Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

Other terrorist attacks?

from the FBI site:

The alleged terrorists on this list have been indicted by sitting Federal Grand Juries in various jurisdictions in the United States for the crimes reflected on their wanted posters. Evidence was gathered and presented to the Grand Juries, which led to their being charged. The indictments currently listed on the posters allow them to be arrested and brought to justice. Future indictments may be handed down as various investigations proceed in connection to other terrorist incidents, for example, the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001.

Who's the first person under that list of fugitives, TruthinessSeeker?

Osama.

And from Osama's very own page...

An additional $2 million is being offered through a program developed and funded by the Airline Pilots Association and the Air Transport Association.

Hmm, airplane pilots and air transport associates are offering $2 million themselves for Osama's capture. I wonder why that is...

Your implication that Osama is not wanted in connection with the September 11th attacks is asinine. Your continued insistence on this point shows an obstinate streak that belies your own claimed "openmindedness" on these issues. I will continue to assume that you actually believe the FBI isn't looking for Osama because of the 9/11 attacks, but it would actually be more charitable to your intellect to attribute this obstinance to a regretable sense of humor.
 
Perhaps I can help us communicate a little more effectively. You misunderstand the importance of looking at decelration. Energy is not "spent" causing deceleration. Rather, deceleration is a symptom of energy being spent. A moving object which transfers energy must lose speed, in proportion to the energy transferred.

Thus, it is not appropriate for you to consider the energy sinks, and add them to the deceleration. Looking at the deceleration, by itself, is a way of totalling the energy sinks. The amount of energy spent will be directly reflected in the amount of deceleration.
I literally do not know what you're talking about. I did not consider energy sinks, whatever they are. I merely calculated the energy that the plane delivered to the tower in terms of (1) the plane's potential energy (the energy the plane encompassed as a result of its height above the ground), and (2) the fuel on board. These calculations were merely to show conservation of energy (First Law) and how the plane's impact contributed to tower collapse. It was an illustration of how the whole event (crash and collapse) was one event in the time/space continuum and was to counter your assertion that the energy of impact could not impact the collapse. I was merely trying to show that, although the actual impact energy did not go into the actual collapse energy directly, the impact of the plane had other energetic results. Those calculations did not relate at all to my deceleration argument.

Now to return to that deceleration argument: Here is a further explication of the butter = aluminum analogy scenario. This scenario encompasses both of my objections to Reynolds's deceleration premise, but especially the latter that I discussed in the response to Gravy (i.e., that deceleration of the back end of the plane on entry constitutes the only loss of KE that can be attributed to the initial impact*):

Imagine a knife, standing upright on a stand, blade pointing outward and immobilized. This knife is not going to move, nohow. (This knife represents a massive steel column on the outside of the tower).

Then imagine throwing a block of soft butter (representing the aluminum fuselage of the plane), at the knife. Imagine some immense force propelling the butter thru the knife blade. The back "end" of the butter block will not decelerate significantly prior to being cut by the knife. Nevertheless, the block of butter will have a certain amount of KE on impact which shall be lessened by the impact.

Now imagine a whole bunch of knives lined up with blades outward (representing all the beams on the outside of the tower), and a large block of butter being thrown with great force at them. Again, the back side of the butter block will not significantly decelerate on impact of the front side of the butter block. Nevertheless, after passing thru the knives, the butter block will be significantly changed by impact. In fact, it will be cut into a lot of smaller pieces, each with a smaller KE (which is a direct function of mass). These smaller pieces will each be significantly more susceptible to loss of KE because their size is so much smaller and they can thereby be impacted and slowed much easier.

Thus, the lack of deceleration of the back end of the butter block (the airplane) cannot be taken as any indication of the final state of the butter block (airplane). In the same way, Reynolds is wrong to assume the same about the airplane.

There are two issues here: The final structure of the butter block and its KE. The butter block will be dashed to a lot of smaller pieces by passing thru the knives. The sum total of the KEs of these pieces would be hard to determine (same goes for airplane parts after passing thru the wall of the tower). One might say, initially, that the sum of the KEs of the pieces might approximate the initial KE of the butter block. However, each of these pieces will lose KE much more easily than would the overall structure. Issues of entropy enter here. I don't claim to understand all the math, but clearly disorganized pieces flying in all directions are easier to slow down and stop than a large and complex structure flying in one direction.

In other words, Reynolds takes no account of the tensile strength of the aluminum fuselage of the airplane (soft butter is just a good example of a material with little tensile strength). Nor does he consider the change in velocity and mass of the pieces into which the initial impact of the plane will render it.

Now for the first argument I made in my post to you: Imagine all sorts of other features (knives, tools, etc.) standing up behind the knives. The butter block pieces (which resulted from the initial impact with the knives) will quickly, during impact with those other features, be cut into a million pieces. The exact KE of each of those pieces will be unknown, but it can be guessed that as the butter block breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces, they will lose KE much more rapidly (KE varies directly with mass).

The same goes for airplane pieces breaking down into smaller and smaller pieces by impacts with floors, steel beams, walls, heavy electrical equipment, etc. etc.

Now, on "seeing" planes. Yes, we all saw the plane hitting the south tower. I also saw real live dinosaurs at Jurrassic park. I also, just today, saw a magical changing label on the football field that said "3rd and 7" with an arrow and lines.

The question is whether it was faked in real time. I admit this would be very difficult and risky. I am not at all convinced that the no-planers are right. Not at all. I'm just be a skeptic. In the tradition of James Randi.
Others have answered these as well as I could.

*ETA: Actually, Reynolds makes the ridiculous assertion that the initial loss of KE on impact merely with the side of the tower (as reflected by deceleration) represents the total loss of KE in the plane's entire impact with the tower, but let's be generous. Also, I deal with this issue in my second argument.
 
Last edited:
I literally do not know what you're talking about. I did not consider energy sinks, whatever they are. I merely calculated the energy that the plane delivered to the tower in terms of (1) the plane's potential energy (the energy the plane encompassed as a result of its height above the ground), and (2) the fuel on board. These calculations were merely to show conservation of energy (First Law) and how the plane's impact contributed to tower collapse. It was an illustration of how the whole event (crash and collapse) was one event in the time/space continuum and was to counter your assertion that the energy of impact could not impact the collapse. I was merely trying to show that, although the actual impact energy did not go into the actual collapse energy directly, the impact of the plane had other energetic results. Those calculations did not relate at all to my deceleration argument.

Now to return to that deceleration argument: Here is a further explication of the butter = aluminum analogy scenario. This scenario encompasses both of my objections to Reynolds's deceleration premise, but especially the latter that I discussed in the response to Gravy (i.e., that deceleration of the back end of the plane on entry constitutes the only loss of KE that can be attributed to the initial impact*):

Imagine a knife, standing upright on a stand, blade pointing outward and immobilized. This knife is not going to move, nohow. (This knife represents a massive steel column on the outside of the tower).

Then imagine throwing a block of soft butter (representing the aluminum fuselage of the plane), at the knife. Imagine some immense force propelling the butter thru the knife blade. The back "end" of the butter block will not decelerate significantly prior to being cut by the knife. Nevertheless, the block of butter will have a certain amount of KE on impact which shall be lessened by the impact.

Now imagine a whole bunch of knives lined up with blades outward (representing all the beams on the outside of the tower), and a large block of butter being thrown with great force at them. Again, the back side of the butter block will not significantly decelerate on impact of the front side of the butter block. Nevertheless, after passing thru the knives, the butter block will be significantly changed by impact. In fact, it will be cut into a lot of smaller pieces, each with a smaller KE (which is a direct function of mass). These smaller pieces will each be significantly more susceptible to loss of KE because their size is so much smaller and they can thereby be impacted and slowed much easier.

Thus, the lack of deceleration of the back end of the butter block (the airplane) cannot be taken as any indication of the final state of the butter block (airplane). In the same way, Reynolds is wrong to assume the same about the airplane.

There are two issues here: The final structure of the butter block and its KE. The butter block will be dashed to a lot of smaller pieces by passing thru the knives. The sum total of the KEs of these pieces would be hard to determine (same goes for airplane parts after passing thru the wall of the tower). One might say, initially, that the sum of the KEs of the pieces might approximate the initial KE of the butter block. However, each of these pieces will lose KE much more easily than would the overall structure. Issues of entropy enter here. I don't claim to understand all the math, but clearly disorganized pieces flying in all directions are easier to slow down and stop than a large and complex structure flying in one direction.

In other words, Reynolds takes no account of the tensile strength of the aluminum fuselage of the airplane (soft butter is just a good example of a material with little tensile strength). Nor does he consider the change in velocity and mass of the pieces into which the initial impact of the plane will render it.

Now for the first argument I made in my post to you: Imagine all sorts of other features (knives, tools, etc.) standing up behind the knives. The butter block pieces (which resulted from the initial impact with the knives) will quickly, during impact with those other features, be cut into a million pieces. The exact KE of each of those pieces will be unknown, but it can be guessed that as the butter block breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces, they will lose KE much more rapidly (KE varies directly with mass).

The same goes for airplane pieces breaking down into smaller and smaller pieces by impacts with floors, steel beams, walls, heavy electrical equipment, etc. etc.

Now consider your butter through knives example. Except there are two rows of knives, one behind the other. The butter hits the first row, and passes, just as you describe. After hitting the first row, the butter has been divided into pieces matching the distance between the knives, but is still travelling very fast, because it did not decelerate very much at all, as you describe.

Now the butter encounters the second row of knives.

What happens?
 
Now the butter encounters the second row of knives.

What happens?

This.

8790454ce985cf9d1.jpg


8790454ce9862185f.jpg

​
 
Does anybody have a link to the video of the plane impact that shows the stuff coming out the back side? I know I've seen it and I can't find it. It shows both the approach of the plane and the ejection.

Appreciate.
 
What I remember is that they analyzed it was something before the real impact but it's a CT movie of course... I've made a mistake I thought Greening asked that question but it was NIST who asked that a long time ago and Greening gave some public comments, this is the article that explains the metal collision events I believe

http://www.mms.gov/tarprojects/405.htm
 
Does anybody have a link to the video of the plane impact that shows the stuff coming out the back side? I know I've seen it and I can't find it. It shows both the approach of the plane and the ejection.

Appreciate.

Google video or YouTube

Go and find it yourself! For once...
 
Their numbers show exactly what one should expect--immeasurable deceleration of the tail of the plane even as the nose decelerates rapidly.

Remember that video I showed you?

As soon as the impact begins, the front of the plane decelerates rapidly, but the violence of it decouples it from the rear of the plane, which has not yet measurably experienced the impact.

All but the smallest fraction of the deceleration of the tail happens not from compression against the front portions of the plane, but from impacting stationary objects (i.e., the building).

The animations here ( http://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/cmh/simulation/phase3/ ) give a good insight into the dynamics involved.
:bump4 for Ace, because although this concept has been described in several ways by several posters, Ace still demonstrates that he doesn't understand it.
 
Now for the first argument I made in my post to you: Imagine all sorts of other features (knives, tools, etc.) standing up behind the knives. The butter block pieces (which resulted from the initial impact with the knives) will quickly, during impact with those other features, be cut into a million pieces. The exact KE of each of those pieces will be unknown, but it can be guessed that as the butter block breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces, they will lose KE much more rapidly (KE varies directly with mass).

The same goes for airplane pieces breaking down into smaller and smaller pieces by impacts with floors, steel beams, walls, heavy electrical equipment, etc. etc.
Now consider your butter through knives example. Except there are two rows of knives, one behind the other. The butter hits the first row, and passes, just as you describe. After hitting the first row, the butter has been divided into pieces matching the distance between the knives, but is still travelling very fast, because it did not decelerate very much at all, as you describe.

Now the butter encounters the second row of knives.

What happens?
Oops. Guess you should have read the whole post.
Now for the first argument I made in my post to you: Imagine all sorts of other features (knives, tools, etc.) standing up behind the knives. The butter block pieces (which resulted from the initial impact with the knives) will quickly, during impact with those other features, be cut into a million pieces. The exact KE of each of those pieces will be unknown, but it can be guessed that as the butter block breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces, they will lose KE much more rapidly (KE varies directly with mass).

The same goes for airplane pieces breaking down into smaller and smaller pieces by impacts with floors, steel beams, walls, heavy electrical equipment, etc. etc.
To make the analogy more complete, imagine that the butter is deforming and breaking some of the cutlery during impact.
 
Last edited:
Oops. Guess you should have read the whole post.

To make the analogy more complete, imagine that the butter is deforming and breaking some of the cutlery during impact.


So you mean, some of those heavy bits of debris such as engines and landing gear would somehow become detached from the rest of the lightweight aircraft structure after impact with the perimeter columns and then somehow continue their journey into the building, destroying other structural elements as they crash through, whereas the lightweight elements of the disintegrating aircraft would crash less effectively against internal elements of the structure as their mass was insufficient to carry them through the building now that they are unconnected to the heavy elements?

Now, if that isn't a raging clue........
 
Now consider your butter through knives example. Except there are two rows of knives, one behind the other. The butter hits the first row, and passes, just as you describe. After hitting the first row, the butter has been divided into pieces matching the distance between the knives, but is still travelling very fast, because it did not decelerate very much at all, as you describe.

Now the butter encounters the second row of knives.

What happens?
It depends on how far apart the rows of knives are, whether the two rows of knives match in distance between knives, how fast the butter is traveling initially, and with what orientation toward the row of knives.

If the butter is not initially traveling perpendicular to the row of knives, it would not hit the second row in any defined fashion, and the second row would simply break it up into smaller pieces.

If the butter was initially traveling perpendicular to the row of knives, it is conceivable that some of the pieces would travel thru the second row of knives relatively intact. However, many of the pieces would probably go awry somehow, shearing off in different directions due to minute imperfections in the knives' orientation that would lead to deflections, and thus would be cut into by the second row of knives as well.

Gee, that was an interesting intellectual exercise. If you're implying that it has anything to do with what happened on 9/11, though, you're sadly mistaken. There were not only the outer beams of the towers for the planes to go through.

What is also interesting to me is how Reynolds makes an argument that is logically (as well as scientifically) falacious: He uses certain visual evidence (measuring deceleration from the video of the plane's impact) to (try to) disprove other visual evidence (plane impacting tower). As another example, he uses certain visual evidence (a plane not seen exiting the other side of the tower) to, once again (try to) disprove other visual evidence (plane impacting tower). In other words, some visual evidence, taken on its face, is used to prove that we shouldn't take other visual evidence on its face. It's all very Byzantine and sort of hurts my head to think about.

But, all in all, pretty fun and easy to debunk.

Someone should write a paper refuting Reynolds, claiming that the plane really did exit the other side of the tower, but it was masked using cloaking technology (or some such). That would be taken to prove that Reynolds is wrong and there really were planes.

Have to say: :D
 
So you mean, some of those heavy bits of debris such as engines and landing gear would somehow become detached from the rest of the lightweight aircraft structure after impact with the perimeter columns and then somehow continue their journey into the building, destroying other structural elements as they crash through, whereas the lightweight elements of the disintegrating aircraft would crash less effectively against internal elements of the structure as their mass was insufficient to carry them through the building now that they are unconnected to the heavy elements?

Now, if that isn't a raging clue........
Good points. Reynolds completely ignores the breakup of the plane, which begins upon initial impact with the side of the tower, and continues as the plane continues to insert itself into the tower. This is why economists are not supposed to do physics. :)
 
And physicists probably make lousy economists...just imagine them trying to explain 'overheating the economy' or 'balancing the budget'...phew! :D
 
Now consider your butter through knives example. Except there are two rows of knives, one behind the other. The butter hits the first row, and passes, just as you describe. After hitting the first row, the butter has been divided into pieces matching the distance between the knives, but is still travelling very fast, because it did not decelerate very much at all, as you describe.

Now the butter encounters the second row of knives.

What happens?

TS found dead at failed 600 mph butter experiment. He was still holding a knife.
 
He never specified the temperature of the butter.....we all know that stuff won't spread at anything below 90f
 
The "no planes theory" is really hurting the efforts of The Truth Movement.


Not really. Only to truthers, anyway. The only difference between the holoplanes/beam-weapon/tom-cruise-scientology-hex theories and the thermite theory is that one has a bunch of pseudomath and pseudoscience hiding the underlying pure crazy.
 
The "no planes theory" is really hurting the efforts of The Truth Movement.

Welcome to the forum The Demon's Head. I'm assuming you are sympathetic to at least part of the truth movemnt, so here are a few suggestions for posting here:

1. Familiarise yourself with the sites listed in the links page if you haven't already done so

2. Pick a subject to discuss and try and stick to that subject as much as possible; don't sidetrack into other subjects unless they are directly related; be methodical

3. to avoid repetition, use the search function to find threads that already address your subject - bump them or quote from them if you still have something to discuss

4. don't assume anything about the political views of the people here, or their reasons for arguing the way they do

5. political arguments are best taken to the politics forum

6. don't confuse arguing about the general plausibility of a hypothesis with arguing about the specific evidence of a phenomenom; for more about what I mena by this, see this post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...99#post2098499

7. lastly, try not get sucked into personal disputes, posters can use some pretty blunt language in discussions, but in the main they are attacking the ideas; try and stick to reasoning and evidence. You can report serious personal attacks if necessary.

Once again, welcome!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom