Native American myths/traditions support Bigfoot? A critical look.

I'm particularily interested in the totems displayed in my hometown of Victoria, BC at The Royal British Cloumbia Museum

In the meantime, some questions:

1) Do you think there are any clear representations of bigfoot in totem poles?

As far as bigfoot being represented in totem poles, I've seen no evidence of that yet. However, there are a few masks made by PNW tribes that are very striking.

I stopped by my favorite used book store today and picked up a couple of interesting books. One is titled "People of the Totem" published by Putnam. It has a nice collection of photos of masks and totems and other carvings. One mask in particular caught my attention. It is a Tsimshian mask that is at the Provincial Museum in Victoria, BC. It is cataloged as an 'ape-like face'. Are you aware of this mask and if so, what are your thoughts about it. I can scan the photo if you'd like.

The book does point out however, that the northwest coast indians were primarily a seafaring and fishing culture without much in depth understanding of the forests.
 
Last edited:
As far as bigfoot being represented in totem poles, I've seen no evidence of that yet. However, there are a few masks made by PNW tribes that are very striking.

I stopped by my favorite used book store today and picked up a couple of interesting books. One is titled "People of the Totem" published by Putnam. It has a nice collection of photos of masks and totems and other carvings. One mask in particular caught my attention. It is a Tsimshian mask that is at the Provincial Museum in Victoria, BC. It is cataloged as an 'ape-like face'. Are you aware of this mask and if so, what are your thoughts about it. I can scan the photo if you'd like.

The book does point out however, that the northwest coast indians were primarily a seafaring and fishing culture without much in depth understanding of the forests.
About the masks from Wikipedia's entry on bigfoot evidence:

[edit] Face masks
In "The Tsimshian Monkey Masks and Sasquatch," the anthropologist and ethnologist Marjorie Halpin describes two wood facemasks that were collected from the Tsimshian and Nisga'a tribes (near Prince Rupert, British Columbia). One was obtained by Lieutenant G. T. Emmons in about 1914, and the other was obtained by Marius Barbeau in 1927.[4][5]

Emmons described the artifact as "a mythical being found in the woods, and called today as a monkey" (Halpin and Ames, 211). Halpin also reports that the physical anthropologist R.D.E. MacPhee examined the Emmons mask and noted that it had both monkey- and ape-like features, but could not match it exactly to any recognized species (ibid, 212). Halpin details the elaborate mask-related folklore and rites pertaining to a creature called "pi'kis," which has both human and animal traits (especially connected to otters). He also describes the creature as occupying a "dangerously close intersection between human and animal" in native lore (ibid, 225). As with the carved stone heads, Halpin notes that these monkey-like masks alone do not prove that Sasquatch are real; rather, they are curious artifacts which warrant further investigation.

I wonder if we're getting near Land Otters.

BTW, here's an online tour of the Royal BC Museum's Thunderbird Park if your interested, though I don't know if you're still in the bizarre habit of 'not doing links':

http://www.royalbcmuseum.bc.ca/exhibits/tbird-park/main.htm?lang=eng

Please scan the mask and post the name of the artist and mask.
 
I wonder if we're getting near Land Otters.

BTW, here's an online tour of the Royal BC Museum's Thunderbird Park if your interested, though I don't know if you're still in the bizarre habit of 'not doing links':

http://www.royalbcmuseum.bc.ca/exhibits/tbird-park/main.htm?lang=eng

Please scan the mask and post the name of the artist and mask.

I don't know what would make someone determine Land Otter when looking at this mask. But anything is possible. I'll try and scan it today.

I'll pass on your recommended link.
 
I don't know what would make someone determine Land Otter when looking at this mask. But anything is possible. I'll try and scan it today.

I'll pass on your recommended link.
Suit yourself. One of Mungo Martin's more prominent totems there has dsonoqua carved at the bottom.

Tsimshian masks:

Rotatable:

http://www.nmai.si.edu/exhibitions/all_roads_are_good/TsimshianMask.htm

Fur on the face. Yours for only USD $1,808,000:

http://www.randafricanart.com/Native_American_news.html

Biglip:

http://www.thecityreview.com/f99samind.html

3rd down, Land Otter?:

http://thecanadianencyclopedia.com/index.cfm?PgNm=TCE&Params=A1ARTA0008149
 
Okay, I'll have a look.
When you check it out, click on 'Present Park 1980-2006' then click on the totem in front of the main long house titled 'Kwakwaka' wakw Heraldic Pole 1953'.

BTW, I've been keeping an eye on the recent BFF Native evidence thread. I thought it was rather interesting when BFF Historian Tirademan man said of this collection of wild man drawings:

They make it all the more obvious to me that Squatch has always been out there and humans have always seen them. Another reason not to give skeptics any of your time!

I think Tirademan is rather generous with his use of the word 'obvious'. I wonder if someone were to give a link there to this thread if it would be deleted.
 
The dzonokwa figures are very interesting. Especially considering the historical myth attached.

I didn't notice any mention of Land Otter, did I miss it?
No, you didn't miss it. My use of a question mark after Land Otter was simply based on the mask's resemblance to an otter.
 
I posted the photo at BFF in the Native evidence thread. I was unable to host the photo here because of the size.
 
No artist name or date. It was mixed in with the 1850ish material. It only states in the bibliography - photo page 98, Provincial Museum, Victoria, BC.
The book has many photos of masks and totems from worldwide collections, a couple with the characteristic dzonokwa mouth.
 
I don't have the book here with me to check but I almost vaguely remember that photo being in Krantz's 'Big Footprints' book. What do you think makes it characteristic of being a sasquatch?
 
I don't have the book here with me to check but I almost vaguely remember that photo being in Krantz's 'Big Footprints' book. What do you think makes it characteristic of being a sasquatch?

I don't know what the exact characteristics of sasquatch are. While looking through the book I noticed that this particular mask had a caption that stated it was cataloged as "ape-like face". It was only one of a couple of masks that had the exposed nostrils and lacking chin definition, contrasting the majority of masks. There were also a few that had the characteristic mouth of wild woman.
 
I posted the photo at BFF in the Native evidence thread. I was unable to host the photo here because of the size.
Here's something interesting. In the BFF Native evidence thread in response to the mask you posted, member Bob Zenor posts this image of a Kwakiutl seal mask and with that special brand of bigfoot enthusiast confidence comments:

That is so obviously not a seal that it is amusing. I wonder if it they are really that ignorant to not notice or if they are just so worried about sounding crazy that they refuse to acknowledging the obvious similarity to some sort of apeman.
Here we have a vivid example of footer logic in play. The desire to see bigfoot is strong. It doesn't occur to Zenor that the anthropomorphizing of animals in various indigenous North American cultures is common and consistent. He's convinced himself that he's looking at a Kwakwaka' wakw representation of bigfoot. It takes little effort in examining this subject to find images of native anthropomorphic animal representations such as these:

Bear mask, Tsimshian:

http://www.snowwowl.com/images/legacy3.jpg

Blue Jay mask, Skokomish:

http://www.snowwowl.com/images/legacy12.jpg

Supernatural Cod Fish mask, Kwakwaka' wakw:

http://www.snowwowl.com/images/legacy9.jpg

Mosquito mask, Tsimshian:

http://www.snowwowl.com/images/legacy2.jpg

If bigfoot enthusiasts such as Bob Zenor would avail themselves to the minimal effort it takes to learn things such as this they could avoid the derision they've earned. That they call bigfoot without any investigation and call those who didn't ignorant is the height of arrogance. The mask is listed as representing a seal. It's got great big whiskers like a seal. We know the Kwakwaka' wakw were intimately familiar with the appearance of seals. We know in their art they often made anthropomorphic representations of animals. Dude, get over yourself. It's not a frickin' bigfoot, it's a seal.

MOTS, you should do the Zenor brothers a favour and give them a link here or PM them one if the zealots delete it in thread.
 
Last edited:
The Rev. Elkanah Walker, while describing a race of giants and their propensity to steal salmon, also described a race of little people: "Natives also believed in a race of "little people" the Elequas Tern (Stick Indians), who inhabited high places, such as the Cascade Mountains."

Well, technically, he was describing (quote) "superstitions" of giants.

But the 'howl' that I heard, combined with the other circumstances, lead me in the direction of the mentioned giants being bigfoot. That is one of their descriptive behaviors.

Well, I'll grant you that (minus the howling bit; you might as well lump in werewolves) this is a better fit than your previous attempts to link Native American legends to Bigfoot. However, what you're doing is exactly the type of filtration issue kitakaze was talking about when he started this thread.

I recommend that you look for the thread "The Wallace Hoax prints, Where did he get the idea?" over that the General Discussions section at BFF. Post #18 by RayG should be of interest to you. Those who "do links" can just click here and scroll down to see why it's not a very good idea to try using old legends as evidence for a real animal existing.
 
Well, I'll grant you that (minus the howling bit; you might as well lump in werewolves) this is a better fit than your previous attempts to link Native American legends to Bigfoot. However, what you're doing is exactly the type of filtration issue kitakaze was talking about when he started this thread.


.

False accusation. I merely presented a photo that is cataloged as "ape-like face". Read it again. Think about it.

Same with the manitou. I noticed obvious references to bigfoot characteristics. Characteristics.
 
The book that I picked up has a picture of a 'Bokwus, Kwakiutl Wild-Man-of-the-Woods' mask. Shall I post that at BFF also? It doesn't look ape-like at all.
 
Same with the manitou. I noticed obvious references to bigfoot characteristics.

Regardless of what you noticed, there were no "obvious references to bigfoot characteristics", and you seem willfully oblivious to the author's explanation for whooping warriors that you romantically ascribe to bigfoot. (a long-winded way of saying you were incorrect in your assumption)

RayG
 
Ray, I should have asked you before. Do you think posting a link to this thread in the BFF Native evidence thread would be deleted?
 
False accusation. I merely presented a photo that is cataloged as "ape-like face". Read it again. Think about it.

Um...I wasn't talking about any masks. What made you think that I was?

Same with the manitou. I noticed obvious references to bigfoot characteristics. Characteristics.

Yes, and that's precisely the sort of thing kitakaze and I were talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom