Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

I haven't read all this thread so I am not sure if this has been brought up but if anyone is claiming Obama didn't kill Bin Laden even though he order it then, by extension, Bin Laden didn't kill anyone on 9/11 even though he ordered it.

If that's true, what has all the fighting in Afghanistan been about? :tank:

Or is this a biblical thing where there is a different standard for the Israelite than there is for the heathen?
 
Joint Chiefs Chairman, Special Ops Officers Condemn ‘Shameful’ Anti-Obama Groups

TP said:
The country’s top military officer condemned members of swift boat groups that have cropped up this election season attacking President Obama on national security grounds. Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman Gen. Martin Dempsey would not comment on the substance of the groups’ attacks but told reporters on a plane back to the U.S. from Afghanistan that they’re “not useful”:
“And one of the things that marks us as a profession in a democracy, in our form of democracy, that’s most important is that we remain apolitical.
“That’s how we maintain our bond and trust with the American people,” the general said.
​
 
If I wanted to talk to a Birther lunatic, I'd just go back over to the Conspiracy Theories subforum.

Now, are you going to address the issues and questions put to you in this thread, or aren't you?

Ditto, but I want to know what NAVYSeal thinks about Act of Valor, the movie. He keeps ducking the issue, and I will keep asking the question. I am starting to suspect he does not have what it takes to address the issue.

Daredelvis
 
Oh, it gets better:
Anti-Obama SEAL group wants bin Laden raid book stopped
A group of ex-Navy SEALs wants the Obama administration to use any means available to halt publication of a new book detailing the Osama bin Laden raid.

Scott Taylor, president of the Special Ops OPSEC Education Fund, called on Attorney General Eric Holder to get an injunction against the publication of "No Easy Day: The Firsthand Account of the Mission That Killed Osama bin Laden."

OPSEC — headed by a former Republican candidate for Congress — released a 22-minute video earlier this month that accused President Obama of compromising national security through national security leaks and the release of information about the bin Laden raid.

"We are asking you to commit any and all resources of the Department of Justice necessary, including your authority as the U.S. Attorney General, to immediately seek the extraordinary remedy of an injunction in federal court to prevent this book from being published and distributed until it can be subjected to proper review procedures by the appropriate government agency. A failure to act to prevent an unauthorized disclosure of sensitive or classified information is a failure to act to protect those who serve our country," Taylor wrote to Holder.
http://www.politico.com/politico44/...wants-bin-laden-raid-book-stopped-133327.html
 

NavySEAL, don't you know all current and former SEALs by name? Can't you talk to the author of this book and convince him to stop publication, so the poor OPSEC guys don't hve to rely on our illegitimate, foreign-born Socialist Muslim president?

Oh, and can I also say how much I admire the honor and integrity of the OPSEC guys for wanting Obama to take action against one of their own comrades in the SEALs (and one of the heroes who helped take down Bin Laden, no less), especially after they publicly called Obama an illegitimate, foreign-born Socialist Muslim?

Because I totally do.
 
Last edited:
Got anyone who isn't BS crazy, NavySEAL?

Apparently not.

The lead spokesman for OPSEC Education Fund, a group of former special operations soldiers attacking President Barack Obama's national security credentials, has a long record of questioning the president's birthplace and religion, and calling him names like "Commander-in-Chief Hussein Mao-bama," trumpeting conspiracy theories, and insulting Muslims.

Former Navy SEAL Ben Smith is often quoted representing OPSEC Education Fund, a group of former special operations members who accuse the president of allowing leaks about classified military operations and taking undue credit for the work of special operations forces, such as the May 2011 killing of Osama bin Laden

[...]

Smith, who is featured in OPSEC's 22-minute video "Dishonorable Disclosures," was not only a spokesman for the Tea Party Express, he has a long record of writings that seek to portray the president as a foreign-born imposter bent on driving a socialist-Marxist agenda.

Following the president's January 2012 State of the Union Address, Smith wrote on his Facebook page, "This speech was given by the Heir Communist-in-Chief Hussein Mao-bama."

Smith then wrote that Obama had used "some bad tan lotion because he looked like an old bruised Banana which made me think that Harry Belafonte was walking out to give his rendition of ‘Day-O' before ‘ole' suck and blow' was to come out and enlighten us with his blasphemous spew."

"You are an Imposter, You are a Muslim (Cassius Clay, Lew Alcindor, Barry Soetoro), You are the Manchurian President and may you go back to the country you were born in when you are deposed you little, little man (and take all your communist sympathizers with you)," Smith wrote. "You insult everything that was considered American. May you and your administration be a lesson to history and your posterity be lost to the rebirth of AMERICAN PATRIOTISM!"

Truly, has any other nation been so blessed as to be served by men of such patriotism, integrity, honor, and professionalism that they make such vile and open slurs about the sitting President and Commander in Chief of the United States and call for him to be deposed?

A proud day for America and her armed forces, indeed.
 
Birther? What are you ...oh.

Well, there went any creditability that guy might have had.

Got anyone who isn't BS crazy, NavySEAL?
Birther? Please tell me our best and brightest don't buy into birther nonsense?
 
They don't want a book published about it for one reason... It will hurt the GOP on the foreign affairs and security front. Oh, and they are racists birthers.
 
Somehow this whole saga has only made me lose an enormous amount of respect for Navy Seals in general.

And that is saying something.
 
Somehow this whole saga has only made me lose an enormous amount of respect for Navy Seals in general.

And that is saying something.

I doubt that the majority of the team agrees with what the crazy people speaking for them are doing.
 
NavySEAL, don't you know all current and former SEALs by name? Can't you talk to the author of this book and convince him to stop publication, so the poor OPSEC guys don't hve to rely on our illegitimate, foreign-born Socialist Muslim president?

Oh, and can I also say how much I admire the honor and integrity of the OPSEC guys for wanting Obama to take action against one of their own comrades in the SEALs (and one of the heroes who helped take down Bin Laden, no less), especially after they publicly called Obama an illegitimate, foreign-born Socialist Muslim?

Because I totally do.

I almost started a follow-up thread devoted to this issue since it seems to be a very personal and inflammatory issue for NavySeal.
 
Holy goat locker, am I ever late for this one.

Several points:

1) NavySEAL has been verified to the extent capable without marching into BUPERS and FOIA'ing his DD-214. If he were faking, the tangled web of identity theft and multiple false corroborations would be too much to take seriously. The most trusted source possible (the one the POWNetwork turns to to check SEAL claims against the roll of all naval special warfare operators ever) has vetted him as a personal friend. Move on.

2) Navy SEALs are like any group, they are not of a single political mind. There are SEALs that would likely disagree with NavySEAL about the Osama raid. You won't hear from any AD SEALs on JREF discussing operations, that would be career suicide and a surefire way to lose your trident in disgrace.

3) Full Disclosure for those that don't know: I am NOT a Navy SEAL, nor have I ever claimed to be. I am not a special warfare operator of any sort. I was an electronic warfare technician / intelligence analyst onboard a guided missile destroyer for five years. I vet special forces claims through my resources because people claiming to be part of that brotherhood burns me, particularly when they profit from it financially or egotistically.

4) Odds are I know the former Soviet naval arsenal better than you. :)
 
Maybe they didn't bury Bin Laden at sea.

47625048bf36bea58.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom