New J of 9/11 Studies Paper

realcddeal isn't Crockett Grabbe, for what it's worth.
 
Good to know.

For what it's worth, I ran some calculations on how far a 100 kg blast of TNT would be expected to throw a 3m column section, originally located 15m from the blast (anything closer would probably destroy it). It works out to an initial velocity of only about 5 meters per second. If ejected in this fashion from the top of the Towers, this means a maximum distance of under 50 meters away from the footprint.

So, if Mr. Grabbe is right, we're talking about really, really big explosives. Funny that nobody saw them, including Protec and the LDEO.
 
Good to know.

For what it's worth, I ran some calculations on how far a 100 kg blast of TNT would be expected to throw a 3m column section, originally located 15m from the blast (anything closer would probably destroy it). It works out to an initial velocity of only about 5 meters per second. If ejected in this fashion from the top of the Towers, this means a maximum distance of under 50 meters away from the footprint.

So, if Mr. Grabbe is right, we're talking about really, really big explosives. Funny that nobody saw them, including Protec and the LDEO.
And you're talking only about the force to move the column, not to sever it from its connections, right?
 
Yup. I'm assuming the column was free-standing and unattached when the pressure wave hits.

Much harder to estimate how it behaves if the explosive shears it off. There would probably be some elastic effect, but surely being hard-mounted would dissipate the blast, not actually make it fly farther.
 
You don't suppose that going through life with a name like "Crockett Grabbe" could have a profound psychological impact on a person?

Just sayin'....
 
You don't suppose that going through life with a name like "Crockett Grabbe" could have a profound psychological impact on a person?

Just sayin'....
I love the name. It may even be better than Buster Crabbe.
 
You don't suppose that going through life with a name like "Crockett Grabbe" could have a profound psychological impact on a person?

Just sayin'....

I have to admit, the first thing I thought when I saw the guy's name was, "Jesus, that poor guy had cruel parents."


(But he also goes by another name of his own choosing, which isn't a whole lot better, so.. who knows?)

In any event, his "paper" is complete crap and utterly meaningless; entirely in keeping with the pseudo-scholars' psuedo journal. Sad, no matter how you dissect it.
 
Last edited:
Seems he has some research experience in an area that might qualify him to refute the no-planer Space Beam theories...

TAM:)

Oh god, he's being taught in IOWA.

I'm not drinking the water for a couple of weeks.
 
I'm sure it is already stupid before a single line has been recalculated.
And about peer reviewing, ask your physics bozos and let them review it.

Physics Bozo is on the case!!!!

OK, peer review coming.

The paper makes the assertion that certain photographs of the WTC collapse prove that explosions were responsible for the ejection of debris, but advances no evidence for the assertion. Pictures of damaged cars are produced more to refute the beam weapon theory than to promote the explosives theory; the damage is characterised as due to hot and possibly corrosive debris, but no evidence is advanced that this debris was not ejected as a result of glancing collisions in the collapse of the towers, or that the heating of the debris was not a result of the extensive pre-collapse fires.

In discussion of the "squibs", the key assertion that "overpressure is created by explosions" is not justified. The discussion of the radial distribution of debris is superfluous, as the ejection velocity has already been deduced from videos, and the comment that "it is likely that explosions are also occurring after the growing dust cloud envelopes the area" is pure speculation unsupported by evidence.

In summary, this paper is an attempt at proof by assertion, and no evidence is advanced to support its central thesis. Einsteen's characterisation of the paper as "already stupid before a single line has been recalculated" is a highly perceptive and accurate summary of the paper.

Refused for publication. Re-submission is not advised.

Dave
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.
 
I love it when people who still have to ask mom to stay up past 11 on a school night try to act like they're the reason the earth is still spinning.
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.

You're 15 and seem to be a bright kid. I'm imploring you to do the following.

Call an engineering firm in your area and listen to a structural engineer. Perhaps you have a local college with a decent engineering department. Take the time to talk to people who actually know what they're talking about. It doesn't matter what a theology professor or former Friendly's worker thinks.

Why do I ask you this? I was actually at 7WTC for three years including 9-11. I experienced things that you can't see on You Tube or staring at pictures.

I felt the debris pounding the building on 9-11 and was forced to go out the back because of it. I was on almost every floor SSB had in my role on a daily basis and never saw any construction work being done.

Did you know 3 floors had people on it 24x 7 because they were trading floors? Most people were on there on the weekends too because of the pressures of the job. they paid us well but everyone had to bust their asses Did you know we were packed in like sardines after Salomon/Smith Barney merger? You Tube won't tell you that.

Guess what explanation I receive from "truthers". The building was pre-wired. PRE-WIRED!

Stop using 9-11 truth as a way of finding an identity and use the critical thinking skills I think you have. This isn't a joke for me. My best friend died that day and if I thought for even a second there was a chance of government involvement, I would be the first one storming the White House.
 
You're 15 and seem to be a bright kid. I'm imploring you to do the following.

Call an engineering firm in your area and listen to a structural engineer. Perhaps you have a local college with a decent engineering department. Take the time to talk to people who actually know what they're talking about. It doesn't matter what a theology professor or former Friendly's worker thinks.

Why do I ask you this? I was actually at 7WTC for three years including 9-11. I experienced things that you can't see on You Tube or staring at pictures.

I felt the debris pounding the building on 9-11 and was forced to go out the back because of it. I was on almost every floor SSB had in my role on a daily basis and never saw any construction work being done.

Did you know 3 floors had people on it 24x 7 because they were trading floors? Most people were on there on the weekends too because of the pressures of the job. they paid us well but everyone had to bust their asses Did you know we were packed in like sardines after Salomon/Smith Barney merger? You Tube won't tell you that.

Guess what explanation I receive from "truthers". The building was pre-wired. PRE-WIRED!

Stop using 9-11 truth as a way of finding an identity and use the critical thinking skills I think you have. This isn't a joke for me. My best friend died that day and if I thought for even a second there was a chance of government involvement, I would be the first one storming the White House.

*applauds vigorously* Nothing more need be said.
 
Yes a tour guide that your entire movement is afraid do bebate!!!

TAM:)

Well, except that Jason and Dylan debated him, as did Fetzer. He was set to do the National 911 debate but nobody else from the OCT side would do it. Nobody is afraid to debate Gravy.
 
Well, except that Jason and Dylan debated him, as did Fetzer. He was set to do the National 911 debate but nobody else from the OCT side would do it. Nobody is afraid to debate Gravy.

not afraid to do it once, but they will not ever do it again

they were destroyed
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom