Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

I'm sure you're not being serious, but I can't surmise what your ultimate point is.

I am pro gun because guns are really good at killing people. We are allowed to kill people under certain circumstances.

That is the best case for gun ownership. Anything about hunting is a distraction.
 
I have more respect for folks that call for banning all of them (firearms) than I do for someone that wants to assert a Ruger Mini-14 is a "good gun" and an AR platform rifle is a "bad gun" based on how the firearm looks rather than knowledge of the subject matter.

I agree we should tap into this knowledge base. Present some informed gun folks with the top 100 most common rifles and ask them, "Rank these by which you think would be most efficient at killing a bunch of people quickly in a mass shooting."

Then use that ranking as the basis for a ban.
 
I just have visions of millions of Americans walking round cities carrying AR 15s just in case they see a feral hog.
 
I agree we should tap into this knowledge base. Present some informed gun folks with the top 100 most common rifles and ask them, "Rank these by which you think would be most efficient at killing a bunch of people quickly in a mass shooting."

Then use that ranking as the basis for a ban.

No need to go that far.

Any firearm in civilian hands can potentially be used to commit mass murder, including firearms currently completely unregulated under federal law, so ban 'em all.

If not, logically explain why the rifle designed for military use in 1898 and used to great effect in two world wars is somehow different than a less powerful rifle designed for military use in the 1940's - 1950's.
 
If not, logically explain why the rifle designed for military use in 1898 and used to great effect in two world wars is somehow different than a less powerful rifle designed for military use in the 1940's - 1950's.

Why should I have to explain such stuff to have an opinion? I'm happy to rely on real experts. For your question I think I'd ask someone in the Department of Defense - one assumes they had technical specs and took bids. If they think there's a difference, who am I to disagree?

It seems disingenuous to argue that some category of weapons can't be well distinguished by type and then insist on having the whole category to choose from. If they aren't dissimilar, why do we need more than one brand? Why can't I pick a brand I like and ban the rest?

The truth is they are distinguishable by the enthusiasts. Except when there's nitpicking about the meaning of "assault rifle" to be done.

The rhetorical dodge ain't foolin' nobody.
 
More people are probably familiar with the AR 15 then any other rifle in America for one reason:
Rifles that are basically variants of the AR 15 (M-16,M-16A2,M4,) have been the standard personal weapon for all branches of the US Military for over 50 years ,and if you join any of the branches of the military you are trained to use a version of the AR 15 in Basic Training. There are diffrences, of course, but the general look is the same and basic operations, (loading,etc) are the same.
 
Last edited:
More people are probably familiar with the AR 15 then any other rifle in America for one reason:
Rifles that are basically variants of the AR 15 (M-16,M-16A2,M4,) have been the standard personal weapon for all branches of the US Military for over 50 years ,and if you join any of the branches of the military you are trained to use a version of the AR 15 in Basic Training. There are diffrences, of course, but the general look is the same and basic operations, (loading,etc) are the same.

So people playing soldiers
 
Why should I have to explain such stuff to have an opinion? I'm happy to rely on real experts. For your question I think I'd ask someone in the Department of Defense - one assumes they had technical specs and took bids. If they think there's a difference, who am I to disagree?

It seems disingenuous to argue that some category of weapons can't be well distinguished by type and then insist on having the whole category to choose from. If they aren't dissimilar, why do we need more than one brand? Why can't I pick a brand I like and ban the rest?

The truth is they are distinguishable by the enthusiasts. Except when there's nitpicking about the meaning of "assault rifle" to be done.

The rhetorical dodge ain't foolin' nobody.

Great question.

You can't.

Other than looks, caliber and operating system, anything that launches a projectile is capable of causing death or injury.

There is an absolute difference in terminal effectiveness between a M2 .50 BMG and a .22 rimfire rifle and a reproduction 1860 Colt cap and ball revolver at 1000 yards.

There ain't much difference in terminal effect between the three at 10 yards on a human or animal target.

I'm sure smarter folks than I who have never in their life been trained to shoot, trained to repair weaons, trained to instruct other individuals in this subject matter and have received recognition for their professional skills and in fact worked professionally in the field for the majority of their adult life have all sorts of good questions and sharp observations concerning this issue, and look forward to hearing them express their feelings.

When they get around to discussion based on knowledge rather than "feelings," I'll begin to take them seriously.
 
Great question.

You can't.

Other than looks, caliber and operating system, anything that launches a projectile is capable of causing death or injury.

OK, I'll accept that expert opinion. Let's move to the next step. Are some better at causing death or injury to human beings than others?
 
Obviously doesn't change the fact the dude was a victim of a nutter, but how did this guy get accepted as a cop?

I don't think one's political opinions can be a disqualification when hiring. Maybe it falls under the freedom of association in the Constitution.
 

You might want to shoot many times in a rapid fashion after flushing out a hog at short range. Their tusks are sharp and they're wielded by 600lb+ angry and intelligent monsters. They will quite literally eviscerate you. Your bolt-action rifle will give you one, maybe two shots if you're lucky. If you fail to land a killing shot, while you're surprised and suddenly pumped full of adrenaline, you'll find yourself on the business end of those tusks.

And while you're desperately trying to hold your guts in with your hands, maybe you'll come to the conclusion that having a more effective weapon would have been prudent.
 
You might want to shoot many times in a rapid fashion after flushing out a hog at short range. Their tusks are sharp and they're wielded by 600lb+ angry and intelligent monsters. They will quite literally eviscerate you. Your bolt-action rifle will give you one, maybe two shots if you're lucky. If you fail to land a killing shot, while you're surprised and suddenly pumped full of adrenaline, you'll find yourself on the business end of those tusks.

And while you're desperately trying to hold your guts in with your hands, maybe you'll come to the conclusion that having a more effective weapon would have been prudent.


This doesn't sound like a very safe way of hunting those animals. It's almost like putting one's self in harm's way then justifies the firepower needed to get out of trouble.

Is this the same animal they used to hunt with a boar spearWP?
 
I don't think one's political opinions can be a disqualification when hiring. Maybe it falls under the freedom of association in the Constitution.

Depends if your political opinions would impact your performing the job. Seems to being a white surpemist would have a definent negative impact on performing your job as a cop.
Of course,if he hid his opinions when joining the force,that a real can of worms.
In the US military, if they find out in a background check you were involved with a white surpemist group in the recruiting process you undergo a grilling on it, and unless you can really convince them you have had a change of heart...and the people interviewing you are pretty hard to convince...you will be denied enlistment.
If they find out after you are in,you are pretty much put you on the "will deny reenlistment " list,unless they find a way to get you out quicker.
 
That is fleeing. That is the very definition of fleeing...to run away from someone or something.

There is just no requirement for active fleeing, though, so that feature becomes irrelevant.

In articulating why Tennessee's blanket statute authorizing deadly force against fleeing felons -- which fleeing was a component -- violates the US Constitution's Fourth Amendment, the court promulgates a more general standard for which fleeing is not a component.

Justice White wrote for the majority:

This case requires us to determine the constitutionality of the use of deadly force to prevent the escape of an apparently unarmed suspected felon. We conclude that such force may not be used unless it is necessary to prevent the escape and the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or others.​

The court clearly is focusing on the threat of escape and not active fleeing. Notice also that this opinion concerns unarmed felony suspects, thus it kind of disregards the police power to use deadly force in self defense.

The bottom line for the Garner court:

The use of deadly force to prevent the escape of all felony suspects, whatever the circumstances, is constitutionally unreasonable. It is not better that all felony suspects die than that they escape. Where the suspect poses no immediate threat to the officer and no threat to others, the harm resulting from failing to apprehend him does not justify the use of deadly force to do so. It is no doubt unfortunate when a suspect who is in sight escapes, but the fact that the police arrive a little late or are a little slower afoot does not always justify killing the suspect. A police officer may not seize an unarmed, nondangerous suspect by shooting him dead. The Tennessee statute is unconstitutional insofar as it authorizes the use of deadly force against such fleeing suspects.

It is not, however, unconstitutional on its face. Where the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a threat of serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others, it is not constitutionally unreasonable to prevent escape by using deadly force. Thus, if the suspect threatens the officer with a weapon or there is probable cause to believe that he has committed a crime involving the infliction or threatened infliction of serious physical harm, deadly force may be used if necessary to prevent escape, and if, where feasible, some warning has been given. As applied in such circumstances, the Tennessee statute would pass constitutional muster.
​

Applied to this case, the killing of this suspect is very plainly a seizure or arrest and thus required to be objectively reasonable by virtue of Fourth Amendment prohibitions. It also seems self-evident here that (as reported) the suspect -- as viewed by a reasonably cautious and prudent person -- posed a significant risk of "serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others." Thus, as the court noted, "deadly force may be used if necessary to prevent escape, and if, where feasible, some warning has been given."

It's my opinion that warning was feasible in this instance (as reported) but the risk of escape and the risk -- in situ -- of this idiot furthering his stated goal (among other considerations present at the time) did not reasonably require the police to defer to the suspect's preferred timeline or risk any further threat of "serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others," as articulated by the court.
 
Depends if your political opinions would impact your performing the job. Seems to being a white surpemist would have a definent negative impact on performing your job as a cop.
Of course,if he hid his opinions when joining the force,that a real can of worms.
In the US military, if they find out in a background check you were involved with a white surpemist group in the recruiting process you undergo a grilling on it, and unless you can really convince them you have had a change of heart...and the people interviewing you are pretty hard to convince...you will be denied enlistment.If they find out after you are in,you are pretty much put you on the "will deny reenlistment " list,unless they find a way to get you out quicker.

I didn't know that. Is it official policy or just "the way things are done"?
 
There is just no requirement for active fleeing, though, so that feature becomes irrelevant.

In articulating why Tennessee's blanket statute authorizing deadly force against fleeing felons -- which fleeing was a component -- violates the US Constitution's Fourth Amendment, the court promulgates a more general standard for which fleeing is not a component.

Justice White wrote for the majority:

This case requires us to determine the constitutionality of the use of deadly force to prevent the escape of an apparently unarmed suspected felon. We conclude that such force may not be used unless it is necessary to prevent the escape and the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or others.​

The court clearly is focusing on the threat of escape and not active fleeing. Notice also that this opinion concerns unarmed felony suspects, thus it kind of disregards the police power to use deadly force in self defense.

The bottom line for the Garner court:

The use of deadly force to prevent the escape of all felony suspects, whatever the circumstances, is constitutionally unreasonable. It is not better that all felony suspects die than that they escape. Where the suspect poses no immediate threat to the officer and no threat to others, the harm resulting from failing to apprehend him does not justify the use of deadly force to do so. It is no doubt unfortunate when a suspect who is in sight escapes, but the fact that the police arrive a little late or are a little slower afoot does not always justify killing the suspect. A police officer may not seize an unarmed, nondangerous suspect by shooting him dead. The Tennessee statute is unconstitutional insofar as it authorizes the use of deadly force against such fleeing suspects.

It is not, however, unconstitutional on its face. Where the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a threat of serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others, it is not constitutionally unreasonable to prevent escape by using deadly force. Thus, if the suspect threatens the officer with a weapon or there is probable cause to believe that he has committed a crime involving the infliction or threatened infliction of serious physical harm, deadly force may be used if necessary to prevent escape, and if, where feasible, some warning has been given. As applied in such circumstances, the Tennessee statute would pass constitutional muster.
​

Applied to this case, the killing of this suspect is very plainly a seizure or arrest and thus required to be objectively reasonable by virtue of Fourth Amendment prohibitions. It also seems self-evident here that (as reported) the suspect -- as viewed by a reasonably cautious and prudent person -- posed a significant risk of "serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others." Thus, as the court noted, "deadly force may be used if necessary to prevent escape, and if, where feasible, some warning has been given."

It's my opinion that warning was feasible in this instance (as reported) but the risk of escape and the risk -- in situ -- of this idiot furthering his stated goal (among other considerations present at the time) did not reasonably require the police to defer to the suspect's preferred timeline or risk any further threat of "serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others," as articulated by the court.

That is good stuff.

Here is a weird hypothetical. What if transcripts of the standoff clearly indicate they thought he was incapable of escaping?
 
I didn't know that. Is it official policy or just "the way things are done"?

There is a catchall category called "Unsuitibility For Service" when you try to enlist when covers a multitude of sins,and membership in a racist organization will, 90% of the time,put you in that category. So you can say it is both an official policy or the way things are done. The recruting officer is allowed a fair degree of discretion when applying the Unsuitable label,but normally you will really have to convince him or her that you were young and foolish when you joined the KKK or the Skinheads...and the recruiters tend to be very skeptical.
The US Military is like a private employer;They can pretty much find a good reason for not hiring you if they really don't want to hire you. The days when the Military were sort of a dumping ground for Juvenile Deliquents are long gone.
 
I'm curious... How many non-hostage situations have warranted a sniper?
It depends what you mean by non hostage. An active shooter situation, where police know the criminal has the intent and ability to endanger more lives can justify a sniper. Charles Whitman would be one example. In this case, the criminal was armed, declaring he would kill more people, well within weapon range of innocent people, taking pot shots at police and claiming to have planted bombs.


While I suppose the "non-hostage" qualifier isn't really necessary, I hope you do realize that nothing you've written here is an answer to my question ("How many...?").
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom