Native American myths/traditions support Bigfoot? A critical look.

My apologies to WP. All the time I've taken to post in the last week has been devoted to the PGF thread. I haven't even begun to examine the material presented in the links of his I mentioned in my last post in this thread.

Until then it is my hope that we don't make any large AAH contributions.
 
You have been outed as a troll.
.
"If somebody is simply ignorant or obtuse, it's incorrect to call him a troll. Admittedly, it's not always easy to distinguish between someone pretending to be wrong and someone who is wrong and doesn't know it or won't admit it."*

manofthesea said:
Define troll.
.
"The Contrarian Troll. A sophisticated breed, Contrarian Trolls frequent boards whose predominant opinions are contrary to their own. A forum dominated by those who support firearms and knife rights, for example, will invariably be visited by Contrarian Trolls espousing their beliefs in the benefits of gun control. It is important to distinguish between dissenters and actual Contrarian Trolls, however; the Contrarian is not categorized as a troll because of his or her dissenting opinions, but due to the manner in which he or she behaves:

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number One: The most important indicator of a poster's Contrarian Troll status is his constant use of subtle and not-so-subtle insults, a technique intended to make people angry. Contrarians will resist the urge to be insulting at first, but as their post count increases, they become more and more abusive of those with whom they disagree. Most often they initiate the insults in the course of what has been a civil, if heated, debate to that point.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Two: Constant references to the forum membership as monolithic. "You guys are all just [descriptor]." "You're a lynch mob." "You all just want to ridicule anyone who disagrees with you."

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Three: Intellectual dishonesty. This is only a mild indicator that is not limited to trolls, but Contrarians display it to a high degree. They will lie about things they've said, pull posts out of context in a manner that changes their meanings significantly, and generally ignore any points for which they have no ready answers.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Four: Accusing the accusers. When confronted with their trolling, trolls immediately respond that it is the accusers who are trolls (see Natural Predators below). Often the Contrarian will single out his most vocal opponent and claim that while he can respect his other opponents, this one in particular is beneath his notice.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Five: Attempts to condescend. The Contrarian will seek refuge in condescending remarks that repeatedly scorn his or her critics as beneath notice – all the while continuing to respond to them.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Six: One distinctive mark of Contrarian Trolls is that every thread in which they dissent quickly devolves into a debate about who is trolling whom. In the course of such a debate the Contrarian will display many of the other Warning Signs mentioned above."**

RayG

*http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/mtroll.html
**http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=1032102
 
Would it have been better to have it transcribed to 'hillbilly' then? Chief Sealth spoke Salish, it was transcribed in a formal literary prose. Kinda like the constitution and other important writings.
Oh, please... The constitution wasn't translated through 3 languages.
Funnily enough, though, it is constantly misquoted and misintepreted depending on the needs, biases or beliefs of those wishing to appeal to it's authority.
 
I'd bet that is the first time ever that flowery was used to describe this speech.
Wrong. You obviously ignored the text that I quoted. Other examples.
http://www.yvwiiusdinvnohii.net/history/seattle1.html
http://www.fs.fed.us/eco/eco-watch/ew920221
http://www.synaptic.bc.ca/ejournal/wslibrry.htm
http://tafkac.org/misc/chief_seattle_environment_speech.html
http://www.tr.wou.edu/perc/documents/ExaminingMulticulturalPictureBooks.pdf

Have you ever read it's entirety, no matter the source?
Never heard of it, Chief Seattle, Dr.Smith before this thread. As for source, the first article quotes Dr.Smith as stating in his 1887 column for the Seattle Sunday Star,
"...He makes it very clear that his version is not an exact copy, but rather the best he could put together from notes taken at the time. There is an undecided historical argument on which native dialect the Chief would have used, Duwamish or Suquamish."

So regardless of your unsubstatiated claims to the good doctor's linguistic skills, he seems to state that his recollection was inaccurate.

Straight from the horse's mouth. No need for arguments on whether translations were inaccurate or not - Dr.Smith states that his "transcript" is not an exact copy, but rather the best he could put together from notes taken at the time.
 
Wrong. You obviously ignored the text that I quoted. Other examples.
http://www.yvwiiusdinvnohii.net/history/seattle1.html
http://www.fs.fed.us/eco/eco-watch/ew920221
http://www.synaptic.bc.ca/ejournal/wslibrry.htm
http://tafkac.org/misc/chief_seattle_environment_speech.html
http://www.tr.wou.edu/perc/documents/ExaminingMulticulturalPictureBooks.pdf

Never heard of it, Chief Seattle, Dr.Smith before this thread. As for source, the first article quotes Dr.Smith as stating in his 1887 column for the Seattle Sunday Star,
"...He makes it very clear that his version is not an exact copy, but rather the best he could put together from notes taken at the time. There is an undecided historical argument on which native dialect the Chief would have used, Duwamish or Suquamish."

So regardless of your unsubstatiated claims to the good doctor's linguistic skills, he seems to state that his recollection was inaccurate.

Straight from the horse's mouth. No need for arguments on whether translations were inaccurate or not - Dr.Smith states that his "transcript" is not an exact copy, but rather the best he could put together from notes taken at the time.

And all that means nada. You're taking issue with a text printed by U. of Oklahoma. It is reference material. You seem to desire a transliteration of the event, which is nonexistant at this time. His notes are the most correct.
 
Last edited:
Here's a quote from the book leading to the speech.
"The speech given here was taken down by Dr. Henry Smith, a man of some talent, who mastered the Duwamish language in about two years. Dr. Smith has done us a great service in preserving this address, which may cause some present day citizens to wonder at Seattle's predictions."
 
It is my assertion that Native American traditions do not support the existence of bigfoot and that what is put forth by bigfoot enthusiasts as evidence for the existence of bigfoot has been cherry-picked and misrepresented.

I agree, and we saw a recent example of that with manofthesea and his misrepresentation of the poem/song by James Fenimore Cooper.

RayG
 
Me Too

I agree, and we saw a recent example of that with manofthesea and his misrepresentation of the poem/song by James Fenimore Cooper.

RayG

You are the one who consistently misrepresents historical and current facts.

Firstly, Indians (historically and currently) have been noted to assign a 'spirituality or deity' type of respect for all creatures, and many objects.

Secondly, the poem by Cooper uses the term Manitou ten (10) separate times. It also uses the terms woods, whoops, yell, and other terms consistent with bigfoot.

The setting being situated in the New York Lakes area made it more interesting. And the year, 1850 or so.
 
Here's a quote from the book leading to the speech.
"The speech given here was taken down by Dr. Henry Smith, a man of some talent, who mastered the Duwamish language in about two years. Dr. Smith has done us a great service in preserving this address, which may cause some present day citizens to wonder at Seattle's predictions."
You quote an book written in 1971.

I quoted an article written by Dr.Smith himself in 1887.

So who do you think is more correct on the recollection and transcribing of the speech?

The man who wrote it?
Or an author who wrote about the man who wrote it?
 
You are the one who consistently misrepresents historical and current facts.

Firstly, Indians (historically and currently) have been noted to assign a 'spirituality or deity' type of respect for all creatures, and many objects.

Yes, I haven't argued otherwise. Keep in mind, many of their myths, legends, and stories are not based on any facts (just like your manitou-bigfoot connection).

Secondly, the poem by Cooper uses the term Manitou ten (10) separate times. It also uses the terms woods, whoops, yell, and other terms consistent with bigfoot.
It doesn't matter if he mentioned it 100 times, he makes no connection between manitou and bigfoot, you do. You have grabbed onto some sounds penned in a song/poem that you attribute to bigfoot, when the author clearly indicated the true, non-bigfoot source. You're engaging in intellectual dishonesty by advocating a position you know full well is false.

RayG
 
Well I'm Iroquois, and after consulting with my various wind spirit guides and ghost wolves, I can safely say that not only is Bigfoot real, but he wears a headdress and eats babies raw. Wow, we Indians sure are a wacky bunch, aren't we?!
 
Last edited:
Short but sweet:


I've addressed some of them and now I'll quickly deal with the one that she pronounced as 'stemahah' or STEE-MAH-HAH.

Also from Franzoni and Glickman's bigfoot native name list:

name/tribe/translation

Seatco Yakama/Klickitat/Puyallup "Stick Indian"

I've recently received verification/authentication from an informed source concerning 'Stick Indian'. The person is a member of the Colville group of tribes. And he resides on the reservation also. He stated that Stick Indian is the term currently used by the elders to describe sasquatch.
 
I've recently received verification/authentication from an informed source concerning 'Stick Indian'. The person is a member of the Colville group of tribes. And he resides on the reservation also. He stated that Stick Indian is the term currently used by the elders to describe sasquatch.

Page 50 of Ella Elizabeth Clark 's Indian Legends from the Northern Rockies says that many Native Americans use the term "Stick Indian" in reference to supernatural dwarves.

I also found this to be of interest.
 
Ella Elizabeth Clark 's Indian Legends from the Northern Rockies says that many Native Americans use the term "Stick Indian" in reference to supernatural dwarves.

.

This person, as I mentioned, resides on the Colville. That particular tribal group also inhabits the Cascades, which I am primarily interested in. It is a legitimate confirmation of historical legends. Note, this person had an encounter with a possible unknown creature while hunting. That is what started his current interest and willingness to discuss the circumstance. He stated that he was aware of the legend, but unconvinced as to the existence of a real creature(s).

Concerning Ella Clark, does it state her source of reference? Also, how big are supernatural dwarf's feet?
 
Concerning Ella Clark, does it state her source of reference?

She used many sources for her book; I think that the references for the "stick indian" stories are given on page 327, but it's hard to say for sure since Google only offers certain pages in their online preview.

Also, how big are supernatural dwarf's feet?

There are no comments regarding the size of the feet. However, considering that they're described as being "...just like human beings except that they were small," I'd imagine that the feet aren't big.
 
There are no comments regarding the size of the feet. However, considering that they're described as being "...just like human beings except that they were small," I'd imagine that the feet aren't big.

The Rev. Elkanah Walker, while describing a race of giants and their propensity to steal salmon, also described a race of little people: "Natives also believed in a race of "little people" the Elequas Tern (Stick Indians), who inhabited high places, such as the Cascade Mountains."

But the 'howl' that I heard, combined with the other circumstances, lead me in the direction of the mentioned giants being bigfoot. That is one of their descriptive behaviors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom