Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

No!!! Lots of people do not know the name of every Navy SEAL.

You wanted an opinion from "ALL" SEALs, so far it is 100% against Obama.
How many of "all" SEALs do you want polled?
I will keep at it till you say stop.

stop.
 
No!!! Lots of people do not know the name of every Navy SEAL.

You wanted an opinion from "ALL" SEALs, so far it is 100% against Obama.
How many of "all" SEALs do you want polled?
I will keep at it till you say stop.

Argument called on account of temper tantrum.
 
I just watched an interesting interview on CNN, Wolf Blitzer speaking with Adm. William McRaven. He is the SOC, Special Ops Commander. The SEALs commander.

He seemed pretty happy to discuss the Bin Laden operation on behalf of the SEALs who pulled it off, with certain reservations. He was very careful to give full credit to Obama as well as CIA and other organizations who coordinated the raid. He said the military portion was the least difficult, as the intelligence part was very complex. He stated that the SEALs did 11 other operations that same night, though the Bin Laden was a little more involved (I think he used the word "artistic", but I can't recall).

Interesting individual, with a pleasant sense of humor and a keen sense of duty. I was trying to picture him in command of a bunch of Obama haters. It didn't fit. Maybe I'm naive.
 
The Navy SEALs are not pleased at all by Mr. Obama's statements.
Our concerns have nothing to do with politics.
Problem is you haven't been able to explain what you are concerned about, other than politics.

Olowkow
I know the name of every Navy SEAL that has lived or is living.
After you are able to handle that statement we will move on.
Geez, you can look at the Big Book of Names down by the Amphib Base - so what?

Are you claiming that by "knowing their names" this somehow translates into you knowing the POV of each and every one of them, past and present?

Zinke said he and other members of the special operations community are outraged that SEAL Team 6 was identified as the commando unit that carried out the raid, saying it put its members and their families at risk. Zinke said he believes the president has politicized his role as commander in chief to win re-election"..............

Since their names weren't revealed, your point would be? Or is your claim all members of SEAL Team 6 (DEVGRU) can be looked up in the phone book? Maybe al Qaeda has a Rolodex of their names and addresses and just wanted to know which Team it was before extracting their revenge?

The stealth helo was public the minute it crashed. The operation was public even before it started. That the President was courteous and gave DEVGU the credit for finding and killing OBL, this bothers you? :rolleyes:

So far all I've seen here is a play to denigrate the actions of brave men in order to promote a partisan political agenda. And it's not from Obama.


Criticism is allowed, refusing to obey an order is not.

Got a few bucks laying around? Why not bet that I am not what I say?
Out of curiosity, what part of OPSEC involves you publicly proclaiming your identity on the internet?
 
Last edited:
I just watched an interesting interview on CNN, Wolf Blitzer speaking with Adm. William McRaven. He is the SOC, Special Ops Commander. The SEALs commander.............

Interesting individual, with a pleasant sense of humor and a keen sense of duty. I was trying to picture him in command of a bunch of Obama haters. It didn't fit. Maybe I'm naive.

MCRAVEN: "The president of the United States is fantastic. And, again, I am not a political guy. I have worked in both administrations. I very, very much enjoyed working for President Bush, and I very much enjoy working for President Obama. … This is about a commander in chief who I have the opportunity to engage with on a routine basis, and watching him and the decisions he makes, along with his national security team. They’re a very impressive group of guys and gals."

Who are these Obama hating SEALs that he leads?
 
MCRAVEN: "The president of the United States is fantastic. And, again, I am not a political guy. I have worked in both administrations. I very, very much enjoyed working for President Bush, and I very much enjoy working for President Obama. … This is about a commander in chief who I have the opportunity to engage with on a routine basis, and watching him and the decisions he makes, along with his national security team. They’re a very impressive group of guys and gals."

Who are these Obama hating SEALs that he leads?

Not my claim. You tell me.
I was under the impression that your claim was that 100% of SEALs supposedly were anti Obama for taking credit for the Bin Laden operation, though it was never made clear why this should be the case.

The Navy SEALs are not pleased at all by Mr. Obama's statements.

My apologies if I have misunderstood. My point was that McRaven did not appear to be in agreement with this claim. He seems to disagree with you.
 
Look, I am really starting to wonder why NAVYSeal has not addressed Act of Valor, the movie? Might it be because he was the leaker that spilled his guts to those sneaky bastards in Hollywood? If the 100% Navy Seals are pissed at Obama, they have to be absolutely apoplectic with the treasonous cowards that allowed that movie to be produced. I fear for your safety if the other Seals find out you were complicit in the attack on America's fighting men that Act of Valor, the move, was.

Daredelvis
 
I have the feeling that his offense of this is that it's Obama that is "overselling" the mission accomplishment.

If it was a Republican, it would be ok. Heck, maybe even a Democrat.. a white democrat.
 
Now, now. Let us not go overboard with accusations of racism.

All we know is he hates Obama and this is blinding him to the obvious. We have no reason to think it is because of racism.
 
Now, now. Let us not go overboard with accusations of racism.

All we know is he hates Obama and this is blinding him to the obvious. We have no reason to think it is because of racism.

More likely due to being a resentful hate-filled pensioner who regrets the choice he made to serve his country. Likely also chases children off his lawn.
 
Ding ding ding ding!

If it's a military success during a Republican administration, it can be hyped loudly, far and wide, parades and flag waving and cross your heart for the Anthem.

If it's a Democratic administration, he'll get criticized for preparing to mention it.

The double standard is insane.

I know I'm rather late to this shindig, and I didn't bring any beer this time, but I agree. And what you'll find even more surprising....I'm a registered Republican.

I feel that everyone who had knowledge of the operation, and had their hand in it, should be very proud! It was a great day for me personally, and many others in my family. We had quite the party at my place that night in celebration. We were proud, and we had NOTHING to do with it. The ones who had their hands in the operation, should ABSOLUTELY be proud. Damn right. And for someone else, no matter what side of the political spectrum they are on, should not criticize them for their great accomplishment.
 
Last edited:
I know I'm rather late to this shindig, and I didn't bring any beer this time, but I agree. And what you'll find even more surprising....I'm a registered Republican.

I feel that everyone who had knowledge of the operation, and had their hand in it, should be very proud! It was a great day for me personally, and many others in my family. We had quite the party at my place that night in celebration. We were proud, and we had NOTHING to do with it. The ones who had their hands in the operation, should ABSOLUTELY be proud. Damn right. And for someone else, no matter what side of the political spectrum they are on, should not criticize them for their great accomplishment.

Thank you for being an actual Patriot.
 
No!!! Lots of people do not know the name of every Navy SEAL.

You wanted an opinion from "ALL" SEALs, so far it is 100% against Obama.
How many of "all" SEALs do you want polled?
I will keep at it till you say stop.

Again, you'll have to prove that you've interviewed every US Navy SEAL.

I'm sure that there are some that don't like Obama. I am sure that there are some that do.
 
Thank you for being an actual Patriot.

Thank you kind sir.

I don't like the "Republican V Democrat" fight. It is very divisive, IMO.

Why can't we be just be "Americans"?

Anyway, I hardly believe that any one person can speak about the personal opinions of every US Navy SEAL. Just as I cannot speak for every republican, or firefighter, or gun enthusiast, or fisherman....... And to claim that 100% are unhappy about something, especially something that didn't occur, is.....unfounded.
 
Thank you kind sir.

I don't like the "Republican V Democrat" fight. It is very divisive, IMO.

Why can't we be just be "Americans"?

Anyway, I hardly believe that any one person can speak about the personal opinions of every US Navy SEAL. Just as I cannot speak for every republican, or firefighter, or gun enthusiast, or fisherman....... And to claim that 100% are unhappy about something, especially something that didn't occur, is.....unfounded.

I'm with you. Can we just form an American party?
 
Taking credit

The search for Bin Laden was well underway before the American public elected Obama. He was persuaded by the top military generals to act on intelligence gathered as to where he was hiding. Anyone in office would have done the same thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom