Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

If you can point me to the physics and the scientific papers that support your comparison, then maybe I will take you seriously and start investigating light bulbs.
You've missed Mojo's point completely. The electromagnetic spectrum goes from the highest frequency/most energetic end (gamma rays), down through X rays, ultra violet, visible light, infra red, microwaves and finally radio waves which are the lowest frequency/least energetic. Gamma rays are the most damaging to tissue, radio waves the least damaging (zero damage). Compare where the ones you're so concerned about are on the spectrum to where light is and you might understand why Mojo is asking what steps you are taking to shield yourself from visible light.

ETA: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_spectrum
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, exactly what loosely bound molecules are you talking about?


This is now a good question.

I took it from a table of binding energies.

To follow up, there are loosely bound water molecules which play an important part in humans. Some of the loosely bound molecules are the ones forming a "skin" on the outside of membranes to hydrate them.

They are more than just water molecules and regulate various processes.

One source gave a figure of 2-30 kJ/mol (which is about 2-20 milli eV).

See
http://www.exobiologie.fr/index.php...re-and-function-of-biological-macromolecules/

and

https://www.researchgate.net/public...gical_macromolecules_and_age-related_diseases

Many of the effects of radiation on various systems of molecules are dependent on the frequency as well as the magnitude.
 
You've missed Mojo's point completely. The electromagnetic spectrum goes from the highest frequency/most energetic end (gamma rays), down through X rays, ultra violet, visible light, infra red, microwaves and finally radio waves which are the lowest frequency/least energetic. Gamma rays are the most damaging to tissue, radio waves the least damaging. Compare where the ones you're so concerned about are on the spectrum to where light is and you might understand why Mojo is asking what steps you are taking to shield yourself from visible light.


And you think I am not very aware of this? Could you not tell from the questions I asked him?

You are limiting yourself to the most obvious and simplistic effects of radiation, and ignoring absorption, penetration, resonance, electrical fields, power densities, pulsation, interference effects and many more. You show little understanding of biological processes and their complexity. You put humans on the complexity level of machines and computers.

Read my recent posts, especially the one just before this.

If one put a little bit of sand in the oil of a car and checked it after a month there would be almost no measurable effect. But its lifespan would be noticeably decreased. You could contribute the decreased lifespan to poor assembly and poor materials used at the start, but we all know that the sand slowly grinds the parts down.
 
Notice - just a bit of conspiracy humor. :) I am not serious at all.

If the Russians had won their World Cup soccer match against Croatia one could maybe say that the Russians knew that microwaves could be configured to cause mild concussive brain trauma and had tested it on the Americans at the consulates to see at what levels it could be detected, and if microwaves would be blamed as the cause.

We are blaming the Russians for the UK poisonings and for affecting the US elections, so what is wrong with this bit of imaginative scheming? Microwaving the opposing teams. :jaw-dropp

Once more - do not take me seriously at all. The Russians did very well, and are feeling justifiably proud of their team. The home field advantage is a powerful psychological booster. They would never risk anything that would possibly tarnish their hosting of such a world event.

And of course, no one believes microwave radiation can have such effects, now do they? :D

When South Africa won a rugby world cup here in Johannesburg the Kiwis raised the excuse that they had been given "bad food" deliberately and were suffering from the ill effects. :covereyes
 
And of course, no one believes microwave radiation can have such effects, now do they? :D


:)
Well, I wouldn't recommend putting your head (or your poodle) in a microwave oven, but now it seems that the U.S. diplomats may not suffer from a "concussion-like syndrome" after all. See my latest post in the US-may-close-Cuba-Embassy-over-'health-attacks' thread. A letter in the Journal of Neurology from two neuroscientists criticizes the study published in JAMA by doctors at the University of Pennsylvania as "seriously flawed".
 
:)
Well, I wouldn't recommend putting your head (or your poodle) in a microwave oven, but now it seems that the U.S. diplomats may not suffer from a "concussion-like syndrome" after all. See my latest post in the US-may-close-Cuba-Embassy-over-'health-attacks' thread. A letter in the Journal of Neurology from two neuroscientists criticizes the study published in JAMA by doctors at the University of Pennsylvania as "seriously flawed".


Is that what the article said?

I thought it just said that the test was too broad and unscientific to establish anything. That does not mean that there were no "Sonic-like" impairments to the sufferers or that they did not suffer concussion-like syndrome.

There was a test in the UK that was run using emf-hyper-sensitive individuals. They got a small group together and started tests. A number left the group because of the discomfort.

The conclusion was that there was no verifiable evidence that such people actually suffered. Why? Because the sample was deemed too small. That detail was not obvious, and the test is cited as "proof" of lack of risk.

As for microwave explosions. True story. A Kiwi engineer microwaved three eggs. He put them in a bowl of water thinking that the water would stop the eggs from overheating. It did not. The fatty proteins preferentially absorbed the microwaves. All three exploded simultaneously, blowing the door open and spraying a fine yellow mist across the room. Luckily, none of us were in the room at the time. It would have made a great slow motion video.
 
This is now a good question.

I took it from a table of binding energies.

To follow up, there are loosely bound water molecules which play an important part in humans. Some of the loosely bound molecules are the ones forming a "skin" on the outside of membranes to hydrate them.

They are more than just water molecules and regulate various processes.

One source gave a figure of 2-30 kJ/mol (which is about 2-20 milli eV).

See
http://www.exobiologie.fr/index.php...re-and-function-of-biological-macromolecules/

and

https://www.researchgate.net/public...gical_macromolecules_and_age-related_diseases


Hydrogen bonding, then.

Many of the effects of radiation on various systems of molecules are dependent on the frequency as well as the magnitude.


Yes, that’s what we’ve been telling you.
 
There was a test in the UK that was run using emf-hyper-sensitive individuals. They got a small group together and started tests. A number left the group because of the discomfort.

The conclusion was that there was no verifiable evidence that such people actually suffered. Why? Because the sample was deemed too small. That detail was not obvious, and the test is cited as "proof" of lack of risk.


Do you have a reference for where this “test” was reported?

As for microwave explosions. True story. A Kiwi engineer microwaved three eggs. He put them in a bowl of water thinking that the water would stop the eggs from overheating. It did not. The fatty proteins preferentially absorbed the microwaves. All three exploded simultaneously, blowing the door open and spraying a fine yellow mist across the room. Luckily, none of us were in the room at the time. It would have made a great slow motion video.


What do you think this anecdote shows? We already know that microwave ovens work.
 
Last edited:
As for microwave explosions. True story. A Kiwi engineer microwaved three eggs. He put them in a bowl of water thinking that the water would stop the eggs from overheating. It did not.
Was this really an engineer? Boiling water can carry away heat because it evaporates, but the eggs are heated from inside so the water cannot stop the heat source from affecting the eggs. The experiment sounds like complete idiocy for me.
 
A couple of months ago when I was on vacation in Las Palmas, I used a microwave oven to boil eggs, one at a time. First I used it to make the water boil in a cup, then I put the egg in and turned the microwave oven on again.
The soft-boiled eggs were fine, but maybe I was just lucky, so I won't recommend it as method in general. I don't have much experience with microwave ovens! :)
 
Is that what the article said?


Yes, that is what the article said:

... it seems that the U.S. diplomats may not suffer from a "concussion-like syndrome" after all. See my latest post in the US-may-close-Cuba-Embassy-over-'health-attacks' thread. A letter in the Journal of Neurology from two neuroscientists criticizes the study published in JAMA by doctors at the University of Pennsylvania as "seriously flawed".


I have highlighted the may for you.

I thought it just said that the test was too broad and unscientific to establish anything. That does not mean that there were no "Sonic-like" impairments to the sufferers or that they did not suffer concussion-like syndrome.


Exactly. It also doesn't mean that there actually were any ""Sonic-like" impairments to the sufferers" or that they actually did "suffer concussion-like syndrome." So there's no reason to think that their suffering was organic rather than psychogenic.
 
A couple of months ago when I was on vacation in Las Palmas, I used a microwave oven to boil eggs, one at a time. First I used it to make the water boil in a cup, then I put the egg in and turned the microwave oven on again.
The soft-boiled eggs were fine, but maybe I was just lucky, so I won't recommend it as method in general. I don't have much experience with microwave ovens! :)
The problem is the rigid egg shell. I once had a couple of largish egg cups intended for holding the contents of an egg for boiling in a microwave oven. The soft-boiled eggs were OK, but there is some romanticism, or pizzazz lost with the shape. For some reason the hard-boiled variety also lacked a bit of taste.
 
What do you think this anecdote shows? We already know that microwave ovens work.


That sometimes the logic used sounds logical but the actual effects can show that something was overlooked.

The guy was a software engineer. Code does not explode. ;)

One site: Lightly prick the bottom of the egg with a safety pin or thumbtack (IMPORTANT or the egg will explode). Place the egg into the bowl of hot water, cover with a plate, and microwave at 50% power for 4 minutes. If you like a runnier yolk, remove and peel the egg
 
Yes, that is what the article said:

I have highlighted the may for you.

Exactly. It also doesn't mean that there actually were any ""Sonic-like" impairments to the sufferers" or that they actually did "suffer concussion-like syndrome." So there's no reason to think that their suffering was organic rather than psychogenic.


That is what I said. It does not rule out physical damage.


IF damage to a person's brain DOES occur, it would seem that it is not easy to measure or detect.

Let us say that a kid grows up next to a tower and is found to have autism. Can you positively rule out the tower as a possible cause?

Mothers say they would rather not take a chance. They know the agencies and government have both lied, and been wrong, a number of times in the past. Money, money, money.
 
That is what I said. It does not rule out physical damage.
It gives no good reason to suspect it either.

IF damage to a person's brain DOES occur, it would seem that it is not easy to measure or detect.
If damage cannot be measured or detected there is no damage.

Let us say that a kid grows up next to a tower and is found to have autism. Can you positively rule out the tower as a possible cause?
If multiple studies show that kids who grow up next to a tower are no more likely to be autistic than children who don't then yes, you certainly can. This is how the MMR vaccine was ruled out as a cause of autism.

Mothers say they would rather not take a chance. They know the agencies and government have both lied, and been wrong, a number of times in the past. Money, money, money.
You know that children have died because their mothers were persuaded by bogus health scares to "not take the chance" of getting them vaccinated?
 
Pixel42 has already answered you, PartSkeptic, but let me comment on this one:

Money, money, money.


The question of profits should make you suspicious when big business claims that something is safe. Two fairly well-known examples:

Tobacco kills more than 7 million people each year.
WHO
In 1994, it was estimated that trans fats caused 20,000 deaths annually in the United States from heart disease.
Wikipedia


And these links from another thread show my own skepticism of Big Pharma:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12282394#post12282394
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12282609#post12282609
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12284406#post12284406

But don't forget that money, money, money also plays an important role in the world of alternative medicine. I can recommend Bob Goldacre's book Bad Science, which criticizes both Big Pharma and Big Alt. Med.
 
The problem is the rigid egg shell. I once had a couple of largish egg cups intended for holding the contents of an egg for boiling in a microwave oven. The soft-boiled eggs were OK, but there is some romanticism, or pizzazz lost with the shape. For some reason the hard-boiled variety also lacked a bit of taste.


Double blind taste test required.

Would they have tasted different if you had no idea they were cooked in a microwave? Could you tell the difference if you didn't know which was which?
 
You're right, of course. Steen should have somebody set him up for a double-blind test.
However, I have heard people claim that a casserole that got too spicy will become edible if you reheat it in a microwave oven because it loses some of the flavours, but I bet they didn't do a double-blind test.
From experience, I know that reheating a croissant in a microwave oven is not as good as doing it in an oven, but that is a question of texture, not of taste: It is less crispy when it is heated from the inside out instead of the other way. And no, I also never did a double-blinded test of it, but in this case the difference is very obvious. And, of course, very few people eat the shell of a hard-boiled egg! :)
And there's this: Science: Why microwave cooking fails the taste test (New Scientist, Jan. 18, 1992)
 
Is that what the article said?
As for microwave explosions. True story. A Kiwi engineer microwaved three eggs. He put them in a bowl of water thinking that the water would stop the eggs from overheating. It did not. The fatty proteins preferentially absorbed the microwaves. All three exploded simultaneously, blowing the door open and spraying a fine yellow mist across the room. Luckily, none of us were in the room at the time. It would have made a great slow motion video.

What were you microwaving, emu eggs????
let me just say I doubt the accuracy of this statement
(I love my eggs and usually microwave them, putting them in a sealed container is always a good idea as yes they will explode, and after having to disassemble the microwave as egg had penetrated the light fitting shield and goes a bit pongy after a day or two of ozzie heat- I now have special containers that have a small vent in the top to stop the top blowing off)
Have never seen one explode hard enough to break the door latches open and cover an entire room though
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom