Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

This came up in New Scientist magazine last week:

No, mobile phones still won’t give you brain cancer

The supposed health risk from mobile phones is the story that will never die. The latest claim, branded an “inconvenient truth” by the Observer newspaper, is that new research shows they cause cancer in rats. But like all previous incarnations of this tale, the real truth is that the evidence has been overblown and there is nothing to worry about.

There is no scientific controversy here. It has been studied extensively, and the studies are extremely clear: non-ionising radiation is not harmful and does not cause cancer or other adverse health effects. End of story.
 
The WHO statement is based on a review of all the studies that have been done, it doesn't cherry pick and describe the ones that show no cause for concern to justify its conclusion the way that woo slingers cherry pick and describe the ones that might possibly show there might possibly be damage if you squint very hard to justify theirs. Asking for the studies that show no cause for concern to be cherry picked for you is a sure sign of a fundamental misunderstanding of how science works.


Fine. Where is the transparency of their review?

Where can I find paper or papers or an article where the study group ranks the studies in terms of possibly true, and then gives a considered opinion on the front-runners as to why they are considered to be unreliable?

Can you not see the difference between an unbiased review and a blanket dismissal.

I can. I have been on the wrong end of a number of legal judgments in which (right honorable, his Lordship) has simply given a decision that ignores the facts of the case and the facts of the law. In case you think I am biased, their unfair decisions do not stand when appealed.

The devil is in the detail. Just one example. Why is the VGCC study wrong?
 
This came up in New Scientist magazine last week:

No, mobile phones still won’t give you brain cancer

There is no scientific controversy here. It has been studied extensively, and the studies are extremely clear: non-ionising radiation is not harmful and does not cause cancer or other adverse health effects. End of story.


Do you think that living in a sea of non-stop microwave radiation next to a tower that pulsates and surges is totally harmless?

Any limits of the frequency or strength or combinations or pulsations?

Oh, wait. Let me check what you wrote. Yes, you do think it is harmless. End of story.
 
Do you think that living in a sea of non-stop microwave radiation next to a tower that pulsates and surges is totally harmless?


Argument from incredulity.

Any limits of the frequency...


Yes, that’s the point.

...or strength...


Stronger signals will cause more heating, but there's absolutely no reason to think that it will have different effects to heating by other means, for example from sunlight or fires.

...or combinations or pulsations?


And no plausible reason to think that these may be harmful. Your body doesn't include a radio receiver.
 
Do you think that living in a sea of non-stop microwave radiation next to a tower that pulsates and surges is totally harmless?

Any limits of the frequency or strength or combinations or pulsations?

Oh, wait. Let me check what you wrote. Yes, you do think it is harmless. End of story.
Yes, I do. It has been investigated again and again and again and again and again and again and again. And again. And every time, no link between EM fields and any kind of harm has been demonstrated.

Why is this so hard for you to grasp?
 
Yes, I do. It has been investigated again and again and again and again and again and again and again. And again. And every time, no link between EM fields and any kind of harm has been demonstrated.

Why is this so hard for you to grasp?


Because he doesn’t want a cellphone tower at the bottom of his garden.
 
Yes, I do. It has been investigated again and again and again and again and again and again and again. And again. And every time, no link between EM fields and any kind of harm has been demonstrated.

Why is this so hard for you to grasp?


No link? And you say so because the "experts" say so?

https://olis.leg.state.or.us/liz/2013I1/Downloads/CommitteeMeetingDocument/41776

Martin L. Pall
Professor Emeritus of Biochemistry and Basic Medical Sciences
Washington State University

...The 2014 Report of the Canadian Panel of Experts on Safety Code 6 accepts the ICNIRP safety standards that rest solely on avoiding heating but ignores an important literature on voltage-gated calcium channels (VGCCs) and other calcium-related effects, oxidative stress, nitric oxide and a wide range of other effects that take place at non-thermal levels.

... The Canadian Report fails to analyze thousands of studies each of which apparently falsify their position, studies widely considered to be the most important type of scientific evidence. The Report falsely claims that there is no biophysically viable mechanism by which low level effects can occur. The genotoxicity part of the Report falsifies claims of inconsistencies in the literature.
 
No link? And you say so because the "experts" say so?
If I cared to spend the time, which I don't, I could provide a hundred links to peer-reviewed papers published in reputable high impact journals. But there's not much point, because you are clinging to your false belief with ideologically unshakable fervour. There's no point. You're not interested.
 
No link? And you say so because the "experts" say so?

You really should read beyond the abstract. The body of the paper begins,

Calcium provides an essential role in cell function and homeostasis and serves as a critical gatekeeper of membrane integrity and metabolism. A recent review (1), noted that in 2 dozen studies, calcium channel blocking drugs block a wide range of electromagnetic field (EMF) effects on cells and organisms by affecting voltage-gated calcium channels (VGCCs which are also known as voltageoperated, voltage-dependent or voltage-regulated calcium channels). Because measured effects were significantly lowered by calcium channel blocking drugs, this indicates that activation of these channels accounts, at least in part, for the wide-ranging impacts of EMF effects (1). In most but not all cases, L-type VGCCs were primarily involved. Such VGCC activation is thought to act mainly by increasing intracellular calcium ([Ca2+]i). Other considerations also support VGCCs as a major EMF target, accounting for numerous biological impacts of microwave exposures (2,3) at levels not able to produce substantial changes in temperature.

and if you then look at footnote (1-3) you find,

1. Pall ML. Electromagnetic fields act via activation of voltage-gated calcium channels to produce beneficial or adverse effects. J Cell Mol Med (2013) 17: 958-65.
2. Pall ML. Electromagnetic field activation of voltage-gated calcium channels:role in therapeutic effects. Electromagn Biol Med (2014) Apr 8. [Epub ahead of
print]
3. Pall ML. Microwave electromagnetic fields act by activating voltage-gated calcium channels: why the current international safety standards do not predict biological hazard. Recent Res Devel Cell Biol (2014) 7: in press.

Referencing yourself is not exactly a crime, but if an author can't find anybody else to cite to support a claim, this suggests that the author's position is, shall we say, idiosyncratic. Certainly this degree of self-referencing should raise a red flag.
 
Last edited:
If I cared to spend the time, which I don't, I could provide a hundred links to peer-reviewed papers published in reputable high impact journals. But there's not much point, because you are clinging to your false belief with ideologically unshakable fervour. There's no point. You're not interested.
If he was interested he would use Google Scholar to find them himself. But then if he knew how to use Google Scholar he wouldn't be under the impression that there are "thousands" of studies which suggest possible harm when there are actually only a handful.
 
Electromagnetic Fields at Work Show No Brain Tumor Risk

A new study takes a close look at occupational exposure or electromagnetic fields (EMF), specifically radiofrequency (RF) and intermediate frequency (IF) EMF, and also show no association. The researchers individually rated workers by their exposure to radio frequency and intermediate frequency EMF, and compared 4,000 cases of either meningioma or glioma (the two most common types of brain tumor) and 5,000 controls. They found:

Overall, around 10% of study participants were exposed to RF while only 1% were exposed to IF-EMF. There was no clear evidence for a positive association between RF or IF-EMF and the brain tumors studied, with most results showing either no association or odds ratios (ORs) below 1.0. The largest adjusted ORs were obtained for cumulative exposure to RF magnetic fields (as A/m-years) in the highest exposed category (≥90th percentile) for the most recent exposure time window (1–4 years before the diagnosis or reference date) for both glioma, OR = 1.62 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.86, 3.01) and meningioma (OR = 1.52, 95% CI: 0.65, 3.55).​
 
You really should read beyond the abstract. The body of the paper begins,



and if you then look at footnote (1-3) you find,



Referencing yourself is not exactly a crime, but if an author can't find anybody else to cite to support a claim, this suggests that the author's position is, shall we say, idiosyncratic. Certainly this degree of self-referencing should raise a red flag.


I had read the paper and had seen the references. But no harm in pointing them out.

Who better to challenge the experts "certain" view than "real" expert who knows not only the science but the ways in which papers can be reviewed.
 
Quite busy to really give answers now but just an update on the shower shock.

Once more a series of coincidences which I will not bore you with. They helped me find the problem in a matter of minutes with no equipment.

A wire feeding a light on our metal carport had touched the rusted metal and caused the earth circuit in the apartment to "go live". The drain was the real earth/ground potential. Only that circuit did not go through an earth leakage device. I will put one in. The electrician (the professional everyone trusts) could not be bothered to add a separate box to house another one like he should have. Huh, only a light circuit he probably thought.

Why did the earth go up as much as 52 volts ac? Because here in SA they steal the copper wires. Earth and neutral are the easiest. They take an underground cable, strip off the outer plastic, cut off the steel armor and sell that for scrap, then separate out the neutral copper wire, cut it and sell that.

Many places have no earthing and no neutral for quite a while.

It is possible that the illegal tower circuit cut the armor (the earth) and did not bother to connect one side to the other.
 
PartSkeptic appears to have a new ally:

The symptoms experienced by the Cuba patients match symptoms in other people who are “electrosensitive,” according to her analysis, which relies on the JAMA study and news reports.
Scientists and doctors zap theory that microwave weapon injured Cuba diplomats (Washington Post, Sep. 6, 2018)


I have already mentioned and quoted from the Washington Post article a couple of times in the thread Alien Attack? Mass Hysteria? Conspiracy?/US may close Cuba Embassy over 'health attacks'

It's interesting to see the kind of allies that the fans of the alleged microwave attacks on U.S. American embassy employees attract ...
 
There are more details from the U.S. scientist Beatrice Golomb, MD, PhD, professor of medicine at University of California, San Diego School of Medicine, who claims that they symptoms of the U.S. diplomats are similar to "what has been reported for persons affected by RF/MW radiation." :)

Unfortunately, I'm not sure that politicians and people in general have as good an understanding of what this implies as most skeptics probably do ...
 
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...avana-could-have-been-crickets-say-scientists

The mysterious wave of illness fuelled speculation that the staff had been targeted by an acoustic weapon. It was an explanation that appeared to gain weight when an audio recording of a persistent, high-pitched drone made by US personnel in Cuba was released to the Associated Press.

But a fresh analysis of the audio recording has revealed what scientists in the UK and the US now believe is the true source of the piercing din: it is the song of the Indies short-tailed cricket, known formally as Anurogryllus celerinictus.
 
Anyone for mass hysteria, fuelled by tension and stress, with layers of media nonsense on top?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom