My favourite homoeopathic remedies

I do not know why this was not done but from our side the only thing that I can say is that the resources available to us are limited and the type and scale of research that the allopaths can take up will be impossible for us to duplicate and therefore at least our group in Mumbai would intend to take up research that would be more relevant to us.

Does the government of Mumbai support homeopathy?
 
You are exaggerating this, all that I said was that air travel is not frequently used in our country. It is mostly used only when a person is traveling out of the country.Such trips are for long durations and the patient always has to be advised to consult a local physician in case of ill-health, so the question of any of my patient asking this question in the near future is pretty remote.I assure you by the time this question becomes significant to me I will surely have the answer to it,till that time I do not wish to give an answer about which I am not sure.To tell you frankly I became aware of this issue only when you asked me about it and frankly I thank you for it.

And yet we are often invited of share in horror at conventional medicine's allegedly poor handling of small risks posed by its drugs.

Like all other homeopaths I have met, you seem to lack either the intellectual tools or the basic curiosity to see that there is a problem and also to see that there is a very simple solution.
 
Mumbai is what we call Bombay in India, is it not? I think homeopathy is pretty well established in India and enjoys some government support.

You're quite right. I became confused with [SIZE=-1]Myanmar, whose government policies towards homeopathy I [/SIZE]suddenly became curious about, knowing little of their antics.
 
And yet we are often invited of share in horror at conventional medicine's allegedly poor handling of small risks posed by its drugs.

Like all other homeopaths I have met, you seem to lack either the intellectual tools or the basic curiosity to see that there is a problem and also to see that there is a very simple solution.

is this the only reason why you think homoeopathy does not work.
 
is this the only reason why you think homoeopathy does not work.

As Rolfe has just said, "No". To which I might add, "Don't be silly".

The lack of engagement with the evident problems of homeopathy by homeopaths is just one more depressing feature of the whole charade.

Let's give you another chance:-

Why do you think some homeopaths think it is OK to put their remedies through X-ray scanners yet others are adamant that this must not be done?
 
{snip} Why do you think some homeopaths think it is OK to put their remedies through X-ray scanners yet others are adamant that this must not be done?
Presuming for a moment to speak for sabbylewis, because when you are selling nonsense- it's all good.
 
As Rolfe has just said, "No". To which I might add, "Don't be silly".

The lack of engagement with the evident problems of homeopathy by homeopaths is just one more depressing feature of the whole charade.

Let's give you another chance:-

Why do you think some homeopaths think it is OK to put their remedies through X-ray scanners yet others are adamant that this must not be done?

Actually you have been continuously asking me about an issue which as of now does not have much significance in my country.Homoeopaths in my country do not have to advise about air travel because it is that rarely used.I agree this issue may be important in your country but the onus lies at the moment on Homoeopaths from your country to find these answers.I have already promised you an accurate answer in the near future.If Homoeopaths in your country have not shown the inclination to find out the truth about something that is really significant to them then it would be a failure on their part and not of Homoeopathy as a system.
 
Actually you have been continuously asking me about an issue which as of now does not have much significance in my country...
You have been continuously dodging a very simple question. Countries don't matter, much, these days- you are using the "World" Wide Web. What would you tell a customer who asks this question- you are not interested? How long would it take you to come up with an answer? In the USA dotors don't say "I am sorry; but we don't see enough malaria (cholera, whatever) to help you."

You are an unartful dodger.
 
Actually you have been continuously asking me about an issue which as of now does not have much significance in my country.

You are a disgrace tro the medical profession just for that alone.

Homoeopaths in my country do not have to advise about air travel because it is that rarely used.

But surely not "never", right?

So, what will you do if one of your patients ever asks you that same question? You can whine all you want here about not needing to know, but that won't help you if a patient of you ever asks.

Suggesting that a patient consult a local doctor doesn't cut it, either. If a doctor elsewhere tells me to take medication X, I will not always have to buy new supplies. Especially not if I was already being treated before I started a journey!

Since I do ocasionally fly - does anyone here know if it is a common problems with real medication?
 
Why do you think some homeopaths think it is OK to put their remedies through X-ray scanners yet others are adamant that this must not be done?
Actually you have been continuously asking me about an issue which as of now does not have much significance in my country.Homoeopaths in my country do not have to advise about air travel because it is that rarely used.I agree this issue may be important in your country but the onus lies at the moment on Homoeopaths from your country to find these answers.I have already promised you an accurate answer in the near future.If Homoeopaths in your country have not shown the inclination to find out the truth about something that is really significant to them then it would be a failure on their part and not of Homoeopathy as a system.


The question isn't whether or not the remedies are inactivated by the scanners. The question is: why is there disagreement between homoeopaths about this? If the remedies have any detectable effect, it should be perfectly simple to test whether the effect is still present after they've been through a scanner. Why have homoeopaths been unable to resolve this one way or the other?
 
The question isn't whether or not the remedies are inactivated by the scanners. The question is: why is there disagreement between homoeopaths about this? If the remedies have any detectable effect, it should be perfectly simple to test whether the effect is still present after they've been through a scanner. Why have homoeopaths been unable to resolve this one way or the other?
The sample is too large and needs to be diluted before it is powerful enough to provide certainty. When they achieve zero instances of remedies going through scanners then they'll be able to provide a definitive answer.
 
An interesting twist on this problem is the discovery that there is such a remedy as "X-ray", - a homeopathic preparation made by exposing water/alcohol to X-rays.

Surely this remedy inactivates itself?
 
An interesting twist on this problem is the discovery that there is such a remedy as "X-ray", - a homeopathic preparation made by exposing water/alcohol to X-rays.

Surely this remedy inactivates itself?

What's 'x-ray' supposed to treat? anorexia?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom