Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

I think my children will grow up in a better world if the perpetrators are brought to justice.

Really?

Of course these perpetrators could not possibly be Islamic fundamentalists could they?

I would like my children brought up in a world free from the garbage you conspirators pump out. A world were people actually recognise and acknowledge cultural differences and rather than dismiss it, acknowledge it, understand it and address it.

Something your children, given your approach,will never do.
 
Last edited:
TS, in a previous post you ask, “Just explain where Reynolds/Rajter are wrong.” Trigood and others pointed out that the Reynolds/Rajter paper is extremely disrespectful to the victims and states that the family members are “in on it”. Yeah, that’s WRONG.

In addition, Reynolds/Rajter states:
1. Flights AA11 and AA77 were not scheduled that day. – WRONG
2. Gag orders were issued to everyone from the FAA to the FDNY. – WRONG
3. Virtually everyone’s view of the towers was blocked. – WRONG
4. Eyewitness (including myself) lied when they said they saw the 2nd plane hit. – WRONG
5. Government and media never produced credible passenger manifests for the flights. – WRONG

And that’s only the WRONGs I picked up after a quick read.





I was referring to their scientific argument involving KE and deceleration. Where is that wrong?
 
I was referring to their scientific argument involving KE and deceleration. Where is that wrong?

The problem is their "scientific argument" is moot. It is so obvious that planes did indeed hit the building that trying to prove it was otherwise the way they are doing it is simply some sick intellectual exorcise. It is totally meaningless and a total waste of everybody’s time.

It's almost akin to someone trying to scientifically prove the sky cannot be blue.
 
Mackey, or someone, straighten Trigood out here. Don't worry Trigood, you don't have to give up the official story to admit your error here.
Don't worry, Truthseeker: I have no problem admitting I may be in error, and seeking out the real deal. I don't subscribe to any "story;" I just use my mind and the things I've learned over the years to reason things out.

I admit that what I said may not technically be accurate, exactly as stated.

I'll grant that you're probably correct in stating that the energy of impact itself could not be "stored" as energy and used in the collapse.

In one sense, I admit that what I said was in error; in another sense, however, I was stating the larger scientific truth that energy can be neither created nor destroyed, as posited in The First Law of Thermodynamics.

We are discussing two different energy sources. The Kinetic energy of the jet crash comes from the jet fuel burning, thrusting the mass of the plane forward. After the crash, when the parts have stopping moving, that energy is spent.
There are more two sources of energy in this system. In addition to the KE, there is also the potential energy of the plane and its contents, which would equal:

~450,000 lbs x 1000 ft (rough est. for NT impact) = 450,000,000 ft-lbs
= 600 x 10^6 joules
= about 1/7th of the estimated KE = 4 x 10^9 joules

There's also the jet fuel. The jet fuel contains ~650 times as much energy (2.6 x 10^12 joules) as was present in the KE of impact (~4 x 10^9 joules). (Numbers in red are exponents; can't figure out how to make 'em superscript.)

By the way, I would highly recommend reading the link above; here, I'll give the link by itself:
http://www.asse.org/prac_spec_analysis_wtc.pdf
It seems very intuitive but also rigorous, so I'm going to look at it thoroughly myself.

The "collapse" is blamed on gravitational energy, turned into kinetic energy when the mass is allowed to fall. This energy is spent when things stop falling and breaking.
The gravitational potential energy can only operate when the forces holding up the building are not sufficient to continue doing so. That happened in this case, because of structural damage from the impact, as well as structural weakening from fires fueled by the 2.6 x 10^12 joules of jet fuel (OK, some burned off outside the building or spilled downstairs, but the great majority stayed in the impact zone, I believe the best science shows), as well as fireproofing getting knocked off by the impact.

I was wrong about the KE translating directly from lateral KE of impact into KE of collapse; however, I was right about the fact that energy is conserved in the larger system, and the work done by the KE (in damage to both structure and fireproofing) aided in the collapse.

There is also energy delivered by the plane in the form of its PE, which directly added to the potential energy of the collapse, as well as the jet fuel delivered by the plane, which clearly aided the collapse by the fires it fueled, which induced structural failure in the steel members.

I'm not aware of any way to store the unspent energy of the plane crash in order to apply it to the "collapse".
Not qua energy. Touche'.

However, are you ready to acknowledge that the entire Reynolds/Ratjer facade is built on a faulty premise, namely, that the KE of the plane at the moment of impact should equal the KE of the plane following its breakup by concrete/steel floors, steel beams, steel trusses, gypsum walls, heavy machinery, heavy furniture, computers, and other objects found within the building?

The KE of impact would be equal to the heat added minus the work done by the system (in this case, the airplane), once again the First Law of Thermodynamics:

(Delta) U = energy added to system = KE(impact) = Q - W

(where Q = heat and W = work)

Since a great deal of KE clearly disappeared into the building (as we can see with our own eyes), and the impact itself probably added but little heat to the building (comparatively speaking; the jet fuel obviously added heat thru fires, but the impact itself added only a fraction of that heat), then a great deal of "work" was done on the building by the KE of impact. That "work" was damage to beams, fireproofing, etc., all of which contributed to the eventual collapse.

Can you not see the absolute logical absurdity of statements such as the following by Reynolds in this paper:

If the plane cannot get through the second half of the building, how could it have gotten through the first half so easily? What KE advocates are saying is, "Four billion joules got the plane through the first three-quarters of the building easily, but 3.8 billion joules could not get it 'no how' through the last quarter of the building." This is ridiculous. KE advocates believe the plane had invincible energy one moment, dropped off by a mere 8 percent and totally fell apart, to never be seen again. This is an impossible theory.
#1, the plane did not, as Gravy says, get thru the first half of the building "so easily." It was work, "hard work," as George Bush likes to say. It impacted floors, walls, steel beams, windows, heavy equipment/furniture, elevators, etc., and in the process no doubt broke up into many smaller pieces. That said, some of those pieces did come out the other end of the building, as can be clearly seen in many videos of the ST impact.

#2, the statement that the KE "dropped off by a mere 8%" is fallacious, as well. It is based on a (probably specious, but let's grant valid, for the sake of argument) calculation of the apparent visible deceleration of the plane on impact. This calculation, however, would not be the total loss of KE on impact. The loss of KE on initial impact with the outer beams of the structure would be minor compared to the loss of KE as the plane delved further into the structure and impacted the aforementioned floors, walls, steel beams, windows, heavy equipment/furniture, elevators, etc., inside the building. Reynolds completely ignores those impacts. How is that scientific, or even logical?

No, TS, this paper deserved to be rejected, even by the Journal of 9/11 Studies.
 
I am sorry but I really cant understand why this amount of time and energy is being used to counter such an obvious troll.
TS is well aware that planes flew into those buildings, he is also well aware of the consequences of such damage.
He is looking for attention and he is getting it, why keep feeding his psychosis?
Its really not doing him any favours in the long run, he needs help that isnt available on this forum.
:mad:

You're quite right. He's a lunatic and an attention whore, as well as a ...



 
By the way, I would highly recommend reading the link above; here, I'll give the link by itself:
http://www.asse.org/prac_spec_analysis_wtc.pdf
It seems very intuitive but also rigorous, so I'm going to look at it thoroughly myself.
Trigood, there are some faulty assumptions in that paper. The weight of the aircraft is far overstated: 450,000 lbs is the max. takeoff weight. The actual weights were about 280,000 lbs, according to NIST (I'm rounding off these numbers). The fuel loads, at about 9,000 gallons, were less than half the maximum. The impact speed on the north tower is about the same as stated at 440 mph, but much higher on the south tower, at over 550 mph.

There is no indication that the steel in the standing towers melted, as the paper states. The steel, especially in the lightweight floor trusses, only had to weaken, not melt, to precipitate the collapses.
 
What brought the buildings down?
• Impact was clearly not the cause...no analysis needed.
• Did the fuel melt/or weaken the structural metal?
–Adiabatic flame temperature of Kerosene = 1727C–Melting temperature of steel = 1570C
–Clearly, at the flame front the Kerosene can melt the steel–Flames billowed out the windows...the tower uses a
structural steel skin...the flame was licking that skin, so the steel melted.
–Even if T was half the flame temp, the metal would creep rapidly, kink a column and buckling failure occurs.


Thomas J. Mackin
Department of Mechanical Engineering
The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Copyright © 2001, Thomas J. Mackin
I think that the reason so many engineers lied about kerosene melting steel is that, in the beginning, a lot of witnesses were reporting "molten metal" and "molten steel" and "molten steel dripping off the ends of beams" and so on. They had to come up with an explanation fast.

It was the truth movement that began pointing out that this is impossible, which led to the abandonment of the "fire melts steel" theory.

Look at the diagrams in this paper. They perfectly match what so many JREF's imagine. The top part of the building falls down on the intact lower structure, which acts like a sledgehammer and powers down through the lower floors. The problem, of course, is that this bears no resemblance to observation.
 
Last edited:
Sure there is. That would be the yellow-to-white hot molten metal pouring out of the south tower before it "collapsed".
Oh, so steel melted, but aluminum, which melts at half the temperature, didn't? What a maroon.
 
Truthseeker,

No person with any knowledge of construction would have assumed the steelwork would have reached melting point before failure.

Rather they would know that the steel would have failed before reaching melting point.

This is not some obscure scientific fact that only came to light after 9/11. The towers themselves, built in the early 70's, had fireprotection applied to the structural steelwork. Why is this protection provided if not to extend the integrity of the structure in the event of a fire.

The same is true for virtually all steel structures built around the world, because the dangers of steel failure during fire are well known and understood, and they have nothing to do with 'melting'.
 
Truthseeker,

No person with any knowledge of construction would have assumed the steelwork would have reached melting point before failure.

Rather they would know that the steel would have failed before reaching melting point.

This is not some obscure scientific fact that only came to light after 9/11. The towers themselves, built in the early 70's, had fireprotection applied to the structural steelwork. Why is this protection provided if not to extend the integrity of the structure in the event of a fire.

The same is true for virtually all steel structures built around the world, because the dangers of steel failure during fire are well known and understood, and they have nothing to do with 'melting'.

Correct. That is how we know that the kindly professor Mackin was lying, not mistaken.
 
Oh, so steel melted, but aluminum, which melts at half the temperature, didn't? What a maroon.

I never said that. The problem is, how do you get material up to white (or even yellow) temperatures in an office fire? Mackin, Wise, and several others say kerosene does it. We don't believe them, but it is clear why so many of these guys had to come out and try to pitch the idea. The reason is that we observe molten metal before and after the "collapses".

Forget melted for a moment, what about the evaporated steel reported by Barnett? Or is that one flushed down the memory hole?
 
This would prove it to me. Passengers. Yes. Passengers exited the building and came out the other side. Hmmmmmm. Ok.

Really?

Everybody here is just really salivating to prove it to you.

Prove what? That reality exists!
 
I never said that. The problem is, how do you get material up to white (or even yellow) temperatures in an office fire? Mackin, Wise, and several others say kerosene does it. We don't believe them, but it is clear why so many of these guys had to come out and try to pitch the idea. The reason is that we observe molten metal before and after the "collapses".

Forget melted for a moment, what about the evaporated steel reported by Barnett? Or is that one flushed down the memory hole?
All been dealt with here before, TS. You know that, and you know it doesn't support your theories. Use the search function.

Now, care to explain how fires as intense as those in the towers, on the floors where the collapses initiated, fit into any demolition scenario? Think about the WTC 2 corner photo I just posted in Christophera's thread. It was burning that hot from the moment the plane hit. Just a coincidence that the collapse started where the exterior columns were bowing in on both towers, on the floors that were on fire? Can you describe the history of controlled demolitions of buildings that were burning furiously?
 
No, that ain't it. I (and millions) have become convinced that 9/11 was an inside job. I have kids. I think my children will grow up in a better world if the perpetrators are brought to justice.

Great. So put on your army gear, and head for the mountains of Afghanistan/Pakistan. let me know when you have OBL in custody...

TAM:D
 
Sorry, OBL is not wanted for 9/11, because there is no hard evidence. Ask the FBI.
So why hasn't someone in the FBI blown the whistle on that fact? Can you find a single person in the FBI who will state that "there is no evidence" of OBL's involvement in 9/11? Bet you can't!
 
Sorry, OBL is not wanted for 9/11, because there is no hard evidence. Ask the FBI.
More proof that you're full of [rule 8]:
[SIZE=-1]The alleged terrorists on this list have been indicted by sitting Federal Grand Juries in various jurisdictions in the United States for the crimes reflected on their wanted posters. Evidence was gathered and presented to the Grand Juries, which led to their being charged. The indictments currently listed on the posters allow them to be arrested and brought to justice. Future indictments may be handed down as various investigations proceed in connection to other terrorist incidents, for example, the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001.[/SIZE]

How does it feel to be so consistently wrong?
​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom