NYT Op-Ed: "My New Vagina Won’t Make Me Happy" - It's bad.

Recently I've been reading through the Wikipedia articles related to nuclear weapon design. The metaphor on my mind is critical mass of fissionable material. In normal concentrations, gingers don't produce enough soulons to generate a soul. But put enough of them together, perhaps with a gadget to generate an initiating soulon pulse, and you might get something.

If you want a nuclear analogy, I'd consider them more like boron in a nuclear reactor. They suck up soulons, and thus interfere with the positive feedback that normal souls have with each other. Too many of them in one place and the people around them might as well be soulless too.
 
It really does read like a strawperson. I don't normally think such a possibility is worthy of consideration, though. Weird

The thing read weirdly to me but now that you mention it, you might be right. Almost reads like something written to smear trans people.


A dozen or so years ago, I would have considered the possibility to be laughable, but given everything I've learned about the various disinformation campaigns, and about the various anti-minority crusaders out there (racist, sexist, anti-LGBTQ, etc.), combined with what I've been learning about the burgeoning TERF movement in the last year (and their leaders/organizations like Cathy Brennan and Get the L Out), as well as activities by religious right organizations like the Pacific Justice Institute, I can more readily believe that this is yet another disinfo tactic.

Not that I'm saying it definitively is a disinformation troll or agent provocateur, after all it could just be a mentally ill individual who has had the bad fortunate to be unduly influenced by anti-trans rhetoric, but it does have a lot of the hallmarks, and fits the conspiracy theories far too neatly.
 
If you want a nuclear analogy, I'd consider them more like boron in a nuclear reactor. They suck up soulons, and thus interfere with the positive feedback that normal souls have with each other. Too many of them in one place and the people around them might as well be soulless too.
Metaphor, please.

I don't want any kind of analogy.
 
Vivacity is to fulgurite as ineffable is to...

A) infrangible
B) irrefragable
C) inion
D) vicereine

Remember, your SAT score determines your entire life!

Grammar-based process of elimination leaves only c and d.

Judging from your avatar, I'm thinking you must mean C. :)
 
Back to the OP for a moment: I get the feeling that this person's new vagina won't make anyone else happy either.
 
Not every trans is the same trans, it's why I hate labels.
people have different reasons to do what they do.

Seems to me the OP has bigger issues.
 
Last edited:
RE: The thread title. This reminds me of the classic Aladdin, where the evil magician walks down the street yelling "New lamps for old." In both cases the ignorant woman removes a functional rub activated gene shooting model and swaps it for an alternate cosmetic version that lacks most of the important functions, and doesn't necessarily look any better.
Typical woman.
 
Last edited:
Being a transperson myself, and having numerous trans friends in various states of transitioning or non-transitioning, I'd have to say that this person, assuming this person is who and what she says she is, has some serious mental issues that are not even remotely related to her being or not being transgender. Transpeople can suffer from any mental disorder that cispeople can, and this appears to be one of those cases.

I say appears to be, because I'm not necessarily convinced that this person is who she says she is. This entire thing reads like a page from the TERF conspiracy theory manual. She hits nearly all of their anti-trans propaganda points -- trans is just a mental illness, transwomen are only looking to invade female spaces, transpeople are "turned" trans rather than being born trans, GRS is nothing but genital mutilation and hormone therapy is inevitably damaging and not valid treatment, and so on. Her reference to Solanas kind of cements this view.

The options I see are:

1) She's trans, but has a lot of unrelated mental issues, and likely some internalized-oppression issues.
2) She's not trans, but has an untreated mental disorder that has her seriously confused about who and what she is.
3) She's a TERF, or a useful idiot spewing TERF anti-trans propaganda, trying to discredit transpeoples' experiences.

I'm leaning heavily toward 3 at this time, but the other two are equally likely.

What I do know is that there will be a whole lot of TERFs, religious nutjobs, and other anti-trans crusaders who will hold her up as epitomizing all transpeople and being typical of trans experience.

It really does read like a strawperson. I don't normally think such a possibility is worthy of consideration, though. Weird

The thing read weirdly to me but now that you mention it, you might be right. Almost reads like something written to smear trans people.

A dozen or so years ago, I would have considered the possibility to be laughable, but given everything I've learned about the various disinformation campaigns, and about the various anti-minority crusaders out there (racist, sexist, anti-LGBTQ, etc.), combined with what I've been learning about the burgeoning TERF movement in the last year (and their leaders/organizations like Cathy Brennan and Get the L Out), as well as activities by religious right organizations like the Pacific Justice Institute, I can more readily believe that this is yet another disinfo tactic.

Not that I'm saying it definitively is a disinformation troll or agent provocateur, after all it could just be a mentally ill individual who has had the bad fortunate to be unduly influenced by anti-trans rhetoric, but it does have a lot of the hallmarks, and fits the conspiracy theories far too neatly.

Here's her bio:

https://www.andrealongchu.com/full-bio/

And her CV:

https://static1.squarespace.com/sta.../1536062073646/Andrea+Long+Chu-CV+7-26-18.pdf

And here's her GFM:

https://www.gofundme.com/buy-me-a-new-body

Where she links to other portions of her body of work, including her Twitter feed. Apparently she's written several articles for a wide range of publications. I'm sure that with an evidence trail like that, you truth-seekers will be able to expose this fraud in no time.

Tell me one thing, though: Is the NYT in on the hoax, or were they fooled too?
 
Last edited:
I don't think they ARE a fake person or controlled opposition or whatever. I just think it reads that way.
 
Here's her bio:

https://www.andrealongchu.com/full-bio/

And her CV:

https://static1.squarespace.com/sta.../1536062073646/Andrea+Long+Chu-CV+7-26-18.pdf

And here's her GFM:

https://www.gofundme.com/buy-me-a-new-body

Where she links to other portions of her body of work, including her Twitter feed. Apparently she's written several articles for a wide range of publications. I'm sure that with an evidence trail like that, you truth-seekers will be able to expose this fraud in no time.

Tell me one thing, though: Is the NYT in on the hoax, or were they fooled too?
I think that people have to accept that this is her lived experience. She is under no obligation to be positive about her life, body or experiences just to validate others.

Having been close at one time to someone who was transitioning I do recognise anxieties that my friend had.

1) That she mourned the girlhood she never had. She did have an interest in what it was like to grow up a girl. She wanted to vicariously share the experience. At times her need could be uncomfortable for me.
2) Hormone therapy does affect the emotions. Interestingly about 50% of M to F TG people express sexual attraction to women pre transitioning; half of those will change their sexual preference post hormone therapy.
3) Surgery is not great. Vaginas need daily maintenance, this is a constant reminder that one is TG. One does not transition to being a woman, one is in a constant state of transitioning. Surgery for F to M is even worse.

The phrase that her vagina is an open sore in the op-ed I read as being metaphorical rather than literal. The open sore being her continual need to maintain her femininity by artificial means. It is an open psychic sore.

We know people are capable of being irrational, but those irrational feelings are real to them, we should recognise their validity. For TG people there are a series of summits, coming out and living as a woman, getting hormone therapy, getting surgery, more surgery; each is the greatest challenge, then once is completed there is another challenge, it is only natural that there is a come down.

The reality is a proportion of people subsequently regret decisions they made around transitioning, particularly as it relates to fertility. There are many life affirming narratives of transitioning, but it is not inappropriate for someone to say that for some it can also be a trial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom