BobTheCoward
Banned
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2010
- Messages
- 22,789
Why? Should people's ability to hunt not be protected?
No. Hunting isn't a right. I'm perfectly happy to make hunting something other than an animal you own illegal.
Why? Should people's ability to hunt not be protected?
Feral hogs don't hang out in cities. They run amok out in Non Urban terrain. I'd not use an AR-15, I've got a 7mm mag and a .270 that I think would be more appropriate, though when considering Newton's Bit's points, the .30/.30 lever action (brush gun) might be the better choice if I were a better shot with it. (Need to get out to the range and work on that if I am to go and help my friend GJ on his ranch in the fall).
No need to go that far.
Any firearm in civilian hands can potentially be used to commit mass murder, including firearms currently completely unregulated under federal law, so ban 'em all.
If not, logically explain why the rifle designed for military use in 1898 and used to great effect in two world wars is somehow different than a less powerful rifle designed for military use in the 1940's - 1950's.
You might want to shoot many times in a rapid fashion after flushing out a hog at short range. Their tusks are sharp and they're wielded by 600lb+ angry and intelligent monsters. They will quite literally eviscerate you. Your bolt-action rifle will give you one, maybe two shots if you're lucky. If you fail to land a killing shot, while you're surprised and suddenly pumped full of adrenaline, you'll find yourself on the business end of those tusks.
And while you're desperately trying to hold your guts in with your hands, maybe you'll come to the conclusion that having a more effective weapon would have been prudent.
On further reading, I retract my apology. It doesn't seem to be what you're getting at, at all. You seem to have both a profound ignorance of firearms and a conclusion you have reached about them anyway. And you seem to be trying to express your conclusion in terms of leading questions, which doesn't really help matters.
Anyway. Here's the deal: the iconic appearance of the AR family of rifles is entirely irrelevant to its usefulness as a hunting rifle versus a mass killing rifle. There are perfectly legal hunting rifles, such as the Ruger Mini-14, that fire the same bullet, with the same power, at the same rate, and with the same capacity, as an AR.
There are only two things that really distinguish the Mini-14 from an AR: It doesn't have that iconic "assault rifle" appearance (even though its operation and ergonomics are substantially similar), and it hasn't been featured prominently in the media as some kind of dangerous weapon.
Everything that makes the Mini-14 an effective hunting rifle makes the AR an effective hunting rifle. Everything that makes the AR an efficient killing machine makes the Mini-14 an efficient killing machine. There is no such thing as "hunting rifles" and "killing rifles". There are just "rifles".
So the military moved away from the better weapons? I guess they really are all incompetent government workers.
So spray and pray and suppressing fire is needed to hunt boar.
So the good news is that one of the cops killed in Dallas might have been a white supremacist, which means, er, well I'm not sure what it means...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jesse-benn/slain-dallas-cop-mightve_b_10953276.html
And apparently, people are doing this willingly.
I'm becoming convinced that boar hunting is too dangerous for civilians.
If the goal is to get them off your land, why not poison them?
So spray and pray and suppressing fire is needed to hunt boar.
If the goal is to get them off your land, why not poison them?
Not even ignorant hillbillies with a vertical family tree would think that. A reasonable person, however, would want the option of a second or third shot in case the first misses.
But then again, your arguments aren't about reasonableness, they're absurd and pointless.
Because they're on ranching lands, and the ranchers don't want to poison their own livestock. This isn't rocket surgery.
What most people don't realize is that every single commonly available bolt action rifle is a direct descendant of a rifle made specifically for military use, the Mauser model of 1898, and every single modern commonly available high-power (real, not term of art) rifle cartridge for both semi auto and bolt action rifles is a direct descendant of two military cartridges, the American .30 caliber model of 1906 and the Mauser 8mm x 57mm of 1898. Even the modern 5.56mm x 45mm cartridge in the AR platform is based partially (case and base diameter) on the 9mm parabellum cartridge of 1902.
The rifles that individuals like to cite as being "appropriate" for civilian use are, other than mechanical action, absolutely no different in origin and in fact are of far greater power than any firearm, including fully automatic examples, using intermediate range cartridges such as the M16 and AK designs.
I have more respect for folks that call for banning all of them (firearms) than I do for someone that wants to assert a Ruger Mini-14 is a "good gun" and an AR platform rifle is a "bad gun" based on how the firearm looks rather than knowledge of the subject matter.
No need to go that far.
Any firearm in civilian hands can potentially be used to commit mass murder, including firearms currently completely unregulated under federal law, so ban 'em all.
If not, logically explain why the rifle designed for military use in 1898 and used to great effect in two world wars is somehow different than a less powerful rifle designed for military use in the 1940's - 1950's.
Pigs and cattle do not eat the same things. Why would the cattle eat the pig bait?
Poisons are often dangerous to non-target species (including domestic animals).If the goal is to get them off your land, why not poison them?
For the record, I have no problem with the hunting of hogs for sustenance or as a form of "pest" control. The problem I have is using an AR-15 to do so. It's just an excuse to use a fancy toy.
Go set up a feeder and a tree stand. Take your average hunting rifle and scope or bow up the tree near dawn/dusk. Shoot the pig.
Lather, rinse and repeat as necessary.
Congratulations, you just lost your whole herd due to ignorance! Insurance won't cover poisoning your own livestock, but they might investigate you for insurance fraud.