Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

Since when did being in custody automatically mean you committed a crime?

Not saying other people didn't help him. But that's a right dumb way to argue they did. Especially this early in a high profile investigation where the police will aggressively pursue every lead.

You seem to be disagreeing with me over something I haven't said. I didn't say or imply that they have "committed a crime", nor did I argue (in "a right dumb way" or in any other way) that they helped the shooter (whose name is Micah Johnson I believe).
 
You seem to be disagreeing with me over something I haven't said. I didn't say or imply that they have "committed a crime", nor did I argue (in "a right dumb way" or in any other way) that they helped the shooter (whose name is Micah Johnson I believe).
It certainly appeared you implied that there was some connection between his claim to have operated alone and there being people in custody. The seemingly natural inference of that connection being that he didn't operate alone.

Otherwise I'm not sure why you mentioned the two together. I'm sorry to have misunderstood if that wasn't the case.
 
Last edited:
You seem to be disagreeing with me over something I haven't said. I didn't say or imply that they have "committed a crime", nor did I argue (in "a right dumb way" or in any other way) that they helped the shooter (whose name is Micah Johnson I believe).

"If he did it alone, who are these other three people in custody then?"

This could be construed as implying he did not do alone and the person in custody are accomplice.

To answer your question, it is probable that they are people in custody waiting for clarification of identity or maybe caught with other stuff (drug, 237 parking tickets, whatever).

ETA: @tale you said it better than i have
 
Last edited:
France does not have as harsh law as the US, is hardly "homogeneous" (ethnically diverse nation with significant wealth disparities and ethnic tensions - large does tells nothing) , and yet manage a lower crime rate (for violent crime, for petty crime like pick-pocketing or stealing in stores we have more). Heck our lowest criminal age of responsibility is 13 (versus apparentely as low as 6 in USA).

Try again.

For reference, I was talking about Norway. However, France does not have a history of importing a substantial minority for the purpose of slave labour for 2 centuries, then after slavery being abolished, imposes segregation on said minority for a century, and then there's the fun of 50 years of mass incarceration being imposed not only on that, but also a growing hispanic minority.

With the rise of Trump, I think we're only seeing the beginning of renewed ethnic tensions. There are few things more dangerous than a dominant group afraid of losing power and feeling as though it has nothing to lose, exacerbated by growing minority groups (including descendants of slaves) being eager to claim more resources for themselves.
 
It doesn't mean nothing. In competitive target shooting, high-power is a distinct class. For general comparison, small-bore typically shoots at 50 ft distance where high-power is 100 yd. I'm not sure if there is a universal definition, but I assume some sanctioning bodies classify by muzzle velocity. It's been over 20 years since I shot competitively so I don't know the details.

What I know about firearms would fit comfortably on the back of a postage stamp, but...


Isn't it the ammunition that defines the 'power' rather than the rifle, which, ultimately, is just a fancy tube?

No ! Gun is build around ammunition. You can't just use different types. While you can have different loads for the same gun, the power wont vary as much as different types of ammunition.

Anyway I think in news talk, high power rifle means 'it was big'.

In gunner's world, there is full-power cartridge rifle, which uses standard size of the cartridge. Standard here means basically cartridges used in WW1 and mostly in WW2. Common examples are 7.62×51mm, 7.62×54mmR.
Such cartridges (and rifles built around them) are used today mostly for hunting, and in army in machine guns and sniper rifles. Such rifles can be effective up to 1000m and even more.

Opposed to full-power cartridge there is intermediate cartridge, which is smaller or at least shorter. During WW2 soldiers came up with idea, that the full power cartridge is way too strong, and especially way too big. They didn't need 1000m cartridge. 400m was considered enough. So Germans came up with 7.92x33mm (shorter variant of their full-power 7.92x57), Russians came up with 7.62x39, and after the war, US went for 5.56x45, which is not only shorter, but also smaller diameter. Russians later adapted smaller diameter 5.45x39.
These cartridges are smaller, so more can be fit in magazine, they have enough power for military use, and especially, they are more controllable in automatic fire. Intermediate cartridge gave birth of assault rifle, the term is defined as 'rifle with automatic capability firing intermediate cartridge'.

These cartridges (5.56x45) are usually used in the infamous AR15, even though there are many AR-15 variants.

In most US shooting you can expect handgun or semi-auto intermediate cartridge rifle, like AR-15 (which is not assault rifle by definition, because of lack of the full-auto mode).

Gunners may use term 'high power rifle' but they would most likely mean some special hunting cartridge with power even greater then common full-power cartridge.

I'm willing to concede that it may have a legitimate technical definition. I was (and this is the last I'll contribute to this derail) referring to the vernacular as was being used in the thread as it was apparently used on TV news - which I maintain is a term that is intended to have more "oomph" but conveys no information.

Aaaaanyway.....

The local radio afternoon drive DJ, Russ Martin, has a charity for the families of fallen police and fire personnel in Dallas-Fort Worth, if anybody wants to contribute. Here's the link:

http://www.russmartin.fm/donate/
 
For reference, I was talking about Norway. However, France does not have a history of importing a substantial minority for the purpose of slave labour for 2 centuries, then after slavery being abolished, imposes segregation on said minority for a century, and then there's the fun of 50 years of mass incarceration being imposed not only on that, but also a growing hispanic minority.

With the rise of Trump, I think we're only seeing the beginning of renewed ethnic tensions. There are few things more dangerous than a dominant group afraid of losing power and feeling as though it has nothing to lose, exacerbated by growing minority groups (including descendants of slaves) being eager to claim more resources for themselves.

This reek of "we are sooooo special" all country are specials by that . Well sorry we have had a history of importing people from north Africa and treating them like ****, and we had 2 century of colonialism and we *had* slave back in the 19th century in sugar cane colonies. So Yeah. That is not better.

Basically you can try to muck up any excuse you want, the bottom line is that with similar socio cultural wealth and education in OECD country, it is clear that comparing crime rate, longer and harsher punishment have no positive correlation to lower crime rate.
 
...With the rise of Trump, I think we're only seeing the beginning of renewed ethnic tensions. There are few things more dangerous than a dominant group afraid of losing power and feeling as though it has nothing to lose, exacerbated by growing minority groups (including descendants of slaves) being eager to claim more resources for themselves.

I think we are also seeing the waking-up of an oppressed generation. I think it's a kind of cycle: an older generation has a certain relief at the gains they've made from past battles. The newer generation feels those gains less, and eventually will focus on the violations still needing to be confronted.
 
ChristianProgressive;11374954 People in medieval times thought it worked pretty darn well.[/QUOTE said:
Then they were stupid. And if you want to follow medieval thinking in that manner then what does that make you?
 
This reek of "we are sooooo special" all country are specials by that . Well sorry we have had a history of importing people from north Africa and treating them like ****, and we had 2 century of colonialism and we *had* slave back in the 19th century in sugar cane colonies. So Yeah. That is not better.

Basically you can try to muck up any excuse you want, the bottom line is that with similar socio cultural wealth and education in OECD country, it is clear that comparing crime rate, longer and harsher punishment have no positive correlation to lower crime rate.

I didn't know that France had imported Africans to their country on a proto-industrial scale to serve as Chattel for two centuries, before imposing segregation laws on them and economically marginalising them for another century on a legal basis (Look up Lynching, Redlining, Tulsa and Jim Crow). Basically, Black Americans have had a history of being kicked around that is comparable to the Gypsies and the Jews in Europe before the Holocaust. Here's the difference between Europe and the USA: The latter had the equivalent of Apartheid South Africa and Rhodesia as an inherent component, while the former was capable of jettisoning its former colonies when they were either bled dry or the World Wars rendered imperialism unprofitable. When it comes to the question of diversity, I don't think Europe is on the cusp of becoming Minority-Majority in 35 years, which tends to bring its own fun when you have a growing political polarisation. In short, the USA is in for some fun times. And to be perfectly frank, this "Oh, europe has ethnic minorities too, we're just like the USA!" shtick really ignores the deeper nuances. It would be like saying the Rohingyas in Myanmar or the Uighur Muslims in China are like the Turks in Germany.

Meanwhile, China has demonstrated that Harsh Punishments, combined with rehabilitation for drug addicts, can work (FFS, look at Lin Zexu's work before the First Opium War), and Singapore, due to effective and draconian governance since Independence, has a lower crime rate than Norway.
 
Last edited:
It certainly appeared you implied that there was some connection between his claim to have operated alone and there being people in custody. The seemingly natural inference of that connection being that he didn't operate alone.

I have no idea if he acted alone or not. All I have to go on is his alleged insistence that he did. If you have any more information I would be grateful to hear it. Apart from that your attempt at mind-reading is a failure.

Otherwise I'm not sure why you mentioned the two together. I'm sorry to have misunderstood if that wasn't the case.

Apology accepted.

aepervius said:
To answer your question, it is probable that they are people in custody waiting for clarification of identity or maybe caught with other stuff (drug, 237 parking tickets, whatever).

That may well be, but this morning Dallas Police Chief David Brown said police believed the four suspects had worked together to launch the attack, but he did not speculate on a motive for the shootings. He said the people in custody were not cooperating. “We are waiting for the suspects to break,” he said. Link
 
This is about the worst day I've seen since '09 when OPD lost 4 officers in one incident, one a close friend.

My heart goes out to the victims, their families and the departments.
 
For reference, I was talking about Norway. However, France does not have a history of importing a substantial minority for the purpose of slave labour for 2 centuries, then after slavery being abolished, imposes segregation on said minority for a century, and then there's the fun of 50 years of mass incarceration being imposed not only on that, but also a growing hispanic minority.

With the rise of Trump, I think we're only seeing the beginning of renewed ethnic tensions. There are few things more dangerous than a dominant group afraid of losing power and feeling as though it has nothing to lose, exacerbated by growing minority groups (including descendants of slaves) being eager to claim more resources for themselves.

All of which has an effect on crime rates. My point was that severe punishment does not mean low crime.
 
Why the frak not? If our punishments were a bit harsher, we'd have less crime.

As it stands, we have a bunch of cop-haters doing the 9/11 Palestinian dance online about "dead pigs" and justifying the shootings based on alleged improper acts by police.

That crap needs to stop and right now.

Harsher punishments for crimes would lead to a reduction of "cop-haters doing the 9/11 Palestinian dance"?
 
I didn't know that France had imported Africans to their country on a proto-industrial scale to serve as Chattel for two centuries, before imposing segregation laws on them and economically marginalising them for another century on a legal basis (Look up Lynching, Redlining, Tulsa and Jim Crow). Basically, Black Americans have had a history of being kicked around that is comparable to the Gypsies and the Jews in Europe before the Holocaust. Here's the difference between Europe and the USA: The latter had the equivalent of Apartheid South Africa and Rhodesia as an inherent component, while the former was capable of jettisoning its former colonies when they were either bled dry or the World Wars rendered imperialism unprofitable. When it comes to the question of diversity, I don't think Europe is on the cusp of becoming Minority-Majority in 35 years, which tends to bring its own fun when you have a growing political polarisation. In short, the USA is in for some fun times. And to be perfectly frank, this "Oh, europe has ethnic minorities too, we're just like the USA!" shtick really ignores the deeper nuances. It would be like saying the Rohingyas in Myanmar or the Uighur Muslims in China are like the Turks in Germany.

Meanwhile, China has demonstrated that Harsh Punishments, combined with rehabilitation for drug addicts, can work (FFS, look at Lin Zexu's work before the First Opium War), and Singapore, due to effective and draconian governance since Independence, has a lower crime rate than Norway.

All of this is just an excuse to pretend that the absence of correlation found between harsher punishment, longer sentence and criminality rate does not apply to the US. Whatever. Keep ignoring studies and pretend you are special so those studies never apply to you.

ETA: and our ethnic minority encompass 10% of the population as muslim so sorry if I smirk at your "we are so special". There is wider cultural gap between muslim in France and Christian in France than black/white both christian minorities in the US.
 
Last edited:
That may well be, but this morning Dallas Police Chief David Brown said police believed the four suspects had worked together to launch the attack, but he did not speculate on a motive for the shootings. He said the people in custody were not cooperating. “We are waiting for the suspects to break,” he said. Link

Alternatively they know that even if innocent anything can be used against them and they followed the advice that lawyer and even cop tell everyone : shut the hell up and ask if you are under arrest and if you are under arrest ask for a lawyer and shut the hell up.
 
All of this is just an excuse to pretend that the absence of correlation found between harsher punishment, longer sentence and criminality rate does not apply to the US. Whatever. Keep ignoring studies and pretend you are special so those studies never apply to you.

I am pointing out that the reasons for differing criminal justice attitudes in the US and Europe make direct comparisons extremely difficult. As I said above, Europeans seem to think that because we have small ethnic minority groups in our countries (France is ~80% white (Wikipedia)* and the UK is 87% white compared to the USA's 62% BTW), we somehow know more about the world and can directly compare ourselves to other nations. It doesn't work that way. You cannot compare Arab French to Black Americans, you cannot compare German Turks to Chinese Uighurs or Myanmarse Rohingya. The fact of the matter is, if European countries had an ethnic minority with significant presence and historical baggage that Black Americans do, crime rates would be far worse (and there'd be a lot more open racism and other social issues that come with ethnic tensions). For another comparison, look at Mexican immigration to the US, compared to the recent refugee crisis in the Med. Even the Federal government wasn't openly mooting Drone Strikes in Mexico against "coyotes" and drug runners. It's also a fact that more ethnically diverse societies tend to be less trusting, which leads to more problems. Compare Homogenous Japan with more diverse USA.

*French law prohibits ethnicity from being reported in census statistics
 
Last edited:
This is just the third domino. My additional concern is, does it escalate from here? And at what rate? Linear, Fibonacci series, exponential, logarithmic?

My hope is that everyone would take a step back, but my fear, as a warm summer weekend approaches, is that that will not happen.
 
I agree that the escalation is frightening. Cops will be even more jumpy now and so even more inclined to shoot black people.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom