Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

"High-powered rifle" is a term that means nothing. It's not like high and low explosives which really are things. And no, military rifles tend to be of lower power than hunting rifles, certainly WRT deer rifles.


What I know about firearms would fit comfortably on the back of a postage stamp, but...


Isn't it the ammunition that defines the 'power' rather than the rifle, which, ultimately, is just a fancy tube?
 
Then it is "generally agreed" WRONG. It removes the ability of those particular offenders to re-offend and sends a powerful deterring message to those who might be inclined to follow.

It also reassures the public that criminal behavior will not be tolerated.

I call that win/win/win.

Not to divert this thread any further but why do the studies on crime statistics say the opposite?
 
What I know about firearms would fit comfortably on the back of a postage stamp, but...


Isn't it the ammunition that defines the 'power' rather than the rifle, which, ultimately, is just a fancy tube?

No ! Gun is build around ammunition. You can't just use different types. While you can have different loads for the same gun, the power wont vary as much as different types of ammunition.

Anyway I think in news talk, high power rifle means 'it was big'.

In gunner's world, there is full-power cartridge rifle, which uses standard size of the cartridge. Standard here means basically cartridges used in WW1 and mostly in WW2. Common examples are 7.62×51mm, 7.62×54mmR.
Such cartridges (and rifles built around them) are used today mostly for hunting, and in army in machine guns and sniper rifles. Such rifles can be effective up to 1000m and even more.

Opposed to full-power cartridge there is intermediate cartridge, which is smaller or at least shorter. During WW2 soldiers came up with idea, that the full power cartridge is way too strong, and especially way too big. They didn't need 1000m cartridge. 400m was considered enough. So Germans came up with 7.92x33mm (shorter variant of their full-power 7.92x57), Russians came up with 7.62x39, and after the war, US went for 5.56x45, which is not only shorter, but also smaller diameter. Russians later adapted smaller diameter 5.45x39.
These cartridges are smaller, so more can be fit in magazine, they have enough power for military use, and especially, they are more controllable in automatic fire. Intermediate cartridge gave birth of assault rifle, the term is defined as 'rifle with automatic capability firing intermediate cartridge'.

These cartridges (5.56x45) are usually used in the infamous AR15, even though there are many AR-15 variants.

In most US shooting you can expect handgun or semi-auto intermediate cartridge rifle, like AR-15 (which is not assault rifle by definition, because of lack of the full-auto mode).

Gunners may use term 'high power rifle' but they would most likely mean some special hunting cartridge with power even greater then common full-power cartridge.
 
Last edited:
Ha, apparently a high-powered rifle is the exact opposite of what I thought it was.

You learn something new every day, thanks :)

McHrozni
 
I saw the video of the gatherings in front of the Governor's mansion and had an bad feeling that people were an easy target.

I'm going back to CNN instead of flipping. Fox's guy just walked up to the police tape, see, here is the police tape, right here, the police tape it is, right here.

FOX!? I have been flipping around the last couple days -- all FOX has been reporting as the top story is about Clinton's emails, both on air and on the web page. The shooting incidents were buried not even in the secondary picture section, but on the list below.
 
Last edited:
... [The death penalty] removes the ability of those particular offenders to re-offend and sends a powerful deterring message to those who might be inclined to follow.

It also reassures the public that criminal behavior will not be tolerated...

The message that the death penalty sends:
There are non-combat circumstances in which it is justified to kill a human.

The consequence:
Jokers who think they are so justified kill those who 'deserve' it.

A better approach:
Killing is wrong.

***
Back to Dallas: Sad situation; awaiting facts.
 
Actually it probably does, but it is generally agreed that such punishments are worse than the crimes they're supposed to prevent.

McHrozni

Gibbets used to be pretty common over here in the middle ages, I don't recall there being any shortage of criminals to put in them. I otherwise agree.

Plus of course, if the punishment is too out of proportion to the crime the 'might as well get hung for a sheep as a goose' and 'no witnesses' principals come to the fore.
 
Then it is "generally agreed" WRONG. It removes the ability of those particular offenders to re-offend and sends a powerful deterring message to those who might be inclined to follow.

It also reassures the public that criminal behavior will not be tolerated.

I call that win/win/win.
Does it reduce crime in fact? Was the incidence of crime lower in England a couple of centuries ago?
During the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries concern over levels of property theft led to several other forms of theft being added to this list. These included housebreaking, the theft of goods worth more than 40 shillings from a dwelling house, shoplifting of goods worth more than 5 shillings, and sheep and cattle stealing. A death sentence in such cases therefore became automatic,​
 
Last edited:
What I know about firearms would fit comfortably on the back of a postage stamp, but...


Isn't it the ammunition that defines the 'power' rather than the rifle, which, ultimately, is just a fancy tube?

Indeed comparing 7.62 NATO to .22 is silly. Roughly 3 time the muzzle velocity and AFAIK 4 time the bullet weight... That is what , 12 time the kinetic energy m*v ?
 
This is all really disturbing, Dallas is my city and the DPD don't deserve this. One of the officers is a DART cop and I recognized him, I ride the train into Dallas all the time with my daughter.

But what do I know, I'm just a white guy livin' in the 'burbs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom