My favourite homoeopathic remedies

How would you go about finding out? In these days of international travel and airport security, surely this is an important matter?
 
I really don't see the effects in terms of symptoms.These have come more from the head of the person who has put them on the net


So you don't think these are actual proving symptoms? Perhaps you could take that up with her over at otherhealth, where she's currently complaining about this forum attacking homoeopathy, and about "negative opinions" of homoeopathy generally. I doubt that she'd take much notice of anything said by a "skeptic".
 
How would you go about finding out? In these days of international travel and airport security, surely this is an important matter?
I have no intention of finding out in the near future.The medicines that I use in my clinic are manufactured locally and do not pass thru any X-ray scanner.I may think about it at some time when it becomes significant.
 
So you don't think these are actual proving symptoms? Perhaps you could take that up with her over at otherhealth, where she's currently about this forum attacking homoeopathy, and about "negative opinions" of homoeopathy generally. I doubt that she'd take much notice of anything said by a "skeptic".
I intend to do that
 
A question I tried to ask her, before she left the badscience.net forums[/url] was: at what point in the history of homeopathy did people start proving with homeopathic doses?
I do not know exactly at what point he took to proving with dilutions but I have the fifth and the sixth edition of the Organon. In the fifth edition he advises the initiation of the proving at the thirtieth dilution and gradually reducing the dilutions till the appearance of symptoms.Secondly I wish to say that the term Homoeopathic dose means a medicine chosen which is similar to that of the disease, it does not mean a dilution which probably you are suggesting
 
I have no intention of finding out in the near future.The medicines that I use in my clinic are manufactured locally and do not pass thru any X-ray scanner.I may think about it at some time when it becomes significant.
OK, so none of your patients take their remedies with them through airport x-ray scanners. But I am sure you accept that this happens, and that it is important for the patients to know if their remedies are invalidated.

How do you think this could be tested?
 
I think we were discussing provings how did this topic change suddenly .Regarding the X-ray part I have frankly not given much thought to it as it hardly affects me .Hardly four or five patients travel by air every year and these patients are always advised to consult a local physician in case they fall sick, so at this moment it is hardly of much importance.
 
Actually, we were discussing our favourite homoeopathic remedies. And we are concerned if they would stop working if put through a scanner.

Now, the question for you - as the resident homoeopath of this thread - is how would homoeopaths go about testing this? It is not important if your own patients do not travel by air; it is an important question for homoeopaths in general because lots and lots of homoeopath patients travel by air in the developed world. Some homoeopaths claim that X-ray scanners destroy the remedy, and other claim that there is no effect on the remedy. How come that homoeopath researchers have not performed any test to see what is right? Surely, homoeopaths do perform research, hmm?
 
I do not know exactly at what point he took to proving with dilutions but I have the fifth and the sixth edition of the Organon. In the fifth edition he advises the initiation of the proving at the thirtieth dilution and gradually reducing the dilutions till the appearance of symptoms.Secondly I wish to say that the term Homoeopathic dose means a medicine chosen which is similar to that of the disease, it does not mean a dilution which probably you are suggesting

Sorry, I wished to find an economical way to say "a dose of substance diluted well past the Avogadro limit such as is commonly used in homeopathic therapy."

Thanks for your reply.
 
One classified black, male, sea horse, from the Indian Ocean, was sent to Michael Quinn at Hahnemann Pharmacy to be potentized.

Whatever that means, it doesn't sound good for the seahorse. Does PETA know about this?

Historically, I believe there were valid reasons for taking homeopathic cures: since they were essentially just water, at least they weren't going to actively harm you, as opposed to the then mainstream medicines. Mercury, anyone?
 
Actually, we were discussing our favourite homoeopathic remedies. And we are concerned if they would stop working if put through a scanner.

Now, the question for you - as the resident homoeopath of this thread - is how would homoeopaths go about testing this? It is not important if your own patients do not travel by air; it is an important question for homoeopaths in general because lots and lots of homoeopath patients travel by air in the developed world. Some homoeopaths claim that X-ray scanners destroy the remedy, and other claim that there is no effect on the remedy. How come that homoeopath researchers have not performed any test to see what is right? Surely, homoeopaths do perform research, hmm?

Well the easiest way to test such a thing would be to conduct a proving of that substance before and after passing through a scanner
 
I have no intention of finding out in the near future.The medicines that I use in my clinic are manufactured locally and do not pass thru any X-ray scanner.I may think about it at some time when it becomes significant.

I find your closed-mindedness and blithe disregard of such a potential problem to be quite disconcerting.

Let's posit a parallel diaglogue with a proper doctor.

"Doctor, I've been told that airport Xray scanners will inactivate my insulin"

"I only work with diabetic patients who don't travel. Also I really don't care whether such a thing happens. Why should I be bothered if it does and some dumb-schmuck of a patient goes into a coma because we doctors can't be bothered to find out whether this happens or not. Now kindly leave my office I do not wish to be disturbed by awkward questions"

I think any citizen having such a conversation reported to them would rightly be outraged.

But that's the joy of homeopathy. You can earn a living free from any obligation to show that your sugar and water do what they are supposed to do. It really is a quite excellent scam.
 
p.s. Isn't it amazing what a deeply incurious bunch homeopaths turn out to be given their self-proclaimed status as iconoclasts and free-thinkers.

In truth I have never met a more dogmatic and narrow-minded group of people outside the world of religious fundamentalism. Which, demands, yet again the obvious inference that homeopathy really is nothing more than an incoherent and wilfully blinkered form of religion.
 
Well the easiest way to test such a thing would be to conduct a proving of that substance before and after passing through a scanner
Excellent!

Why do you think that this simple test has not been performed long ago?
 
I find your closed-mindedness and blithe disregard of such a potential problem to be quite disconcerting.

Let's posit a parallel diaglogue with a proper doctor.

"Doctor, I've been told that airport Xray scanners will inactivate my insulin"

"I only work with diabetic patients who don't travel. Also I really don't care whether such a thing happens. Why should I be bothered if it does and some dumb-schmuck of a patient goes into a coma because we doctors can't be bothered to find out whether this happens or not. Now kindly leave my office I do not wish to be disturbed by awkward questions"

I think any citizen having such a conversation reported to them would rightly be outraged.

But that's the joy of homeopathy. You can earn a living free from any obligation to show that your sugar and water do what they are supposed to do. It really is a quite excellent scam.
You are exaggerating this, all that I said was that air travel is not frequently used in our country. It is mostly used only when a person is traveling out of the country.Such trips are for long durations and the patient always has to be advised to consult a local physician in case of ill-health, so the question of any of my patient asking this question in the near future is pretty remote.I assure you by the time this question becomes significant to me I will surely have the answer to it,till that time I do not wish to give an answer about which I am not sure.To tell you frankly I became aware of this issue only when you asked me about it and frankly I thank you for it.
 
Excellent!

Why do you think that this simple test has not been performed long ago?
I do not know why this was not done but from our side the only thing that I can say is that the resources available to us are limited and the type and scale of research that the allopaths can take up will be impossible for us to duplicate and therefore at least our group in Mumbai would intend to take up research that would be more relevant to us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom