That's the guy. Don't let my dyslexia interfere with our conversation.
That's why you don't answer questions?
I'll try and make it easy for you. Would point form be better?
- Do you believe that manitou was an Indian name for bigfoot?
- If yes, do you have a source that supports that belief?
- Does Cooper's poem have some correlation between Native American myths/traditions and bigfoot?
- Do you believe that Kushtaka was an Indian name for bigfoot?
Simple questions. Did you want to discuss Native American myths/traditions and whether they support bigfoot or not?
As to your question,
What do you think about Hekanah [Elkanah]
Walker?
Not much, but at least he's perceptive. He calls them superstitions not fact. You should know there are no shortage of myths, legends, and superstitions among Native American cultures and other cultures around the world. Some of these 'stories' are about giants.
Greek & Roman mythology for example:
The Giants were huge, violent creatures with long hair and beards. There were 24 of them birthed to Gaea on Thracian Phlegra. The Giants later attacked the Olympian gods after Gaea was upset at the punishment to the Titans. The Giants were defeated and also imprisoned under the earth. It is said that wherever a volcanoe errupts is where a giant is hidden.
.
Here's a list of
names of giants and the cultures that have assigned the name:
* Daitya (Sanskrit)
* Gigantes (Greek)
* Titans (Greek)
* Cyclopes/Cyclops (Greek)
* Upelleru (Middle Eastern)
* Azrail (Armenian)
* Anakim (Hebrew)
* Enim (Hebrew)
* Rephaim (Hebrew)
* Zamzummim (Hebrew)
* Nephilim (Hebrew)
* Gog (Hebrew/British)
* Magog (Hebrew/British)
* Jake (Bruns)
* Goliath of Gath (Hebrew)
* Og of Bashan (Hebrew)
* Fomorians (Celtic)
* Wrnach (Welsh)
* Bendigeidfran (Welsh)
* Jotuns (Norse/Teutonic)
* Frost Giants (Norse/Teutonic)
* Fire Giants (Norse/Teutonic)
* Earth Giants (Norse/Teutonic)
* Ice Giants (Finnish)
* Yak (Thai)
* Puntan (Micronesia)
* Albadan (Spanish)
* Famangomadan (Spanish)
* Dehotgohsgayeh (Iroquois)
* Gedegwsets (Coos)
* Inugpasugssuk (Netslik)
* Kiwahkw (Maliseet)
* Yeitso (Navajo)
* Nunhyunuwi (Cherokee)
* Si-Te-Cah (Paiute)
* Dzoo-Noo-Qua (Kwakiutl)
* Nahgane (Slavey)
* Chahnameed (Pequot)
* Paul Bunyan (American)
* Hewiixi/hewietari (Huichol)
* Cawr (Welsh)
* Kaour (Breton)
* Dasa Maha Yodayo (Sri Lanka)
* Gotaimbara (Sri Lanka)
* Mahasena (Sri Lanka)
.
Notice the inclusion of the Iroquois, Navajo, Cherokee, Paiute, and Kwakiutl terms for
giant.
http://www.geocities.com/dragar.geo/WSP/monsters.html said:
giant
Culture of Origin: wide spread Description: Giants are a race of huge beings with super human size and strength. In Norse mythology giants were a primeval race, existing before the gods and overcome by them, similar to the Greek Titans. In most European tales giants appear as cruel and stupid, given to cannibalism, often one-eyed, and scarcely distinguishable from monsters. Although kindly giants occur, most were feared and hated. Greek Mythology refers to giants as Titans or Cyclops. c.f.: Cyclops, Titan
.
Surely you've heard of Cyclops, a race of giants who had only one eye, in the middle of the forehead? What about Ogres? Jeebus, they're man-eating giants.
http://www.geocities.com/dragar.geo/WSP/monsters.html said:
ogre Culture of Origin: European Folklore Description: Ogres are a man-eating monster or giant.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ogre said:
An ogre (feminine: ogress) is a large, mean and hideous humanoid monster. Ogres are often depicted in fairy tales and folklore as feeding on human beings, and have appeared in many classic works of literature. In art, ogres are often depicted with a large head, abundant hair and beard, a huge belly, and a strong body. The term is often applied in a metaphorical sense to disgusting persons who exploit, brutalize or devour their victims.
.
Could the superstitious creatures Walker writes about be mere ogres and not bigfoot? Maybe they were
trolls and not ogres at all.
troll Culture of Origin: Scandinavian Folklore Description: A race of supernatural beings, sometimes referred to as giants or dwarfs, living underground or in caves. Other references indicate, trolls are giant, monstrous beings, sometimes possessing magic powers. Trolls are hostile to men. They live in castles and haunt the surrounding area after dark. If exposed to sunlight they burst or turn to stone. In later tales trolls often are man sized or smaller beings similar to dwarfs and elves. They lived in mountains, sometimes stole human maidens, and could transform themselves and prophesy.
.
Giants, living in mountains, and stealing human maidens? Isn't that similar to Walker's description?
--
Bear with me if I trouble you with a little of their superstitions. They believe in a race of giants, which inhabit a certain mountain off to the west of us. This mountain is covered with perpetual snow. They (the creatures) inhabit the snow peaks. They hunt and do all their work at night. They are men stealers. --
Dang! Now the bigfoot romantics will equate trolls to squatches.
manofthesea said:
I never heard of any of those guys anyway. Remember, I've never read ANY bigfoot books.
.
No idea who Henry Franzoni, Jeff Glickman, or Kyle Mizokami are? I'm not surprised. But then you just started this past summer, so you've a lot of catching up to do. Here's an incomplete list of names you
should be familiar with:
Green, Krantz, Dahinden, Byrne, Meldrum, Bindernagel, Fahrenbach, Sanderson, Bourne, Porshnev, Grieve, Bayonov, Patterson, Perez, Short, Williams, Coleman, Pyle, Gimlin, Freeman, Titmus, Huyghe, Bourtsev, Greenwell, Noll, Napier, Sarmiento, Fish, Coon, Berry, Sprague, Slick, Gordon, Moneymaker, Heuvelmans, Steenburg, Gates, Donskoy, Wylie, Haas, Slate, Crowe, Guttilla, Hibner, Franzoni, Laverty, Burns, Orchard, Keating, Wasson, Taft, Swindler, Glickman, Kirlin, Gill, Markotic, Murphy, Caddy, McClarin, Tchernine, Alley, Jackson, Shackley, Davis, Woolheater, Perry, Mizokami, Halpin, Ciochon, Baird, and Bord.
Contributions to bigfootdom by the above named can be found at your library or online.
RayG