Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

They also kill pest animals all the time.

What if a rancher has a herd of antelope on his land, are they his? With no legal hunting I assure you wild deer and the like encroaching on ranch land would become a huge problem. They'd have to be killed.

Or: rancher earns some extra cash by letting one of his pigs free and transferring ownership to someone to let them kill it for him.

Or: Federal government: you can only kill animals you own. Texas: OK buying a white-tail license transfers ownership of one deer to you.

In the definition of hunting it says "especially for food or sport". That was the kind I was referring to.

Two just sounds like a good idea, but I would replace pig with all sorts of animals people like to hunt (I'm 100% cool with people shooting their animal for entertainment. It is some "right to commons" I object to on a libertarian basis).
 
Nope -- it means you should have been up a tree instead. Or hunted from a farther distance. Or any number of other solutions.

If one well placed shot does not incapacitate the prey, you aren't using an appropriate weapon. If you miss, that's on you.

Quite right. Trying to use more efficient tools is just wrong.

I hunt with a club. That's how Ug did it and that's good enough for me.
 
... If one well placed shot does not incapacitate the prey, you aren't using an appropriate weapon. If you miss, that's on you.

Everybody knows I don't like firearms in most ways and shapes, however, a human life - including of course that of the ones I most disagree with - comes ahead of that of an animal in a case like this one.
 
Everybody knows I don't like firearms in most ways and shapes, however, a human life - including of course that of the ones I most disagree with - comes ahead of that of an animal in a case like this one.

Wait -- these aren't people sitting in their living rooms getting mauled by pigs. These are people deciding to go hunting. I'm not telling them to hunt pigs with a bowie knife, I'm saying they should use some basic common sense and figure out a way to hunt boars with the same tools that sufficed for years.
 
Quite right. Trying to use more efficient tools is just wrong.

I hunt with a club. That's how Ug did it and that's good enough for me.

Your right, we should just lob grenades at them. How's that for efficient?
 
Irrelevant, since I wasn't talking about rights. I don't remember the right to shoot people being in the Constitution, either.

Some believe that the Constitution gives them the right to fight the elected government. The NRA supports that interpretation tooth and nail. Taking the side of the Militia Movement and idiots like Cliven Bundy.

In reality the Militia of the Constitution exists to support our government. Operating under the discipline set by Congress and taking orders from the President when called to national service. But knowing that require that you read the rest of the Constitution and not just the part of the Second Amendment that in often seen on bumper stickers.
 
Wait -- these aren't people sitting in their living rooms getting mauled by pigs. These are people deciding to go hunting. I'm not telling them to hunt pigs with a bowie knife, I'm saying they should use some basic common sense and figure out a way to hunt boars with the same tools that sufficed for years.

The only person I know that went wild boar hunting bagged one with a bolt action rifle that had been in her family for years.
 
The only person I know that went wild boar hunting bagged one with a bolt action rifle that had been in her family for years.

********. I have it on good authority that a single boar cannot be brought down without a chain-fed M-60. This is a skeptic forum, good sir/madam.
 
When did I step into bizarro world, I wonder...

Some people think ripping the life out of an animal (human or otherwise) for entertainment is obscene and shouldn't be considered a "right". Totally bizarre, I know.
 
Last edited:
In the definition of hunting it says "especially for food or sport". That was the kind I was referring to.

Two just sounds like a good idea, but I would replace pig with all sorts of animals people like to hunt (I'm 100% cool with people shooting their animal for entertainment. It is some "right to commons" I object to on a libertarian basis).

Personally, I'm not even 1% cool with that.
 
I don't know. I think people eat them. Probably one of the few animals you can harvest yourself that doesn't taste like chicken.
Yes. They can be pretty good eating.



There is a reason that the military/swat uses the M-16 (or similar) platform. If they are so similar to a classic bolt-action rifle, why don't our armed services clear buildings in Iraq with such?
For each mission you use the best kit. Building clearing is a close range bit of work. A variety of weapons are used, to include shot guns and some auto weapons, grenades, etc.

Say your going to invade Canada tomorrow (and thank god for that -- it's about time). What rifle do you want?
For my infantry squad, M-4's and SAW's, but I really want the radio, the laser designator, and some on call AH-64's. Combined arms for the win. :thumbsup:
 
No. Just stop it.

This is not some sort of precedent-setting case where cops are now going to be killing people who committed traffic violations with C4.

They killed an active shooter.

He was not active at the time of death. I have not claimed this will lead to deaths over traffic offences, strawman argument.

Blindly repeating stupid memes.

The standard being discussed is "the true rule of law" articulated through "the supremacy of the courts."

There was a limited attempt to arrest and instead they sent a bomb in to kill him. Are you really happy that is justice?
 
Exactly how much more effort would you have wanted them to make to capture this guy? How many cops' lives do you want them to throw away in order to reach this utopic goal?



I am so sick and tired of people using "summary execution". When someone is shooting at you and you shoot back, it isn't a summary execution. It's self-defense.

In the UK it is contain, cover and negotiate. He was contained, the cops were behind cover, they decided not to keep negotiating and instead sent in a bomb to kill him. The only difference between me and the Dallas cops involved is that I would still be negotiating with him today if that is what it took.
 
In the UK it is contain, cover and negotiate. He was contained, the cops were behind cover, they decided not to keep negotiating and instead sent in a bomb to kill him. The only difference between me and the Dallas cops involved is that I would still be negotiating with him today if that is what it took.

How is that "contained" when he didn't want to negociate? How was he not still a threat?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom