New J of 9/11 Studies Paper

That's not a nitpick, it's true. It's a feature of my calculations. I'm attempting to show that the impulse from explosives, even with an extremely generous overestimate of the pressure and duration, still gives you unimpressive velocities. This is explained in my forthcoming report.

Thanks for the reference, by the way. It's not the same as mine but should give me a good basis for comparison. I high-balled the estimate because the other structure will give you a focusing effect -- possibly the upper and lower floors would increase the pressure at that distance, and also give you reflected waves that could add up making a longer pulse. It's going to be very difficult to calculate it precisely, so a generous estimate was good enough for my purposes.

So, in summary, you're quite right. And it drives the stake even deeper into the heart of the "CD" hypothesis.

Can you link to your references? I'd like to check and compare as well.
 

I have read those links before, but using the equation given by Nonaka will further demonstrate how ridiculous the CD nonsense is. I'd like to see Mackey's sources as well though.

If we stick to Mackey's model, in which none of the impulse is dissipated through shearing or plastic bending, and using the same box column at the top of the tower, a constant pressure load of about 896.4 kPA is needed for 17 milliseconds to eject the member at the top floor of the WTC at the required velocity to travel 500 ft.

If the charge is detonated at 15 meters, it will have to be equal to about 1950 kg of TNT using Nonaka's equation in appendix B(which gives the peak pressure load, which then decreases monotonically, rather than remaining constant, as is being assumed here). And if you make the assumption that the massive charge would not be sitting in the middle of an office and would be hidden within the core at a minimum of 60ft, the size of the charge jumps up to approx 3500kg of TNT.

The smaller of the two explosions is 4 times the size of the explosion from the 93 WTC bombing.
 
I have read those links before, but using the equation given by Nonaka will further demonstrate how ridiculous the CD nonsense is. I'd like to see Mackey's sources as well though.

Sorry for the delay, I was at the Cape all week.

The reference I used is "A Review of Methods for Predicting Bomb Blast Effects on Buildings", A. Rememnikov, Journal of Battlefield Technology, Vol. 6 No. 3, 2003. There is an archived copy readable here. The example I use is taken verbatim from Page 3.

The reason I chose this reference is because of his correct usage of wave reflection, which is an important factor in actual impulse felt by a structure, and the "reasonable" size of his reference explosive. This paper is, after all, intended to directly address the question of explosives versus buildings, which is what we need to know.

Another reason is that the Journal of Battlefield Technology is about the coolest name for a Journal that I've ever seen. :tank:
 
Thanks, thats pretty interesting, and definitely a great name for a journal.

Kind of wish he would info on the effects of distance and charge weight since his numbers are not in close agreement with the other reference, where these are given, but effects of wave reflection are not. Although I suppose the point is made easily enough with the reference charge used.
 
For us non-technical types, is it an accurate to say that Dr. Grabbe's paper is self-debunking because he estimates the speed of the "squib" in Figure 4 as between 100 and 200 feet/second (68-136 miles/hour), which would be way too slow for it to have been generated by an explosion?
 
For us non-technical types, is it an accurate to say that Dr. Grabbe's paper is self-debunking because he estimates the speed of the "squib" in Figure 4 as between 100 and 200 feet/second (68-136 miles/hour), which would be way too slow for it to have been generated by an explosion?

I think 'an explosion' is not enough to characterize the event. The paper I linked to as well as RM's paper show that the blast loads from an explosion are dependent on scaled distance as well as the weight of the charge. Mackey's link includes the effect of reflected waves as well.

So I would say Dr. Grabbe should have attempted to show how much explosive was used, and where this charge was placed, in order to create the 'squib' observed, which is certainly reasonable. This way it can be seen if his claim has scientific merit, but as it stands, his work seems more like a collection of assumptions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom