My favourite homoeopathic remedies

I wish to say that there is some substance in this system ....


No, there really isn't!

I would caution you against assuming that anyone here is unfamiliar with the homoeopathic literature, or the strengths and weaknesses of its claims. If you intend to try to demonstrate that the remedies have any physiological effect over and above what one would expect of the carrier material, be prepared for some well-informed argument.

Rolfe.
 
You guys just reminded me:
I haven't taken my homeopathic remedy in a week!
I'm gonna overdose!
(call a doctor)
 
I agree with the fact that there is a lot of stupidity going on in the name of Homoeopathy but I request you all not to get carried away with all this stupidity. I wish to say that there is some substance in this system and it would be advisable not to get carried away just because there are people who are interested in making a fast buck or easy publicity.

From what I've seen berlin wall has some followers.

These gutys have always appeared to be serious:

http://www.tanasen.com/Forum/default.asp

And are pretty pro non standard homeopathic forumaltions and remedy machines.
 
You guys just reminded me:
I haven't taken my homeopathic remedy in a week!
I'm gonna overdose!
(call a doctor)
This has already been done many times, including a few well-published "mass suicides by homeopathic sleeping pill".

Aka: sugar highs.
 
let me explain

No, there really isn't!

I would caution you against assuming that anyone here is unfamiliar with the homoeopathic literature, or the strengths and weaknesses of its claims. If you intend to try to demonstrate that the remedies have any physiological effect over and above what one would expect of the carrier material, be prepared for some well-informed argument.

Rolfe.
I have been reading posts in this forum for some time and I know that you people do have a good knowledge about Homoeopathy . The only thing that I want to say you are clubbing everyone together.Like if someone is just going to prove the Berlin wall it cannot reflect on the entire system.The remedies mentioned above were never heard by me or any of my colleagues and we have been practicing for the past ten years.I understand the scientific approach that you take and I firmly believe that Homoeopathy stands upto it.There certainly are deficiencies but the general philosophy is not something that is illogical.
 
I have been reading posts in this forum for some time and I know that you people do have a good knowledge about Homoeopathy . The only thing that I want to say you are clubbing everyone together.Like if someone is just going to prove the Berlin wall it cannot reflect on the entire system.The remedies mentioned above were never heard by me or any of my colleagues and we have been practicing for the past ten years.I understand the scientific approach that you take and I firmly believe that Homoeopathy stands upto it.There certainly are deficiencies but the general philosophy is not something that is illogical.

The generaly philosophy of most forms of homeopathy would have not problem with berlin wall as a remedy. It has been through a proveing what more do you want?
 
I agree with the fact that there is a lot of stupidity going on in the name of Homoeopathy but I request you all not to get carried away with all this stupidity. I wish to say that there is some substance in this system and it would be advisable not to get carried away just because there are people who are interested in making a fast buck or easy publicity.

If there is substance in the system itself, can you tell us what the failings of the homeopathic provings cited here were, in homeopathic terms? What homeopathic principles did they violate? What did they do wrong that is wrong in homeopathy, to disqualify them from being legitimate in the context of homeopathy? If you cannot find a fault in the provings within the contextual rules of homeopathy, I think it's fair to question the substance of the system itself.
 
I have been reading posts in this forum for some time and I know that you people do have a good knowledge about Homoeopathy . The only thing that I want to say you are clubbing everyone together.Like if someone is just going to prove the Berlin wall it cannot reflect on the entire system.The remedies mentioned above were never heard by me or any of my colleagues and we have been practicing for the past ten years.I understand the scientific approach that you take and I firmly believe that Homoeopathy stands upto it.There certainly are deficiencies but the general philosophy is not something that is illogical.


Are you suggesting that the remedies mentioned in this thread (e.g. the thunderstorm one) do not actually have the effects claimed?
 
Last edited:
I have been reading posts in this forum for some time and I know that you people do have a good knowledge about Homoeopathy . The only thing that I want to say you are clubbing everyone together.Like if someone is just going to prove the Berlin wall it cannot reflect on the entire system.The remedies mentioned above were never heard by me or any of my colleagues and we have been practicing for the past ten years.I understand the scientific approach that you take and I firmly believe that Homoeopathy stands upto it.There certainly are deficiencies but the general philosophy is not something that is illogical.

I do hope you are not going to be another fly-by-night homeopath who runs at the first sign of a tricky question that highlights the internal inconsistencies in their belief system.

Try answering geni, bruto and Mojo's questions. There are of course plenty more, but start with those.

Over to you.
 
No, I can't resist.

drsabbylewis, do airport X-ray scanners inactivate remedies? Yes or no. Give the reasons for your answer.
 
I would like to see a remedy made on STEAM. I can barely figure out what it might be good for! :boggled:
 
The generaly philosophy of most forms of homeopathy would have not problem with berlin wall as a remedy. It has been through a proveing what more do you want?
I read the proving of the berlin wall.To begin with a proving is only a collection of symptoms that are obtained when a specific drug is given to a healthy person,I don't understand how you can get a symptom of Those who suffer from family strife and oppression, often from childhood.This is an opinion of the person who conducted the proving( the practitioner) and not that of the prover(i.e. the person who took the drug.The remaining symptoms listed are also on the same lines. I hardly see a symptom that can qualify as a true symptom.
 
Are you suggesting that the remedies mentioned in this thread (e.g. the thunderstorm one) do not actually have the effects claimed?
I really don't see the effects in terms of symptoms.These have come more from the head of the person who has put them on the net
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom