Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Terrorist 2: Good plan! After pizza we will atttack both SEAL bases.

Exactly.

You know I do not want to be giving NavySEAL a hard time; I really respect what he did for the country.

I simply do not think that soldiers, current or former, need to say anything about the President at all.

POLICY, yes.

Elections, yes.

Politics in general, yes.

The POTUS, NO.

Nor do I believe that they ought to believe that they can speak for all soldiers, or even all members of their former outfit, unless they have in some way been elected or delegated in such a way as to make the assent of those represented apparent.

Finally, former military often have the unshakable notion that everything they know is classified, and that civilians should not know a damned thing about the operation of the military - and that is why the Constitution was written as it was to give the military itself no political power whatsoever.
 
Exactly.

You know I do not want to be giving NavySEAL a hard time; I really respect what he did for the country.
Giving him a hard time? He's the one playing games here.

I simply do not think that soldiers, current or former, need to say anything about the President at all.

POLICY, yes.

Elections, yes.

Politics in general, yes.

The POTUS, NO.

Nor do I believe that they ought to believe that they can speak for all soldiers, or even all members of their former outfit, unless they have in some way been elected or delegated in such a way as to make the assent of those represented apparent.

Finally, former military often have the unshakable notion that everything they know is classified, and that civilians should not know a damned thing about the operation of the military - and that is why the Constitution was written as it was to give the military itself no political power whatsoever.
I agree with this.
 
Beside this attack line by the Republicans being incredibly stupid, don't they realize they're hurting themselves in the process by constantly reminding people Obama killed Osama?

I'd just ignore it as much as I could if I were the Republicans.
 
Last edited:
Beside this attack line by the Republicans being incredibly stupid, don't they think they're hurting themselves in the process by constantly reminding people Obama killed Osama?

I'd just ignore it as much as I could if I were the Republicans.

Good point, let it alone
 
Exactly.

You know I do not want to be giving NavySEAL a hard time; I really respect what he did for the country.

I simply do not think that soldiers, current or former, need to say anything about the President at all.
I disagree with the bolded bit. I cannot see how former soldiers don't have the same right as all Americans.
Nor do I believe that they ought to believe that they can speak for all soldiers, or even all members of their former outfit, unless they have in some way been elected or delegated in such a way as to make the assent of those represented apparent.
This does not only apply to soldiers. I don't have the right to speak for all scientists, drunks, or 6'3" redheads.
Finally, former military often have the unshakable notion that everything they know is classified, and that civilians should not know a damned thing about the operation of the military - and that is why the Constitution was written as it was to give the military itself no political power whatsoever.
This I totally agree with.

Daredelvis
 
I simply do not think that soldiers, current or former, need to say anything about the President at all.
That's gonna be kinda tough you know, since a great number of politicians are ex-soldiers. Are you saying Jimmy Carter shouldn't say anything about the President? John McCain? GHW Bush?*

No, Ben, this is simply ridiculous. Ex-soldiers have the same rights as all other citizens.


*I'd include GW Bush, but I'm not absolutely certain he was ever a soldier.
 
That's gonna be kinda tough you know, since a great number of politicians are ex-soldiers. Are you saying Jimmy Carter shouldn't say anything about the President? John McCain? GHW Bush?*

No, Ben, this is simply ridiculous. Ex-soldiers have the same rights as all other citizens.


*I'd include GW Bush, but I'm not absolutely certain he was ever a soldier.

Yeah, you're probably right, but it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth when they do.
 
Well I think soldiers have the right to an opinion. I just don't think they should try and use their status to make their opinion seem more important.

And really if NavySEAL had just said that he doesn't really care for Obama we could have avoided most of this argument. Going down this silly road where the President supposedly isn't allowed to talk about successful missions is just silly.
 
Exactly.

You know I do not want to be giving NavySEAL a hard time; I really respect what he did for the country.

I simply do not think that soldiers, current or former, need to say anything about the President at all.

POLICY, yes.

Elections, yes.

Politics in general, yes.

The POTUS, NO.

Nor do I believe that they ought to believe that they can speak for all soldiers, or even all members of their former outfit, unless they have in some way been elected or delegated in such a way as to make the assent of those represented apparent.

Finally, former military often have the unshakable notion that everything they know is classified, and that civilians should not know a damned thing about the operation of the military - and that is why the Constitution was written as it was to give the military itself no political power whatsoever.
Thank you. Good post.
 
There's a show on Discovery Channel right now called "Secrets of SEAL Team 6".

You must be furious about that, NavySEAL.
 
"Hello NavySEAL, it appears that you have not posted on our forums in several weeks. Why not take a few moments to ask a question, help provide a solution or just engage in a conversation with another member in any one of our forums?"

OK willl do.

"Retired member of SEAL Team 6 launches anti-Obama PAC


A new super PAC that includes retired special operations personnel and other veterans announced plans Wednesday to raise money to run ads in swing states against President Obama.

The group, Special Operations for America, filed paperwork Monday with the Federal Election Commission. It is headed by retired Navy SEAL Commander Ryan Zinke. During his 23-year career, Zinke spent time in the Navy's elite SEAL Team 6, the same team that killed Osama bin Laden in a commando raid last year.

Zinke said he and other members of the special operations community are outraged that SEAL Team 6 was identified as the commando unit that carried out the raid, saying it put its members and their families at risk. Zinke said he believes the president has politicized his role as commander in chief to win re-election"..............

http://www.coloradoan.com/usatoday/article/56322128?odyssey=obinsite
 
Well yesterday I didn't know that Ryan Zinke was a former Navy Seal and apparently a huge *******. Today I do.


Thanks Ryan for outing yourself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom