Couple of problems Steve-o:
1. Jones won't send his paint chip dust to independent labs.
2. The original article was junk.
3. At the end of the day, testing of a sample is about as routine as you can get. The only thing that article is good for is teaching college freshman how not to do it.
1. As I mentioned elsewhere on this thread about this very point...does NIST not have their own dust samples they can use? Geez how thorough was their "thorough" investigation if they don't even have any dust samples but must have the help of a private citizen for them to do their jobs properly?
2. What a great statement of opinion, do you have anything to back up your opinion? Like a peer reviewed article in some science journal or anything? What's that? You don't? Oh well, better luck next time.
3. Yes it was so routine that NIST and all of it's paid contractors did not bother do do this simple little routine testing. How thorough was that "thorough" NIST investigation again?
The only difference here it was done by morons working far outside their field of expertise,
Ah yes first attack the arguer. Then make a false claim, I mean after all Niels Harrit is a chemist no? What about the other scientists that worked on the paper? Did not their combined expertise give the research a much more thorough examination?
completely unconcerned about their academic reputations that had been shredded long before, willing to put up $800 and willing to lie about the peer review process.
So you admit that the academic reputations of the "Official investigators" is a big issue. Thank you for finally admitting that as a valid reason for not trusting them
But keep pushing this "super thermite" nonsense, PLEASE! The tears of your failure nourish us.
Will do, and when I wipe those tears from laughing so hard that I am finally able to type again I will continue to show you for the fraud you are.
Still waiting on the explanation why they asked for the $800 check after discovering the article was a hoax. .
Ah yes this old trick, well I decided to play devil's advocate just for you...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4981117&postcount=241
And now I'm still waiting on a peer reviewed paper in a scientific journal that refutes the Harrit paper! But I will be waiting a very very very long time won't I!