New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

So judging from this response you obviously have no evidence to back up your beliefs and claims


My engineering background tells me that Jones' papers and allegations are silly. Other, many here, have specific relevant expertise and explain to me exactly why.

It's a fact that the U.U. Faculty kicked Jones off the campus.
 
Hey everyone, go back to the beginning of this thread, heck pick any old thread here at JREF at random and see just how very very often the cult here at JREF uses this attack the arguer tactic instead of actually attacking the argument! It will be really enlightening!
If you were a proven scientific fraud (based on publicly available documents), I and others here would call you a scientific fraud and not even address your arguments. Sorry for you but fraud is not protected by the MA and neither is your god Jones. Only a truther would be idiotic enough to insist the MA applies to a non-member.
 
NIST (Or the EPA or some other agency) has lots of dust samples. They all show how absurd Jones' claims are. JREF thread have cited these published papers.

NIST doesn't have Jones' samples because he hasn't offered them, or at least he hasn't told us he has and that is the #1 way we'd know.

Mmmm all the dust samples come from the same general area and should all be adequate for the task. So if NIST (Or the EPA or some other agency) has lots of dust samples then why the need for JREF cult members to keep harping this straw man and demanding that Jones submit HIS samples when they could just use their own samples and send those to a truly independent lab somewhere?

Just a little more common sense that shoots down another JREF straw man argument
 
Mmmm all the dust samples come from the same general area and should all be adequate for the task. So if NIST (Or the EPA or some other agency) has lots of dust samples then why the need for JREF cult members to keep harping this straw man and demanding that Jones submit HIS samples when they could just use their own samples and send those to a truly independent lab somewhere?

Just a little more common sense that shoots down another JREF straw man argument


this is why

Only in Jones/harrit sample was this alleged nanothermite claimed. therefore any other sample can be brushed away as inconclusive as it is NOT from the batch Jones tested. therefore it is imperative that Jones share his sample for independent blind study testing. Refusal to share this sample casts doubt on the legitimacy of the results Jones claims.
 
the harrit paper wasn't published

Yes it was, it was published in Bentham. For you to keep repeating this lie only proves you do not care about truth.

again with the nist dust. Only in Jones/harrit sample was this alleged nanothermite claimed. therefore any other sample can be brushed away as inconclusive as it is NOT from the batch Jones tested. therefore it is imperative that Jones share his sample for independent blind study testing. Refusal to share this sample casts doubt on the legitimacy of the results Jones claims.

So your saying that only the Harrit/Jones dust sample are adequate? What about the tons of other dust? Why can NIST/EPA/Whoever etc. not use their dust samples from their "very thorough" investigation and send those to a truly independent lab to see whose findings are truly accurate, the Harrit/Jones findings or the "Official" findings?
 
My engineering background tells me that Jones' papers and allegations are silly. Other, many here, have specific relevant expertise and explain to me exactly why.

It's a fact that the U.U. Faculty kicked Jones off the campus.

Then all of you here should be able to cooperate on a peer reviewed scientific paper debunking the Harrit/Jones paper and have it published in a scientific journal?

If you cannot do that then all your words are just hot air.
 
Arguing about the legitimacy of the Bentham "journal" is like arguing over the legitimacy of MAD magazine as a legitimate scientific journal.

truthers are just upset because their one holy grail turned out to be a tin cup.

TAM:)
 
Then all of you here should be able to cooperate on a peer reviewed scientific paper debunking the Harrit/Jones paper and have it published in a scientific journal?

If you cannot do that then all your words are just hot air.

Why? The only people that believe them are morons who wouldn't be convinced anyway.
 
If you were a proven scientific fraud (based on publicly available documents), I and others here would call you a scientific fraud and not even address your arguments. Sorry for you but fraud is not protected by the MA and neither is your god Jones. Only a truther would be idiotic enough to insist the MA applies to a non-member.

Couple of points...

First of all, I wish you JREF cult members would decide if Jones or Harrit are either my guru or my god?

Secondly, who is talking about the MA, I am talking about fraudulent debating tactics!
 
Mmmm all the dust samples come from the same general area and should all be adequate for the task. So if NIST (Or the EPA or some other agency) has lots of dust samples then why the need for JREF cult members to keep harping this straw man and demanding that Jones submit HIS samples when they could just use their own samples and send those to a truly independent lab somewhere?

Just a little more common sense that shoots down another JREF straw man argument


A "truther" invoking common sense--hilarious! Some of us are wondering why Jones and his fellow frauds refuse to submit their samples to independent labs. I'm sure you've devoted a great deal of thought to this question. Perhaps they have no interest in winning a Pulitzer Prize.

I'm guessing that today, like every day, is not the day when you finally show us the myth that can stand scrutiny.
 
You're killing me here! There are apparently no lengths that you won't go to defend you guru! Of course, I understand this is all part of your act to make twoofers look bad. You really do such an excellent job of it!

Now we are back to guru! Sheesh I wish you guys could keep your stories straight!
 
And none of them show evidence of thermate/thermite/nano-anything.

So you have one group that says it does contain nanothermite and another group that says it doesn't.

What normal people do in this circumstance is to get a 3rd opinion from an independent source.

NIST/EPA/Whoever should still have tons of dust samples from their "thorough" investigation that they could send to an independent 3rd party no?
 
Now we are back to guru! Sheesh I wish you guys could keep your stories straight!

You see, unlike twoofers, who believe whatever their gurus tell them to believe, we are individuals and may have different opinions, especially regarding something so insiginifant as some random twoofer.
 
Couple of points...

First of all, I wish you JREF cult members would decide if Jones or Harrit are either my guru or my god?

Secondly, who is talking about the MA, I am talking about fraudulent debating tactics!
No...you are talking to yourself now since you just put yourself on ignore.
 
Couple of points...

First of all, I wish you JREF cult members would decide if Jones or Harrit are either my guru or my god?

Secondly, who is talking about the MA, I am talking about fraudulent debating tactics!

A1. They are both.
A2. Please don't start up on the whole debate tactics thing again. I had you on ignore because of it (actually you are technically still there, but I check in on your comments occasionally to see if you have given up that insanity).

TAM:)
 
So you have one group that says it does contain nanothermite and another group that says it doesn't.

What normal people do in this circumstance is to get a 3rd opinion from an independent source.

NIST/EPA/Whoever should still have tons of dust samples from their "thorough" investigation that they could send to an independent 3rd party no?

Great idea. Surely your fraudulent gurus have sent their samples for independent testing. Wait...they haven't. Well, color me shocked!
 
Last edited:
Why Steve-0 can't read

So your saying that only the Harrit/Jones dust sample are adequate? What about the tons of other dust? Why can NIST/EPA/Whoever etc. not use their dust samples from their "very thorough" investigation and send those to a truly independent lab to see whose findings are truly accurate, the Harrit/Jones findings or the "Official" findings?

Can you read? I explained why in the very post you quoted!

again
Only in Jones/harrit sample was this alleged nanothermite claimed. therefore any other sample can be brushed away as inconclusive as it is NOT from the batch Jones tested. therefore it is imperative that Jones share his sample for independent blind study testing. Refusal to share this sample casts doubt on the legitimacy of the results Jones claims.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom