LSSBB
Devilish Dictionarian
I think that people have to accept that this is her lived experience. She is under no obligation to be positive about her life, body or experiences just to validate others.
Having been close at one time to someone who was transitioning I do recognise anxieties that my friend had.
1) That she mourned the girlhood she never had. She did have an interest in what it was like to grow up a girl. She wanted to vicariously share the experience. At times her need could be uncomfortable for me.
2) Hormone therapy does affect the emotions. Interestingly about 50% of M to F TG people express sexual attraction to women pre transitioning; half of those will change their sexual preference post hormone therapy.
3) Surgery is not great. Vaginas need daily maintenance, this is a constant reminder that one is TG. One does not transition to being a woman, one is in a constant state of transitioning. Surgery for F to M is even worse.
The phrase that her vagina is an open sore in the op-ed I read as being metaphorical rather than literal. The open sore being her continual need to maintain her femininity by artificial means. It is an open psychic sore.
We know people are capable of being irrational, but those irrational feelings are real to them, we should recognise their validity. For TG people there are a series of summits, coming out and living as a woman, getting hormone therapy, getting surgery, more surgery; each is the greatest challenge, then once is completed there is another challenge, it is only natural that there is a come down.
The reality is a proportion of people subsequently regret decisions they made around transitioning, particularly as it relates to fertility. There are many life affirming narratives of transitioning, but it is not inappropriate for someone to say that for some it can also be a trial.
I think this is well written, and makes sense to me.
One thing that gets me about how folks seem dismayed at this OP-Ed, is the point of view that the change isn't possibly being pursued to make them happier. Well, sometimes folks have reasons other than happiness that they pursue a goal - for some it may be to fulfill a certain purpose they feel for their life. We all aim to craft our lives to fulfill some vision we have of it, and happiness is not a mandatory part of that equation for anyone, we just may choose happiness as part of it.