Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

By Western standards and imprisonment rates, the USA already has the harshest punishments.

Some conservative on this board once characterised the U.S. as a third world country with a first world economy. At the time I thought it a bit of a dumb observation but now I think that it has some merit.
 
Why the frak not? If our punishments were a bit harsher, we'd have less crime.

As it stands, we have a bunch of cop-haters doing the 9/11 Palestinian dance online about "dead pigs" and justifying the shootings based on alleged improper acts by police.

That crap needs to stop and right now.

Well, "Christian Progressive", I think you are wrong. I don't think medieval punishment and displays of rotting corpses actually does reduce crime.
 
We very obviously do not. That's probably the single largest issue here.

All the police being tried for various alleged incidents would beg to differ.

The laws and procedures we have are working, separating the innocent and the guilty according to the evidence.

ETA: and it's very clear that a large portion of our officials and people are striving to keep the current, entirely broken system in place.

That is in no way clear.

Then how and why did this happen? :confused:

It happened because extremists on BOTH ends of the political spectrum hate a common society and have so poisoned the public discourse that the public is primed for radical overrreaction.

Your right. This was actually cops shooting themselves to get sympathy and hope people forget about all the Blacks they killed for no reason.

Does not justify what these animals did in the slightest.

We have laws and investigations and trials to handle alleged incidents of police brutality and malfeasance, and they generally work.
 
Well, "Christian Progressive", I think you are wrong. I don't think medieval punishment and displays of rotting corpses actually does reduce crime.

Actually it probably does, but it is generally agreed that such punishments are worse than the crimes they're supposed to prevent.

McHrozni
 
By Western standards and imprisonment rates, the USA already has the harshest punishments.

Guaranteed "3 hots and a cot" plus free medical on the public dime when law-abiding decent people are left to fend for themselves is hardly "harshest punishment".

Well, "Christian Progressive", I think you are wrong. I don't think medieval punishment and displays of rotting corpses actually does reduce crime.

People in medieval times thought it worked pretty darn well. It certainly delivers more justice than letting them luxuriate with guaranteed "rights" that ordinary decent folk are denied.

If appealing to Stage 1 moral reasoning ("I don't do wrong because I fear the consequences") is the only way to get it through their skulls that society will not put up with this crap, then so be it. I said the same thing about the Bundy and Wildlife Sanctuary situations too.
 
Last edited:
Actually it probably does, but it is generally agreed that such punishments are worse than the crimes they're supposed to prevent.

McHrozni
Mediaeval punishments didn't produce a crime free society in the Middle Ages. Quite the contrary, in fact.
 
Actually it probably does, but it is generally agreed that such punishments are worse than the crimes they're supposed to prevent.

McHrozni

Then it is "generally agreed" WRONG. It removes the ability of those particular offenders to re-offend and sends a powerful deterring message to those who might be inclined to follow.

It also reassures the public that criminal behavior will not be tolerated.

I call that win/win/win.
 
Your right. This was actually cops shooting themselves to get sympathy and hope people forget about all the Blacks they killed for no reason.

And it's working!

Ask Northern Ireland how that logic turned out. When you had "**** the police!" used to justify having Death Squads randomly torture and murder people, and you had the entire province effectively placed under martial law for 30 years.

And **** the "equality feels like oppression to the privileged!" ********. Tell that to the Alawite families who get massacred by Sunni Death Squads in Syria.
 
Then it is "generally agreed" WRONG. It removes the ability of those particular offenders to re-offend and sends a powerful deterring message to those who might be inclined to follow.

It also reassures the public that criminal behavior will not be tolerated.

I call that win/win/win.

You have the right to your own opinion.

McHrozni
 
Mediaeval punishments didn't produce a crime free society in the Middle Ages. Quite the contrary, in fact.

Nothing will ever produce a crime free society. Stronger/harsher punishments will produce a less crime society, which is the goal.

We mustn't allow a goal of "perfection" to preclude us seeking a goal of "better".
 
Nothing will ever produce a crime free society. Stronger/harsher punishments will produce a less crime society, which is the goal.

We mustn't allow a goal of "perfection" to preclude us seeking a goal of "better".

Compare USA crime rates to other Western countries. They have lower crime rates and lower imprisonment rates.
 
People in medieval times thought it worked pretty darn well.

Ughm, yes, but they also believed in witches and vampires and thought the Earth was flat.

That doesn't make them right.
 
Compare USA crime rates to other Western countries. They have lower crime rates and lower imprisonment rates.

Most of those other countries are largely ethnically homogenous and don't really have the same racial issues that come with enslaving a significant minority for 2 centuries then outright segregating them for another.
 
Ughm, yes, but they also believed in witches and vampires and thought the Earth was flat.

That doesn't make them right.

Nitpick, medieval Europeans were well aware the Earth is round. They just thought the Ocean that separated Europe from Asia was too vast to sail across.

This would be entirely correct for their day, if there wasn't a vast continent in the way.

McHrozni
 
Saudi Arabia give very harsh punishments, maybe in line with what Christian progressive wants

Where those punishments are warranted, why not? Saudi's problem is that they give harsh punishments for things that don't merit such, or even punishment at all.

We went through this sort of hand-wringing about "excessive" punishments back in the 80s (maybe early 90s, I don't recall the exact year) when some bratty American was caught vandalizing property in Singapore and they sentenced him to be caned.

There was much wailing about "excessive" and "harsh" punishment back then too, but you know what? For the most part, the streets in Singapore (at the time) were a lot cleaner and safer than our own streets were. That was because Singaporians knew that if they did x, y, or z there would be a painful and humiliating (and at the most extreme, final) punishment waiting for them.

It's easy to avoid having to be punished, if you just don't do wrong things.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom