My favourite homoeopathic remedies

You have been continuously dodging a very simple question. Countries don't matter, much, these days- you are using the "World" Wide Web. What would you tell a customer who asks this question- you are not interested? How long would it take you to come up with an answer? In the USA dotors don't say "I am sorry; but we don't see enough malaria (cholera, whatever) to help you."

You are an unartful dodger.

I have never tried to dodge this question .Right in the beginning i have said that I do not know the accurate answer to this question.As far as I know till date no major studies have been done on this issue.In the meantime if I do recieve a patient with this question I will ask him not to let the medicines pass through a scanner or not to rely on medicines passed through a scanner as the probability of their being deactivated is pretty high.Regarding the time limit for an answer to this question I would put it at around 3 years.
 
The question isn't whether or not the remedies are inactivated by the scanners. The question is: why is there disagreement between homoeopaths about this? If the remedies have any detectable effect, it should be perfectly simple to test whether the effect is still present after they've been through a scanner. Why have homoeopaths been unable to resolve this one way or the other?

The disagreement has been because of the slower pace of studies which in turn has ben due to a lack of funds.Most studies to date have been carried out with the personal funds of the physicians themselves and as such research has been more concentrated on matters which had more significance in practice ,the other less significant issues had to be postponed till more funds are available.I also do not think that disagreement is bad for any Science topics need to be debated and opposition should continue till the matter is properly solved.
 
The disagreement has been because of the slower pace of studies which in turn has ben due to a lack of funds.Most studies to date have been carried out with the personal funds of the physicians themselves and as such research has been more concentrated on matters which had more significance in practice ,the other less significant issues had to be postponed till more funds are available.


Given, for example, the sort of proving symptoms that homoeopaths claim to observe, it should be a really simple test to run. And there seemed to be no shortage of funds when, for example, a group in Bristol wanted to run a 6-year outpatient study which had no control group and therefore was not capable of producing results that were useful other than as propaganda. So much for research being "more concentrated on matters which had more significance in practice".
 
Most studies to date have been carried out with the personal funds of the physicians themselves and as such research has been more concentrated on matters which had more significance in practice ,the other less significant issues had to be postponed till more funds are available.

What could have "more significance in practice" than whether or not the remedies work?
 
... if I do receive a patient with this question I will ask him not to let the medicines pass through a scanner or not to rely on medicines passed through a scanner as the probability of their being deactivated is pretty high.

So it is better if the patient passes the medicine through the magnetic scanner instead of the x-ray scanner at the airport?
 
I have never tried to dodge this question .Right in the beginning i have said that I do not know the accurate answer to this question.As far as I know till date no major studies have been done on this issue.In the meantime if I do recieve a patient with this question I will ask him not to let the medicines pass through a scanner or not to rely on medicines passed through a scanner as the probability of their being deactivated is pretty high.Regarding the time limit for an answer to this question I would put it at around 3 years.

Why do you say that the probability is high, though, if the answer is so recondite that it will take three years to test it? Sorry if my question seems obtuse, but why can't you just test this idea, at least to your own satisfaction, if not to that of the rest of the scientific world? The only reason I can think that this would be a difficult matter to address is if the difference between effectiveness and ineffectiveness in homeopathy is itself impossible to measure honestly. If that is not the case, then a borrowed X ray machine (perhaps a cooperative chiropracter could be enlisted) and a handful of homeopathic headache remedies ought to give you your answer in whatever time it takes to find and treat a handful of patients with headaches.
 
So it is better if the patient passes the medicine through the magnetic scanner instead of the x-ray scanner at the airport?


Ouch! Wish I'd thought of that one!

Why will the "in all probability" be inactivated? On what evidence was that statement based?

How do you distinguish an active from an inactivated remedy?

Rolfe.
 
It seems like Cyril W. Smith thinks that something maybe a bit like proton NMR is going on:

My criticism of homeopathic trials in general is that there is no quality control. In a box of double-blinded vials of verum and placebo, the placebo will be potentized by proximity or by impact; if placed in a steel cupboard or filing cabinet, everything will be erased—all will become placebos. A homeopathic potency needs the presence of the Earth’s magnetic field for permanence.

So it seems like remedies are safer going through the x-ray machine than they are going through the magnetic scanner.

http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089/acm.2007.0585
http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089/107555304322848977

(blog)
 
My criticism of homeopathic trials in general is that there is no quality control. In a box of double-blinded vials of verum and placebo, the placebo will be potentized by proximity or by impact; if placed in a steel cupboard or filing cabinet, everything will be erased—all will become placebos. A homeopathic potency needs the presence of the Earth’s magnetic field for permanence.


Wow. Just.... wow.

I don't suppose there's any way at all of asking this guy what basis he has for any of these statements?

Rolfe.
 
I think we should appreciate the polite tone of drsabbylewis, and not keep pounding on some particular line which has been answered repeatedly, even if we find the answer to be unsatisfactory. Drsabbylewis has admitted to not knowing whether remedies are hurt by x-rays or not, and to not knowing why this is not known to the homeopathic community. Whether we find this lack of knowledge lamentable or not, it is what it is, and there is no reason to keep whipping a lifeless horse.

Instead, why don't we invite drsabbylewis to elaborate on how he/she finds homeopathy to "have some substance", as indicated in his/her first post in this thread.

Then we might have some fruitful discussions about that "substance".

Hans
 
Drsabbylewis,

shpalman has bought us the startling news that according to some homoeopaths, "a homeopathic potency needs the presence of the Earth’s magnetic field for permanence", and that homoeopathic remedies "if placed in a steel cupboard or filing cabinet, everything will be erased—all will become placebos."

Surely this is must be an issue in your country, too: Steel cabinets may not be be common, but homoeopaths must regard it as crucial to determine if a steel cabinet or a steel countainer ruins all their remedies.

Do you think that homoeopaths will investigate this claim, and how do you propose it can be tested if the claim is true?
 
Wow. Just.... wow.

I don't suppose there's any way at all of asking this guy what basis he has for any of these statements?

Rolfe.
What makes you think he has any basis for them? ;)

Evidently, they are just something he dreamed up to explain why homeopathy cannot be tested in a controlled test.

... At least his explanation is quite concrete (if nonsensical), unlike certain others I have discussed this subject with.:p

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom