However, I was not trying to establish the existance of bigfoot by means of Cooper's writings.
.
You certainly
seemed to be equating manitou with bigfoot. Like when you said:
manofthesea said:
You've been into bigfoot "for a little more than three decades", you must be aware of James Fenimore Cooper's little 'poem' about manitou.
.
Cooper wrote a song/poem about manitou not bigfoot.
You made the bigfoot-manitou association.
And then you said:
manofthesea said:
As far as 'manitou', and the poem I referenced (See my signature at BFF), the manitou is noted as having a "long whoop, long cry, and a yell" in the forest. That is a physical description matching bigfoot. Simple.
.
The explanation for that "long whoop, long cry, and a yell" was simply and clearly pointed out by Cooper himself:
"...was the well-known and terrific war- whoop, which burst from the lips of the young warrior, like a combination of all the frightful sounds of battle."
.
Again,
you made the manitou-bigfoot association.
The term manitou was in a list, since denied, that contained the term manitou as referring to bigfoot.
.
As was pointed out, it's a list created by bigfooters to try to associate names with anything that might remotely resemble bigfoot. Large, bipedal and humanoid? Hey, those are the main requirements. Claws and fangs? Sure, why not. Giant otter? Close enough.
Not sure I understand what you mean by "since denied". Denied by who? It was simply and clearly pointed out to you by kitakaze that:
Regarding the list I cited as compiled by Henry Franzoni, Jeff Glickman, and Kyle Mizokami:
One of the authors (I will not say which due to a request for anonymity) has contacted me and informed me that the list "Native American Names for Bigfoot" it is not now nor ever was representational of his views. Furthermore, the document is apparently not an original and was compiled from numerous sources by an unknown party
.
.
You obviously associated manitou with bigfoot, even when presented with evidence to the contrary from many sources. Clinging to a
belief will not make it come true.
Here again is that association that
you, as a bigfoot romantic see:
manofthesea said:
Having a collection of books myself, I decided to look at a few. Whadayaknow, I found a cool poem in the first American literature book that I checked. Above all, it contained the whoop and yell, somewhat associated with modern bigfoot. Not to mention the location of this fictional incident, but yet referencing a tribe local to that area. So I thought it interesting and made mention of it.
.
You thought it
interesting? No, in your romanticism,
you thought it confirmed that manitou = bigfoot.
You made that perfectly clear when you only quoted a portion of the books' poem/song, and then conveniently left off the actual explanation (provided by the author himself in the very same book). The behavior
you exhibited, and 'facts'
you presented speaks volumes about your investigative abilities, attention to detail, and desire to sensationalize.
My current inclination concerning accurate native historical accounts and legends of sasquatch is that the Colville area, with it's historically associated tribes would be the BEST source.
.
Just how does one determine an
accurate native historical account of bigfoot?
RayG