New J of 9/11 Studies Paper

RedIbis

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Messages
6,899
Lace up your debunking boots, this is a fairly brief analysis that REFUTES Woods' and Morgan's space beam theories. Instead, calculations are presented to conclude:

"Calculations using a range of estimates from observations show the destruction from these explosions range up to 1/4 mile or more in most directions. These strongly enhance the evidence presented in previous studies, such the photo in Figure 1 which shows the rapidly expanding huge dust clouds from the towers resulting from massive pulverization of the non-metallic parts of the towers in mid-air, along with hundreds of pieces of metal cladding and beams flying through the air on their rim. All of them provide dramatic examples of the devastation of the explosions in the World Trade
Center towers 6 years ago."

Direct Evidence for Explosions: Flying Projectiles and
Widespread Impact Damage
Dr. Crockett Grabbe
http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/200704/GrabbeExplosionsEvidence.pdf
 
Gee, it's not like two 110 story building collapsing could do any of that, no sir.
 
Oh. My. God. Stupidest Journal of 9/11 Stundies paper yet? It's certainly up there. What horrible incompetents these people are.
 
Oh. My. God. Stupidest Journal of 9/11 Stundies paper yet? It's certainly up there. What horrible incompetents these people are.

Your specificity, reasoning and logic are hard to argue with. At least you didn't disappoint by relying on nothing but a cheap ad hom attack. Well done.
 
I'm sure it is already stupid before a single line has been recalculated.
And about peer reviewing, ask your physics bozos and let them review it.
 
Conspiracists will do anything, I mean anything, to press their issues. If they want to take the Government to court without any evidence then why don't they just do it and be done with? What's taking them so long to accomplish this?

I would just die laughing when they do take the Government to court and then we'll see who are the clowns in the "circus" courtroom.
 
Figures 5 and 6 show these high-speed squibs shot out material up to 1/4 mile or more from the towers. This ejection distance xhit is not all that sensitive to the height of origin: raising or lowereing the ejection height by over 800 feet changes xhit by less than 500 feet for the
low resistivty side, and just over 200 feet on the high resistivity side.

So the charges were powerful enough for the above mentioned to happen, yet were so quiet that none of the recording devices around that day picked anything that sounded like CD charges?
 
So the charges were powerful enough for the above mentioned to happen, yet were so quiet that none of the recording devices around that day picked anything that sounded like CD charges?


Not to mention that these alleged explosives powerful enough to eject material 1/4 of a mile outward didn't even produce any vibrations that could be detected by the same seismographs that picked up the plane impacts...
 
Dang, my computer seems to hate pdf documents at the moment.

Do they state what kind of weapon it supposedly is?

ETA: From the quote in the OP, they don't seem to state what their theory is as to what weapon/fairy dust brought down the towers.
 
Last edited:
I love how the truthers HATE the concept of peer review...because they know it is something none of their "scientists/experts" will ever be successful at passing.

TAM:)
 
Seems he has some research experience in an area that might qualify him to refute the no-planer Space Beam theories...

C L Grabbe, Space Weapons and the Strategic Defense Initiative (Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, 1991)

TAM:)
 
Thanks for the link...

Well he seems to be full blown truther, which makes me doubt anything he has to say, but according to his home page (which of course, could be along the lines of Torin Wolf in terms of exaggerated credentials), he does seem to have some knowledge/expertese that might make him qualified to denounce/refute the "Beam Weapons".

TAM:)
 
Not to mention that these alleged explosives powerful enough to eject material 1/4 of a mile outward didn't even produce any vibrations that could be detected by the same seismographs that picked up the plane impacts...

You really have to explain the connection you are implying.

Are you saying an explosive in the upper stories would provide a similar effect on the building's lower levels as the aircraft impact at those upper stories?

Are you equating the aircraft energy with an explosive needed to take out a beam?

I thought I read where Crockett Grabbe says the high speed ejections were 1/3 of the width of the towers or approximately 70 feet from the tower perimeter. I think the remaining distance the material traveled was due to trajectory since it strated out at a great height not its initial force.
 
Last edited:
You really have to explain the connection you are implying.

Are you saying an explosive in the upper stories would provide a similar effect on the building's lower levels as the aircraft impact at those upper stories?

Are you equating the aircraft energy with an explosive needed to take out a beam?

I thought I read where Crockett Grabbe says the high speed ejections were 1/3 of the width of the towers or approximately 70 feet from the tower perimeter. I think the remaining distance the material traveled was due to trajectory since it strated out at a great height not its initial force.


Please read the "paper", specifically the quote in post #8 of this thread, then get back to us.
 
Last edited:
Please read the "paper", specifically the quote in post #8 of this thread, then get back to us.

There's a strong possibility that "realcddeal" is Mr. Grabbe. But I could be wrong, if I'm not mistaken there are two such papers on the JONES that dispute the space-beam theories. It's not hard to do, I've done it here, myself.

Whomever assembled that... pamphlet, it's ruddy awful. Doesn't even resemble a proper whitepaper.

One of the key arguments against is that, if explosives were really to blame, drag works both ways in such a case. A smaller object will have a lower ballistic coefficient, and thus will be more affected by aerodynamic drag and differential pressure. This means, yes, a larger object with the same initial velocity will fly farther than a smaller object, but they don't start with the same initial velocity, if they're driven by explosives.

If the propulsion is caused by explosives, the smaller object will be accelerated much, much more than the larger one, by the same physics, and as a result we would see the smaller objects flying farther. Taking all other effects into account, there will be a "sweet spot" at extreme range where an intermediate-sized object, probably in the centimeter range, travels the farthest -- but this doesn't match what we saw at all.

If, on the other hand, the ejection is gravity-driven, then all pieces will have the same velocity, by virtue of falling the same distance or all being part of the same more-or-less cohesive collapse front until ejection. In this scenario, the larger pieces will fly farther, the larger the better. Oddly enough, this is exactly what we see, apart from pieces so small that they are effectively wind-borne and no longer ballistic in the first place.

This paper is just another poke in the eye for Dr. Jones and the "Scholars."
 
This paper is just another poke in the eye for Dr. Jones and the "Scholars."

Indeed. Yet, the "Scholars" don't even have enough sense to be embarrassed by such pathetic "scholarship" and that is actually sad.






Well, okay, it would be sad if it weren't so uproariously funny. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom