Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

According to the Daily Beast:

"Additionally, Brown said, the deceased suspect told negotiators that 'he was upset about Black Lives Matter, he said he was upset about the recent police shootings. The suspect said he was upset at white people. The suspect stated he wanted to kill white people, especially white officers. The suspect stated he was not affiliated with any groups, and he stated that he did it alone.'

If he did it alone, who are these other three people in custody then?
 
Not sure if it was mentioned, but the police took out the barricaded gunman by placing an explosive device on the bomb-squad robot, driving it over to him and detonating it.

I think we will be seeing a lot more of this type of thing (but I hope not). I anticipate the first report of a drone aiding in a similar situation.
 
A small, largely homogenous nation with a lot of wealth and historically low crime rates compared to a large, ethnically diverse nation with significant wealth disparities and ethnic tensions. South East Asia manages a Zero Tolerance Policy when it comes to crime, yet they have lower first-time and reoffending rates.
So, according to you the major cause of crime is wealth inequality and tension between ethnic groups. I wholly agree.

So why is the proposed "solution" harsher punishment, instead of trying to address these causes?
 
I think we will be seeing a lot more of this type of thing (but I hope not). I anticipate the first report of a drone aiding in a similar situation.

Jesus. Good call. All of the capabilities (more or less) of a bomb robot but significantly more mobile and nimble.
 
I think we will be seeing a lot more of this type of thing (but I hope not). I anticipate the first report of a drone aiding in a similar situation.

Maybe. I am sure it will be (or is) being discussed. I am guessing that it will be harder to implement than planned. Not technology-wise. But the idea of hovering-bombs is probably going to get some blow-back.
(no pun intended)
 
So, according to you the major cause of crime is wealth inequality and tension between ethnic groups. I wholly agree.

So why is the proposed "solution" harsher punishment, instead of trying to address these causes?

Addressing inequality is easier said than done, especially in a large country like the USA. Norway has the benefits of both a highly concentrated and homogenous population, which allows for greater social cohesion, meaning inequalities are far easier to address. The USA on the other hand, is a huge country that is more scattered in population while ethnic tensions are growing between a dwindling majority and growing minorities. In terms of South East Asian countries such as Singapore and Indonesia (which both have a lower murder rate per Capita than Norway), I suspect it's Geography that contributes, as both countries are clusters of populations (especially the latter's status as an Island chain) allowing governments to have greater control.
 
Obviously 99% of cops are fine, but you can't seriously say there aren't dodgey ones

I'm still sorting through my feelings about this, so I am trying to use measured language.

That said, the highlighted is just not true. Or perhaps I should say, I do not believe that a full 99% of the LE community (nor any other) is "fine". I know you weren't trying to use that figure in an exact way, but it is a common meme that appears anytime these conversations happen.

There is a significant portion of the LE community that is problematic for one reason or another. What percentage? I dunno, but it is surely more than 1%.

I think (and I'm not singling cullennz out here in any way -- just using the post as a jumping off point) that part of the problem is that many of the police encountered by those living in wealthy/white neighborhoods are entirely different from many of those one encounters in poor/black neighborhoods.

As a white kid from the suburbs who lived in the straight-up hood for many years as a young adult, I have seen largely appropriate (if cloaked in eight layers of douchy arrogance) behavior from cops in wealthy/white neighborhoods, and truly abhorrent behavior from the police in poor/black neighborhoods.

So even as a white, nearly 40-year-old-dude who doesn't really get many second looks from the cops, I fundamentally fear them. I can't imagine how terrifying they would be for me if I were black.

Perhaps the best outcome from all of this would be if the goddamn blue wall got a few bricks punched out (not intended as a support of violence), and the X% of good cops started protecting us all from the X% of bad cops, by reporting their often well-known problems.
 
I wonder how the cops who shot those black men are feeling this morning. In addition to their victim's blood, they also have the blood of those dead cops on their hands too.
 
I wonder how the cops who shot those black men are feeling this morning. In addition to their victim's blood, they also have the blood of those dead cops on their hands too.

In this logic it was fault of the black guys who got shot.
Either you want to make difference between legal and illegal, reasonable and unreasonable reaction, or you don't.
 
... ethnic tensions are growing between a dwindling majority and growing minorities.
The tensions were even higher half a century ago, as I remember, when the "majority" was larger, and subjected the "minority" to all kinds of oppression and harassment. So I don't think it's the increasing number of non-"majority" citizens that is the problem. But if it is, how do you suggest this numbers issue should be addressed?
 
Does anyone know of an easy way to find a list of Joe Walsh's commercial sponsors? I've looked around a bit, but can't find anything easy.

I will immediately stop supporting any brands that advertise on his show (probably the entire network/station) unless he is publicly disavowed and I would like to let them know.
 
In this logic it was fault of the black guys who got shot.
Either you want to make difference between legal and illegal, reasonable and unreasonable reaction, or you don't.

That's just it -- reasonable to whom?

Violence probably wasn't the answer, but nothing else has worked. Things are bad in many minority communities with respect to police relations.
 
I wonder how the cops who shot those black men are feeling this morning. In addition to their victim's blood, they also have the blood of those dead cops on their hands too.
And you're not shooting cops why? Is it because you don't actually agree with this justification? Or are you just afraid of getting caught doing what you believe is the right thing?
 
If he did it alone, who are these other three people in custody then?

Since when did being in custody automatically mean you committed a crime?

Not saying other people didn't help him. But that's a right dumb way to argue they did. Especially this early in a high profile investigation where the police will aggressively pursue every lead.
 
A small, largely homogenous nation with a lot of wealth and historically low crime rates compared to a large, ethnically diverse nation with significant wealth disparities and ethnic tensions. South East Asia manages a Zero Tolerance Policy when it comes to crime, yet they have lower first-time and reoffending rates.

France does not have as harsh law as the US, is hardly "homogeneous" (ethnically diverse nation with significant wealth disparities and ethnic tensions - large does tells nothing) , and yet manage a lower crime rate (for violent crime, for petty crime like pick-pocketing or stealing in stores we have more). Heck our lowest criminal age of responsibility is 13 (versus apparentely as low as 6 in USA).

Try again.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom