Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Not anything?

Do you believe President Obama is responsible for "the details of the use of stealth helicopters" in the Bi Laden raid being revealed?

If so, what would you have done differently to prevent those details from being revealed, if you were the President at the time?
 
If he claims to speak for the SEALs he lies. Knowing full well that none of those in active service will get involved in this political fight and correct him.

Please go to pages 44-5-6-7 Vol 36 NO.4 July/August Skeptical Inquirer.
They list 20 logical fallacies.
Do you see any in the BenBurch post?
 
Please go to pages 44-5-6-7 Vol 36 NO.4 July/August Skeptical Inquirer.
They list 20 logical fallacies.
Do you see any in the BenBurch post?

Please tell me how the real Navy SEALs are going to respond to Act of Valor, the movie? It has to be pissing them off something fierce.

Daredelvis
 
This is the sort of thing that is likely to back fire. It likely won't do more than to remind the population that OBL was removed under Obama's watch.
 
I wonder if anyone else remembers this very interesting case that played itself out on JREF?
Joey Donuts and Longtabber PE are registered JREF members.

http://www.socnet.com/showthread.php?t=89699

Internet "Tough Guy?"

I've read the SOP on "poser busting" but unfortunately I can't say for certain if this person is claiming SF anywhere but on an internet forum. I am also aware that investigations into people expend time and effort. I guess what I'm asking for is for the subject matter expert community here to take a look at what this person's claiming and see if it passes your professional B.S. radar.
These guys are the real McCoy, so it would be easy to check to see what they think. My impression from another forum is that the Bin Laden operation greatly increased the number of applicants for SEAL training, which was viewed as a good thing, but that some SEALSs preferred to not have the publicity.
 
Last edited:
Another JREF poster has apparently verified NavySEAL's credentials as an actual former Navy SEAL.

EDIT: It was Joey Donuts himself that did this verification, too.
 
Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Sour grapes much?

If the GOP was allowed to sell OBL's continued existence as a reason to start a war or two, then Obama is allowed sell OBL's death.
 
Last edited:
*vomits*

Man, I appreciate your service but you're so self-congratulatory you hardly need anyone else to praise you.
 
I know the name of every Navy SEAL that has lived or is living.

So do lots of people. Heck, they're even written down in a number of places.

After you are able to handle that statement we will move on.

Yes, let's move on.

Do you believe President Obama is responsible for "the details of the use of stealth helicopters" in the Bin Laden raid being revealed?

If so, what would you have done differently to prevent those details from being revealed, if you were the President at the time? How would you have kept the Pakistanis from releasing pictures of the intact tail rotor assembly, for instance, or stopped them from allowing the Chinese to inspect the wreckage?

If not, why do you think Ryan Zinke blamed Obama for those details being revealed?
 
No!!! Lots of people do not know the name of every Navy SEAL.

You wanted an opinion from "ALL" SEALs, so far it is 100% against Obama.
How many of "all" SEALs do you want polled?
I will keep at it till you say stop.
 
No!!! Lots of people do not know the name of every Navy SEAL.

Just you, then? That seems like it would prove problematic for the Department of Defense's recordkeeping.

You wanted an opinion from "ALL" SEALs, so far it is 100% against Obama.

You have shown no evidence of that so far.

How many of "all" SEALs do you want polled?

A properly-determined statistical sample will do. There are a number of polling companies that can assist you with this, if you don't have the requisite statistical education to be able to do it yourself.

I will keep at it till you say stop.

Does this mean you're not going to answer my questions?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom