NYT Op-Ed: "My New Vagina Won’t Make Me Happy" - It's bad.

As a father of a trans teen, I know what my sons reaction will be to this ball of crap.

Nevertheless, I will present it without prejudice just to see what he makes of it.

Result to follow whenever he reads it.
 

The author of the op-ed reminded me of your posts a lot.
Arguing that principles should be applied no matter the outcome, and arguing that stuff like happiness, success, viability and so on shouldn't play a part in our decision making process.
 
I would agree with Buddha that the op-ed author seems to have a lot of emotional complications surrounding her gender identity. Gender dysphoria, suicidal thoughts, fetishization, and radical gender politics all in a witches brew of self-doubt and unhappiness.

While her situation may be more complicated than most trans people, I expect most would have a pretty complicated set of emotions when it comes to gender dysphoria, self identity, and reassignment surgeries. I don't even know where someone would begin trying to establish any kind of psychological standard for gatekeeping this procedure, nor whether that is a good idea. I don't envy anyone in these situations.
 
Last edited:
How would she have many? They're like, one in a thousand, if that. I have trouble finding red-haired people around me, and I live up north.

Have you tried actively seeking out the redheads, though? Gay people are a minority but we manage to find each other. By, you know, looking. Try your local redhead bar, or the sunscreen aisle in the drug store.
 
Have you tried actively seeking out the redheads, though? Gay people are a minority but we manage to find each other. By, you know, looking. Try your local redhead bar, or the sunscreen aisle in the drug store.

That's where I meet most of my bald friends, too.
 
The story is a recursive loop into existentialist hell.

The Onion used to do these fake newspaper covers that were supposedly from decades ago. I remember one of them, supposedly from 1944, had a headline, "French playwright says that Hell is other French people".
 
I'd love for them to find a physical cause for LGBT, it would put the debate to rest.

Isn’t there a theory that it is largely explained by exposure to testosterone in the womb, and that this can account for not only sexual preference but also to other phenotypes typically thought common to the opposite sex?
 
How would she have many? They're like, one in a thousand, if that. I have trouble finding red-haired people around me, and I live up north.

Ok so one in a thousand... then how many live in NYC, where she lives? Do you think people with something in common, something which also alienates them from others, might seek each other out?
 
Ok so one in a thousand... then how many live in NYC, where she lives? Do you think people with something in common, something which also alienates them from others, might seek each other out?

There are only so many pro basketball players in the world, and yet, somehow, ten of them have managed to find one another right here in the middle of this arena!
 
For both angles in one, we have this article:

The truth is, I have never been able to differentiate liking women from wanting to be like them.

...

It was in my junior year of college that I first read the SCUM Manifesto, crossing over the East River in a lonely subway car. It exhilarated me: the grandeur, the brutal polemics, the raw, succulent style of the whole thing. Solanas was cool. Rereading SCUM, I realized this was no accident.

...

This line took my breath away. This was a vision of transsexuality as separatism, an image of how male-to-female gender transition might express not just disidentification with maleness but disaffiliation with men. Here, transition, like revolution, was recast in aesthetic terms, as if transsexual women decided to transition, not to “confirm” some kind of innate gender identity, but because being a man is stupid and boring.


I was curious about the date of that article since it reminded me of one of the episodes of American Horror Story: Cult (2017). The article is from 2018!
I think that the writer may have been inspired by the two self-hating gay characters in Cult rather than by the actual SCUM Manifesto.
 
What a great way to put it. Contentment is always going to be out of reach.

That's not quite right, though. It's true that there seems to be no limit to human desire, and that even people who have "everything" still want something more. But this person is describing a deep and sickening sense of *lack* that goes far beyond the healthy human experience of (partial) contentment.
 
How would she have many? They're like, one in a thousand, if that. I have trouble finding red-haired people around me, and I live up north.

But they're not entirely randomly distributed across the world. Trans people like many groups who aren't looked on too fondly by conservative America, flock to cities like NYC. And within those cities, trans people, like other marginalized groups, concentrate around things like the arts and political activism. I run in similar social circles and have a lot more gay and trans friends and aquaintences than the national average would suggest.
 
Being a transperson myself, and having numerous trans friends in various states of transitioning or non-transitioning, I'd have to say that this person, assuming this person is who and what she says she is, has some serious mental issues that are not even remotely related to her being or not being transgender. Transpeople can suffer from any mental disorder that cispeople can, and this appears to be one of those cases.

I say appears to be, because I'm not necessarily convinced that this person is who she says she is. This entire thing reads like a page from the TERF conspiracy theory manual. She hits nearly all of their anti-trans propaganda points -- trans is just a mental illness, transwomen are only looking to invade female spaces, transpeople are "turned" trans rather than being born trans, GRS is nothing but genital mutilation and hormone therapy is inevitably damaging and not valid treatment, and so on. Her reference to Solanas kind of cements this view.

The options I see are:

1) She's trans, but has a lot of unrelated mental issues, and likely some internalized-oppression issues.
2) She's not trans, but has an untreated mental disorder that has her seriously confused about who and what she is.
3) She's a TERF, or a useful idiot spewing TERF anti-trans propaganda, trying to discredit transpeoples' experiences.

I'm leaning heavily toward 3 at this time, but the other two are equally likely.

What I do know is that there will be a whole lot of TERFs, religious nutjobs, and other anti-trans crusaders who will hold her up as epitomizing all transpeople and being typical of trans experience.
 
Last edited:
It really does read like a strawperson. I don't normally think such a possibility is worthy of consideration, though. Weird
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom