Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

What are you hoping to achieve by showing that what you say is the case, is in fact the case?
 
You must see much more detail than I see.


The resolution is far from great.

Most of the visible damage in the clear, lower right pictures is the facade, and need not indicate damage to columns backing it, although I expect that damage to be considerable.

Remember the wings of a jetliner are built around a huge aluminum beam called the main spar, which is designed to support the aircraft through (typically for passenger planes) up to 4 G's of maneuver, and also handles most of the drag at speeds of up to 0.8 Mach. Yet it's thin-walled and light, meaning it's capable of smacking into an object very hard, but then disintegrates rapidly once its structural integrity is gone.

The wings are also backed by 20,000 pounds of fuel or more in this case (I recall ~5,000 gallons at least in the wing tanks).

So imagine being clocked by a giant aluminum baseball bat, backed by a medium-size swimming pool of flammable liquid moving close to the speed of sound. It's going to leave a mark.

But it's also going to give up its energy quickly. The aluminum aircraft won't stay intact for long, and the rush of liquid will dump nearly all of its energy as it swirls all around the building's internal structure. This is why some of it punched out the other side (as your lower right picture shows), but most of it remains captured in the structure. Pretty simple to understand, really.

Perhaps there is a better picture of the hole in WTC2. Can anyone find one?

So where exactly do Reynolds/Rajter go wrong?
 
The calculations are provided in Reynolds/Rajter, the very subject of this thread. Perhaps you should read it prior to posting on this thread.

Zoiks! Appendix A of that nutbar article is a doozy! If Websters ever need a definition of "junk science" I could think of no better article to qoute then this gem below.

For my own analysis, I decided to use the widely known Scott Myers camera pictures, so I didn't have to worry about compression issues, frame rates, etc. I found the highest resolution version I could get my hands on in order to minimize loss or measurement precision. The 15-picture spread was (allegedly) taken using fixed 0.033 second intervals, features a nearly fixed camera angle, and has a fairly decent contrast on key plane features. Thus, it is perfectly suited for frame-by-frame analysis, one of the best videos in terms of high signal-to-noise ratio.

Words fail.


One of the major oddities of all WTC2 videos is the apparent lack of plane deceleration from many of the observed camera angles. The plane seems to fly in effortlessly, but then comes to a complete stop while inside (apparently violating conservation of momentum and energy). To the layman, these two conservation laws mean we should expect TWO major sources of slowdown when one object penetrates another:

The bolding part of that article reveals to me the author's lack of forensic capabilites. We have no way of determining with 100% accuracy the exact manner in which the plane traveled inside the tower. Portions of the plane, such as the engines, most likely broke apart and took on their own flight trajectory. Why does the author ignores the building steel tube core?

Anyone know exactly what force the curtain wall was designed to withstand? I know that it was designed to withstand the impact of wayward 707 flying at approach speed (roughly 100 mph). What factor of safety was thrown in to achieve this? I know that the curtain wall functioned to hold up the building skin. What percentage of the curtain wall was glass?
 
Just explain where Reynolds/Rajter are wrong. I refer to their argument that if entry required only 5% of KE, then the plane would cut all the way through.

Even Steven Jones's review team found errors in the paper. Start with those and get back to me if you have further questions.

Regarding the "cut all the way through" remark, it is true (as shown in the ubiquitous Greening, pp. 10-11) that the aircraft had enough kinetic energy to cut all of the columns on a single floor by a considerable margin. However, that assumes a 100% efficient process.

As your picture shows, the aircraft hit multiple floors. It also hit plenty of things other than the columns -- some energy is ablated by the building's exterior, some goes into destroying office furniture and drywall, some is lost compressing the interior of the entire building, some is lost making the entire building sway, and some flies clean through and out the other side. Greening treats this in some detail.

Furthermore, as dictated by the Laws of Thermodynamics, we may expect the overall efficiency of this operation to be very low. It happened very quickly and involved an enormous increase in entropy. 100% efficient processes are reversible processes, viz. ones that happen slowly and incrementally. The airliner crashes are the exact opposites.

Again, what happened is precisely what I would expect. And I have seen no incredulity from anyone -- anyone at all -- with experience or training in relevant subjects.
 
I would expect the fragile nose to crumple as it hit. I would expect the wings to break. I would expect some parts to bounce off and stay outside the building. In short, I would not expect the entire plane to enter the building.
If you are serious, then why do you expect these things? If you think that what happened is unusual, then you must have a reason to expect that something else should have happened. You've told us what you think should have happened. But why do you believe that? What facts and physical laws support your beliefs?

Again, how do you expect to see those details from a low-resolution handheld video, when the entire plane enters the building in a fifth of a second? Please explain how the video could capture the details of such an event. (Note: this will require you to learn some things about video.)

Observe the famous video of the military test where they smashed the plane into the concrete wall. 100% of the plane stayed outside the wall.
Duuuuuuude, it was a 12-foot-thick reinforced concrete wall! The whole point of it was to keep the plane outside!

Next, calculate the difference in kinetic energy between the Sandia Labs F-4 and flight 175 traveling at 500 kts. Report back with your results.

Complete deceleration was observed. In this case, the exact opposite happened. True, the WTC tower was a grid, not a solid surface. I have no problem seeing how the plane would go through the windows. The parts that impacted vertical columns, and especially those parts that impacted floors edge-on, I would think would slow down.
They did.

However, if my expectations are wrong, there is still a problem. Assume the plane is strong enough and going fast enough to bust right through the walls and floors, as is appears. How then does it stop inside the building? If it is strong enough to enter so effortlessly, and spend only 5% of KE, then it could easily sail right on through.
Bolding mine. You keep saying effortlessly. That is completely wrong. The plane breaks into thousands of pieces on entry. It takes work to break an aircraft into thousands of pieces. Get it?

The plane at WTC2 mostly missed the core, as evidenced by the huge fireball exiting the east face.
False. The core was only 35 feet from the south wall of the south tower. Flight 175 slammed directly into it.

Why don't plane parts come out?
They do. Thousands of them, large and small. Mother of suffering Ed, TruthSeeker1234, I thought you had seen photos and videos of the crash? You don't see the debris being ejected? You don't see the flaming,smoking trails of debris? Are you blind?

If you have these questions, why are you unwilling to do the slightest research to find out the answers? Just read the eyewitness accounts.

I've seen no evidence of any plane parts at WTC, except a landing gear under the scaffolding, and a piece of fuselage with windows. And one unburned passport.
Where have you looked? Anyone with five minutes of time and an internet connection can easily find everything you say you're looking for. Why can't you be bothered to look? And why do you always want US to research YOUR idiotic claims?

8790454ce9862185f.jpg


8790454ce985cf9d1.jpg

​
 
Last edited:


This has better resolution I believe. Although, I think it is the other impact...not sure.

TAM
 
Ongoing searches of birth, death and marriage records suggest many passenger names were fake.6 Families of air crash victims remain oddly silent, suspicious behavior as government lies and evades while dissatisfied families of ground zero victims are outspoken.7 Searches fail to show hull insurance paid on the four jetliners despite the small number of insurers in the industry. Then we have missing airport surveillance video tapes, an incredible string of 19 airport security/screening failures, flights disappearing from conventional radar, missing flight data (fdr) and cockpit voice recorders (cvr), gag orders on FAA flight controllers-military-firefighters-police-airline-employees, physically impossible cell phone calls8 with fake dialogue9 ("I see water and buildings. Oh my God! Oh my God!" "Hello, mom. This is your son, Mark Bingham"), not to mention the technical inability of the purported Arabs to pilot the planes as advertised. Nothing checks out in the official account about the alleged flights. Controlled media naturally steer a wide berth from these problems in favor of canonizing the Official Government Conspiracy Theory (OGCT) and ridiculing the Alternative Conspiracy Theory (ACT).

These guys are axxholes.
 
I find this whole discussion ◊◊◊◊◊ ridicolous. Two security video's at the Pentagon are not enough to convince the nutters a plane crashed there, they want more video's, that show a plane entering the building. On the other hand, dozens of photo's and video's of planes crashing into the WTC are not proof either. What the hell??

When the hell are the nutters satified with the evidence provided to them?
 
If I told you this world wasnt real, how much would it take to convince you...alot. Probably no amount of convincing would do it. Same for these delusional idiots. In their world, the WTC plane crashes had to be faked, or their world comes crashing down, so no matter what you show them, they will not be convinced.

They make for a great way to divide and conquer their stupid silly movement though.

tAM
 
It is so funny. I thought Jone's paper was a pile of silly dung...then this paper comes along, and my god, Jones looks like einstein next to it.

TAM
 
Correct. I observe no damage of any kind to the plane which entered WTC2. No twisting. No bending. No breaking. No slowing. I'm going to make a still picture of a frame I find very interesting.

Really TS?

I take you observe planes flying into tall buildings at high speed regularly then?

I am just lost at what to write,to summarise the sheer scale of your stupidity.
 
Last edited:
I've seen a landing gear, and a piece of fuselage with windows. Perhaps you can link us to pictures of the thousands of plane parts. Did they ever match up serial numbers on any of those parts? No, I wasn't aware that larger body parts of passengers and building occupants were strewn everywhere. Links?
Why do you demand "thousands" of plane parts? Why is that necessary to prove a plane existed? Wouldn't it make sense that much of the plane would get broken up inside the tower, when impacting floors, walls, elevators, electrical system/machinery, stairwells, office furniture, etc.?

For the same reasons, you should not demand "larger body parts of passengers and building occupants." Do you have any idea how much damage all that KE you're so fond of talking about can do? It can atomize things and people.

But for the record, there is at least one account of a witness seeing a body in an airline seat on the plaza between the towers. This witness saw this while exiting the North tower. I am positive that a witness said this in a book I read recently, because one doesn't forget a detail like this. However, I have read so many books lately that I can't be sure which one. It was possibly 102 Minutes, or else Report from Ground Zero. Or it might have been some other book -- sorry, I'm not sure. But I definitely read it.

As for the planes, a gentleman named Stan Praimnath, who worked on the 81st floor of the south tower was glancing out his window and saw an airliner coming straight at the building (and him). He barely escaped with his life. Was holographic imaging equipment placed in his window prior to the event? Note that following impact, he also clearly sees an airplane wing within 20 feet of him. Imaging equipment? Links:

http://stanleypraimnath.com/1.htm

Fifteen minutes later, he is retrieving phone messages when a red-orange flash catches his eye. Outside his window, flames cough black smoke as a result of American Airlines Flight 11 plunging into the WTC north tower next door. Praimnath puts down the phone.
Watching fireballs fall to the ground, Praimnath tries unsuccessfully to call his boss in the north tower.
"Go, go, go," he says to Delise, a temporary worker, the only other person around. "Let’s get out of here."
They rush to the 78th-floor sky lobby to catch an express elevator down and are joined by three top Fuji executives. At ground level they are met by a security guard. "Don’t leave the building," the guard says. "A plane accidentally hit the north tower; you’ll be safer inside because of falling debris."

Praimnath and the executives return to the elevator, but Praimnath, sensing uneasiness in his soul, sends Delise home. The three other men head off to their departments. Praimnath will never see them again.
As Praimnath enters his office, his phone is ringing. A friend from Chicago asks Praimnath if he heard about the north tower being hit. He assures her all is fine.
But all is not fine. It is 9:03 a.m. and United Airlines Flight 175 is staring him in the face.
"Suddenly I see this big gray airplane with red letters on the wing and tail filling my window," Praimnath says. "It’s coming right at me."
Praimnath drops the phone and tucks under his desk in a fetal position as the plane obliterates the wall. The impact is a prolonged, gut-wrenching screech, a hideous, metallic roar. "It sounded like a huge steel cage being ripped apart," Praimnath recalls. Intense smoke and soot punctuate the agonizing explosion.

Then silence.

A flame interrupts the awful blackness, revealing a protruding aircraft wing blocking the exit only 20 feet away. I’m going to die, Praimnath thinks. Yet he cries out to God.
"Lord, help me," he prays, trying to stand. "I can’t do this by myself. I don’t want to die. I want to see my two little girls." Tears spill from squinting eyes as he realizes he is buried shoulder deep in debris. A nail pierces his right hand. Pain sears his body.
http://www.ctv.ca/special/sept11/hubs/canadian/ctv_lopes_survivors.html

"I saw this giant airplane," Praimnath says. "I saw it coming towards me at eye-level ... and I'm frozen. I drop the phone and I screamed and I don't know why but I said: 'Lord. I can't do this - you take over!' and I just dove under my desk."
The book Before and After: Stories from New York has many eyewitness accounts. Just glancing through it, I found witnesses to both the first and second airline hits. Here's the first:

From a man, Charles Waters, standing on the Plaza before the first tower was struck (p 13 of Before and After):

As he spoke [he was talking to his father on his cellphone], I turned slowly, for no reason, and saw an airplane wing extended out from the bulding above me. An explosion, Then smoke, Then everything was frozen, very still, a perfect New York blue sky above a backdrop of explosions.

"Oh my God, Dad..." I was still on the phone, not realizing what I was saying. "I think ... [rule8], a plane ust hit the building!"
Note also, Praimnath's (above) description of the impact of the plane: "It sounded like a huge steel cage being ripped apart." This is more like a crash than an explosion.

Let's imagine there were no "Big Boeings." What does Mssrs. Reynolds and Ratjer imagine caused the damage and how did the sorcerers get all these people to hallucinate that they saw large passenger planes crashing into the towers, sometimes within mere feet of themselves?

I also think that it's funny how there's too much energy, in the opinion of Reynolds et al., for the airplanes to behave as they did, but for most CTers, there's too little energy in the system to allow for the collapse of the towers to happen as they did, so they have to add more explosives into the mix. One wonders if eventually, the CTers will have to pick one story and stick with it.
 
Last edited:
I also think that it's funny how there's too much energy, in the opinion of Reynolds et al., for the airplanes to behave as they did, but for most CTers, there's too little energy in the system to allow for the collapse of the towers to happen as they did, so they have to add more explosives into the mix. One wonders if eventually, the CTers will have to pick one story and stick with it.

The impact of the planes and the "collapses" of the towers are two different things altogether.

The "story" should be repeatedly changed until it is consistent with all the data. The "official story" has changed many times, for example.
 
It is so funny. I thought Jone's paper was a pile of silly dung...then this paper comes along, and my god, Jones looks like einstein next to it.

TAM
It is impossible to overestimate the stupidity of the "truth" movement.
 
The impact of the planes and the "collapses" of the towers are two different things altogether.

The "story" should be repeatedly changed until it is consistent with all the data. The "official story" has changed many times, for example.
It has, and it is. Although those changes haven't been nearly as sweeping as you might think. Pancake vs. progressive is the only big one I can think of.

C'mon, Alex, this isn't that hard to figure out. You have to actually look for problems, and immediately assume it's more likely for the entire scientific establishment to have made a mistake than yourself, in order to be so consistently wrong as you've proven to be.
 
The impact of the planes and the "collapses" of the towers are two different things altogether.
Yes, but both events happened in the same time/space continuum. You see the problem with claiming there is both too much and too little energy?

Any "excess" energy from the plane crashes could be "utilized" in the collapse of the towers, in other words.

The "story" should be repeatedly changed until it is consistent with all the data. The "official story" has changed many times, for example.
Um, I think the no-planers are ignoring quite a bit of data. Thousands of eyewitness accounts, for one thing.

There is no "official story." Who has released an "official story"? You are using the meme of an "official story" to marginalize the views of the vast majority of people who think, talk, and write about 9/11. As James Meigs says in "The Conspiracy Industry":

http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/research/4199607.html

Marginalization of Opposing Views

The 9/11 Truth Movement invariably describes the mainstream account of 9/11 as the “government version” or “the official version.” In fact, the generally accepted account of 9/11 is made up of a multitude of sources: thousands of newspaper, TV, and radio reports produced by journalists from all over the world; investigations conducted by independent organizations and institutions, including the American Society of Civil Engineers, Purdue University, Northwestern University, Columbia University, the National Fire Protection Association, and Underwriters Laboratories, Inc.; eyewitness testimony from literally thousands of people; recordings and transcripts of phone calls, air traffic control transmissions, and other communications; thousands of photographs; thousands of feet of video footage; and, let’s not forget the words of Osama bin Laden, who discussed the operation in detail on more than one occasion, including in an audio recording released in May 2006 that said: “I am responsible for assigning the roles of the 19 brothers to conduct these conquests . . .”

The mainstream view of 9/11 is, in other words, a vast consensus. By presenting it instead as the product of a small coterie of insiders, conspiracists are able to ignore facts they find inconvenient and demonize people with whom they disagree.
An "official version" only makes sense if we had an agency such as Tass had in the days of the Soviet Union. The man on the street expected that 90% of what came out of Tass was untrue. Today, the man on the street knows that 90% of the common consensus is true. Big difference between your common bloke's attitude toward an "official story" and a consensus. Please don't confuse them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom