Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

It just occurred to me, quadraginta, that there may be a very simple test to determine if the brains of any U.S. diplomats stationed in Havana, Uzbekistan, Guangzhou or Singapore (The State, June 26, 2018) were microwaved:


Double-blinded, of course ...


This would work.

I would recommend the use of brains from Republican politicians though, since, not having been used for anything, they would provide a more uniform basis for comparison.
 
Interestingly there was a question addressed on the Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast this week about whether non-ionising radiation could be harmful. Steve Novella's thoughtful and nuanced response, in a nutshell, was that we could not absolutely rule it out, but the available evidence is largely negative so it is still extremely unlikely. Basically as close to "no" as an honest scientist can say.
 
Interestingly there was a question addressed on the Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast this week about whether non-ionising radiation could be harmful. Steve Novella's thoughtful and nuanced response, in a nutshell, was that we could not absolutely rule it out, but the available evidence is largely negative so it is still extremely unlikely. Basically as close to "no" as an honest scientist can say.

I read an article recently arguing that oxygen is as harmful as radiation. (The premise being that much of the biological injury from ionising radiation is due to the generation of reactive oxygen species. Breathing high levels of oxygen also generates reactive oxygen species causing 'radiation-like' tissue injury.) Now there are clearly issues with dosing etc. but as a speculative discussion it was interesting reminding one of how toxic oxygen is to life.
 
Here is an article about histoplasmosis. The Thai cave boys.

Note that it says that to get seriously sick, for the infection to spread from the lungs to other organs, one HAS to have a weakened immune system. That was not the case with me, my late wife or my son. So much for the "conventional wisdom".

What was worse was that my son's doctor and my doctor refused to treat us by prescribing the Itraconazole after we both diagnosed ourselves. Because they said it was not possible for us to have the systemic infection.

And after 7 years, I am still on it. Last week I only took about 2 capsules. I got sick again this week and am now on 2 capsules a day to get back to "normal". Our cases are not reported in any medical journal though.

http://www.foxnews.com/health/2018/...lation-as-doctors-monitor-for-infections.html

Cave disease," also called histoplasmosis, is a lung infection caused by the fungus "Histoplasma," which thrives in areas with high bird or bat populations, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

"People can get histoplasmosis after breathing in the microscopic fungal spores from the air, often after participating in activities that disturb the soil," the CDC explains in a blog post online. "Although most people who breathe in the spores don’t get sick, those who do may have a fever, cough, and fatigue."

Most people who contract histoplasmosis just need time to recover, but those who have weakened immune systems could be at risk for serious, sometimes fatal, infections.

"In some people, such as those who have weakened immune systems, the infection can become severe, especially if it spreads from the lungs to other organs," the CDC says.

There is medicine to treat the disease, however. According to the CDC, many doctors prescribe the antifungal medication Itraconazole, which may need to be taken anywhere from three months to a year in order to completely fight off the infection.
 
It gives no good reason to suspect it either.


If damage cannot be measured or detected there is no damage.


If multiple studies show that kids who grow up next to a tower are no more likely to be autistic than children who don't then yes, you certainly can. This is how the MMR vaccine was ruled out as a cause of autism.


You know that children have died because their mothers were persuaded by bogus health scares to "not take the chance" of getting them vaccinated?


Something caused the symptoms - and they resemble cell tower symptoms. I would say that is a logical reason.

If God cannot be detected then there is no God. I give you marks for consistency in your logic.

Do we have to wait for the studies on a massive scale over many years to determine this kind of damage? Is it okay to do experiments on the general public, like Ciprofloxacin, where one reassesses initial assumptions? Should we not be a little more proactive and slow down to assess more studies?

How many children will die if they do not have towers next to them? With vaccination, the mothers were faced with a choice of two risks. In the tower case, the choice is risk versus no risk (err on the side of caution). Somewhere two kids died within an hour of getting inoculated. The risk is not zero, but it the latter case it was likely a defective dose.
 
Pixel42 has already answered you, PartSkeptic, but let me comment on this one:

The question of profits should make you suspicious when big business claims that something is safe. Two fairly well-known examples:

And these links from another thread show my own skepticism of Big Pharma:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12282394#post12282394
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12282609#post12282609
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12284406#post12284406

But don't forget that money, money, money also plays an important role in the world of alternative medicine. I can recommend Bob Goldacre's book Bad Science, which criticizes both Big Pharma and Big Alt. Med.


Yes to all you have said.

I took my mother home to care for her after a hospitalization. She was taking so many medications prescribed over the years by her doctor including meds for high blood pressure. Over a period of two weeks, I weaned her off all of them. Her blood pressure went to normal and until she died years later, all she needed was the occasional ibuprofen tablet.

My father had diabetes from being overweight. He refused to take insulin and had to cut out sugars. When he got older and lost weight he could eat sugar once more. Yes, I agree.

99% of sinus infections in the USA are untreatable with antibiotics. The doctors say the patients just have to live with it. They do not prescribe the one antibiotic that bacteria never developed a resistance to which is silver. Spray or sniff colloidal silver and one can get rid of such infections. But it is seen as alternative medicine
 
Last edited:
Note that it says that to get seriously sick, for the infection to spread from the lungs to other organs, one HAS to have a weakened immune system.
That's not what it says. Not even remotely. Look, here's the relevant section, copied directly from your post:

Most people who contract histoplasmosis just need time to recover, but those who have weakened immune systems could be at risk for serious, sometimes fatal, infections.

Note the things it doesn't say. It doesn't say anthing about one HAVING to have a weakened immune system. It doesn't say that people without a weakened immune system NEVER are at risk for serious infections. It doesn't even say that ALL people with weakened immune systems acquire a serious infection. It says that people with weakened immune systems COULD BE AT RISK for serious infections.

It's a far cry from "could be at risk" to your capitalised absolute.
 
What were you microwaving, emu eggs????
let me just say I doubt the accuracy of this statement
(I love my eggs and usually microwave them, putting them in a sealed container is always a good idea as yes they will explode, and after having to disassemble the microwave as egg had penetrated the light fitting shield and goes a bit pongy after a day or two of ozzie heat- I now have special containers that have a small vent in the top to stop the top blowing off)
Have never seen one explode hard enough to break the door latches open and cover an entire room though

This event was caused by three eggs at once. When the first one exploded it caused the other two to explode at the same time. And he likely had the microwave on high. Some latches are not as strong as others.

The main spray went completely across the room in a cannon-like blast of about thirty degrees to either side and top and bottom. The back and sides of the room escaped. It looked like yellow spray paint, and the opposite wall was covered. Although the whole room needed cleaning.

A dumb blonde I met once put a can of fish into a regular oven and put the oven on high. The fine spray and the smell were not to be forgotten for a while. Luckily, she was not in the kitchen at the time. Do not try this at home.
 
That's not what it says. Not even remotely. Look, here's the relevant section, copied directly from your post:



Note the things it doesn't say. It doesn't say anthing about one HAVING to have a weakened immune system. It doesn't say that people without a weakened immune system NEVER are at risk for serious infections. It doesn't even say that ALL people with weakened immune systems acquire a serious infection. It says that people with weakened immune systems COULD BE AT RISK for serious infections.

It's a far cry from "could be at risk" to your capitalised absolute.


I guess I am being influenced by the literature which does say that. It took a few years to find one or two studies that said there is an extremely small chance of infection in immune-competent people. That small chance is not communicated to the medical profession. Even the specialists in mycology did not know that is was possible.
 
I guess I am being influenced by the literature which does say that. It took a few years to find one or two studies that said there is an extremely small chance of infection in immune-competent people. That small chance is not communicated to the medical profession. Even the specialists in mycology did not know that is was possible.
I just noticed that the source of the quote you posted was Fox News.

Nuff said.
 
Interestingly there was a question addressed on the Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast this week about whether non-ionising radiation could be harmful. Steve Novella's thoughtful and nuanced response, in a nutshell, was that we could not absolutely rule it out, but the available evidence is largely negative so it is still extremely unlikely. Basically as close to "no" as an honest scientist can say.


You do realize that in order to say that, one must go through the many studies showing harm or an undesirable effect, and discount them all. That is what ICNRIP does. Selective and biased adjudication. One discounts them as "anecdotal" and not "evidence" because of some flaw or perceived flaw in the method.

And, of course, we are talking about healthy 200 lb males in the form of a modelled lump of meat or rats. Not people who might not susceptible. The susceptible people who might suffer ill effects from the radiation cannot be differentiated because of the lack of health to start with.
 
You do realize that in order to say that, one must go through the many studies showing harm or an undesirable effect, and discount them all. That is what ICNRIP does. Selective and biased adjudication. One discounts them as "anecdotal" and not "evidence" because of some flaw or perceived flaw in the method.
They went through one particular recent study that was specifically sent to them, and found that it was not placebo controlled, had a small sample size, and was subject to a severe selection bias. The conclusion was that there was no reason to change the consensus that there is no harmful effect from non-ionising radiation based on the results of that study.
 
The second paragraph of the Wikipedia entry on histoplasmosis - Wikipedia - acknowledges that immunocompetent people can be infected.

Get better sources.


I checked my file of 2011. It appears that the wiki article has been updated. The reason I found the articles a few years later about immunocompetent infections was likely that updates were starting to appear.

I stand by my statements for the year of 2011. And acknowledge that medicine has caught up.
 
I read an article recently arguing that oxygen is as harmful as radiation. (The premise being that much of the biological injury from ionising radiation is due to the generation of reactive oxygen species. Breathing high levels of oxygen also generates reactive oxygen species causing 'radiation-like' tissue injury.) Now there are clearly issues with dosing etc. but as a speculative discussion it was interesting reminding one of how toxic oxygen is to life.


I take concentrated oxygen at night. Before I did, I checked the dosing and was surprised to find that it had to be limited in concentration. To get medical oxygen one needs a prescription, but not for the concentrate because it can only be produced at a low rate.
 
Something caused the symptoms - and they resemble cell tower symptoms. I would say that is a logical reason.
And you would be wrong, for the reasons already explained to you ad nauseum. It is entirely illogical given our current understanding of (a) the effects of non-ionising radiation and (b) human psychology.

Do we have to wait for the studies on a massive scale over many years to determine this kind of damage?
Yes.

Is it okay to do experiments on the general public, like Ciprofloxacin, where one reassesses initial assumptions?
Nobody is "doing experiments on the general public". Doctors are prescribing what, based on the best scientific evidence currently available, is the most effective treatment for whatever ails them.

Should we not be a little more proactive and slow down to assess more studies?
Not if it means denying sick people effective treatment for no good reason.

There are standards in place designed to ensure that drugs are not approved until they have been adequately tested. That does not mean that mistakes cannot be made, but being over cautious can result in people dying whilst waiting for a drug to be approved that would have saved their lives. Experts whose job it is to make such judgements agonise over them every day. What makes you think that you, a rank amateur with virtually no relevant knowledge or experience, can do better?

How many children will die if they do not have towers next to them? With vaccination, the mothers were faced with a choice of two risks. In the tower case, the choice is risk versus no risk (err on the side of caution). Somewhere two kids died within an hour of getting inoculated. The risk is not zero, but it the latter case it was likely a defective dose.

How many children will die because their parents are unable to use their cell phones to call emergency services because a tower was not built due to a bogus health scare?

You do realize that in order to say that, one must go through the many studies showing harm or an undesirable effect, and discount them all.
In order to conclude that cell towers are dangerous you have to discount many large scale, properly conducted studies which show no harm and pay attention only to the handful of much smaller less rigorous studies that cannot definitively rule it out. This is what believers in homeopathy do when they bang on about the small number of poor studies which suggest a tiny positive effect and ignore the much larger number of much better conducted studies which show no effect over and above placebo.

You need to look at all the studies and weigh all the evidence fairly, which is what scientists. Cherry picking only the ones that support what they've decided to believe is what crackpots and conspiracy theorists do.
 
Last edited:
They went through one particular recent study that was specifically sent to them, and found that it was not placebo controlled, had a small sample size, and was subject to a severe selection bias. The conclusion was that there was no reason to change the consensus that there is no harmful effect from non-ionising radiation based on the results of that study.


Do you know which study it was?
 
A double-blinded study? Notice that her symptoms are triggered by varying field - the change rather than the presence.


https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21793784

RESULTS:

In a double-blinded EMF provocation procedure specifically designed to minimize unintentional sensory cues, the subject developed temporal pain, headache, muscle twitching, and skipped heartbeats within 100 s after initiation of EMF exposure (p < .05). The symptoms were caused primarily by field transitions (off-on, on-off) rather than the presence of the field, as assessed by comparing the frequency and severity of the effects of pulsed and continuous fields in relation to sham exposure. The subject had no conscious perception of the field as judged by her inability to report its presence more often than in the sham control.

Do I have to wait for you guys to die off? :D

– A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it. – Max Planck 1858-1947
 
Last edited:
An interesting article.


https://www.thenation.com/article/h...cell-phones-are-safe-a-special-investigation/

Lack of definitive proof that a technology is harmful does not mean the technology is safe, yet the wireless industry has succeeded in selling this logical fallacy to the world. In truth, the safety of wireless technology has been an unsettled question since the industry’s earliest days. The upshot is that, over the past 30 years, billions of people around the world have been subjected to a massive public-health experiment: Use a cell phone today, find out later if it causes cancer or genetic damage.

Meanwhile, the wireless industry has obstructed a full and fair understanding of the current science, aided by government agencies that have prioritized commercial interests over human health and news organizations that have failed to inform the public about what the scientific community really thinks. In other words, this public-health experiment has been conducted without the informed consent of its subjects, even as the industry keeps its thumb on the scale.

“The absence of absolute proof does not mean the absence of risk,” Annie Sasco, the former director of epidemiology for cancer prevention at France’s National Institute of Health and Medical Research, told the attendees of the 2012 Childhood Cancer conference.

"Creative truth-telling". Is that the same as "Creative accounting".

When the Interphone conclusions were released in 2010, industry spokespeople blunted their impact by deploying what experts on lying call “creative truth-telling.” “Interphone’s conclusion of no overall increased risk of brain cancer is consistent with conclusions reached in an already large body of scientific research on this subject,” John Walls, the vice president for public affairs at the CTIA, told reporters. The wiggle word here is “overall”:

Mmmm. Now how about this paragraph.

The scientific evidence that cell phones and wireless technologies in general can cause cancer and genetic damage is not definitive, but it is abundant and has been increasing over time. Contrary to the impression that most news coverage has given the public, 90 percent of the 200 existing studies included in the National Institutes of Health’s PubMed database on the oxidative effects of wireless radiation—its tendency to cause cells to shed electrons, which can lead to cancer and other diseases—have found a significant impact, according to a survey of the scientific literature conducted by Henry Lai. Seventy-two percent of neurological studies and 64 percent of DNA studies have also found effects.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom