New J of 9/11 Studies Paper

Are you afraid of capital letters and periods?

They were not destroyed at all.

uncle fester was made to look a fool

how many words did dylan actually utter? not counting the ones that he used to correct jasons mistakes

if those had been boxing matches the trainer would have thrown in the towel

we don't call then periods in my country short stuff

if i use capitals i may scare you off
 
Sorry Rev, but their patterns of behaviour on this matter leads me to believe they are all afraid to bebate him. They only have to read his papers, watch his debates with LTW and Fetzer to realize he is not some "out of the loop" scientist or beurocrat that they can bamboozle with the fog of 9/11 twoof.

TAM:)
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.

What kind of asinine appeal to authority is this?

Do you really want me to start playing this game with you? Where'd you get your degree from?
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.
I don't need to be an astonomer to know that a paper put out by an astronomer claiming that the Sun goes around the Earth is nonsensical.
 
Lace up your debunking boots, this is a fairly brief analysis that REFUTES Woods' and Morgan's space beam theories. Instead, calculations are presented to conclude:

"Calculations using a range of estimates from observations show the destruction from these explosions range up to 1/4 mile or more in most directions. These strongly enhance the evidence presented in previous studies, such the photo in Figure 1 which shows the rapidly expanding huge dust clouds from the towers resulting from massive pulverization of the non-metallic parts of the towers in mid-air, along with hundreds of pieces of metal cladding and beams flying through the air on their rim. All of them provide dramatic examples of the devastation of the explosions in the World Trade
Center towers 6 years ago."

Direct Evidence for Explosions: Flying Projectiles and
Widespread Impact Damage
Dr. Crockett Grabbe
http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/200704/GrabbeExplosionsEvidence.pdf
Your nonsense is garbage, only kids with no education fall for. If you had studied CD, you would know that explosives are not used to destroy the building but gravity is. You have failed to understand your world. I warn you now, if you are as poor in all aspects of your life, you could be in danger of making mistakes that risk your life. You must get better at understanding the real world and people. You have fallen for the biggest lies in modern history, the 9/11 truth movement. I can tell from your post you do not understand how gravity can do what you saw on 9/11 and that you did not know the primary energy used in CD is due to gravity.

Go get an education before you make serious mistakes in life. Being fooled by 9/11 truth only makes you look foolish. BTW, the idiot who wrote the paper is missing the blast effects to send object 1/4 of a mile. The sound alone would have been heard, but it was not. Sorry to debunk a paper without reading it, but you gave away the BS in your post. What has happened to rational thinking? Why are you so easily fooled?
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.
Pay attention young person of woo. When a paper is published in the journal of woo, you know it as, " Journal of 9/11 Studies", it is wrong and does not have to be read after one of the experts, like you, from LCF endorses it. I have found if you (R91) endorse something, it is 99.999999 percent BS. Not sure why this works but take any paper from the Journal of Woo, and you will find out too.

Go ahead, take a paper and show me one that is good for anything 9/11. Got one? This one is the biggest piles of junk, and I can see from just RedIbis and you, that it is woo too.

So should I read it? (1:25PST) (Kevin Ryan and Jones make it 99.99999999999999 Percent BS, you have more potential to become a real person who can think than these two clowns, but you have to start thinking for yourself and stop being a drone to 9/11 truth idiots)

Oops, read it! (1:28) It is total BS. What a bunch of BS, no comment is needed to mark this woo, with the mark of woo. Funny, he uses work of other truthers to make a paper of junk. Yes, from an engineer this is not very scientific, but get this real good. People who lie this bad and make up stuff this stupid do not deserve a critique. These people from 9/11 truth are so low, they are dumb as dirt. How can anyone push this tripe as science? You need to get help if you can not find enough information to debunk this yourself. If you can't do it yourself you are stuck in the 9/11 truth movement. Your problem.

I am sure other people with post the other scientific reasons, I am still laughing too much to even try.
 
I love it when extremely qualified internet posters, such as tour guides, dismiss physicists papers without even reading them.

If Gravy is not qualified to comment on this paper because he's a tour guide, albeit one with encyclopedic knowledge of all things 9/11, then surely R.Mackey, who is a NASA scientist, is qualified. And he thinks it's garbage too.

You really shouldn't advertise your ignorance so.
 
Last edited:
Oh god, he's being taught in IOWA.

I'm not drinking the water for a couple of weeks.

It's worse than that, I believe he's the one teaching.

I knew that the Iowa City water could get bad sometimes, but I had no idea. I'm happy with Mississippi river mud water:D
 
Good to know.

For what it's worth, I ran some calculations on how far a 100 kg blast of TNT would be expected to throw a 3m column section, originally located 15m from the blast (anything closer would probably destroy it). It works out to an initial velocity of only about 5 meters per second. If ejected in this fashion from the top of the Towers, this means a maximum distance of under 50 meters away from the footprint.

So, if Mr. Grabbe is right, we're talking about really, really big explosives. Funny that nobody saw them, including Protec and the LDEO.

Can you lay those calculations out in detail? It might be worthwhile to demonstrate this further, since the ejection of beams is such a major truther claim.

I believe there were reports of beams found 500 feet away, so if these came from the top floor they would need a horizontal velocity of 16.6m/s. Though that is just assuming they are ejected strait out and doesn't consider any kind of optimized trajectory. It still shows a huge difference while making ridiculous assumptions in favor of explosives though.
 
Can you lay those calculations out in detail? It might be worthwhile to demonstrate this further, since the ejection of beams is such a major truther claim.

I believe there were reports of beams found 500 feet away, so if these came from the top floor they would need a horizontal velocity of 16.6m/s. Though that is just assuming they are ejected strait out and doesn't consider any kind of optimized trajectory. It still shows a huge difference while making ridiculous assumptions in favor of explosives though.
Those calculations appear in my upcoming re-bunk of Dr. Griffin. Basically I found a published paper that describes the pressure load of a 100 kg TNT reference explosion, which at 15 meters creates a wave of about 270 kPa (40 psi) for 17 milliseconds. Multiply that times the facing area of the column and you get total impulse, divided by mass and you get initial velocity. I used a 3m high box column, 20 cm on a side, with 4 cm thick walls for sake of argument. This gives an initial velocity of about 5 meters per second.

It's a rough figure, but there's little point trying to sharpen it. The exact pressure and duration are a factor of explosive geometry and how the wave is shaped and reflected by solid objects. What's important is that, in the collapse front, we already expect speeds of 20 m/s or even more just from gravity alone at places fairly high in the structure. To get higher speeds with explosives, you need very large explosives. 100 kg of TNT is enough to get your attention, even if detonated while the Towers were coming down.
 
Those calculations appear in my upcoming re-bunk of Dr. Griffin. Basically I found a published paper that describes the pressure load of a 100 kg TNT reference explosion, which at 15 meters creates a wave of about 270 kPa (40 psi) for 17 milliseconds. Multiply that times the facing area of the column and you get total impulse, divided by mass and you get initial velocity. I used a 3m high box column, 20 cm on a side, with 4 cm thick walls for sake of argument. This gives an initial velocity of about 5 meters per second.

It's a rough figure, but there's little point trying to sharpen it. The exact pressure and duration are a factor of explosive geometry and how the wave is shaped and reflected by solid objects. What's important is that, in the collapse front, we already expect speeds of 20 m/s or even more just from gravity alone at places fairly high in the structure. To get higher speeds with explosives, you need very large explosives. 100 kg of TNT is enough to get your attention, even if detonated while the Towers were coming down.

I might be nitpicking, but I looked into it a bit further. I found a paper on the 1993 WTC bombing in the journal of impact engineering:

Shear failure of a steel member due to a blast
T. Nonaka

From the equation in appendix A, it would give the reference charge you used would give a peak pressure of 189.02 kPA, which would then decrease monotonically, so the impulse you are using is likely to be a generous overestimate.

It is also interesting to note that the calculated Mu(ratio of peak blast load to plastic collapse load) for this blast load on the example beam used in the paper is less than one, equaling 0.63158. Not only that, but about 10 times more energy will be absorbed by shearing than by bending anyway. Although the members may not be comparable and a friend pilfered my AISC handbook.
 
Last edited:
I might be nitpicking, but I looked into it a bit further. I found a paper on the 1993 WTC bombing in the journal of impact engineering:

Shear failure of a steel member due to a blast
T. Nonaka

From the equation in appendix A, it would give the reference charge you used would give a peak pressure of 189.02 kPA, which would then decrease monotonically, so the impulse you are using is likely to be a generous overestimate.

That's not a nitpick, it's true. It's a feature of my calculations. I'm attempting to show that the impulse from explosives, even with an extremely generous overestimate of the pressure and duration, still gives you unimpressive velocities. This is explained in my forthcoming report.

Thanks for the reference, by the way. It's not the same as mine but should give me a good basis for comparison. I high-balled the estimate because the other structure will give you a focusing effect -- possibly the upper and lower floors would increase the pressure at that distance, and also give you reflected waves that could add up making a longer pulse. It's going to be very difficult to calculate it precisely, so a generous estimate was good enough for my purposes.

So, in summary, you're quite right. And it drives the stake even deeper into the heart of the "CD" hypothesis.
 
That's not a nitpick, it's true. It's a feature of my calculations. I'm attempting to show that the impulse from explosives, even with an extremely generous overestimate of the pressure and duration, still gives you unimpressive velocities. This is explained in my forthcoming report.

Thanks for the reference, by the way. It's not the same as mine but should give me a good basis for comparison. I high-balled the estimate because the other structure will give you a focusing effect -- possibly the upper and lower floors would increase the pressure at that distance, and also give you reflected waves that could add up making a longer pulse. It's going to be very difficult to calculate it precisely, so a generous estimate was good enough for my purposes.

So, in summary, you're quite right. And it drives the stake even deeper into the heart of the "CD" hypothesis.

All of that on top of the fact your velocity estimate will be even higher since you are neglecting the energy that will be dissipated by shearing and plastic bending, doing the CD hypothesis another favor. I guess that really makes it easy to see why the truth movement never got out of the 'just asking questions' phase and never formulated a coherent or quantifiable hypothesis.

Can't wait for your report though.
 
It's Beer Reviewed.
dark%20beer.gif
dark%20beer.gif
 
You're 15 and seem to be a bright kid. I'm imploring you to do the following.

Call an engineering firm in your area and listen to a structural engineer. Perhaps you have a local college with a decent engineering department. Take the time to talk to people who actually know what they're talking about. It doesn't matter what a theology professor or former Friendly's worker thinks.

Why do I ask you this? I was actually at 7WTC for three years including 9-11. I experienced things that you can't see on You Tube or staring at pictures.

I felt the debris pounding the building on 9-11 and was forced to go out the back because of it. I was on almost every floor SSB had in my role on a daily basis and never saw any construction work being done.

Did you know 3 floors had people on it 24x 7 because they were trading floors? Most people were on there on the weekends too because of the pressures of the job. they paid us well but everyone had to bust their asses Did you know we were packed in like sardines after Salomon/Smith Barney merger? You Tube won't tell you that.

Guess what explanation I receive from "truthers". The building was pre-wired. PRE-WIRED!

Stop using 9-11 truth as a way of finding an identity and use the critical thinking skills I think you have. This isn't a joke for me. My best friend died that day and if I thought for even a second there was a chance of government involvement, I would be the first one storming the White House.

This is a bump for Rev. Great post, ND. Rev, what are your thoughts?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom