Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

This is the bit in this study that caused me a chuckle:

http://nebula.wsimg.com/d1e65ba8eb5...114F8E0676B9465FB&disposition=0&alloworigin=1

The power density values read by the mobile phone company are extremely low, suspiciously low, compared with measurements taken near other base stations (Ab del-Rassoul et al. 2006). Furthermore, the power density was measured only once by the mobile phone company, whereas this kind of measurement should be conducted several times. Although the power density, as measured by the mobile phone company, was too low to be considered relevant in aggravating the health problems experienced by residents, we have used these measurements as reference levels in this case study.
 
There are studies out there. How about this one? Trouble is that I cannot get access to the papers freely.


https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22138021

OBJECTIVES:
This study is concerned with assessing the role of exposure to radio frequency radiation (RFR) emitted either from mobiles or base stations and its relations with human's hormone profiles.

DESIGN AND METHODS:
All volunteers' samples were collected for hormonal analysis.
RESULTS:

This study showed significant decrease in volunteers' ACTH, cortisol, thyroid hormones, prolactin for young females, and testosterone levels.

CONCLUSION:
The present study revealed that high RFR effects on pituitary-adrenal axis.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0009912011027330?via=ihub

This study is concerned with assessing the role of long-term exposure to high radio frequency radiation emitted either from mobile phones or from base stations and its relations with human's hormone profiles.
All volunteers are followed for 6 years and blood samples were collected regularly every 3 years for time intervals of 1 year, 3 years and 6 years for hormonal analysis and the blood samples were taken at 8.0 a.m.

This study showed reduction in volunteers' plasma ACTH, serum cortisol levels. Also, they showed decrease in the release of the thyroid hormones especially T3. In addition, each of their serum prolactin in young females (14–22 years), and testosterone levels significantly dropped due to long-term exposure to radio frequency radiation.

Conversely, serum prolactin levels for adult females (25–60 years) significantly rose with increasing exposure time. In conclusion, the present study revealed that high radio frequency radiation effects on pituitary–adrenal axis represented in the reduction of ACTH, cortisol, thyroid hormones, prolactin in young females, and testosterone levels.
 
There are studies that are trying to correlate health and base stations:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969711005754

Between 1996 and 2006, 7191 deaths by neoplasia occurred and within an area of 500 m from the BS, the mortality rate was 34.76 per 10,000 inhabitants.

Outside of this area, a decrease in the number of deaths by neoplasia occurred.

The greatest accumulated incidence was 5.83 per 1000 in the Central-Southern region and the lowest incidence was 2.05 per 1000 in the Barreiro region.
 
Are you expecting us to analyse and critique every study you decide to cherry pick?

Once again: cherry picking only the studies which appear to support what you have decided to believe is what crackpots and conspiracy theorists do. For an honest assessment of the evidence you need to look at all of it.

Just for a change, why don't you analyse and critique some of the dozens of studies which show no harm and explain why those results should be discounted?
 
There are studies that are trying to correlate health and base stations:

that is weird, the base station is per 10.000 whereas the other numbers are per 1000 and the 5.83 should thus be 58.3, and greater than around the bs!
 
Last edited:
Here is one that questions the label of hysteria and nocebo effects:


I don't think the study says what you think it says!

By using the battery of biomarkers we have investigated in this study it now seems possible to objectively characterize and identify EHS and MCS. Although termed “idiopathic”, IEI has been defined as abnormal responses possibly (!) triggered by exposure to organic chemicals and/ or metals. It is believed that in addition, to MCS several pathological disorders such as fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome, because they may share a similar environment-related intolerance condition, could be part of IEI. We have shown multiple lines of evidence that EHS and MCS share a similar pathogenesis and so might be the same pathological disorder whatever their putative causal stressors. This strongly reinforces the concept that both EHS and MCS must be part of the so called IEI syndrome.


EHS: electromagnetic hypersensitivity (Wikipedia)
IEI: idiopathic environmental intolerance (Wikipedia)
MCS: multiple chemical sensitivity (Wikipedia)

A systematic review in 2005 showed no convincing scientific evidence for symptoms being caused by electromagnetic fields. Since then, several double-blind (!!!) experiments have shown that people who report electromagnetic hypersensitivity are unable to detect the presence of electromagnetic fields and are as likely to report ill health following a sham exposure as they are following exposure to genuine electromagnetic fields, suggesting the cause in these cases to be the nocebo effect.electromagnetic hypersensitivity

Although the symptoms themselves are real, and can be disabling, MCS is not recognized as an organic, chemical-caused illness by the World Health Organization, American Medical Association, or any of several other professional medical organizations. Blinded (!!!) clinical trials show that people with MCS react as often and as strongly to placebos as they do to chemical stimuli; the existence and severity of symptoms is related to perception that a chemical stimulus is present.
idiopathic environmental intolerance]multiple chemical sensitivity (Wikipedia)


In other words, people's imagination and anxieties make them sick. When the study says that "the common co-occurrence of EHS and MCS strongly suggests a common pathological mechanism," i.e. that the different values that can me measured by means of blood samples are similar, it simply means that what they have in common is their fears and anxieties!
(People doing actual research wouldn't put it as bluntly as I do!)
 
Last edited:
Here is one that questions the label of hysteria and nocebo effects:


From the conclusions of your linked article:

Whatever the causal origin of EHS and/or MCS, there is compelling evidence that EHS and/or MCS self-reporting patients constitute an unsolved, large and growing health problem worldwide.
As far as EHS is concerned, about 1%–10% of the investigated population, e.g. 5% in Switzerland (13), 5% in Ireland, 9% in Sweden, 9% in Germany and 11% in England are presently estimated to be EHS self-reporting persons (201). Given the seven billion persons worldwide using cordless and/or mobile phone it is expected these percentages may increase in the 50 next years. However, because at the time these estimations were made there was no objective criteria for identifying EHS (21), these data require confirmation by more objective investigations.


EHS is short for electrohypersensitivity. Note that this is talking about persons self-reporting EHS and that the authors are drawing no conclusions, saying that the proposed diagnostic criteria they describe had not been applied to any such persons at least at the time the article was published in 2015.

You blithely throw this over the wal,l expecting us to accept it as evidence. Why? "No claimer" excuse in 3,2,1...

ETA: ninja'd in part by dann
 
Last edited:
Are you expecting us to analyse and critique every study you decide to cherry pick?

Once again: cherry picking only the studies which appear to support what you have decided to believe is what crackpots and conspiracy theorists do. For an honest assessment of the evidence you need to look at all of it.

Just for a change, why don't you analyse and critique some of the dozens of studies which show no harm and explain why those results should be discounted?


So your definition of cherry picking is just what ICNIRP does. This one shows no harm - acceptable. This study shows harm - not acceptable.

Then you say I am cherry picking because I use one study that indicates harm. How many do you need? It is not a matter of 1,000 studies show no harm so I have to present 1,001 studies showing harm in order to prove there is harm.

And the reason for rejecting the studies is very simple. ICNIRP has decided that harm can only come from either heating effects or from ionising effects. How unscientific.

People are beginning to see how biased the ICNIRP and WHO committees are. But you refuse to believe that bias can influence their "scientific" analysis of the various papers - even though they are mostly engineers reviewing medical studies.

Here is a paper that tackles the bias at these organizations:
https://www.scribd.com/document/352714568/ijo-2017-4046-AOP-PDF
Have a look at table 1 on page 4 regarding the commonality of members on different committees.

Also:
https://es-ireland.com/2016/12/20/has-the-who-emf-project-been-hijacked-by-icnirp/
 
So your definition of cherry picking is just what ICNIRP does. This one shows no harm - acceptable. This study shows harm - not acceptable.
No, that's not how it works. You look at all the studies. And when the studies show no harm are more numerous, better designed and show more robust results than the studies that show harm, then you conclude that there is probably no harm.
 
A disgraceful piece in today's Observer:

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/14/mobile-phones-cancer-inconvenient-truths

Two BTL comments sum it up:

Essentially the article's message is that scientists are split on whether phones cause cancer, but when you remove industry-funded research the balance clearly tips towards the positive. This is likened to what happened with smoking, where the industry funds research in order to keep the argument alive and prevent stronger conclusions being reached.

I'm all for getting industry funding out of this research. But it's important to present an accurate sense of what current literature tells us- and from what I can gather it doesn't resemble the picture painted by the article.

It seems that there are a ton of studies which in aggregate show a mixed picture. But most of those can't be used to draw any firm conclusions because of the nature of the experiments involved. For example, many involve subjecting lab-cultivated cells to radiation rather than cells in a human body, or rats, or much higher levels of exposure. Others involve possible confounding variables which we can't rule out.

But there are a couple of more reliable large-scake cohort studies available and these suggest that there is no link. Add that to a lack of spike in cancer rates in the general population since the spread of mobile technology, plus the lack of a plausible mechanism for how phones would actually cause cancer and the evidence is clearly pointing towards there being no link. More research is needed to be sure, however, hence the precautionary advice.

So while there's nothing outright false in the article or on the level of anti-vaxxer stuff, it is misrepresentating the science in a sensationalist manner- and one which probably is counterproductive to the goal of removing conflicts of interest in science.



If Ben Goldacre still worked here he would probably resign in disgust that this nonsense was published.
 
Back on Sunday. Beach holiday. Weather good - no surprise. Got a drug resistant chest infection last week. Some twists and turns there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom