Native American myths/traditions support Bigfoot? A critical look.

I Got Your Thunderdome

Came across this photo of William Parcher in his early footin' days.



(A little hollow earth with that, sir?)
 
Stop your constant references to your own ancestral heritage. It doesn't matter. I have ancestry too. They believed in ridiculous things just like yours did. It's all a bunch of garbage when the conversation is about what is actually real. Can't you separate reality from myth in spite of what your ancestors had to say?

You really meet the definition of beligerent ignoramus despite your knowledge of the PGF. I don't bring up my heritage unless in jest. Like my day at the beach collage. I've brought up William Brandon's study of the Kwakiutl, in particular his mentioning of Baxbaxwalanuksiwe. I've brought up James Fenimore Cooper's (a contemporary of the Melvilles, Humboldts, etc) writing of the great power of Manitou. I displayed various northwest native carvings described as "ape-like", Bokwus, etc..I defended Chief Seattle's speech when described as children's writing by Spektator. I mentioned that the word Gwich'n was unrecognizable to my mother, who said her tribe is called G'nich. (You can take her word because she was taken and re-educated by our Great White Father)

I even ordered that crackpot's book, Manlike Monsters.
 
Came across this photo of William Parcher in his early footin' days.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1977047f5d2f365ae0.jpg[/qimg]

(A little hollow earth with that, sir?)
As a rule I don't let anything get me upset. If I was the type of person to get upset easily, racism accusations of the cuff would probably do it pretty good. MOTS, I can't help but see irony in the fact that you are making Hitler jabs at WP yet you just drop this stinker like it's nothing:

Standard Skeptic's use of racially charged bigotry, hypocrisy, and ignorance.

I would ask how you associate Hawaiian with bigfoot? But you're just a decrepit old bigfoot hunter without a bigfoot to show for all your wasted effort.

But, since I'm the only indian here, why even discuss bigfoot? Maybe you should have a go at the holy grail or something. Or unicorns, werewolves...
First of all, you're obviously assuming that everyone here is of European decent. Secondly, haven't you been paying attention? The contention that I'm getting at here is that bigfoot is not a part of indigenous North American myth and life. Not as an animal or a mythical being of which there were countless among the multitude of cultures that made up those peoples.

Americans of European decent made bigfoot. It was North Americans of European decent who made the words 'Bigfoot' and 'Sasquatch'. It is my opinion that bigfoot is a unique North American cultural invention. It's like the culture that came from colonial beginnings decided to have a new boogeyman for the ogres, trolls, woodwoses, werewolves, and other various man-beasts of the cultures of their origins. He's bigfoot, the natives say he's the Boss of the Woods. Haven't you heard? You cut down his trees and he'll throw some fuel barrels like pebbles and break you in two. He's a peaceful giant, a screaming maniac. He sometimes talks, sometimes inside your mind. He's the Boss. When he is about not even birds and bees and crickets will make a sound. Everybody shut up! The Boss is here. What's that? Just a grizzly bear? Carry on. Old grizz don't have glowing red eyes and infra-sound, dude. Infra-sound. Yikes.

Just for the record, the two First Nations members in this thread who have participated have made it clear that bigfoot is no part of their culture.
 
Kitakaze, new guy here. This topic has taken some fairly radical turns from what it was when you opened it in January (I just found it today while googling), and it's the opening statements I would like to address. Your findings are very good, and I would like to use some of them at a site I run that is skeptical of cryptozoology.

I'm presently working on something else, and time isn't on my side, so I wouldn't be able to cover the Native American Myths for a while. But when I do, I would like to make sure you don't mind me using some of your research.
Hi, Karl. Welcome to the JREF. Yeah, for some reason we were suddenly talking about underground dance music culture. I'm pleased that you've found this thread interesting. Please feel free to use whatever you like. I would only ask that it be sourced and when the time comes that you finish, please share with us a link. Member Big Les did something similar with his blog which you may find interesting. I'll go back and link it.
 
Put on your 1964 authentic first edition Superman cape, encircle yourself with a power ring of all your finest Marvel Action Figures, and chant: Where is the body? Show me proof! (until exhausted)
No, no. In this thread the chant is "Where is the myth? Show me the tradition!"

We haven't seen any yet. Show me one native tribe that recognize bigfoot as a part of there culture and a living animal. A singular boogeywoman who's rather stupid, steals kids, and brings fortune isn't going to cut.
 
...But, since I'm the only indian here, why even discuss bigfoot? ...
As usual, you resort to assertion based on your opinion only.

And as usual, there are readily available facts to point out your error:
From Post 254
Well I'm Iroquois, and after consulting with my various wind spirit guides and ghost wolves, I can safely say that not only is Bigfoot real, but he wears a headdress and eats babies raw. Wow, we Indians sure are a wacky bunch, aren't we?!
 
Last edited:
As usual, you resort to assertion based on your opinion only.

And as usual, there are readily available facts to point out your error:

As usual, you are speaking out of your ass. That troll popped in for one post and stated he was indian. And you believe him, because it suits you.
 
Americans of European decent made bigfoot. It was North Americans of European decent who made the words 'Bigfoot' and 'Sasquatch'. It is my opinion that bigfoot is a unique North American cultural invention.

If you're referring to the Patty type, bloke in a suit creature, then yes, you are right. However, Bob Gimlin has been identified as (part) Apache.:)
What about Roger, which tribe is he from?

But if you're referring to a powerful forest creature, giant in stature, and potentially harmful to humans, then you are wrong.
 
As usual, you are speaking out of your ass. That troll popped in for one post and stated he was indian. And you believe him, because it suits you.
That 'troll' has 1280 posts as of the time of this post and has been a member of this forum for more than two years. I have no reason to doubt his claim of being Iroquois or his sarcasm to bigfoot. There's nothing extraordinary about it. This is a skeptic's forum, not a place where we presume everything a member says to be a lie. Your own mother told your her tribe has no bigfoot. Last I checked, no Iroquois bigfoot myths.
 
MOTS, you are some kind of poster boy for the contrarian troll that happens to find himself in a skeptical forum. You claim a childhood close encounter with Bigfoot (which you never saw) and everything moves forward from there. Your mind seems fully closed to the potential that you were never near a Bigfoot, or that this animal does not even exist. That puts you at a special disadvantage in this forum, but I think your personality feeds upon and is compelled by this 'underdog' position. There are probably ways to personally testify your experience and beliefs without being trollish. You seem comfortable acting this way and almost never break from this stereotypical character.

Your accusation of racism is just more of the same. It could have been predicted. Your responses (Hitler) are equally predictable. I can hardly take anything as truly offensive or insulting from you because it is not ever coming from a base of intelligence. It's all just a goofy stage show from a goofy guy.

If you really want people to applaud your speculations about NAs seeing Bigfoot you should take your show to BFF. I see that you do post there but the conversations seem stalled. Maybe it's because you have a special knack for twisting almost anything to point towards Bigfoot. The devoted believers may not even know how to deal with your personality.
 
As usual, you are speaking out of your ass. That troll popped in for one post and stated he was indian. And you believe him, because it suits you.
.... and there you go again with the baseless assertions (as well as an ad hominem attack). .... and of course the irony of "you believe him, because it suits you" is just too precious.

Try doing some research before blustering away.
Here's a post from Wheezebucket, Oct 07, right here on the JREF Forums:

I suggest you take a deep breath and count to 10 before you fire off your unsupport assertions. You know from your track record here that we will check your claims for validity.
 
Last edited:
But if you're referring to a powerful forest creature, giant in stature, and potentially harmful to humans, then you are wrong.
Well, by that definition you could be talking about centaurs, ogres, etc. If you can be more specific we might get somewhere. Maybe say, tell us how 'Stick Indians' correlate to bigfoot.

It's funny, you know. You'd think things would be simpler, finding evidence of a race of giant 8ft hairy bipedal primates across the continent alongside humans all these ages. I've been reading various origins myths lately, particularily the types in which the animals receive their names. It's funny how our big wood ape never seems to pop up. Bears, wolves, foxes, coyotes, eagles, salmons, moles... all these creatures and poor bigfoot is getting screwed. What's going on? Isn't he the Boss of the Woods? Not majestic enough?
 
That 'troll' has 1280 posts as of the time of this post and has been a member of this forum for more than two years. I have no reason to doubt his claim of being Iroquois or his sarcasm to bigfoot. There's nothing extraordinary about it.

Last I checked, no Iroquois bigfoot myths.

The last half of his sentence also stated that he has "wind spirit guides" and "ghost wolves". That's better than bigfoot. Start a thread and let's have it at this spirit guide, ghost wolf stuff that you now credit as truthful.

Your OP, let me say that again, your OP has two mentions of Iroquois myths associated with bigfoot. Otneyarheh and Tarhuhyiawahku. You apparently have no regard for previously stated facts.
 
If you really want people to applaud your speculations about NAs seeing Bigfoot you should take your show to BFF. I see that you do post there but the conversations seem stalled. Maybe it's because you have a special knack for twisting almost anything to point towards Bigfoot. The devoted believers may not even know how to deal with your personality.

Well, at least they don't call me Tonto. You should see how the devoted believers are now treating Dr. Bindernagel (never heard of him) and his reported sighting that will be detailed in a future documentary. The truly devoted (PGF) dislike me. Rockinkt, BitterMonk, WmRoy, a certain mod.

But I never showed up here as a self proclaimed bigfoot scientist, I just got my ******* *** chased.
 
Oh earlier today I read about Bindernagel's BF sighting. I just love the subtitle of that thread: "Good News for Science". LOL.
 
Your OP, let me say that again, your OP has two mentions of Iroquois myths associated with bigfoot. Otneyarheh and Tarhuhyiawahku. You apparently have no regard for previously stated facts.
We also know the quality and reliability or lack thereof of that list.

Go back and read the thread a little, take the words "associated with bigfoot," and then keep in mind "by who?"
 
Your own mother told your her tribe has no bigfoot.

Correct. My tribe is located in the Alaskan Interior on the Yukon River. Near the Tanana River junction. She stated that when she was a child that the men in her tribe would occasionally battle "Eskimos" while out on a hunt. When I asked her why, she stated "because they're different". Eskimos aren't that different, so I still have some questions, for later.

However, like you said, the native makers of certain artifacts know exactly what creatures they are portraying. Whether it be a wolf, bear, or Bokwus-Wild Man of the Woods.

Here's a bag that my grandmother, a noted Athabascan crafts maker, made and gave to my wife after we married more than 25 years ago. She described the creature as an eagle and I have no reason to doubt her.



 
Earlier today I read about Bindernagel's BF sighting. I just love the subtitle of that thread: "Good News for Science". LOL.

I think the Bigfooters are hesitant to become highly excited about this. They are probably anticipating that the film will be of a blobsquatch. As was already mentioned in that thread, if the filmed subject was truly remarkable and convincing it would already be in the hands of mass media. That seems pretty reasonable to think, but it may not be the truth. It will be interesting to see how this plays out when the information is released from the BF "research" entity that is behind it all. Anyway, this is off topic for this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom