New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

Oh poor twoof. LOOK IT UP.

Bentham and peer review. Feel free.

and unlike you, I do provide citations.
http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2009/06/hoax-exposes-incompetence-or-worse-at.html

(now you see all of those blue words, they are links to other sources they cite. Try to read them.)

Where is that citation you claim again stevie?

You know if I were an editor and I received what is obviously a crap paper I would try and find out who sent it to me, I would try and find out who attempted to submit a transparent fraud.

hmmm...

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."
 
You know if I were an editor and I received what is obviously a crap paper I would try and find out who sent it to me, I would try and find out who attempted to submit a transparent fraud.

hmmm...

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."

Hmmmmm, then riddle me this: if Bentham knew it was a hoax, why did they ask for the $800?
 
Oh twoof.
Being calleda LIAR by such an accomplished one is an amazing honor.

But of course what else do we expect... they get nailed for their craptacular peer review, they get embarassed after accepting the paper (and sending the recommendations of the PEER REVIEWERS), so they wait a week, and try to play up the "yea I knew you were doing that."

ROFLMAO.
Poor widdle stevie... You can't even get into a ****** vanity journal w/out screwing it up.

wonderful fantastic journal there twoof.

I'll take JEM, journal of fracture, structural engineering journals.

why can't you get JUST ONE SIMPLE article through ANY respected journal?

A P.O. Box in Dubai... amazing that...

So the paper was never published and Bentham says they knew it was a crap paper and were trying to get more info on who sent it in.

Yet you do not want to believe bentham because it would ruin your opinion, and it is just that, YOUR OPINION.

Boy, arguments from incredulity rock don't they?
 
Hmmmmm, then riddle me this: if Bentham knew it was a hoax, why did they ask for the $800?

by getting a check and cashing it they would know for sure of course
and of course - no refunds! lol

ETA: and if they knew no one would have quit in shame
 
Actually some physicists did accept the possibility. It was the chemists that sounded the first alarm.

Yup. *some* did. The claim was that lots or most did, and 9/11-investigator cited a NYT story that really contradicted his claim.
 
This repeated and repeated dishonesty by every JREF "debunker" just show everyone else that JREF is not a place to come to get the truth.

particularly when you make up stuff, and then don't provide a single citation to support it twoof.

See what I mean, JREF "debunkers" rely on simiply repeating falsehoods in the hopes that eventually people will believe them
 
If I was the publisher of a sham journal that will publish literally anything and the journal's non existent peer review was exposed, I would probably tell a pathetic lie in order to fool some idiots.

And Stone Cold, why did an editor quit over the nonsensical computer generated article that was approved for publication if they were just trying to catch who submitted it?
 
Last edited:
Yup. *some* did. The claim was that lots or most did, and 9/11-investigator cited a NYT story that really contradicted his claim.
Never understood why though. Within hours of the announcement by Pons and Fleischmann we had an equation written that accounted for all the energy without fusion. Eventually Pons and Fleischmann "disappeared" and forgot about their foolishness but some idiots like Jones still believe in the disproven witchcraft.
 
You know if I were an editor and I received what is obviously a crap paper I would try and find out who sent it to me, I would try and find out who attempted to submit a transparent fraud.

hmmm...

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."

:dl:

Yeah.....they were pretending it was accepted :oldroll:

Are you truthers serious? After all of that investi-googling I would think you would be able to spot a real conspiracy when you see one.....

but, alas, I have once again expected too much from "truthers"....
 
They were attempting to find out their identity? They could easily have gotten more information. Or they could just look and find the real names.

why did that journal editor quit in disgust and shame if they were trying to OUT a hoax? Huh twoof?

considering that editor NEVER SAW THAT PAPER either. How can a journal know of a hoax and be willing to STING the hoaxer, if the head editor doesn't know about it? (sounds like that other bentham head editor who didn't know about a journal article... oh yea bentham open chemical physics Nanocrap article)

http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2009/jun/18/science-editor-resigns-hoax-article

try again stevie.... this time with facts.
The level of peer review at bentham is equal to "did the check clear?"

Oh you mean that editor that lied about her own expertise and background?

You mean this one?

http://www.911blogger.com/node/19963

"The editor in chief of the journal where recently the paper: "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe" was published, resigned, claiming she wasn't informed of the publication. She proceeds to provide not a single solid scientific rebuttal, only administrative bickering and personal political bias against, well.. inconvenient science. One particularly notable comment attributed to Ms. Pileni is this one: "Marie-Paule Pileni points out that because the topic lies outside her field of expertise, she cannot judge whether the article in itself is good or bad.".

Strangely, her areas of research seem to contradict that. I'll quote you an excerpt of her resume:

OTHER ACTIVITIES
1990-1992: Chairperson on workshops related to the French Defense research.
1989-1992: Consultant at the Minister of Recherche concerning the National Defense 1989: Member of the “Institut des Hautes Etudes de Défense Européenne”.
1987-1988: Member of the ’“Institut des Hautes Etudes de Défense Nationale” (IHEDN)1984-1986: Member of National exam in Chemistry

EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERSHIP
2006: Accounts of Chemical Research, American Chemical Society.
Journal of experimental nanosciences, Publisher Taylor&Francis.
2002: Journal of Physical Chemistry, Board member, American Chemical Society.

CONSULTING EXPERIENCE
1990-1994: Société Nationale des Poudres et Explosifs, SNPE, France (Literally translated: National Society of Powders and Explosives)

LABORATORY MANAGEMENT
2001: Laboratoire des matériaux mésoscopiques et nanomètriques, LM2N.
1992-2000: Structure et réactivité des systèmes interfaciaux, SRI. (Literally translated: Structure and reactivity of interfacial systems)

Interesting. Firm ties with the French/European military industrial complex. Experience with explosives and nanotechnology. It's reasonable to assume Ms. Pileni is familiar with nano-explosives. So Ms. Pileni's contention that "the topic lies outside my field of expertise" is false. Why would a nanotechnology expert and former consultant for the SNPE not want to comment on a paper discussing nano-thermitic explosives? A paper which caused her to resign? Puzzling."
 
You know if I were an editor and I received what is obviously a crap paper I would try and find out who sent it to me, I would try and find out who attempted to submit a transparent fraud.

hmmm...

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."


Or they could have just looked at who sent them the $800.00 check. But they probably no longer had a record of it since they rushed to the bank as soon as they got it.
:dl:

It is fairly obvious that Mahmood Alam is just covering his ass so as not to look like the fools they are.


If I were the editor. i would simply not accept the paper. why bother wasting time and resources pretending to accept the paper? Just ignore it.
 
Last edited:
Why do you prefer braying mindlessly to making the effort to read what Sunstealer, a materials scientist, has written about Jones and his fellow frauds? Over three different threads, he has presented a magisterial refutation of the sort of pseudo-science that makes you aggressive know-nothings go gaga, but somehow never makes a stir in the real world.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140363

Pssst! You prefer braying mindlessly to reading because you are a "truther.'

Has he managed to have it published in a peer reviewed journal? What's that? No? Then why would I bother reading a forum poster from some anonymous guy? Especially when much of what he says was already discredited in the paper itself.
 
Because Jones hasn't asked them? He hasn't asked anyone. Only Jones claims to have samples of something he says is evidence for (but isn't) nano-thermite.

So are you trying to say that NIST, with their "completely thorough" investigation do not have any dust samples and have to rely on a private citizen to supply it to them?

How thorough was the NIST investigation again?
 
Has he managed to have it published in a peer reviewed journal? What's that? No? Then why would I bother reading a forum poster<sic> from some anonymous guy? Especially when much of what he says was already discredited in the paper itself.


Why not Steve-0? you read and respond to pretty much everything else. How would you know he's been discredited when you haven't even read it? Show us what points exactly have been discredited.
Links Please!!
 
Has he managed to have it published in a peer reviewed journal? What's that? No? Then why would I bother reading a forum poster from some anonymous guy? Especially when much of what he says was already discredited in the paper itself.

Your gurus have never published their garbage in a peer reviewed journal either. And besides, I doubt it would even be worth it to publish a rebuttal to those frauds in a journal. It's not as if there is any real controversy. The only people that take them seriously are a small group of morons.
 
Last edited:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_E._Jones
But if Jones is an 'idiot' I am very curious to learn about the credentials of 'uk_dave' himself.
There was a time that even you were a nice, innocent baby but things change. Same way Jones was once a good scientist but in the 80s he stepped over the line into scientific fraud so uk_dave's use of idiot is a bit light. Jones is a piece of garbage.
 
Because, as has been repeatedly pointed out to you, there IS no evidence for thermite of any kind, nano- or otherwise, in the WTC dust. Sunstealer has thoroughly debunked the entire nano-thermite concept. Go ahead and invite your pal Jones to look at Sunstealer's work and see if he can find any flaws. I'll wait*.

* - For a long time, I'll wager.

Then it should be no problem for him to get his paper published. Heck he doesn't have to publish it in Bentham, he can choose any other publication where he does not have to pay for it himself.

So let him publish it and allow the world to see his information, otherwise it is nothing more than unproven hot air.
 
Then it should be no problem for him to get his paper published. Heck he doesn't have to publish it in Bentham, he can choose any other publication where he does not have to pay for it himself.

So let him publish it and allow the world to see his information, otherwise it is nothing more than unproven hot air.


why should he publish a paper in rebuttal to a paper that hasn't been published itself yet?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom