Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

How is that "contained" when he didn't want to negociate? How was he not still a threat?

Johnston had been shot, he was cornered in a stairwell/corridor in an empty building. From one quote by Dallas Police "We had negotiated with him for about two hours, and he just basically lied to us, playing games, laughing at us, singing, asking how many did he get and that he wanted to kill some more." So minimal effort to resolve the situation in a non violent way they sent in a bomb to kill him.

He was a threat, but a contained one who was injured. What is wrong with playing the waiting game? Keep him going till he finally gives up or collapses.
 
I'm a bit confused over this thread derail....hunting pigs? I suppose in some weird way it is on topic, but only if the pigs used robots with a bomb attached to blow up hunters.
 
Johnston had been shot, he was cornered in a stairwell/corridor in an empty building. From one quote by Dallas Police "We had negotiated with him for about two hours, and he just basically lied to us, playing games, laughing at us, singing, asking how many did he get and that he wanted to kill some more."

So he in fact intended to continue no matter what.

What is wrong with playing the waiting game?

Depends how much of a risk the police thought he really was.
 
How is that "contained" when he didn't want to negociate? How was he not still a threat?


How do "not contained" and "refuses to negotiate" relate? Because, as I understand it, someone could refuse to negotiate and yet still be unable to leave their current location without confronting the cops.
 
So he in fact intended to continue no matter what.

Depends how much of a risk the police thought he really was.

According to the cops what he continued doing was laughing, singing, and lying to them, no matter what, for a frankly pathetic 2 hours before they decided to kill him.

Considering what people have been shot by the police for which lead to this shooting and all the protests, any risk is too high a risk according to some cops.

So what we have during protests against police killing people who are not posing them an immediate deadly risk, is the police killing someone who was no longer posing an immediate deadly risk. The police had recently killed two black men, who were armed, but were not posing an immediate deadly risk to them. Now they kill someone once that immediate deadly risk had passed.

I say that the police are only justified in using deadly force when there is a ongoing immediate deadly risk.
 
How do "not contained" and "refuses to negotiate" relate? Because, as I understand it, someone could refuse to negotiate and yet still be unable to leave their current location without confronting the cops.

Exactly, he was injured and cornered and contained. But he lied to and laughed at the cops, so they blew him up.
 
How do "not contained" and "refuses to negotiate" relate? Because, as I understand it, someone could refuse to negotiate and yet still be unable to leave their current location without confronting the cops.

Yeah that was poorly written.

According to the cops what he continued doing was laughing, singing, and lying to them, no matter what, for a frankly pathetic 2 hours before they decided to kill him.

Considering what people have been shot by the police for which lead to this shooting and all the protests, any risk is too high a risk according to some cops.

So what we have during protests against police killing people who are not posing them an immediate deadly risk, is the police killing someone who was no longer posing an immediate deadly risk. The police had recently killed two black men, who were armed, but were not posing an immediate deadly risk to them. Now they kill someone once that immediate deadly risk had passed.

I say that the police are only justified in using deadly force when there is a ongoing immediate deadly risk.

Fair enough.
 
A honest observer might note the multiple officers wounded and killed before that point.

An honest observer would note that suggests the kill was revenge for fallen comrades and certain people are happy with that.
 
He was not active at the time of death. I have not claimed this will lead to deaths over traffic offences, strawman argument.
Then what are you worried about? I understand the academic argument that the he was "denied due process," but I think reasonable minds will agree that he was clearly guilty and clearly dangerous.
 
Then what are you worried about? I understand the academic argument that the he was "denied due process," but I think reasonable minds will agree that he was clearly guilty and clearly dangerous.

Where there is rule of law it is the courts and due process who decide on guilt and punsihment. It is the police's job to detect criminals and bring them to the courts.

I am worried that the US police have taken a significant step towards thinking it is OK that they get to decide guilt and punishment.
 
An honest observer would note that suggests the kill was revenge for fallen comrades and certain people are happy with that.

To me. it doesn't make any difference if the shooter shot and killed a group of Muslims, Gays, Democrats, Republicans or accordion players.

The moment he committed those acts and didn't surrender or DIP (Die in Place) he was fair game, and anything that was done to him is on him
 
Last edited:
To me. it doesn't make any difference if the shooter shot and killed a group of Muslims, Gays, Democrats, Republicans or accordion players.

The moment he committed those acts and didn't surrender or DIP (Die in Place) he was fair game, and anything that was done to him is on him

That's a doctrine from Scientology, right? Means something like, "by any and all means; without boundaries in law, convention, or ethics."
 
To me. it doesn't make any difference if the shooter shot and killed a group of Muslims, Gays, Democrats, Republicans or accordion players.

The moment he committed those acts and didn't surrender or DIP (Die in Place) he was fair game, and anything that was done to him is on him

The law disagrees with you
Deadly force has specific requirements and those are not it.
 
A honest observer might note the multiple officers wounded and killed before that point.

Shooting at people because they wounded somebody when they are not an immediate threat is called vigilante execution. Cops should not get a free card for revenge. they have , as Nessie pointed out, respect due process and only go for the kill if the person is an immediate threat. he was not. He was from what I read above, stuck in a place, wounded, and unable to flee.

So if there was no immediate threat.... Then why kill and not do the waiting game ?
 
Last edited:
That's a doctrine from Scientology, right? Means something like, "by any and all means; without boundaries in law, convention, or ethics."

I can't comment on any Co$ connection, but the first time I heard it was as a kid in the 1960's out of my father's mouth, and he for sure didn't have anything to do with any church of anything.

I don't dispute your description of the term, and stand by my use of the term in this conntext.
 
You don't think poverty is the root of, if not a majority, a considerable portion of, crime?

No, I don't think poverty is the root of crime. If it was, then rich people wouldn't ever commit crimes, but they do. Social pathologies are the root of most crime, and while they are certainly correlated with poverty, and poverty may sometimes be a contributor, the reverse is also true. Those social pathologies often cause poverty, and in those cases, fixing the symptom won't cure the disease.

As a simple example, rape is not an economically motivated crime. Rapists do not rape because they are poor. Giving a poor rapist money will not make him any less likely to rape.
 
If actor A surrenders, he should be taken into custody and should be afforded every civil right they are entitled to.

If actor A does not surrender after committing mass murder, **** 'em.

Legal, moral, ethical, sit on your collective asses and write about it.

My experience in the subject matter does not afford me an objective viewpoint.

If anybody wants to view me as a scumbag because of it, that's their right, but I do not come from a place that allows me a dispassionate pov.
 
Because that is the common argument -- I need my AR-15 because I'm being overrun by hogs!!!

Whether that's a common argument elsewhere, that's not the argument that was being debated between me and Tony99. Remember, Tony99 didn't simply claim that one didn't need an AR-15 for hog hunting, he claimed it was actually the wrong gun for the task. This is what he said: "If you're hog hunting with an AR-15 you are doing it wrong." But that really doesn't seem to be true at all. Hog hunting with an AR-15 is quite common, and lots of people do it quite successfully. It seems to be just fine for hog hunting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom