johnny karate
... and your little dog too.
- Joined
- Jan 12, 2007
- Messages
- 18,950
Rev was banned.
That's not a nitpick, it's true. It's a feature of my calculations. I'm attempting to show that the impulse from explosives, even with an extremely generous overestimate of the pressure and duration, still gives you unimpressive velocities. This is explained in my forthcoming report.
Thanks for the reference, by the way. It's not the same as mine but should give me a good basis for comparison. I high-balled the estimate because the other structure will give you a focusing effect -- possibly the upper and lower floors would increase the pressure at that distance, and also give you reflected waves that could add up making a longer pulse. It's going to be very difficult to calculate it precisely, so a generous estimate was good enough for my purposes.
So, in summary, you're quite right. And it drives the stake even deeper into the heart of the "CD" hypothesis.
It's Beer Reviewed. [qimg]http://www.goldenweb.it/software/immagini/icone/food/food_2/dark%20beer.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://www.goldenweb.it/software/immagini/icone/food/food_2/dark%20beer.gif[/qimg]

I debunked some of this before it even came out.
http://www.debunking911.com/jones.htm
http://www.debunking911.com/collapse.htm
I have read those links before, but using the equation given by Nonaka will further demonstrate how ridiculous the CD nonsense is. I'd like to see Mackey's sources as well though.

For us non-technical types, is it an accurate to say that Dr. Grabbe's paper is self-debunking because he estimates the speed of the "squib" in Figure 4 as between 100 and 200 feet/second (68-136 miles/hour), which would be way too slow for it to have been generated by an explosion?