the field of threating students, sitting, waiting for their punishment by the policeman, who is judge and jury, and correction officer administering the punishment for smart talk. Take that evil students, we are your friendly police force, here to save you from yourselves. Don't worry, we are not capable of writing this up to make any charges stick anyway!

Here is a kid arrested, being walked out of the gauntlet of students sitting, armed with big scary WORDS! Oh my.
[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg[/qimg]
Shortly before the kids armed with words were peppered to protect the world from who knows what, a kid is escorted off the quad. The police, even though blocked by sitting students, were able to escort kids who had been arrested off the field of battle, where WORDS beat pepper spray.



lol, the super hero pepper spray king stepped over the massive blockade, and hit them with pepper in the face. I can't see how you can step over students who are sitting. Wow...


Ignore the fact the policeman stepped over the kids, to get them in the face, and the fact police are on both sides of the kids who surround them by sitting... The earth is round, so I guess the students sort of surround the whole world. Great work. Who should we pepper spray today?

How did he step over them?

Photo shows police on both sides of students sitting.
Photo shows arrested student escorted out of the area before the pepper spray incident, which is evidence of police misconduct.
Photo shows police man who started pepper spray step over the students.

And I thought you said they were surrounded? Must be a perspective things and some quote-mining.

UC Davis said it was a mistake, they apologized for pepper spraying the kids, and I agree it was a mistake.

What? The police are on both sides of the kids, the kids are sitting barely taking up a 50 foot radius area, out of >500 feet all directions. Are you being funny? I see a big gap for all the police in the right third of the photo, off the quad to the street; but I do have a 111 inch TV at 1080p. I cheated, I looked at google earth, and have been on campus. It would take 100 to 1000 times more students to block the quad.

This photo debunks your transport the prisoner lie.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg
Frame taken from video just before the kids are pepper sprayed. Was that punishment for smarting off to police? Bully tactics. Pride. Ego. Or just because they can do it?

The student was already cuffed with plastic ties, and is being taken off the field of battle, though the gauntlet of kids with words. There are so many videos which debunk your can't get the arrested kids off the field lie.


See the exit here? Looks like the students sitting are surrounded by police. oops
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/...manstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
This is a cool photo, proves there was no blockade of police. The policeman steps over, there are police on both sides of the kids. If you look close, easy to see, there is a gap you could run for touchdown though the gauntlet of people who surround the riot gear clad cops, who brought peppers spray to a war of words, a peaceful student sitting demonstration, one Gandhi might approve. MLK would be proud the students did not fight being peppered.

UC Davis apologized.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg
This student on the right is outside the circle of kids sitting, being escorted off the quad, the kids are sitting out of frame on the right. It is a lie they were unable to move arrested kids off the quad before the pepper spray punishment was dished out.

Why did UC Davis chancellor apologize? I know why the police lied they were surrounded.





Are some of the police unable to walk? I am still laughing when the police say they were surrounded, and then to spray them in the face he walks over the kids. The funny part, he leaves being surrounded, and on the other side, more police, and a clear show off the quad. Surrounded is busted.

Oh noes, we be surrounded, by kids sitting... step over them silly. :words: yes these are words; poorly connected, but words...

A lie. Here is a kid leaving the field under arrest before the pepper spray. http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg

The kid with the policeman on the left is being taken away from the kids who "surrounded" the police. Arrested kids were taken away from the quad, the police were not blocked. Kids saying they were trying to block the police from removing the kids arrested, failed to block anything.

By sitting? I believe the student believes they encircled the police, but it served as a symbolic obstruction backed with words; as effective an obstruction as Les Nessman's masking tape walls. Failed to stop the police.

What is the point?
The only people who would be obstructed by sitting students; those who can't walk, those with short legs, or those who can't think for themselves. Sitting kids armed with words. Better pepper spray them in the face.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/...manstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
(lol, there is a guy with a camera inside the sitting kids, how did he get "surrounded" since the students were "blocking"..., this is hilarious)

The sitting students failed to obstruct the police removing arrested kids before the pepper spray punishment was dished out.



Surrounded? They were on both sides of the kids, surrounded? There is a clear path off the quad in the "still".
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Maybe the video in motion is hard to see things, which debunk surrounded.
One frame, over 6 police not surrounded, and more in the video.

The students said? Let me look.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Nope, the students were wrong. I see >6 police not surrounded, and one walking over the kids, so the police could surround the kids and pepper them in the face, and from behind. Surrounded students, claim they surrounded the police who shot them with pepper from both sides.
Oh, yes, I was fooled, I guess a frame showing police not surrounded is; fake? A visual illusion? The truth? Right.

Irony, two frames debunk the surrounded lie, and no arrested students could be taken away.

In the "still", proof a rational policeman could take one student at time, arrest them, and easily move them off the quad. Is it easier to pepper spray kids, let the fire department fix them up or send them to the hospital, than arresting them?


On a personal note, yes I am, Suitable for Framing, Three Dog Night, side one, track one. Thank you very much.


Arrested students, charges dropped.

So in answer to your question will you accept "a minimum of 31"? And in revieweing these quotes I see they are actually all attributed to Beachnut, but I think my point stands.
 
The students are adults, and deserve to be referred to and treated as such. Seated unarmed adults. Care to address the question of whether seated unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed? Or can I take that as a given?

Sorry I forgot to address this.

I do not think any and all seated and unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed. I do think that in the particular case being discussed here that pepper spraying was the appropriate response for the police in order for them to do their job of arresting some protesters while minimzing the risk to themselves.
 
Sorry I forgot to address this.

I do not think any and all seated and unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed. I do think that in the particular case being discussed here that pepper spraying was the appropriate response for the police in order for them to do their job of arresting some protesters while minimzing the risk to themselves.
Nice to see some perspective in a post around here for a change.

You must be one of them. :wink:
 
He did look kind of chummy with a student he sprayed. Did they plan this?


????


That would be you providing photographic evidence that doesn't support your side.

Is the 9/11 CT subforum rubbing off on you?
 
The students are adults, and deserve to be referred to and treated as such. Seated unarmed adults. Care to address the question of whether seated unarmed adults should be pepper sprayed? Or can I take that as a given?

They were treated as adults, as evidenced by the photo showing the cop having a discussion with one of them.
 
Many many times in this thread those defending the students actions have referred to them as "kids". This seems to be red-herring attempt at garnering extra sympathy for them based on their age. I have not seen any "kids" in the videos posted. The protesters in these videos all appear to be adults and deserve to be referred to and treated as such.
I see kids, I see them everywhere, ... they don't know they are kids

In 83 days and 14 13 hours I will be sixty, I see kids, I see them all over the video. Thanks for reality, I thought I was a kid. My "kids" are older than the "kids" pepper sprayed. If calling them adults makes the pepper spray go down, change all kids to adults. I did not intend to garner sympathy.

The quad is middle of nothing, over two football fields in size, the perfect place to keep kids who are protesting. Thousands can gather around and hear, and not a single person needs to be moved, or pepper sprayed that day.

The policemen are on leave, the "kids" are in class.
The chancellor of the school apologized. It was a mistake. The person in charge thinks the pepper spray is wrong, I agree.

It appears the police pepper spraying the "kids" failure is reflected further, "insufficient information contained within the police reports submitted by the UC Davis Police Department to justify the filing of criminal charges” (District Attorney Jeff Reisig).

Chancellor Linda Katehi’s public comments indicate she did not want the protesters prosecuted.
Please substitute anything that makes you feel better for "kid", "kids", etc. It will not help erase a mistake of pepper spraying humans sitting, in this case.
 
The quad is middle of nothing, over two football fields in size, the perfect place to keep kids who are protesting. Thousands can gather around and hear

Entirely irrelevant. The police were encircled in a rather small part of the quad. The quad can be enormous, but if an event happens in a small section of it, why is it relevant to talk about the size?
 
Entirely irrelevant. The police were encircled in a rather small part of the quad.
Did the encirclement consist entirely of interlocked seated protestors? And that's not rhetorical. I don't think that's the case but I honestly don't know.
 
"Officer, you have no warrant, but I have nothing to hide. I will let you search my home. Hey, what?! Don't pepper spray me, dude!"

Gosh, isn't life simple when you don't allow for complications. Of course, you'll argue that the two 'let's are different, but that's the nub of the argument anyway.

I'm pretty sure you know what I meant. ;)
 
Did the encirclement consist entirely of interlocked seated protestors? And that's not rhetorical. I don't think that's the case but I honestly don't know.

After twelve pages, you still don't know?
 
Well, from the last two pages alone - see hilites:
So in answer to your question will you accept "a minimum of 31"? And in revieweing these quotes I see they are actually all attributed to Beachnut, but I think my point stands.

Fair enough. 31 is many many times. I have beachnut on ignore, so I had no idea. Counting may well make your point 'stand', but it collapses again when we suggest that counting the times a single poster said something may not be the best measure. One. That's the count you want. One poster. But one isn't as helpful to you as 'many many'. Try that for size. "One poster says" vs "Many many times". Your point stands only if your point is that someone isn't right, therefore all opposition to you is wrong.
 
I'm pretty sure you know what I meant. ;)

Yeah, you meant 'the seated unarmed students deserved to be pepper sprayed, the long-hair pinko liberals. Who do they think they are? Citizens? The police represent the politicians, not the people. The people should do as they're told. They don't know what's good for them. Pepper spray is a food product! They should be thanking us for the free lunch!"

Right?

I figure I'm free to invent whatever the hell I like for 'what you meant', since apparantly 'what you said' isn't 'what you meant' at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom