NYT Op-Ed: "My New Vagina Won’t Make Me Happy" - It's bad.

2) She's not trans, but has an untreated mental disorder that has her seriously confused about who and what she is.

What exactly is the difference?

Last time I checked, gender dysphoria is indeed a mental disorder, that is treated by the medical and social transition to the subject's desired socio-biological gender construct.
 
Have you tried actively seeking out the redheads, though? Gay people are a minority but we manage to find each other. By, you know, looking. Try your local redhead bar, or the sunscreen aisle in the drug store.

Gays and lesbians, I get. But why would trans people go out looking for one another? You're right, I haven't looked for gingers, because there's no reason for us to congregate.

Plus, as you've surely noticed, we're all massive pricks.
 
I say appears to be, because I'm not necessarily convinced that this person is who she says she is. This entire thing reads like a page from the TERF conspiracy theory manual. She hits nearly all of their anti-trans propaganda points -- trans is just a mental illness, transwomen are only looking to invade female spaces, transpeople are "turned" trans rather than being born trans, GRS is nothing but genital mutilation and hormone therapy is inevitably damaging and not valid treatment, and so on. Her reference to Solanas kind of cements this view.

The thing read weirdly to me but now that you mention it, you might be right. Almost reads like something written to smear trans people.
 
What exactly is the difference?

Last time I checked, gender dysphoria is indeed a mental disorder, that is treated by the medical and social transition to the subject's desired socio-biological gender construct.

If a person is in significant distress because of gender dysphoria, that and that alone makes it a "disorder" (almost by definition).

Transpeople are not necessarily in distress of any significant magnitude over gender dysphoria issues, though.
 
But why would trans people go out looking for one another?

Members of minority groups often seek friendship and companionship with other members of the same group.

It's just nice to not be the oddball sometimes.
 
Op eds aren't news.

Fake op eds have the same implications for media credibility as fake news reports. I don't mind putting them under the same heading.

ETA: And I wouldn't say they aren't news. Certainly when the New York Times publishes an opinion, they're saying, "this opinion is newsworthy." "You should consider these ideas." Etc. In a sense, fake op eds are even worse. They're not giving you bad facts. They're giving you bad ideas and bad conclusions.
 
Last edited:
I can't really tell what the motive of this op-ed is. Is it meant to be a public commentary on the wider issue of medical gatekeeping for GRS and trans people, or just a human interest story specifically about this very conflicted person.

If it's supposed to be the former, it seems a bit sketchy to me. I don't think this author's story typifies the dilemma that trans people face when making these decisions by a long shot.

I wouldn't go so far as calling it fake news, but I do find it a bit muddled and strange for the NYT.
 
Nonsense. You can't add zeros to produce a non-zero number.

Recently I've been reading through the Wikipedia articles related to nuclear weapon design. The metaphor on my mind is critical mass of fissionable material. In normal concentrations, gingers don't produce enough soulons to generate a soul. But put enough of them together, perhaps with a gadget to generate an initiating soulon pulse, and you might get something.
 
Recently I've been reading through the Wikipedia articles related to nuclear weapon design. The metaphor on my mind is critical mass of fissionable material. In normal concentrations, gingers don't produce enough soulons to generate a soul. But put enough of them together, perhaps with a gadget to generate an initiating soulon pulse, and you might get something.

Just why exactly were you reading up on nuke design? Planning to give a few as presents to the Ukraine? I think they'd appreciate it very much around now!

I've been reading up on food taboos. Things I've learned: bear meat isn't kosher, eating cat meat was legal in Germany until 1996, and Sunni Islam is okay with eating whale meat but only if the whale died from natural causes.

Wikipedia is awesome.
 
Recently I've been reading through the Wikipedia articles related to nuclear weapon design. The metaphor on my mind is critical mass of fissionable material. In normal concentrations, gingers don't produce enough soulons to generate a soul. But put enough of them together, perhaps with a gadget to generate an initiating soulon pulse, and you might get something.

Yeah but you're assuming that we generate any at all.
 
Just why exactly were you reading up on nuke design? Planning to give a few as presents to the Ukraine? I think they'd appreciate it very much around now!

I've been reading up on food taboos. Things I've learned: bear meat isn't kosher, eating cat meat was legal in Germany until 1996, and Sunni Islam is okay with eating whale meat but only if the whale died from natural causes.

Wikipedia is awesome.

Whales just giant sea pigs, as far as I'm concerned. I'd think they have a problem with that.
 
Whales just giant sea pigs, as far as I'm concerned. I'd think they have a problem with that.

Biologically, whales are more closely related to crickets than they are to pigs. Their most recent common ancestor is a metamorphic rock.
 
I wouldn't go so far as calling it fake news, but I do find it a bit muddled and strange for the NYT.

I suppose we could see a different headline somewhere...

"New York Times accused of transphobia for refusing to publish an op-ed by a transperson."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom