New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

So you have one group that says it does contain nanothermite and another group that says it doesn't.

What normal people do in this circumstance is to get a 3rd opinion from an independent source.

NIST/EPA/Whoever should still have tons of dust samples from their "thorough" investigation that they could send to an independent 3rd party no?

I agree. Too bad Steven Jones doesn't. He has refused to provide his samples for INDEPENDENT 3rd party analysis and subsequent confirmation or refutation of his findings.

TAM
 
I agree. Too bad Steven Jones doesn't. He has refused to provide his samples for INDEPENDENT 3rd party analysis and subsequent confirmation or refutation of his findings.

TAM
All tactics used before when he crossed the line into fraud with cold fusion. Why are we even entertaining Jones "intellectual" diarrhea?
 
Attempting to build a straw man argument are we?

arguments from incredulity rock don't they!

Steve, you seem to be aware of the concept of logical fallacy, so you're a cut above some truthers, IMO. Now please do us all a favor and learn and understand the meanings of the fallacies before you cite them. Sorry, no link, but that shouldn't slow down a crack researcher like yourself. Please be aware that learning the meaning of these fallacies will require reading for comprehension and a modicum of thought.

And by the way, Steven Jones is not making the argument here in the forum, so no one is "attacking the arguer" in the sense of the Membership Agreement.

ferd
 
Runlikell - just move the question mark and you've answered your own question:

'they may be wrong, they may be a bit crazy, but surely they are honest men? no.'

If you believe that two people who constantly misrepresent arguments and evidence are honest men, you're a sucker, bud.

Here's just one example out of many more - Harrit still claims that WTC7 fell in 6.5 seconds. That's a gross misrepresentation of the facts.

Steven Jones, in lecture after lecture, referred to the 'peer reviewed' articles in the Journal of 9/11 Studies, but never bothered to mention to his audiences that he was one of the editors, and that some of the articles he sited were in fact by the other editors of the journal.
Is it an honest person who conceals such a glaring conflict of interest, or consistently abuses the term 'peer review'?

Perhaps by the standards of ordinary con-men or swindlers, these guys are paragons of virtue. By most respected scientific standards, they're the opposite.
 
Did NIST's "throughout" investigation test for pixiedust?
And if not why?
 
Runlikell - Doesn't it bother you just a little that Jones' own arguments have been contradictory for many years? For example, in the early days of his thermite/thermate mania, he cited very high temperatures, molten iron, sulphur, barium etc.... as 'proof' of conspiracy and controlled demolition.

After discovering and testing the red/grey chips, he now claims explosive nanothermite did the dirty deed. But nanothermite trades high temperatures for speed - it doesn't (in theory, since neither Jones nor Harrit has obtained samples from sources they cite) generate high temps at all; just explosive gases. And where's the sulphur in the WTC dust? Now they've backed away from it....oops!

Maybe that's a bit too complicated for your tastes, so what about this problem: Neither Jones nor Harrit has obtained even a single sample of nanothermite from any of the sources they think it came from -

Not from Los Alamos National Laboratory
Not from Indian Head Division of the Naval Surface Warfare Center (NSWC/IH)
Not from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory

Nor have they had any of their ideas corroborated by a single expert from the US military research establishment.

Nor has there been a single whistleblower who recognized that materials made in research labs had appeared in WTC dust, and followed their moral and patriotic duty.

Nor has any documented building ever been imploded in controlled demolition using either thermate, thermite or nanothermite. Not one.

Nor have Jones, Harrit et al. identified the organic binder in the chips.

Nor have Jones, Harrit et al. identified the grey layer of the chips.

Nor have Jones, Harrit et al. replicated the red/grey chip material and tested it.

Nor have Jones, Harrit et al. demonstrated, thru direct and unambiguous methods, that this class of material can actually destroy complex steel structure.

Or how it could explode without noticeable explosions.

Or how it could do all the above without leaving obvious signs of explosive destruction on steel, easily recognized by demolition experts who combed the debris.


There are at least 10 major points which would need complete verification in order to support their theories and claims. Without this, they are offering little but clever conjecture - except in the realm of pseudo-cience, they have no basis for claiming they have found the 'smoking gun', the 'loaded gun', or anything of the kind.

In the world of con artists, paranoid fantasy and pseudoscience, they've definitely 'nailed it' and have 'proved' that 9/11 was an inside job. For sure. Everything's real in that realm, even Sylvia Browne.
 
Did NIST's "throughout" investigation test for pixiedust?
And if not why?

Hehe. Much is made of NIST's failure to do an arson investigation of WTC7. Maybe that's because it wasn't arson?

Truthers seem to possess a special talent for missing the obvious.
 
They didn't do a regular crash investigation either, it is almost as if they knew before starting why the planes crashed.
 
You know if I were an editor and I received what is obviously a crap paper I would try and find out who sent it to me, I would try and find out who attempted to submit a transparent fraud.

hmmm...

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."

You are SOOOOO right.

Why then did the HEAD EDITOR OF THAT JOURNAL QUIT IN DISGUST??????

The head editor of that journal quits and says "I never saw that paper."

How does the head editor of the journal NEVER SEE an article they are trying to bust for being a hoax/forgery?

And
Why did he quit in disgust from the journal? That is NOT the action of an editor who is proud of their journal and trying to bust a HOAXER. That is the action of someone disappointed and disgusted with the SHODDY journal they were working with and trying to distance themselves.

Why did he quit over this paper?
why did the editor of the open chemical physics journal quit in disgust stating "this journal is a sham?"

Come on stevie....
 
See what I mean, JREF "debunkers" rely on simiply repeating falsehoods in the hopes that eventually people will believe them

Oh poor stevie.

Lets see.

I have read that thread. You make the claim that there were 1000 paid shills. You didn't supply a single citaiton. Not for 15 pages.

Someone else found a similar paper full of crap and posted the citation. YOU NEVER SUPPLIED IT.

how hard is that to understand?

You made a claim.
You were than asked to provide a citation
YOU THEN NEVER DID.

Very straightforward twoof.
 
Then it should be no problem for him to get his paper published. Heck he doesn't have to publish it in Bentham, he can choose any other publication where he does not have to pay for it himself.

So let him publish it and allow the world to see his information, otherwise it is nothing more than unproven hot air.

Here you go twoof. Over 50 articles posted which support NIST and the common narrrative. Notice, not one is in a vanity journal. Not one craptacular and mocked for their ****** editorial policy. What do you have again? I mean if it is so easy high school drop outs like you can figure it out you shoudl have hundreds of REAL peer reviewed journals to refute NIST. Take ONE. In ANY LANGUAGE. I'll wait.


Performance based structural fire engineering for modern building design
Rini, D., Lamont, S. 2008 Proceedings of the 2008 Structures Congress - Structures Congress 2008: Crossing the Borders 314

Engineering perspective of the collapse of WTC-I
Irfanoglu, A., Hoffmann, C.M. 2008 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 22 (1),

Collapse of towers as applied to September 11 events
Cherepanov, G.P. 2008 Materials Science 44 (4), pp. 489-499

Modeling pre-evacuation delay by occupants in World Trade Center Towers 1 and 2 on September 11, 2001
Kuligowski, E.D., Mileti, D.S. 2008 Fire Safety Journal

World Trade Center building disaster: Stimulus for innovations
Kodur, V.K.R. 2008 Indian Concrete Journal 82 (1), pp. 23-31

A collective undergraduate class project reconstructing the September 11, 2001 world trade center fire
Marshall, A., Quintiere, J. 2007 ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, Conference Proceedings

"A new era": The limits of engineering expertise in a post-9/11 world
Pfatteicher, S.K.A. 2007 International Symposium on Technology and Society, Proceedings, art. no. 4362228

Progressive collapse of the World Trade Center: Simple analysis
Seffen, K.A. 2008 Journal of Engineering Mechanics 134 (2), pp. 125-132

Scale modeling of the 96th floor of world trade center tower 1
Wang, M., Chang, P., Quintiere, J., Marshall, A. 2007 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 21 (6), pp. 414-421

Failure of welded floor truss connections from the exterior wall during collapse of the world trade center towers
Banovic, S.W., Siewert, T.A. 2007 Welding Journal (Miami, Fla) 86 (9), pp. 263-s-272-s

The collapse of the world trade center towers: A metallurgist's view
Gayle, F.W. 2007 MRS Bulletin 32 (9), pp. 710-716

Building code changes reflect world trade center investigation
Hansen, B. 2007 Civil Engineering 77 (9), pp. 22+24-25

Fire load in a steel building design
Razdolsky, L. 2008 Proceedings of the 4th International Structural Engineering and Construction Conference, ISEC-4 - Innovations in Structural Engineering and Construction 2, pp. 1163-1167

The structural steel of the World Trade Center towers
Gayle, F.W., Banovic, S.W., Foecke, T., Fields, R.J., Luecke, W.E., McColskey, J.D., McCown, C., Siewert, T.A. 2006 Journal of Failure Analysis and Prevention 6 (5), pp. 5-8

Progressive collapse of structures: Annotated bibliography and comparison of codes and standards
Mohamed, O.A. 2006 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 20 (4), art. no. 001604QCF, pp. 418-425

A simple model of the World Trade Center fireball dynamics
Baum, H.R., Rehm, R.G., Quintiere, J.G. 2005 Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 30 II, pp. 2247-2254

Impact of the Boeing 767 Aircraft into the World Trade Center
Karim, M.R., Hoo Fatt, M.S. 2005 Journal of Engineering Mechanics 131 (10), pp. 1066-1072

High-fidelity simulation of large-scale structures
Hoffmann, C., Sameh, A., Grama, A. 2005 Lecture Notes in Computer Science 3515 (II), pp. 664-671

Collapses of the world trade center towers
[No author name available] 2005 Indian Concrete Journal 79 (8), pp. 11-16

Industry updates: Fireproofing, staircases cited in World Trade Center report
[No author name available] 2005 Journal of Failure Analysis and Prevention 5 (4), pp. 34

September 11 and fracture mechanics - A retrospective
Cherepanov, G.P. 2005 International Journal of Fracture 132 (2), pp. L25-L26

Structural responses of World Trade Center under aircraft attacks
Omika, Y., Fukuzawa, E., Koshika, N., Morikawa, H., Fukuda, R. 2005 Journal of Structural Engineering 131 (1), pp. 6-15

Impact of the 2001 World Trade Center attack on critical interdependent infrastructures
Mendonça, D., Lee II, E.E., Wallace, W.A. 2004 Conference Proceedings - IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics 5, pp. 4053-4058

Use of high-efficiency energy absorbing device to arrest progressive collapse of tall building
Zhou, Q., Yu, T.X. 2004 Journal of Engineering Mechanics 130 (10), pp. 1177-1187

Progressive analysis procedure for progressive collapse
Marjanishvili, S.M. 2004 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 18 (2), pp. 79-85

Lessons learned on improving resistance of buildings to terrorist attacks
Corley, W.G. 2004 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 18 (2), pp. 68-78

Anatomy of a disaster: A structural investigation of the World Trade Center collapses
Abboud, N., Levy, M., Tennant, D., Mould, J., Levine, H., King, S., Ekwueme, C., (...), Hart, G. 2003 Forensic Engineering, Proceedings of the Congress, pp. 360-370

World Trade Center disaster: Damage/debris assessment
Thater, G.G., Panariello, G.F., Cuoco, D.A. 2003 Forensic Engineering, Proceedings of the Congress, pp. 383-392

How did the WTC towers collapse: A new theory
Usmani, A.S., Chung, Y.C., Torero, J.L. 2003 Fire Safety Journal 38 (6), pp. 501-533

Microstructural analysis of the steels from Buildings 7, & 1 or 2 from the World Trade Center
Biederman, R.R., Sullivan, E.M., Sisson Jr., R.D., Vander Voort, G.F. 2003 Microscopy and Microanalysis 9 (SUPPL. 2), pp. 550-551

Brannigan, F.L.
"WTC: Lightweight Steel and High-Rise Buildings"
Fire Engineering v.155, no. 4, (2002): 145-150.

Analysis of the thermal exposure in the impact areas of the World Trade Center terrorist attacks
Beyler, C., White, D., Peatross, M., Trellis, J., Li, S., Luers, A., Hopkins, D. 2003 Forensic Engineering, Proceedings of the Congress, pp. 371-382

Clifton, Charles G.
Elaboration on Aspects of the Postulated Collapse of the World Trade Centre Twin Towers
HERA: Innovation in Metals. 2001. 13 December 2001.

"Construction and Collapse Factors"
Fire Engineering v.155, no. 10, (2002): 106-108.

Bazant, Z.P., & Zhou, Y.
"Addendum to 'Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse? - Simple Analysis" (pdf)
Journal of Engineering Mechanics v. 128, no. 3, (2002): 369-370.

Corbett, G.P.
"Learning and Applying the Lessons of the WTC Disaster"
Fire Engineering v.155, no. 10, (2002.): 133-135.

"Dissecting the Collapses"
Civil Engineering ASCE v. 72, no. 5, (2002): 36-46.

Eagar, T.W., & Musso, C.
"Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse? Science, Engineering, and Speculation"
JOM v. 53, no. 12, (2001): 8-12.

Federal Emergency Management Agency, Therese McAllister, report editor.
World Trade Center Building Performance Study: Data Collection, Preliminary Observations, and Recommendations
(also available on-line)

Gabrielson, T.B., Poese, M.E., & Atchley, A.A.
"Acoustic and Vibration Background Noise in the Collapsed Structure of the World Trade Center"
The Journal of Acoustical Society of America v. 113, no. 1, (2003): 45-48.

"Collapse Lessons"
Fire Engineering v. 155, no. 10, (2002): 97-103

Marechaux, T.G.
"TMS Hot Topic Symposium Examines WTC Collapse and Building Engineering"
JOM, v. 54, no. 4, (2002): 13-17.

Monahan, B.
"World Trade Center Collapse-Civil Engineering Considerations"
Practice Periodical on Structural Design and Construction v. 7, no. 3, (2002): 134-135.

Newland, D.E., & Cebon, D.
"Could the World Trade Center Have Been Modified to Prevent Its Collapse?"
Journal of Engineering Mechanics v. 128, no. 7, (2002):795-800.

National Instititue of Stamdards and Technology: Congressional and Legislative Affairs
“Learning from 9/11: Understanding the Collapse of the World Trade Center”
Statement of Dr. Arden L. Bement, Jr., before Committee of Science House of Representatives, United States Congress on March 6, 2002.

Pinsker, Lisa, M.
"Applying Geology at the World Trade Center Site"
Geotimes v. 46, no. 11, (2001).
The print copy has 3-D images.

Public Broadcasting Station (PBS)
Why the Towers Fell: A Companion Website to the Television Documentary.
NOVA (Science Programming On Air and Online)

Post, N.M.
"No Code Changes Recommended in World Trade Center Report"
ENR v. 248, no. 14, (2002): 14.

Post, N.M.
"Study Absolves Twin Tower Trusses, Fireproofing"
ENR v. 249, no. 19, (2002): 12-14.

The University of Sydney, Department of Civil Engineering
World Trade Center - Some Engineering Aspects
A resource site.

"WTC Engineers Credit Design in Saving Thousands of Lives"
ENR v. 247, no. 16, (2001): 12.
 
Then all of you here should be able to cooperate on a peer reviewed scientific paper debunking the Harrit/Jones paper and have it published in a scientific journal?

If you cannot do that then all your words are just hot air.


Typical truther inversion, everything they pull out their ****-ends is considered established fact until it is disproven with almost mathematical rigour.

Reality: junk paper published in pay to publish journal. Journal has no peer-review process.
Truther: disprove paper in peer-reviewed journal!

Reality: structural engineering, building codes, fire proofing etc. etc. Building high-risers challenging. Aircraft impact degrades structural integrity, fires do the same. Building collapses.
Truther: argues if collapse resistance is intrinsic property of (damaged, burning) buildings. Invokes explosives to explain collapse. Disprove! FEA is not enough, neither is any other damage/fire induced collapse.

The list goes on.

Anything to keep their belief system afloat.
 
Yes it was, it was published in Bentham. For you to keep repeating this lie only proves you do not care about truth.

and the fact that you keep trying desperately to hold on to the "peer reviewed" bentham that you keep repeating it shows that you have NO academic credibility.

Thank you twoof.

So your saying that only the Harrit/Jones dust sample are adequate? What about the tons of other dust? Why can NIST/EPA/Whoever etc. not use their dust samples from their "very thorough" investigation and send those to a truly independent lab to see whose findings are truly accurate, the Harrit/Jones findings or the "Official" findings?

Oh twoof. YOu are too funny. Absolutely too freaking funny.
1. EVEN if NIST, EPA/whoever were to examine the dust and say it is "nanothermite free" you would just disregard it. Wouldn't you twoof? Of course you would.
2. Jones is the one making the claim. So he needs to have independent verification of his samples. Why hasn't he done that? I'll pay the $40 bucks to have it examined.

so please try again... this time with something that makes sense... maybe you should take your haldol and try to write something comprehendable.
 
Here you go twoof. Over 50 articles posted which support NIST and the common narrrative...

Performance based structural fire engineering for modern building design
Rini, D., Lamont, S. 2008 Proceedings of the 2008 Structures Congress - Structures Congress 2008: Crossing the Borders 314

Engineering perspective of the collapse of WTC-I
Irfanoglu, A., Hoffmann, C.M. 2008 Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 22 (1)...

(rest snipped)

Not to overguild the Lilly by beating this point into the ground, but believe it or not, this list is incomplete. For example, one of the earliest studies was conducted by a pair of Tsinghua University (Beijing, China) researchers - LU Xinzheng & JIANG Jianjing - which was a "finite element analysis" (FEA) of the main towers collapses. This was a very early analysis - publication date is Nov. 2002 - and may have been superceded by the more in-depth NIST study, but it was one of the first to concentrate on the effect of the steel's performance in the fires.

Another link on the Lu and Jiang model: http://wtcmodel.wikidot.com/lu-jiang-model

Let's also remember that the University of California's Delta group did an environmental impact study (they measured aerosolized pollution released by the fires and collapses), and while that doesn't speak towards the actual collapse itself, during their research they illuminated one very central detail that helps argue against explosives or thermite, and that's the amount of energy available for the fires from the combustible contents of the towers. It was immense.

We're also missing the Weidlinger Associates and Exponent Failure Analysis Associates studies, although those weren't academic ones. Rather, the first was done at Silverstein's behest for his insurance claim, and the other was commissioned by the insurance companies. Neither saw any cause to address the event as anything other than a collapse proceeding from the jetliner crashes and subsequent fires.

There's the Lioy study that's been misrepresented and misused to make microsphere and therefore thermite arguments.

And last, I noticed that the famous (to those of us studying 9/11) Purdue simulation was not mentioned. That's a pretty important one.

I do not say any of this to knock on TruthersLie; rather, I write this to point out that many very crucial studies do indeed exist, and a fair number have not been mentioned in his brief listing of them. The ultimate point here is that the legitimate studies that have been conducted on the towers collapse tend to validate in some way or another the fact that fires and impact damage was what led to the collapse of the towers. Others that take that as a starting point show that the post-collapse events are consistent with presuming the towers did indeed collapse from impacts and fires, and not from explosives; I challenge people to cruise through Google Scholar, as well as local universities academic e-journals and compare medical studies done in the aftermath of 9/11 with those in the aftermath of the Madrid train bombings, or the Israeli bus bombings. There's no study that does a direct comparison, but you'll note as I have that there is a distinct difference in the numbers and severity of barotraumatic injuries between the collapses and real bombings. That's very significant, in my opinion. It indicates no explosions, and further validates the fact that no demolitions were used that day.

Anyway, I'm starting to ramble. TruthersLie has made a good point here: Conspiracy addicts and peddlers are making a big deal out of the Bentham study, but the fact of the matter is, it is outmassed as well as outclassed by the sheer amount and quality of other research that has been done on 9/11, and none of those studies validate thermite or intentional demolitions in any way. Not in the least bit. True, they don't study that question directly, but they don't have to; the data they'd be examining would be different if the towers were intentionally demolished. Again, I point to my search in the past on incidents of barotrauma. Furthermore, you'd see differing FEA and other structural engineering analyses emerge if the towers were indeed supposed to have stood. That is not happening. The wealth of research out there validates the dominant narrative of jet impacts and fire damage causing the collapses, and that is only apparent when someone takes his/her nose outside conspiratorial sources and looks in the real world for their information.
 
The examples of nano-thermite we know of are for cutting tiny tiny objects.

lol that device in that video looks like it would be useful if you planned to CD your kids metal swing set lol

ETA: i think my sawzall would be more effective than that thing
 
We are the Saudi Arabia of Coal so the dire energy situation is?

That's exactly what you are: the Saudi Arabia of coal. SA will pass peak oil in a couple of years.
And you conclude from that the planet (or the US) is not in a dire energy situation.

Here is a very recent warning from a big shot from the IEA:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/warning-oil-supplies-are-running-out-fast-1766585.html
They are in panic mode.

In order for the energy situation to be dire it is not only important how much fossil fuel is left but also at what production capacity it is available.

For your information: the world is already at, or close by or even has passed 'peak oil'.

And forget about the stories that the US has coal 'for 200 years'. US coal production will likely peak from 20 years from now and then decline.

http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/052504_coal_peak.html

Or here a German study:

http://www.energiekrise.de/kohle/docs2007/EWG-Report_CoalProductionScenario_MAR2007.gif

Post edited for breach of Rule 4; please do not hotlink to copyrighted material.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That's exactly what you are: the Saudi Arabia of coal. SA will pass peak oil in a couple of years.
And you conclude from that the planet (or the US) is not in a dire energy situation.

Here is a very recent warning from a big shot from the IEA:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/warning-oil-supplies-are-running-out-fast-1766585.html
They are in panic mode.

In order for the energy situation to be dire it is not only important how much fossil fuel is left but also at what production capacity it is available.

For your information: the world is already at, or close by or even has passed 'peak oil'.

And forget about the stories that the US has coal 'for 200 years'. US coal production will likely peak from 20 years from now and then decline.

http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/052504_coal_peak.html

Or here a German study:

http://www.energiekrise.de/kohle/docs2007/EWG-Report_CoalProductionScenario_MAR2007.gif
For crying out loud. Are you gonna recycle the peak oil bunk? Time to finally put you on ignore.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom